Whether the employer may refuse payment for completed works when the contractor exits without handing over construction records: the legal nature of the record-handover obligation, the proportionality limit of the defence of refusal to perform, the two exceptions permitting suspension of payment, and the remedies of a handover claim and evidence preservation (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 15)
As a rule there is no blanket refusal to pay: the consideration for the works price is the accepted completed quantities of passing quality (Civil Code Articles 799 and 793), while handing over construction records is an ancillary duty of cooperation and a procedural condition for taking-over and archiving (Article 509(2), Article 16 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, GB/T 50328-2014 Clause 6.0.3); the two are not reciprocal performances. Even where a defence of refusal to perform is invoked, Articles 525 and 526 permit refusal only of the 'corresponding' performance, and a substitutable duty of cooperation cannot be set against the entire price. The employer's proper remedies are: a claim for handover of the site and construction records under Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 15(1); application for evidence preservation before exit under Article 15(2) (referring to Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law); and damages under Civil Code Article 584, or set-off under Article 568, for losses caused by the missing records. Payment may be suspended, to an extent corresponding to the obligation, only where the contract expressly makes record handover a precondition of payment, or where the payment condition (passing taking-over) has genuinely not been satisfied because the records are incomplete.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百零九条、第五百二十五条、第五百二十六条、第五百六十六条、第五百六十八条、第五百八十四条、第七百九十三条、第七百九十九条、第八百零一条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号)第十五条、第二十三条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》(法释〔2020〕25号)第二十条、第二十七条、第三十二条、第四十一条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第六十七条、第八十四条
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第五十八条
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第十六条
- 《保障中小企业款项支付条例》(国务院令第802号,2025修订)第九条、第十条、第十二条、第十四条、第十五条、第十七条
- GB/T 50328-2014 · Code for Filing of Construction Project Documents 第6.0.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.3.5、10.3.7、10.3.14、10.3.16条
- 财建〔2004〕369号《建设工程价款结算暂行办法》第十六条
- 建质〔2013〕171号《房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程竣工验收规定》第五条
Issue and scope
When the contractor exits on termination of the contract (or refuses to hand over after completion), holding back payment for completed works on the ground that 'construction records and completion documents were not handed over in full' is the employer's most common defence. This card answers whether that defence stands, where its limits lie, and what legal tools the employer can really use (handover claim, evidence preservation, damages and set-off); it also gives the two exception scenarios permitting refusal or suspension, and the cut-over point between the old and new interpretations.
Core conclusions
1. The rule: no blanket refusal to pay for completed works. Three layers of reasoning.
Layer 1 - the payment obligation does not mature on record handover. Civil Code Article 799: 'After completion of the works the employer shall promptly take over the works against the construction drawings and specifications and the state-issued acceptance codes and quality inspection standards. Where taking-over passes, the employer shall pay the price as agreed and receive the works. A completed project may be put into use only after passing taking-over; a project not taken over, or failing taking-over, may not be put into use.' Where the contract is void, Article 793 likewise makes 'the works passing acceptance' the precondition for price compensation by reference to the contract, and where the works still fail after remedial work 'the contractor has no right to price compensation by reference to the agreed contract price.' The consideration for the works price is thus completed quantities of verified acceptable quality.
The place of record handover in this scheme: (1) Article 16 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision) lists five conditions for completion taking-over, of which item (2) is 'complete technical archives and construction management records' - records are a component condition of whether taking-over can proceed, not the consideration for whether payment is due; (2) GB/T 50328-2014, Code for Archiving of Construction Project Documents, Clause 6.0.3(2): 'the survey and design units shall archive their project records on completion of their tasks; the construction and supervision units shall archive theirs with the employer before completion taking-over' - archiving falls before taking-over and is a procedural, substitutable duty; (3) Civil Code Article 509(1), 'the parties shall perform their obligations fully as agreed', and Article 509(2), 'the parties shall observe good faith and perform such duties as notice, assistance and confidentiality according to the nature, purpose and practice of the transaction' - record handover is in essence an ancillary duty of cooperation.
Layer 2 - the performance defence is 'corresponding' only, never 'total'. Civil Code Article 525: 'Where the parties owe each other debts and no order of performance applies, performance shall be concurrent; either party may refuse the other's demand for performance until the other performs. Where a party's performance does not conform to the agreement, the other party may refuse its corresponding demand for performance.' Article 526: 'Where the parties owe each other debts and the party to perform first does not perform, the party to perform later may refuse the demand for performance; where the first party's performance does not conform to the agreement, the later party may refuse its corresponding demand for performance.' Both defences require mutual debts (a relationship of reciprocal performance) and confine refusal to the 'corresponding' part: missing records correspond at most to 'the quantities unverifiable for want of those records' or to an amount commensurate with the cost of re-creating the records - plainly out of proportion to the whole price of the completed works.
Layer 3 - the judicial interpretation grants a remedy of 'getting the records', not 'not paying'. Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation (II) of the Supreme People's Court on Construction Contract Disputes, Article 15(1): 'Where a construction contract is terminated, if the employer requests the contractor to hand over the site and construction records, the people's court shall support the request in accordance with law.' Article 15(2): 'Where a party applies for evidence preservation before the contractor exits, the people's court shall handle the application under Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law.' Were the legislative intent 'no records, no payment', there would be no need to create a separate handover right of action. Price treatment on termination otherwise follows Civil Code Article 566: '...obligations not yet performed cease to be performed; for those performed, the parties may, in light of the performance and the nature of the contract, request restitution or other remedial measures and claim damages. Where the contract is terminated for breach, the terminating party may hold the defaulting party liable for breach...'.
2. The employer's real routes (three substitutes for 'holding back the money')
- Handover claim: sue on Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 15(1) for handover of the site and construction records, together with contract liquidated damages for delayed handover or damages.
- Evidence preservation: where the vacated site and process records risk being lost or becoming unobtainable, Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) Article 84 permits an application to the court during the suit, and the court may also act on its own initiative; in urgent cases an interested party may apply before suit or arbitration to the court where the evidence is located, the respondent is domiciled or the court has jurisdiction. On the arbitration route, Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Article 58: the arbitration institution shall transmit the party's evidence-preservation application to the basic people's court where the evidence is located, which shall deal with it in accordance with law and in good time; in urgent cases a party to the arbitration agreement may apply to the court before arbitration under the Civil Procedure Law.
- Damages or set-off: for the cost of reconstituting records, appraisal fees, delayed taking-over losses and delayed completion-filing losses, claim damages under Civil Code Article 584 - 'damages shall be equivalent to the loss caused by the breach, including the benefit obtainable on performance of the contract; but they may not exceed the loss the defaulting party foresaw, or should have foreseen, at the time of contracting'; or exercise set-off under Article 568 - 'where the parties owe each other debts and the subject matters are of the same kind and quality, either party may set off its own debt against the other party's due debt... the party asserting set-off shall notify the other party, and the notice takes effect on arrival. Set-off may not be subject to a condition or a term.' Note: set-off must be asserted against a due, same-kind, set-offable determined amount; the entire price cannot be swept aside as 'losses still to be quantified'.
3. Affirmative scenarios - two exceptions permitting refusal or suspension of payment
- The contract expressly makes record handover a precondition of payment (agreed terms prevail, subject to two limits): perform first under Article 509(1); but the scope of refusal stays within the 'corresponding' limit of Articles 525 and 526 and may not swallow the whole price. Where the contractor is an SME and the employer is a state organ, public institution or large enterprise, the agreement is further overridden by the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs (State Council Decree No. 802, 2025 revision): Article 9 - payment within 30 days of delivery of the goods, works or services, at most 60 days where the contract provides otherwise; large enterprises pay within 60 days of delivery; payment may not be conditioned on receipt of third-party payment or made pro rata to third-party payments; Article 10 - where payment is conditioned on passing inspection or taking-over, the period runs from the date of passing, and where the employer delays inspection or taking-over, from expiry of the agreed inspection or taking-over period; Article 14 - refusal or delay on grounds of change of legal representative or principal, internal payment processes, or (absent agreement) awaiting completion filing or final-account audit is prohibited; Article 12 - audit results may not be imposed as the settlement basis except as laws and administrative regulations otherwise provide.
- The payment condition (passing taking-over) genuinely failed for incomplete records: the true ground of refusal is then that the Civil Code Article 799 condition 'taking-over passed' has not occurred, not 'records not handed over' as such. The reverse limit: for works that have passed completion taking-over, or completed-but-not-taken-over works prematurely used by the employer, quality disputes run under the warranty contract or warranty clauses and 'the final account shall be handled as agreed in the contract' (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.14); blanket stoppage of payment on records or quality grounds is barred.
4. Two easily confused kinds of 'records', treated entirely differently
- Construction records (technical archives, process records, as-built drawings etc.): cannot be set against price payment; the route is a handover claim plus damages (above).
- Final account documents: where the contractor fails to submit them on time, the employer's remedy is not 'not paying' but Clause 10.3.5 of GB/T 50500-2024 - 'where the contractor fails to submit the final account documents within the agreed time and, after the employer's demand, still fails to submit as required or gives no clear answer, the employer may compile the final account from the records available and refer it to the contractor; where the contractor confirms without objection or gives no clear answer within the agreed time, the employer-compiled final account is deemed accepted and may serve as the basis for final account settlement and payment of the settlement price'; Cai Jian [2004] No. 369, Interim Measures for Settlement of Construction Project Prices, Article 16, in the same direction: 'where the contractor fails to provide complete final account documents and, 14 days after the employer's demand, still fails to provide them or gives no clear answer, the employer may review on the basis of the records available, at the contractor's own risk'. The reverse constraint also exists: where the employer, having received the contractor's payment application for the final account price, 'fails to verify within the prescribed time and does not issue the final payment certificate, the contractor's application is deemed accepted', and the employer must pay the amount stated in the application (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.16).
5. Where missing records impede quantity verification (partial suspension only)
- Undisputed parts must first proceed to a partial final account: 'where the employer or the contractor disputes the review result, the undisputed part shall be handled as a partial final account under item 1 of this clause; the disputed part shall be resolved by negotiation between employer and contractor' (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.7); Decree No. 802 Article 15 to the same effect: undisputed parts must be paid promptly.
- Incomplete records but provable quantities do not defeat the right to payment: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 20 - 'disputes over quantities are determined by the signed records and other written documents formed during construction; where the contractor can prove that the employer consented to the work but cannot produce signed records proving the quantities, the actual quantities may be determined from other evidence produced by the parties' - measurement sign-offs, stage settlement documents, photographic records and supervision records can all corroborate.
- Burden of proof: Civil Procedure Law Article 67(1), 'a party is responsible for providing evidence for its own claims'; for specialist questions, Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 32 requires the court to elucidate to the party bearing the burden of proof, and 'a party who, after elucidation, does not apply for appraisal, or applies but does not pay the appraisal fee or refuses to provide the relevant materials, bears the legal consequences of failure of proof'.
- Note the priority-right period does not toll during price disputes: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 41 - 'the contractor shall exercise its priority right to payment out of the proceeds of the works within a reasonable period, at most eighteen months, from the date the employer's payment of the works price falls due'; where the due date is unclear, Article 27 presumes: '(1) works actually delivered - the date of delivery; (2) works not delivered - the date the final account documents were submitted; (3) works neither delivered nor settled - the date of suit.'
6. Cut-over between the old and new interpretations
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 23: 'This interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. It applies to first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted by the people's courts after that date. Earlier SPC interpretations inconsistent with this interpretation yield to it.' The Article 15 handover claim and evidence-preservation guidance thus govern first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted on or after 30 June 2026; for first-instance cases accepted earlier, the handover claim proceeds under Civil Code Articles 566 and 509 and the contract, applying Interpretation (I) (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25).
Boundaries of application
- The conclusions are confined to the issue of resisting payment for completed works on the ground of un-handed-over records. The scope of records (which documents, how many copies, deadlines, format) depends on the particular conditions, the tender documents and the project archive rules; whether what is missing is records critical to taking-over or merely process records for verification matters - the former goes to 'payment condition not satisfied', the latter supports only proportionate suspension.
- Where the contract is found void, price compensation follows Civil Code Article 793; the record-handover duty and the payment duty remain independently assessed and do not cross-secure each other by reason of invalidity.
- Where the records originate with the contractor, its archiving duty ends at archiving with the employer (construction unit); the duty to file the completion archives with the municipal construction archives authority rests on the employer and may not be turned into a payment condition against the contractor (verify under the archive rules of the project location).
- The payment-period and overdue-interest rules of Decree No. 802 (Article 17: an agreed rate no lower than the 1-year loan prime rate at the time of contracting; absent agreement, a daily rate of 0.05%) apply only to procurement by state organs, public institutions and large enterprises from SMEs; they do not apply directly between two ordinary enterprises.
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard whose clauses generally leave room for 'except as otherwise agreed in the contract'; check the particular conditions first, then apply the standard as industry practice where the contract is silent.
- The card does not fix the amount of losses from missing records; loss claims need evidence of causation and foreseeability (Article 584).
Further reading
- Civil Code Articles 509 (full performance and duties of cooperation), 525 and 526 (the 'corresponding' limit of the concurrent- and prior-performance defences), 566 (consequences of termination), 568 (elements of set-off and effect of notice), 584 (foreseeable damages), 793 (price compensation on void contracts), 799 (payment after passing taking-over), 801 (free repair, rework or alteration for non-conforming quality, and liability for late delivery).
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Articles 15 (handover of site and construction records; evidence preservation before exit) and 23 (effective 30 June 2026; cut-over by newly accepted first-instance cases).
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 20 (quantity disputes determined by signed records and other evidence), 27 (three presumptions of the due date), 32 (appraisal elucidation and consequences of failure of proof), 41 (priority right, eighteen months).
- Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) Articles 67 (burden of proof; court collection of evidence) and 84 (in-suit and pre-suit evidence preservation); Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Article 58 (transmission of arbitration evidence preservation to the basic court).
- Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision) Article 16 (five taking-over conditions, including complete technical archives and construction management records); Jian Zhi [2013] No. 171, Provisions on Completion Taking-over of Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects, Article 5 (eleven requirements, item (7): the employer has paid for the works as contracted).
- GB/T 50328-2014 Clause 6.0.3 (archiving may proceed by stages; construction and supervision units archive with the employer before completion taking-over).
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.3.5 (employer compiles the final account where the contractor defaults; deemed acceptance), 10.3.7 (partial final account on disputed review), 10.3.14 (final account proceeds despite quality objections), 10.3.16 (deemed approval where the employer fails to verify and issue the payment certificate in time).
- Cai Jian [2004] No. 369, Interim Measures for Settlement of Construction Project Prices, Article 16 (records incomplete 14 days after demand; liability for 15-day late payment).
- Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs (State Council Decree No. 802, 2025 revision) Articles 9 (30 days / 60 days maximum; 60 days for large enterprises), 10 (time from passing acceptance; delayed acceptance), 12 (no imposed audit basis), 14 (no refusal pending internal processes, completion filing or audit), 15 (prompt payment of undisputed parts), 17 (overdue interest).
Keywords
- 未移交施工资料
- 拒付工程款
- 资料移交义务
- 同时履行抗辩权
- 先履行抗辩权
- 法释〔2026〕12号第十五条
- 证据保全
- 协助义务