Rules for the start point of the defects liability period (the period secured by retention money): the statutory deemed start 90 days after submission of the completion-acceptance report where the employer delays or fails to organise completion acceptance, and a comparison of the start points for normal acceptance, contractor-caused delay, premature use of the works without taking-over, and early acceptance of units or sections
Where for reasons attributable to the employer the works cannot undergo completion acceptance within the prescribed period, the defects liability period is entered automatically 90 days after the contractor submits the completion-acceptance report (Article 8 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138); the base is thus 'submission date plus 90 days' - it runs neither from the date of actual passing of acceptance nor immediately from the submission date. In the normal case it runs from the date of passing completion acceptance; where the contractor is the reason, from the date of actual passing; the period is generally 1 year, 2 years at most.
Applicable Codes
- 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》(2017修订)第二条、第七条、第八条、第十一条
- 最高人民法院法释〔2020〕25号《关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第九条、第十七条
- 建市〔2020〕96号《建设项目工程总承包合同(示范文本)》GF-2020-0216 通用合同条件第11.2款
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》第15.3.3款、第15.4.1款
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第四十条
- 《民法典》第七百九十九条
- 《民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第六十七条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.5.5条
Topic positioning
The rules for fixing the start point of the defects liability period (the period secured by retention money), focused on the statutory deemed start in the high-frequency dispute situation where the employer delays or fails to organise completion acceptance, with a comparison of the start points for normal acceptance, contractor-caused delay, premature use of the works, and early acceptance of units or sections. The start of the defects liability period, the start of the warranty period, the expiry of the retention return period and final closure of accounts are four distinct propositions and must not be substituted for one another.
Core conclusions
1. The statutory start rule in the departmental measure (Article 8 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, verbatim) 'The defects liability period runs from the date the works pass completion acceptance. Where the works cannot undergo completion acceptance within the prescribed period for reasons attributable to the contractor, the defects liability period runs from the date the works actually pass completion acceptance. Where the works cannot undergo completion acceptance within the prescribed period for reasons attributable to the employer, the works automatically enter the defects liability period 90 days after the contractor submits the completion-acceptance report.' Accordingly: (1) normal acceptance - the date of passing completion acceptance; (2) contractor-caused failure to accept on schedule - the date of actual passing; (3) employer-caused failure to accept on schedule - automatic entry 90 days after submission of the completion-acceptance report (a deemed start: it looks neither at the actual acceptance date nor starts immediately on the submission date).
2. Period length and the nature of the money (Article 2 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138) 'The construction works retention money referred to in these Measures ... means the money which the employer and the contractor agree in the construction contract to withhold from the works payment payable, used to secure the contractor's repair of defects arising in the works during the defects liability period.' 'A defect means the construction works quality failing to conform to the mandatory standards for construction projects, the design documents, or the agreed terms of the construction contract.' 'The defects liability period is generally 1 year and shall not exceed 2 years at most, as agreed by the employer and the contractor in the contract.'
3. The judicial line matches the administrative line (Article 17 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) 'In any of the following circumstances, where the contractor requests the employer to return the construction works retention money, the people's court shall support the request: (1) the return period of the construction works retention money agreed by the parties has expired; (2) where the parties have not agreed a return period of the construction works retention money, two years have elapsed since the works passed completion acceptance; (3) where for reasons attributable to the employer the works have not undergone completion acceptance within the agreed period, the return period of the construction works retention money agreed by the parties expires 90 days after the contractor submits the completion-acceptance report; where the parties have not agreed a return period of the construction works retention money, two years elapse counted from 90 days after the contractor submits the completion-acceptance report. After the employer returns the construction works retention money, the contractor's performance of its works warranty obligations under the contract or under law is not affected.' - item (3) uses the same 90-day point as Article 8 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138.
4. The finer situations in the model contract (Clause 11.2 of the General Conditions of GF-2020-0216) 'The defects liability period in principle runs from the date the works pass completion acceptance; the contracting parties shall agree in the special conditions the specific duration of the defects liability period, but that duration shall not exceed 24 months at most.'
- A unit or section passing acceptance before the whole works and being delivered for use: the period runs from the date that unit or section passes acceptance;
- Where for reasons attributable to the employer the works are not accepted within the period agreed in the contract but do pass acceptance: the period runs from the date the contractor submits the completion-acceptance report;
- Where for reasons attributable to the employer the works cannot undergo completion acceptance: the works automatically enter the defects liability period 90 days after the completion-acceptance report is submitted;
- Where the employer puts the works to premature use without completion acceptance: the period starts to run from the date of transfer of possession of the works;
- Where defects caused by the contractor require renewed inspection, examination and repair, the defects liability period of that part of the works or equipment may be extended, with the notice of extension to be given before expiry of the original period, 'but the defects liability period shall not exceed 24 months at most'.
5. Premature use and the completion date (Article 9 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, verbatim) '(1) Where the construction works have passed completion acceptance, the date of passing completion acceptance is the completion date; (2) where the contractor has submitted the completion-acceptance report and the employer delays acceptance, the date the contractor submits the report is the completion date; (3) where the construction works have not undergone completion acceptance and the employer puts them to premature use, the date of transfer of possession of the construction works is the completion date.' - note that the judicial position in item (2) (the submission date deemed the completion date) differs in function from the 90-day deemed start of the defects liability period; the same date must not be used to claim different items.
6. The precondition of delivery for use (Article 799 of the Civil Code) 'After the construction works are complete, the employer shall organise acceptance in good time according to the construction drawings and descriptions and the construction acceptance codes and quality inspection standards issued by the state. On passing acceptance, the employer shall pay the price as agreed and take over the construction works. Only after the construction works pass completion acceptance may they be delivered for use; works not accepted, or not passing acceptance, may not be delivered for use.'
7. Comparison: the start of the warranty period (Article 40 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects) Minimum warranty periods: for infrastructure works, and for the foundation works and main structural works of buildings, the reasonable service life of the works stated in the design documents; for roofing waterproofing works, and toilets, rooms and exterior walls with waterproofing requirements, 5 years; for heating and cooling systems, 2 heating periods and 2 cooling periods; for electrical wiring, water supply and drainage pipes, equipment installation and decoration works, 2 years; other items as agreed by the employer and the contractor. 'The warranty period of construction works runs from the date of passing completion acceptance.' Clause 15.4.1 of GF-2017-0201 adds that 'where the employer puts the works to premature use without completion acceptance, the warranty period runs from the transfer of possession'.
8. The interface after expiry After the defects liability period expires, the contractor applies for return of the retention money; the employer, within 14 days of receiving the application, verifies jointly with the contractor; where the return period is not agreed or is unclear, return is made within 14 days after verification, with liability for breach if late; where the employer fails to reply within 14 days of receiving the application and, after a demand, still fails to reply within 14 days, the return application is deemed approved (Article 11 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138; the same text in Clause 15.3.3 of GF-2017-0201). Clause 10.5.5 of GB/T 50500-2024 provides that final closure of accounts is handled after the defects liability period ends, and the return of the warranty security or the remaining retention money 'shall not carry interest'.
Applicability limits
- The 90-day deemed start applies strictly where 'for reasons attributable to the employer the works cannot undergo completion acceptance within the prescribed period', and where 'the contractor has submitted the completion-acceptance report'; where the contractor is the reason, the period still runs from the date of actual passing of completion acceptance.
- Where the parties dispute 'whether the completion-acceptance report was submitted', 'on which day it was submitted' or 'to whom the delay is attributable', the start point shifts accordingly, so the submission time must be fixed by written service evidence (each party proves its own case, Article 67 of the Civil Procedure Law).
- GF-2020-0216 is a model contract; it binds only where the parties adopt it or the contract incorporates it (its finer position 'not accepted within the agreed period but ultimately passing acceptance - runs from submission of the report' is a contractual rule, not a mandatory rule of law); Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 is a departmental normative document and Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 a judicial interpretation; in case of conflict the judicial interpretation prevails.
- 'Generally 1 year, 2 years at most' and 'not exceeding 24 months at most' are ceilings that cannot be exceeded by contract, and any extension remains subject to the same limit.
- Fixing the start point is not fixing the return date: return additionally requires the application-and-verification procedure; returning the retention money does not release the contractor from continuing to perform its warranty obligations under the contract or for the statutory minimum years.
- The measure is silent on the exact counting of the 90 days (whether the submission day itself counts), and a one-day divergence exists in practice; state the exact node date in the contract or in the return letter to avoid disputes.
Further reading
- Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for the Administration of Construction Works Retention Money (2017 revision), Articles 2, 7, 8 and 11
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes, Articles 9 and 17
- Jian Shi [2020] No. 96, Model Contract for Project EPC Works (GF-2020-0216), General Conditions, Clause 11 (11.1, 11.2, 11.3.4 repair notice, 11.3.6 failure to repair)
- GF-2017-0201, Model Construction Contract, Clauses 15.3.3 and 15.4.1
- Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision), Article 40
- Civil Code, Article 799; Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment), Article 67 (allocation of the burden of proof)
- GB/T 50500-2024, China national pricing standard for BOQ, Clause 10.5.5 (final closure of accounts and return of retention money)
- For the start of the retention return period where the contract is rescinded or void and the works are unfinished, see Article 14 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 and the time-of-effect point in Article 23
Keywords
- defects liability period
- 起算
- 自动进入缺陷责任期
- 提交竣工验收报告90天
- 发包人拖延验收
- 转移占有
- 竣工验收合格之日
- retention money