Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

The access rules and negative exclusions for a contractor's application for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost where the contract stipulates determination of the price by the government audit result or the government fiscal review conclusion, but that conclusion is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract (or not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13)

Yes, but what the contractor obtains is a right of access to judicial expert assessment, not a direct re-pricing by the court under the contract: under Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13, paragraph 1, where the price is agreed to be determined by the audit result or the fiscal review conclusion and that result is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract (or not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor), the people's court shall permit the contractor's application for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost, and the final price is re-determined by the assessment on the basis of the pricing standards and pricing methods agreed in the contract; the reasonable period follows any agreement, and absent agreement is determined comprehensively by the court but may not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final account documents; where pricing by audit/review conclusion was not agreed, the employer's request to determine the price by that conclusion is not supported (paragraph 3). The interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date (Article 23).

Applicable Codes

  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十三条、第二十三条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第十九条、第二十条、第二十一条、第二十九条
  • 最高人民法院〔2008〕民一他字第4号答复
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百五十九条
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第七十九条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.3.8条、第10.3.10条
  • 《保障中小企业款项支付条例》(2025修订,国务院令第802号)第十二条、第十四条

Topic Positioning

Where the contract stipulates that 'the construction price is determined by the audit result of the audit authority / the review conclusion of the government fiscal review institution', but that conclusion is manifestly inconsistent with the contract (or long unissued), can the contractor ask the court to re-determine the construction price through judicial expert assessment? This card sets out the three paragraphs of Article 13 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, the positive and negative scenarios for access to assessment, the commencement and cap of the reasonable period, and the temporal divide between the old and new rules.

Core Conclusion

1. Norm text (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13, three paragraphs in full) Paragraph 1: 'Where the employer and the contractor agree that the construction price is to be determined by the audit result of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the fiscal review institution, but the audit result or review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence proving that the audit result or review conclusion is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract, and the contractor applies for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost, the people's court shall permit it.' Paragraph 2: 'Where the parties have agreed on the reasonable period referred to in the preceding paragraph, the agreement prevails; absent agreement, the people's court determines it comprehensively by reference to the project scale, the amount of the construction cost, the complexity and other factors, provided that the period shall not exceed one year from the date the contractor submits the final account documents.' Paragraph 3: 'Where the employer and the contractor have not agreed that the construction price is to be determined by the audit result of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the fiscal review institution, and the employer requests that the construction price be determined by the audit result or review conclusion, the people's court shall not support it.'

2. Precise statement of the conclusion. The contractor obtains a right of access to judicial expert assessment, not 'the court directly re-prices under the contract'. Once the court permits the assessment, the assessment and the final pricing still follow the contract - Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 19(1): 'Where the parties have agreed on the pricing standard or the pricing method of the construction project, the project price shall be settled in accordance with the agreement.' The assessment opinion must therefore re-determine the price on the basis of the pricing standards and pricing methods agreed in the contract, and the parts of the audit conclusion that break through the contractual pricing rules are no longer adopted.

3. Positive scenarios (assessment permitted)

  1. Pricing agreed by audit/review conclusion, and the contractor has evidence proving that conclusion is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract (Article 13(1), latter half).
  2. Pricing agreed by audit/review conclusion, and the conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor (Article 13(1), former half). Reasonable period: agreement prevails; absent agreement the court determines it comprehensively by the project scale, the cost amount, the complexity and other factors, capped at one year from the contractor's submission of the final account documents (paragraph 2).
  3. Typical indicators of 'manifest inconsistency' in the audit conclusion: unilaterally altering the tendered all-in unit rates or the fee percentage rates, negating site instruction records and design changes already signed off, changing the contractual pricing method (e.g. from lump-sum to quota-norm based pricing), and repeated deduction of content already priced. Any of these supports a claim of 'manifest inconsistency with the construction contract'.
  4. Where the employer improperly prevents or delays fulfilment of the audit condition for its own benefit, under Article 159 of the Civil Code - 'in a conditional juristic act, where a party improperly prevents fulfilment of the condition for its own benefit, the condition is deemed fulfilled; where a party improperly promotes fulfilment of the condition, the condition is deemed not fulfilled' - the contractor may claim that the condition is deemed fulfilled and settle under the contract, which at the same time constitutes 'not issued within a reasonable period' under Article 13(1).
  5. Procedural basis: Civil Procedure Law (2023 Amendment), Article 79 - 'A party may apply to the people's court for expert assessment on specialised questions for ascertaining facts. Where a party applies for assessment, the qualified assessor shall be determined by negotiation between the parties; failing negotiation, the people's court designates one. Where no party applies but the people's court deems assessment necessary for a specialised question, it shall entrust a qualified assessor.'

4. Negative scenarios (assessment not permitted / pricing by audit conclusion not supported)

  1. No agreement on pricing by audit/review conclusion, yet the employer requests determining the price by the audit result or review conclusion - not supported (Article 13(3)); settlement follows the pricing standards and methods agreed in the contract (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 19(1)).
  2. Differences that are merely normal review reductions within the contractual pricing rules (deducting quantities per actual measurement, removing over-estimation and padding, correcting arithmetic errors) - not 'manifest inconsistency'; the application for assessment is not permitted (a contrario reading of Article 13(1)).
  3. The parties reached an agreement on settlement of the price before litigation - an application for cost assessment made in litigation is not permitted (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 29). A 'settlement review closing sheet / audit result confirmation form' signed by the contractor is usually recognised as a settlement agreement.
  4. The contract stipulates 'failure by the employer to respond within the agreed period after receiving the final account documents is deemed approval', and that condition is fulfilled - settlement follows the final account documents submitted by the contractor, and no assessment is needed (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21: 'Where the parties agree that, if the employer fails to respond within the agreed period after receiving the final account documents, it is deemed to have approved the final account documents, the matter shall be handled as agreed. Where the contractor requests settlement of the project price per the final account documents, the people's court shall support it.'); GB/T 50500-2024, Article 10.3.8 provides in the same direction: where the employer, within the agreed time after receiving the final account documents, fails to check them as agreed or raises no checking opinion, the final account documents submitted by the contractor are deemed approved by the employer and the final account is confirmed.
  5. The contract expressly commits specific elements to audit determination (e.g. 'quantities are subject to the audit-verified figures', 'material prices are subject to the audit findings'), and the contractor resiles only as to that agreed element - the audit conclusion stands within the scope of that agreement ([2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4: where the construction contract expressly agrees that the fiscal-investment review conclusion serves as the settlement basis, the review conclusion shall serve as the settlement basis).

5. The two-track separation of audit supervision and civil settlement (basis of the rule) The [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4 reply makes clear: 'The appraisal and review of fiscal investment by the finance department is the state's supervision and administration of the construction unit's capital construction funds, and does not affect the validity and performance of the contract between the construction unit and the contractor. However, where the construction contract expressly agrees that the fiscal-investment review conclusion serves as the settlement basis, the review conclusion shall serve as the settlement basis.' That is: audit/fiscal review is not per se a statutory precondition of civil settlement; its conclusion enters the settlement only through contractual agreement; and once the conclusion departs from the contractual pricing rules, it loses the qualification to 'determine the price as agreed'. Administrative complement: Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (2025 Revision, State Council Order No. 802), Article 12 - 'State organs, public institutions and large state-owned enterprises may not compel the use of the audit authority's audit result as the settlement basis, except as otherwise provided by laws or administrative regulations' (the exception 'otherwise agreed in the contract' formerly in Article 11 of the 2020 State Council Order No. 728 version has been deleted).

6. Temporal divide (application of old vs new rules) Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 23: 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. First-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect are governed by this Interpretation. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails.'

  • First-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026: Article 13 applies (including 'manifest inconsistency / unissued beyond one year permits assessment' and 'absent agreement, the price may not be determined by the audit conclusion').
  • First-instance cases accepted before that date: this Interpretation does not apply; the rules then in force still govern (mainly the line of the [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4 reply: where the fiscal-investment review conclusion is agreed as the settlement basis, the review conclusion serves as such), and the relief available for 'manifest inconsistency' is markedly narrower.

Scope and Limits

  • This applies only where the contract expressly agrees that the price is determined by the audit result of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the fiscal review institution; absent such agreement, the case falls directly to Article 13(3) and the contractual agreement, and 'manifest inconsistency' need not be discussed.
  • The one-year cap on the reasonable period runs from the contractor's submission of the final account documents; the contractor must therefore first effect valid service of the settlement documents and keep the proofs of service/mailing; the one year is a cap, not a fixed period, and any agreement prevails.
  • The burden of proof lies on the contractor: to claim 'manifest inconsistency', it must take the contractual pricing clauses as the benchmark and itemise, with amounts, the deviations of the audit conclusion from the contract (all-in unit rates, percentage rates, quantities, variation records, pricing method); to claim 'overdue for reasons not attributable to it', it must prove that the settlement documents were submitted and demands were issued while the audit still did not issue. Mere objection without a quantified comparison is usually not recognised as 'manifest inconsistency'.
  • Relief for 'manifest inconsistency' and 'deemed approval upon overdue silence' are two mutually exclusive substantive tracks (the former recalculates under the contract, the latter per the submitted price); they should be pleaded in primary and alternative layers rather than claimed cumulatively; once a settlement agreement has been reached (including a signed audit result confirmation form), both tracks are in principle blocked.
  • Article 23 applies by the divide of 'first-instance cases newly accepted by the court'; in arbitration, application depends on the parties' agreement and the tribunal's reliance on the judicial interpretations, and the acceptance-date divide cannot be transplanted directly.
  • Audit as an administrative supervision procedure still runs under the Audit Law, on a track separate from civil settlement relief; this card does not deny the validity of audit conclusions at the administrative supervision level.

Further Reading

  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes, Article 13 (audit/fiscal review conclusions and access to judicial expert assessment) and Article 23 (entry into force and old-new transition); full text on the release page of the Supreme People's Court website.
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes, Article 19 (settlement per the agreed pricing standard or method; where a design change alters quantities or quality standards and no agreement is reached, reference may be made to the pricing method or standard published by the local construction administrative authority at contracting), Article 20 (quantity disputes confirmed by the site records and other written documents formed during construction; where consent to construct is proved but no record exists, the actual quantities may be confirmed by other evidence), Article 21 (deemed approval of the final account documents upon overdue silence), Article 29 (assessment not permitted where a settlement agreement was reached before litigation).
  • Civil Code of the PRC, Article 159 (deemed fulfilment where a party improperly prevents or promotes a condition); Civil Procedure Law (2023 Amendment), Article 79 (application for assessment on specialised questions and determination of the assessor).
  • SPC [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4, Reply on how the review conclusions issued by fiscal review centres are to be determined in construction contract dispute cases tried by the people's courts.
  • GB/T 50500-2024, China national pricing standard for BOQ, Article 10.3.8 (deemed approval of the final account documents where the employer fails to check in time or raises no opinion) and Article 10.3.10 (procedure of entrusting a cost consultant to check, the contractor's written objection to the checking result and deemed approval).
  • Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (2025 Revision, State Council Order No. 802), Article 12 (may not compel the audit result as the settlement basis) and Article 14 (may not refuse or delay payment on the ground of awaiting completion record filing or final-account audit).
  • Related extensions: whether an 'audit prevails' clause can indefinitely delay settlement (the relation between audit supervision and civil settlement), the concurrence of 'deemed approval upon overdue silence' and 'application for judicial assessment' and the layering of primary and alternative claims, and the overall impact of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 on the existing rules - see the dedicated cards cited by this card.

Keywords

Cited By