Procedural rules for an employer's counterclaim for quality losses after the contractor has commenced arbitration over the project payment: legal basis of the counterclaim right, the line between defence and counterclaim, institutional counterclaim deadlines and late acceptance, out-of-scope awards and the risk of being set aside
Yes, it can be raised: Article 38 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) expressly provides that 'the respondent may admit or rebut the claim and has the right to file a counterclaim'. Quality breach, repair costs and compensation for quality losses are property-rights disputes under the same construction contract and fall within the arbitration agreement on which the main claim relies. But three gates must be passed: (1) the counterclaim must rest on the same arbitration agreement as the claim (matters under another contract, against another party, or administrative fines can only be pursued in a separate case); (2) it must be filed within the deadline in the institutional rules (BAC 2026 Rules Article 18: within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defence; CIETAC 2024 Rules Article 71 for domestic arbitration: within 20 days of receipt of the notice of arbitration), and if late, the arbitration institution (before constitution of the tribunal) or the tribunal (after constitution) decides whether to accept it; (3) substantively, it must satisfy contractor cause + notice to repair with a reasonable period given + refusal or failure to repair to the agreed standard + actual repair completed at reasonable cost. Merely seeking a price reduction or withholding payment is a defensive defence that can be made in the answer; once the employer demands payment from the contractor (repair costs, liquidated damages, third-party claims, delay losses), a counterclaim is mandatory, otherwise the award rules on matters beyond the arbitration agreement and risks being set aside under item (2) of paragraph 1 of Article 71 of the Arbitration Law.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第三条、第四条、第十条、第十一条、第三十二条至第四十一条、第四十二条至第五十条、第五十一条至第五十五条、第七十一条至第七十四条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第八百零一条、第七百九十三条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十六条、第二十三条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第十四条、第十六条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第一百四十三条
- 《北京仲裁委员会/北京国际仲裁院国内仲裁规则》(2026版)第十三条、第十五条至第二十条
- 《中国国际经济贸易仲裁委员会仲裁规则》(2024版)第六十八条至第七十五条
- 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》第九条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.5.3条
Scope and Positioning
This card answers a frequent arbitration dispute: the contractor has commenced arbitration over the project payment - can the employer strike back on grounds of non-conforming quality, repair costs or quality losses? Which claims must be brought as a counterclaim and which can simply be raised as defences in the answer; the counterclaim deadlines in the rules of the major arbitration institutions, the consequences of lateness, and the set-aside risk where a claim falls outside the arbitration agreement.
Core Conclusion
1. Legal basis of the counterclaim right (procedural level: it can be raised)
Article 38 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) reads: 'The claimant may abandon or amend its claim. The respondent may admit or rebut the claim and has the right to file a counterclaim.' A counterclaim must fall within the arbitration agreement in the case and the institution's acceptance scope - Article 32 provides that an arbitration application must meet three conditions: (1) an arbitration agreement exists; (2) there are specific arbitral claims, facts and reasons; (3) the dispute falls within the institution's acceptance scope. Article 33 requires submission to the arbitration institution of the arbitration agreement, the statement of claim and copies, and Article 34 lists what the statement of claim must contain (party information, the claims and the facts and reasons on which they rest, evidence and its sources, names and addresses of witnesses); the filing and acceptance of counterclaims are handled by reference to those provisions.
Quality breach, repair costs and quality damage compensation under the same contract are property-rights disputes covered by that contract's arbitration agreement; but Article 3 of the Arbitration Law provides that 'contract disputes and other property-rights disputes between natural persons, legal persons and unincorporated organisations of equal standing may be arbitrated', while expressly listing two categories that cannot: (1) disputes over marriage, adoption, guardianship, maintenance and succession; (2) administrative disputes that by law must be handled by administrative organs. Hence if the quality loss arises from another contract (e.g. an employer-supplied materials purchase contract), another party (a subcontractor, a supplier, or an injured third party's claim), or is an administrative fine, it is outside the arbitration agreement in this case and can only be pursued separately.
2. The line between defence and counterclaim (deciding whether a counterclaim is mandatory)
- Asserting only 'defective quality -> reduce the price, withhold the corresponding payment' is a defensive defence; raising it in the answer suffices to meet the claim.
- Once the employer demands performance from the contractor - repair costs, liquidated damages, third-party claims, rent/delay losses - a counterclaim is mandatory. The tribunal has no power to rule on claims no party has made; if the award touches matters beyond the counterclaim, it falls under 'the matters ruled on are outside the arbitration agreement or the arbitration institution has no power to arbitrate' in item (2) of paragraph 1 of Article 71 of the Arbitration Law, and a party may, within three months of receiving the award (Article 72), apply to the intermediate people's court at the seat of the arbitration institution to set it aside. The corresponding approach in litigation is Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 16: where the employer counterclaims on the ground of quality not conforming to the agreement, for the contractor to pay liquidated damages or compensate the reasonable costs of repair, rework or alteration and other losses, the people's court may hear them together.
3. Counterclaim deadlines in institutional rules and consequences of lateness (deadline level)
- Beijing Arbitration Commission / Beijing International Arbitration Centre Domestic Arbitration Rules (2026 edition) Article 17: the respondent shall submit its statement of defence, evidence and identity documents within 15 days of receipt of the notice of defence; Article 18: any counterclaim shall be filed within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defence, and if filed late, the Commission decides whether to accept it before the tribunal is constituted and the tribunal decides after constitution; in deciding, the necessity of hearing the counterclaim together with the claim, the timing of the late filing, whether it would cause unnecessary procedural delay and other relevant factors shall be considered. Article 19: amendments to a claim or counterclaim must be in writing, with acceptance decided by the Commission before constitution and by the tribunal after; amendments made so late as to prejudice the normal conduct of the proceedings may be refused. Article 13: parties shall pay arbitration fees in advance per the fee schedule; failure to pay within the prescribed period is deemed withdrawal of the arbitration application.
- CIETAC Arbitration Rules (2024 edition) Chapter V 'Special Provisions for Domestic Arbitration' Article 71: the respondent shall submit its statement of defence and evidence within 20 days of receipt of the notice of arbitration, and any counterclaim with its evidence within the same period; the claimant shall reply within 20 days of receipt of the notice of acceptance of the counterclaim; requests for extension for justified reasons are decided by the tribunal, or by the CIETAC Court of Arbitration where the tribunal is not yet constituted. Article 72: the date of the first hearing shall be notified no later than 15 days before the hearing; a party with justified reasons may request postponement by written application within 3 days of receipt of the hearing notice, with the tribunal deciding whether to postpone.
- Article 36 of the Arbitration Law: after receiving a copy of the statement of claim, the respondent shall submit its statement of defence to the arbitration institution within the period prescribed by the arbitration rules; failure to submit a defence does not affect the progress of the arbitration - missing the counterclaim deadline does not stay the proceedings but forfeits the chance to resolve the matter in this case.
4. Loss of rights and risk points at procedural nodes
- Hearing: Article 51 of the Arbitration Law - arbitration shall be heard orally; where the parties agree not to hold a hearing, the tribunal may make the award on the statement of claim, the statement of defence and other materials; Article 52 - arbitration is heard in private; Article 53 - the hearing date shall be notified within the period prescribed by the rules, and a party with justified reasons may request postponement within that period, decided by the tribunal.
- Default: Article 54 - where the respondent, having been notified in writing, fails to appear without justified reason or leaves the hearing without the tribunal's permission, an award may be made in default. If the employer fails to attend, it forfeits the chance to raise its counterclaim and defences at the hearing.
- Tribunal constitution and challenge: Article 42 - the tribunal consists of three arbitrators or one (with a presiding arbitrator when three); Article 43 - where three are agreed, each party selects or entrusts the chairman of the institution to appoint one, and the third (presiding) arbitrator is jointly selected by the parties or jointly entrusted to the chairman; Article 44 - where the parties fail to agree on the constitution or to select arbitrators within the prescribed period, the chairman determines or appoints per the rules; Article 45 - an arbitrator who has circumstances that may give rise to justifiable doubts as to independence or impartiality shall promptly disclose them in writing; Article 46 - grounds for challenge (being a party, an agent or their close relative in the case; having an interest in the case; having other relations with a party or agent that may affect impartial arbitration; privately meeting a party or agent or accepting hospitality or gifts); Article 47 - a challenge shall be raised before the first hearing, or before the close of the last hearing if the grounds become known later; Article 48 - whether a challenge succeeds is decided by the chairman of the institution. Article 49 paragraph 2: after an arbitrator is re-selected or re-appointed due to a challenge, a party may request that the proceedings already held be repeated, with the tribunal deciding whether to permit it - this node can be used to cure earlier evidence and claims.
- Evidence: Article 55 - parties shall provide evidence for their claims; Article 39 permits applications for property preservation (including pre-arbitration emergency preservation), and a wrongful application must compensate the respondent's losses caused by the preservation.
- Finality: Article 10 - after an award is made, where a party applies for arbitration again or sues in court over the same dispute, the institution or the court will not accept it; where the award is set aside or enforcement is refused by court ruling under law, the parties may re-arbitrate under a new arbitration agreement reached between them or sue in court. Hence if quality losses are not raised as a counterclaim in this case, subsequent remedies are extremely limited.
- Online arbitration: Article 11 - arbitration may be conducted online via information networks (unless a party expressly objects), and online proceedings have the same legal effect as offline ones.
5. Substantive requirements of a counterclaim (whether it can succeed)
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (SPC Interpretation (II) on construction contract disputes, effective 30 June 2026 and applying to first-instance construction cases newly accepted after that date) Article 16 reads: 'Where the works quality fails to conform to the agreement due to the contractor's causes and the employer, without notifying the contractor to repair, seeks an order that the contractor pay repair costs up front, the people's court will not support it. Where the contractor refuses to repair or fails within a reasonable period to repair to the agreed standard, and the employer, having repaired, claims the reasonable repair costs from the contractor, the people's court will support it.' That is, four requirements: contractor cause + notice to repair with a reasonable period given + refusal or failure to repair to the agreed standard + the employer has actually repaired at reasonable cost.
Civil Code Article 801: 'Where the works quality fails to conform to the agreement due to the constructor's causes, the employer has the right to demand that the constructor repair, rework or alter free of charge within a reasonable period. If repair, rework or alteration causes late delivery, the constructor bears liability for breach.' Civil Code Article 793 paragraph 2: where the contract is void and the works fail acceptance, (1) if after repair the works pass acceptance, the employer may claim the repair costs from the contractor; (2) if the works still fail after repair, the contractor has no right to discounted compensation by reference to the contract price provisions.
Routes within the defects liability period: Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Measures for Administration of Construction Works Retention Money, Article 9 paragraph 1 - for defects caused by the contractor, the contractor shall repair and bear the assessment and repair costs; where the contractor neither repairs nor bears the costs, the employer may deduct per the contract from the retention money or bank guarantee, and where the costs exceed the retention amount, may claim per the contract against the contractor; the contractor's repair and payment of the corresponding costs does not exempt its liability for losses to the works. Paragraph 2 - for defects caused by others, the employer organises the repairs, the contractor bears no costs, and no deduction from the retention money is allowed. GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.3: for defects or damage caused by the contractor within the defects liability period, where the contractor refuses to repair or fails to repair within a reasonable period and still fails after the employer's written demand, the employer may repair itself or engage a third party, the contractor bears the repair costs, and the employer may deduct from the retention money or the quality warranty guarantee; costs exceeding the retention amount may be claimed against the contractor under Clause 8.11.18 of the standard.
Applicable Boundaries
- Applies to arbitration (including online arbitration under Article 11 of the Arbitration Law). The litigation counterpart is the counterclaim in court, which may be heard together under Article 143 of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) - 'where the plaintiff adds claims, the defendant counterclaims, or a third party raises claims related to the case, they may be heard together' - and Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 16.
- Counterclaim deadlines are institutional-rule matters and must follow the receiving institution's current rules; the deadline figures in this card correspond only to BAC/BIAC Domestic Arbitration Rules (2026 edition) Article 18 and CIETAC Arbitration Rules (2024 edition) Article 71 (domestic arbitration). International/foreign-related arbitration and expedited procedures have different deadlines.
- 'Can file a counterclaim' does not mean 'will necessarily succeed': procedural validity is only the entry ticket; substantively the four requirements of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16 still apply; where the employer claims without notifying the contractor to repair, it can only seek a price reduction or loss compensation, not up-front repair costs.
- Where the employer uses the works prematurely without taking-over and then claims quality non-conformity for the parts used, the claim is unsupported (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 14); only the foundation works and the main structure remain the contractor's responsibility within their reasonable service life - in such situations a counterclaim lacks substantive basis.
- This card rests on the Arbitration Law (2025 revision), the Civil Code, Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 and Fa Shi [2020] No. 25; citations using the old Arbitration Law article numbering or the old Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 12 position must be version-checked before use.
Further Reading
- Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 revision): Chapter I general provisions, Articles 1-12 (arbitrability Article 3; finality Article 10; online arbitration Article 11); Chapter IV arbitration procedure, Section 1 application and acceptance Articles 32-41, Section 2 constitution of the tribunal Articles 42-50, Section 3 hearing and award Articles 51-55; Chapter V applications to set aside awards Articles 71-74 (six set-aside grounds in Article 71; three-month period in Article 72; two-month ruling in Article 73; notice of re-arbitration in Article 74).
- BAC/BIAC Domestic Arbitration Rules (2026 edition) Chapter III arbitration application, defence and counterclaim: Article 13 (application and advance fees), Article 14 (multi-contract consolidated applications), Article 15 (acceptance, within 10 days of fee payment), Article 16 (dispatch of the notice of arbitration), Article 17 (defence 15 days), Article 18 (counterclaim 30 days and discretionary factors for late filings), Article 19 (amendment of claims), Article 20 (joinder of parties).
- CIETAC Arbitration Rules (2024 edition) Chapter V special provisions for domestic arbitration: Articles 68-75 (acceptance, tribunal constitution, defence and counterclaim 20 days, hearing notice 15 days and 3-day postponement application, hearing transcript, award within 4 months of tribunal constitution).
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Interpretation (II) Article 16 (repair costs and prior notice) and Article 23 (effective 30 June 2026 and transitional rules); Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Interpretation (I) Article 14 (premature use) and Article 16 (joint hearing of quality counterclaims).
- Civil Code Articles 801 and 793; Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 9; GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.5.3 and 8.11.18.
Keywords
- 反请求
- 仲裁法第三十八条
- 答辩期限
- 逾期反请求
- 防御性抗辩
- 申请撤销裁决
- 质量损失
- 修复费用