Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Rules for judicial adjustment where agreed liquidated damages are excessively high: how adjustment is triggered (counterclaim or defence), the loss-based measure and the 'exceeding the loss by 30%' test, allocation of the burden of proof, and the court's duty to clarify

Liquidated damages stand as agreed; the court adjusts only on a party's request (counterclaim or defence both suffice): where the damages are below the loss, an increase may be sought; where they are grossly above the loss, an appropriate reduction may be sought. The measure is the loss as defined in Civil Code Article 584, weighing the contract parties, the type of transaction, the performance of the contract, the degree of fault and the background of performance, and following the principles of fairness and good faith - 'where the agreed liquidated damages exceed the loss caused by 30%, the people's court may generally find them grossly above the loss caused'; a request for reduction by a party in bad-faith breach is generally refused. The breaching party bears the burden of proving 'grossly above'; the non-breaching party asserting reasonableness must also produce evidence; a defence resting only on a contractual clause that no adjustment shall be made is not upheld; where a defence succeeds but no adjustment is claimed, the court must clarify.

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百八十四条、第五百八十五条
  • 法释〔2023〕13号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民法典〉合同编通则若干问题的解释》第六十四条、第六十五条、第六十六条(2023年12月5日施行)
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第六十七条

Topic Positioning

The validity of agreed liquidated damages, how judicial adjustment is triggered, the measure (including the 'exceeding the loss by 30%' rule), allocation of the burden of proof, and the court's duty to clarify. Based on Civil Code Article 585 and Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Articles 64 to 66.

Core Conclusions

1. Agreed damages and the statutory power of adjustment (Civil Code Article 585, as enacted)

'The parties may agree that, when one party breaches, it shall pay the other party liquidated damages of a certain amount according to the breach, or agree on a method of computing the loss compensation arising from the breach. Where the agreed liquidated damages are lower than the loss caused, the people's court or the arbitration institution may, on the party's request, increase them; where the agreed liquidated damages are grossly higher than the loss caused, the people's court or the arbitration institution may, on the party's request, appropriately reduce them. Where the parties agree on liquidated damages for delayed performance, the breaching party, after paying them, shall still perform the obligation.' So liquidated damages stand as agreed, but the court does not vary them of its own motion; a party must request it; and damages for delay do not excuse the duty of continued performance.

2. Trigger and burden of proof (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Article 64)

  • 'Where a party requests adjustment of liquidated damages by way of counterclaim or defence, the people's court shall uphold the request according to law.' - no separate action is required.
  • 'A breaching party claiming that the agreed liquidated damages are grossly above the loss caused by the breach and requesting an appropriate reduction bears the burden of proof. A non-breaching party claiming that the agreed liquidated damages are reasonable shall also provide corresponding evidence.'
  • 'A party asserting that the liquidated damages shall not be adjusted merely on the ground that the contract so agrees will not be upheld by the people's court.' - a clause 'contractually excluding judicial adjustment' cannot block adjustment.

3. The measure and the 30% rule (Article 65)

'Where a party claims that the agreed liquidated damages are grossly above the loss caused by the breach and requests an appropriate reduction, the people's court shall take the loss as defined in Article 584 of the Civil Code as the basis, weigh the contract parties, the type of transaction, the performance of the contract, the degree of fault of the parties, the background of performance and other factors, follow the principles of fairness and good faith in measuring, and adjudicate. Where the agreed liquidated damages exceed the loss caused by 30%, the people's court may generally find them grossly above the loss caused. Where a party in bad-faith breach requests a reduction of the liquidated damages, the people's court will generally not uphold it.'

4. Clarification and second-instance adjustment (Article 66)

  • Where the breaching party defends on the grounds that the contract was not formed, is void, was rescinded, is definitively without effect, that no breach occurred, or that the non-breaching party suffered no loss, but does not claim adjustment of the excessive damages, the court 'shall clarify whether, if that defence is not upheld, the party requests adjustment of the liquidated damages'.
  • Where the first instance finds the defence established without clarifying, and the second instance holds that damages ought to be awarded, the second instance 'may clarify directly and, on the party's request, after the parties have fully proved, cross-examined and debated whether the liquidated damages should be adjusted, decree by law an appropriate reduction of the liquidated damages'.
  • Where a defendant was absent from the first instance for objective reasons and appears in the second instance requesting a reduction of the damages, the second instance may, after proof, cross-examination and debate, decree by law an appropriate reduction.

Boundaries of Application

  • 30% is not an absolute red line but the experiential standard of 'may generally be found grossly above': first fix the loss in the Article 584 sense (including expectant interests, capped by the foreseeability rule), then compare against it as the base; where the loss is itself zero or minimal, damages at any ratio may be found excessive, but the court must still weigh the contract parties, the transaction type, the performance, the degree of fault and the background comprehensively, and a reduction requested by a party in bad-faith breach is generally not upheld.
  • Adjustment only on request: the court may not, of its own motion, reduce or increase the liquidated damages; a defence and a counterclaim both qualify as forms of request.
  • Taking the Article 584 loss as the basis means damages and compensation for the same loss cannot be claimed cumulatively; where the agreed damages are below the loss, the non-breaching party may request an increase, but the increase remains capped at the foreseeable range.
  • Damages for delay coexist with continued performance: after paying damages for delay, the debt must still be performed.
  • The validity of a damages clause presupposes a valid contract; where the contract is void or not formed, adjustment of damages does not apply, and the matter is handled as culpa in contrahendo or converted-value compensation.
  • Burden of proof: the party asserting 'grossly above' (usually the breaching party) proves the loss; the party asserting reasonableness (usually the non-breaching party) must also produce evidence (Civil Procedure Law, 2023 revision, Article 67: a party has the responsibility to provide evidence for its own claims).

Further Reading

Civil Code Article 584 (scope of loss and the foreseeability rule), Article 585 (agreement on and adjustment of liquidated damages); Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Part VIII, 'Liability for Breach', Article 64 (mode of and burden for adjustment), Article 65 (factors weighed and the 30% standard), Article 66 (clarification and second-instance adjustment); Article 67(1) (where money is delivered as lien money, security money, retention, contracting money, deposit or earnest money (dingjin) without the character of a deposit being agreed, the deposit penalty does not apply - note the distinction from liquidated damages).

Keywords

  • 违约金过高
  • 违约金调整
  • 百分之三十
  • 民法典585条
  • 法释〔2023〕13号第65条
  • 举证责任
  • 释明
  • 过分高于造成的损失

Cited By