Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-26

The overlap of the two routes of 'deemed approval of the submitted final account upon failure to reply in time' and 'applying for judicial construction cost expert assessment' when the employer delays the audit or the government fiscal review: comparison of requirements, whether both may be asserted, and how to plead primary and alternative claims

The two routes may be raised side by side but only as layered primary and alternative claims; they cannot stand as two simultaneously granted claims, nor can the higher of the submitted price and the expert assessment price be taken: asserting 'deemed approval' (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21) means the price is already determined under the contract, applying for expert assessment (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13) means the price is undetermined and must be recalculated - their substantive effects are mutually exclusive; and Article 29 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 bars an application for construction cost expert assessment where a settlement agreement was reached before litigation, so on adjudication only one of the two can stand. Where no period is agreed, the reasonable period under Article 13 is fixed by the court in the round, but must not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final account documents.

Applicable Codes

  • 法释〔2026〕12号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)第十三条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)第二十一条、第二十九条、第三十二条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第10.3.8条
  • 住建部令第16号 建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法 第十八条
  • 国务院令第728号 保障中小企业款项支付条例 第十一条
  • 最高人民法院〔2008〕民一他字第4号答复

Topic positioning

Where the employer delays the audit or the government fiscal review of the project cost, the contractor faces two remedies: Route A, seeking a ruling that the submitted final account is deemed approved upon the lapse of the response period, and Route B, applying for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost: their normative bases and requirements, whether both may be asserted at once, how to layer the claims in litigation, and the order of application when the contract contains both types of clause.

Core conclusions

I. Normative bases and requirements of the two routes (key sentences of the original preserved)

Route A: seeking deemed approval of the submitted final account

  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21: 'Where the parties agree that, if the employer fails to reply within the agreed period after receiving the final account documents, the final account documents are deemed approved, the matter shall be handled as agreed. Where the contractor claims settlement of the works price according to the final account documents, the people's court shall support it.'
  • GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.8: 'Where the employer, within the agreed time after receiving the contractor's final account documents, neither checks the final account as agreed in the contract nor comments on the checking, the final account documents submitted by the contractor shall be deemed approved by the employer and the confirmation of the final account is complete.'
  • MOHURD Order No. 16 (Measures for the Administration of Pricing in the Award and Contracting of Construction Works, issued 11 December 2013, effective 1 February 2014), Article 18 item (2): 'An awarding party of a state-funded construction project shall engage a construction cost consultancy with the corresponding qualification to review the final account documents and, within the agreed period after receiving them, give the contractor a review opinion on the final account documents issued by the consultancy; where it fails to reply in time, the matter shall be handled as agreed in the contract, and where the contract makes no provision the final account documents shall be deemed approved.' (The former Ministry of Construction Order No. 107 was repealed by this Order; cite Article 18 of this Order instead when invoking the regulatory basis.)
  • Requirements: (1) the contract expressly agrees that 'failure to reply within the period is deemed approval'; (2) the final account documents were served and the data are complete; (3) the agreed period expired without reply.
  • Legal nature: substantively determines the price (a deemed settlement consensus); no further ascertainment of the cost is needed.

Route B: applying for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost

  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13: 'Where the employer and the contractor agree that the works price is to be determined by the audit conclusion of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the government fiscal review institution, but the audit conclusion or review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence that the audit conclusion or review conclusion is clearly inconsistent with the construction contract, and the contractor applies for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost, the people's court shall permit it. The reasonable period referred to in the preceding paragraph is as agreed by the parties; absent agreement, the people's court determines it in the round having regard to the scale of the works, the amount of the construction cost, the complexity and other factors, but the period must not exceed one year from the date the contractor submits the final account documents. Where the employer and the contractor have not agreed that the works price is to be determined by the audit conclusion of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the government fiscal review institution, and the employer requests determination of the works price by the audit conclusion or review conclusion, the people's court shall not support it.'
  • Requirements: (1) an agreement that the works price is determined by the audit conclusion or the fiscal review conclusion; (2) the audit/review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence that it is clearly inconsistent with the construction contract; (3) reasonable period: as agreed if agreed; absent agreement the court fixes it in the round considering the scale of the works, the amount of the cost, the complexity and other factors, but it must not exceed one year from the date the contractor submits the final account documents.
  • Reverse rule (paragraph 3 of Article 13): absent an agreement to determine the price by the audit/review conclusion, the employer's request to determine the price by that conclusion is not supported.
  • Supporting basis: Article 11 of the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (State Council Order No. 728): 'State organs, public institutions and large state-owned enterprises may not compel the use of the audit conclusions of audit authorities as the basis of settlement, except where the contract provides otherwise or laws and administrative regulations provide otherwise'; and the SPC Reply Min Yi Ta Zi [2008] No. 4: 'The fiscal department's review and audit of fiscal investment is the state's supervision and administration of the construction unit's capital construction funds and does not affect the validity and performance of the contract between the construction unit and the builder. However, where the construction contract expressly agrees that the fiscal review conclusion is the basis of settlement, the review conclusion shall be the basis of settlement.'
  • Legal nature: a means of evidence; redetermines the cost.

II. Can both be asserted at once: they may be raised side by side, but only layered as primary and alternative claims

They cannot stand as two simultaneously granted claims, nor can one hope to 'take the higher of both ends'. Three blocks:

  1. Logical self-contradiction (the most practical risk): asserting 'deemed approval' means the documents have already fixed the price; asserting expert assessment means the price is unfixed and needs third-party recalculation. If pleaded side by side without hierarchy, the employer need only point out that 'the contractor itself does not accept the submitted price and has asked for a recalculation' to attack the very basis of Article 21.
  2. The blocking effect of Article 29 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'Where the parties have already reached an agreement on the settlement of the construction project price before litigation, an application by either party in the litigation for expert assessment of the construction cost shall not be permitted.' 'Deemed approval' is strictly speaking not a consensual agreement, but once the court finds it established the price is determined under the contract and the assessment application is usually dismissed for lack of necessity; and vice versa - permission of the assessment amounts to a finding that 'deemed approval' is not established.
  3. No 'better of the two' rule: the same works payment can be determined on one basis only; the court will not award the contractor the higher of the submitted price and the assessment price.

Practical pleading: primary claim - a ruling that settlement follows the contractor's submitted final account documents (the submitted price) plus judgment for the outstanding amount; alternative claim - permission for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost and settlement per its conclusion. Both claims share the same factual basis (the documents were served; the employer did not reply within the agreed period); they do not conflict at the factual level and are mutually exclusive only at the level of the claims, so they may be listed in layers without amounting to an admission against the submitted price.

Burden of proof for the assessment: Article 32 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'Where the parties dispute specialized issues such as the construction cost, quality or repair costs and the people's court considers expert assessment necessary, it shall explain this to the party bearing the burden of proof. If that party, after the explanation, does not apply for assessment, or applies but does not pay the assessment fee or refuses to provide the relevant materials, it shall bear the legal consequences of failure of proof. If the party bearing the burden of proof did not apply for assessment at first instance, or applied but did not pay the fee or refused to provide materials, and applies at second instance, and the people's court considers it truly necessary, it shall deal with it under item (3) of paragraph 1 of Article 170 of the Civil Procedure Law.'

III. Order of application when the contract contains both 'settlement subject to the audit conclusion' and 'deemed approval upon lapse'

  • The two layers govern different things: the audit clause answers 'on what figure' (the basis of settlement), not 'when to reply / when to pay' (the settlement procedure). Delegating the checking and reply duty to the audit authority does not automatically extend the contractual reply period - if the audit is overdue with no conclusion, 'the agreed period expired without reply' is made out and Route A can stand.
  • If the contract expressly makes the issuance of the audit/review conclusion a precondition of settlement or payment, or ties the reply period directly to the completion of the audit, the precondition of Route A is unfulfilled: take Route B (apply for assessment), or invoke the cap in Article 13 of one year from the submission of the final account documents to defeat indefinite delay.
  • Route B carries a burden of proof: that the audit/review conclusion was issued late 'for reasons not attributable to the contractor', or is 'clearly inconsistent with the construction contract' (e.g. the review basis, charging standards or quantities run against the contract); the burden lies on the contractor.

Applicable boundaries

  • The absolute premise of Route A is an express contractual agreement on 'deemed approval upon failure to reply'; claims resting only on regulations, model contract texts or the deemed-approval rule of GB/T 50500-2024 (a recommended national standard) are unsupported by most courts - the national standard rule can be incorporated by the contract as a contractual obligation but cannot independently replace the agreement.
  • Route B presupposes 'an agreement that the works price is determined by the audit/review conclusion'; absent agreement the employer cannot unilaterally close the case on the audit conclusion (Article 13 paragraph 3), and there is no need to detour through expert assessment - settle per the pricing method agreed in the contract.
  • The 'one year' is the cap of the reasonable period, not an automatic expiry; whether it is agreed and has run must be judged case by case on the completeness of the submitted data, when the audit started and the like.
  • Temporal effect: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 is a recently issued judicial interpretation; whether it applies to a case turns on its entry into force and when the case was accepted.
  • This card analyses the application of the provisions and the structure of the claims; it does not replace counsel's opinion or the court's discretion in a specific case.

Further reading

Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 21, 29 and 32; GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.8 (and the clauses on the checking, review and payment of the final account); MOHURD Order No. 16, Measures for the Administration of Pricing in the Award and Contracting of Construction Works, Article 18 (the former Ministry of Construction Order No. 107 is repealed - do not cite it again); Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (State Council Order No. 728), Article 11; SPC Reply Min Yi Ta Zi [2008] No. 4 on how review conclusions issued by fiscal review centres should be treated in construction contract dispute cases.

Keywords

Cited By