The validity of a construction (sub)contract for a specialist work carried at a provisional price within the general contracting scope where the law required tendering but none was conducted: the elements of invalidity, the scope of invalidity, the exception outlet, and the consequences of price-based compensation
Where a specialist work is included within the general contracting scope at a provisional price, falls within the scope of projects subject to compulsory tendering by law, and meets the size threshold (estimated price of a single construction contract above CNY 4 million, or procurable purchases in the same project that can be combined reaching the threshold in total), concluding a construction (sub)contract without tendering falls under 'compulsory tendering required but not conducted' in Article 1, paragraph 1, item (3) of Interpretation (I) (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), and the contract is void under Civil Code Article 153, paragraph 1; the invalidity in principle reaches only that provisional-price part and not the whole general contract lawfully concluded through tendering. Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12), Article 1, creates an exception: where the project was subject to compulsory tendering at contract conclusion but no longer is at the time of suit, the court should not find the contract void merely for want of tendering. If, after invalidity, the works pass acceptance, the contractor is compensated by reference to the price provisions agreed in the contract (Civil Code Article 793, paragraph 1); 'by reference' includes the amount, the pricing method, the payment time, the adjustment method, and the settlement method (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 11).
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》(主席令第45号)第一百五十三条、第一百五十六条、第七百九十一条、第七百九十三条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》法释〔2020〕25号 第一条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》法释〔2026〕12号 第一条、第十一条(2026年6月30日施行)
- 《中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例》(国务院令第709号,2019修订)第二十九条
- 《必须招标的工程项目规定》(国家发展和改革委员会令第16号)第二条至第五条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.4.1条、第8.4.7条、第8.10节
Positioning of the topic
Answers a frequent dispute: a specialist work within the general contracting scope is carried as a provisional price item, falls within the scope of projects subject to compulsory tendering by law and meets the size threshold, but the employer / general contractor, without organising a second-round tender, signs a construction (sub)contract for it - how is the validity of that contract determined: the conclusion, the elements, the exception outlet, and the pricing consequences after invalidity.
Core conclusions
1. Conclusion: void in principle, but the invalidity reaches only the contract for the provisional-price part. The chain of reasoning: statutory duty of second-round tendering -> no tendering -> 'compulsory tendering required but not conducted' -> mandatory provision affecting validity -> contract void.
2. Source of the duty (Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 29, full text) 'The tenderee may, in accordance with law, tender general contracts for the works as a whole or in part, and for goods and services related to the works. Where works, goods, or services included within the general contracting scope at provisional prices fall within the scope of projects subject to compulsory tendering by law and meet the state-prescribed size thresholds, they shall be tendered in accordance with law. The provisional price in the preceding paragraph means the amount of works, goods, or services that the tenderee provisionally estimates in the tender documents because the price cannot be determined at the general contract tender.' That is: the general contract tender cannot substitute for the second-round tender of the provisional-price part; the second tender is a statutory duty. The tendering entity and the organisation model (employer tendering / general contractor tendering / joint tendering by both) should be agreed in the general contract.
3. Basis of the invalidity (Interpretation (I), Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 1, full text) 'A construction contract shall be found void under Article 153, paragraph 1 of the Civil Code where any of the following circumstances applies: (1) the contractor has not obtained a construction enterprise qualification or exceeds its qualification grade; (2) an actual constructor without qualification borrows the name of a qualified construction enterprise; (3) the construction was subject to compulsory tendering but was not tendered, or the award was invalid. Construction contracts that the contractor signs with others after transferring or unlawfully subcontracting the construction works shall be found void under Article 153, paragraph 1 and Article 791, paragraphs 2 and 3 of the Civil Code.' The governing superior law (Civil Code Article 153, paragraph 1): 'A civil juristic act that violates a mandatory provision of a law or administrative regulation is void, except where that mandatory provision does not lead to the invalidity of the civil juristic act.'
4. The size thresholds (Provisions on Projects Subject to Compulsory Tendering, NDRC Order No. 16, Article 5, full text) 'For projects within the scope of Articles 2 to 4 of these Provisions, where the procurement of survey, design, construction, supervision, and important equipment and materials related to the works meets any of the following standards, tendering is compulsory: (1) the estimated price of a single construction contract is above CNY 4 million; (2) for the procurement of important equipment, materials, and other goods, the estimated price of a single contract is above CNY 2 million; (3) for the procurement of survey, design, supervision, and other services, the estimated price of a single contract is above CNY 1 million. Where the procurement of survey, design, construction, supervision, and important equipment and materials related to the works within the same project can be combined, and the combined total of the estimated contract prices reaches the standards of the preceding paragraph, tendering is compulsory.' Note the final paragraph: splitting purchases into pieces below CNY 4 million to evade tendering is judged by the combined estimated prices of purchases 'that can be combined', and tendering remains compulsory.
5. The elements and points of proof (item by item)
- The project falls within the compulsory tendering scope: per Order No. 16, Articles 2 to 4 (state-owned funds holding a controlling or dominant position, use of budget funds above CNY 2 million and above 10% of the investment, and other scenarios) - prove the project approval / feasibility reply, evidence of funding sources, the fiscal budget allocation, and documents on the state capital contribution ratio.
- The specialist work is 'included within the general contracting scope at a provisional price': prove the general tender documents, the 'specialist works provisional price schedule' of the bill of quantities, and the particular conditions of the general contract; the specialist works provisional price is a VAT-inclusive price.
- The size threshold is met (above CNY 4 million, or combined procurable purchases reaching it): prove the subcontract price, the tender price ceiling / estimate book, and the final account documents; check whether the scope was split to evade.
- No tendering, or evasion of tendering by other means: prove that the public resources trading platform / designated media carry no tender notice and no award publication, that there is no notice of award, no evaluation report, and no tender documents; and that the contract was signed before any tendering procedure.
- Compulsory tendering at contract conclusion (the timing element): judge by the contract signing date plus the scope/threshold rules in force on that date; do not reason back from later policy changes.
- Still compulsory tendering at the time of suit (excluding the exception outlet): prove the case-filing date, and whether the project nature and funding sources had changed by the time of suit.
6. The exception outlet (Interpretation (II), Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 1, full text) 'Where a construction contract was concluded for a project subject to compulsory tendering at the time of contract conclusion, the parties concluded the contract without tendering, and at the time of suit the project no longer falls within projects subject to compulsory tendering, the people's court should not find the contract void merely on the ground that no tendering was conducted.' Both time points must be hit together - 'compulsory at conclusion' + 'no longer compulsory at suit' - before voidness for want of tendering can be resisted; where the project is still subject to compulsory tendering at suit, this does not apply.
7. The scope of invalidity The invalidity in principle reaches only the contract corresponding to the untendered provisional-price part; where the general contract itself was lawfully concluded through tendering, it is not void as a whole merely because the provisional-price part was not re-tendered (partial invalidity, Civil Code Article 156). The conclusion and the claims must clearly distinguish 'the whole general contract void' from 'the provisional-price part void'.
8. Treatment after invalidity (Civil Code Article 793, full text) 'Where a construction contract is void but the construction works have passed acceptance, the contractor may be compensated by reference to the price provisions agreed in the contract. Where a construction contract is void and the construction works have failed acceptance, the following applies: (1) where the works pass acceptance after repair, the employer may request the contractor to bear the repair costs; (2) where the works still fail acceptance after repair, the contractor has no right to request compensation by reference to the price provisions agreed in the contract. Where the employer is at fault for the losses caused by the unqualified works, it shall bear the corresponding liability.' The scope of 'by reference' (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 11, full text): 'In the provision of Article 793, paragraph 1 of the Civil Code on compensation by reference to the price provisions agreed in the construction contract, such reference includes the price amount, the pricing method, the payment time, the adjustment method, and the settlement method agreed in the construction contract, and related content.' Hence 'the contract is void' cannot be used to claim re-pricing under the quota norms or payment at the date of suit.
9. Validity and pricing where compulsory tendering does not apply Where the work falls outside the compulsory tendering scope, or below the size threshold, the absence of tendering does not itself affect validity; the question reduces to the price confirmation procedure for the provisional price (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 8.4.7: the contractor may, by the method agreed in the contract, enquire and procure, and upon the employer's confirmation substitute for the provisional price; or the employer and the contractor may jointly tender to fix the VAT-inclusive specialist subcontract price). Conversely, where compulsory tendering applies, the tendered pre-tax material price / VAT-inclusive specialist subcontract price replaces the provisional price to adjust the contract price (Clause 8.4.1).
Scope of application
- Time-effect boundary: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 takes effect on 30 June 2026; its time-effect provision (Article 23) takes 'first-instance construction contract cases newly accepted after effectiveness' as the principle, and cases accepted earlier follow the rules then applicable. The Article 1 exception outlet is open only to cases newly accepted after the boundary.
- This card concerns civil contract validity; the administrative liability for not tendering (fines, ordered rectification, etc.) is handled separately under the Tendering and Bidding Law and runs in parallel with, not in place of, the civil validity question.
- 'Compulsory tendering' is judged by the head of the specific procurement: construction, goods, and services carry different size thresholds; specialist works follow the construction head of CNY 4 million, materials and equipment the goods head of CNY 2 million.
- A project outside compulsory tendering, or one that has left the scope by the time of suit, does not support a direct 'void' conclusion; the latter means only that the court 'should not find void merely for want of tendering' - invalidity for other statutory grounds (no qualification, borrowed qualification, contract transfer, unlawful subcontracting, etc.) is not excluded.
- Determining contract validity is within the authority of the court or the arbitral tribunal; a construction cost expert assessment witness should not decide validity on its own.
Further reading
- Civil Code Article 153, paragraph 1 (mandatory provisions affecting validity), Article 156 (partial invalidity), Article 791, paragraphs 2 and 3 (prohibition of contract transfer and unlawful subcontracting), Article 793 (price-based compensation on invalidity).
- SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), Article 1; SPC Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12), Articles 1, 11, and 23 (effective 30 June 2026).
- Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law (State Council Decree No. 709, 2019 revision), Article 29 (general contract tendering and the definition of provisional price), Article 29, paragraph 1; Provisions on Projects Subject to Compulsory Tendering (NDRC Order No. 16), Articles 2 to 5.
- GB/T 50500-2024, national standard for BOQ-based pricing of construction works, Clause 8.4.1 (compulsorily tendered provisional prices replaced by the awarded price), Clause 8.4.7 (determination of provisional prices not subject to compulsory tendering), Section 8.10 (determination of specialist works prices).
- Extensions: judging and organising the second-round tender, and the VAT-inclusive price confirmation rules, see the cited cards; for the expert assessment approach to price-based compensation after invalidity, see the cited card.
Keywords
- 暂估价专业工程
- 必须招标未招标
- 建设工程施工合同无效
- 建工解释一第一条
- 建工解释二第一条
- 二次招标
- 折价补偿
- 招标投标法实施条例第二十九条