Trigger table for the +/-15% quantity deviation threshold: the three outcomes of retaining the original price, adjusting the rate and deriving new rates, and the dividing lines between them (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2 and 8.9.3)
Under GB/T 50500-2024 the 15% mark is only a threshold on quantity, and it decides only between 'retain the original price' and 'adjust the rate': where the billed quantity of a BOQ item increases or decreases by no more than 15% (15% included) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for that item, the all-in unit rate is set under Article 8.9.1 (item 1: same conditions plus same item description, adopt the contract rate, that is, retain the original price; item 2: similar item description or similar conditions, convert the contract rate of an analogous BOQ item; items 3 to 5: negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate, in substance deriving new rates); where the change exceeds 15% (15% excluded), Article 8.9.2 applies: with an increase, the contract rate and the new all-in unit rates are reasonably reduced to reflect the discounts on labour and material procurement prices; with a decrease, they are reasonably increased to reflect the loss of those discounts. A change of exactly 15% (inclusive) does not trigger the rate-adjustment tier. 'Deriving new rates' is triggered not by quantity but by changes in the item description or the construction conditions; the two lines are independent and can combine.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.2.1条、第8.9.1条、第8.9.2条、第8.9.3条、第7.1/7.2/7.4节
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第9.6.2条、第9.6.3条、第9.3.1条
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 · Work Guideline for Construction Cost Appraisal 第4.4.4条
Positioning
Answers 'at what quantity deviation must the all-in unit rate be adjusted, and at what point must new rates be derived'. Core judgement: the +/-15% mark is only a threshold on quantity, and it decides only between 'retain the original rate' and 'adjust the rate'; 'deriving new rates' is triggered not by quantity but by whether the item description or the construction conditions have changed. The two lines are independent and can combine. Basis: Articles 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2 and 8.9.3 of GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ (unit-rate contracts in the main); GB 50500-2013 has been superseded and applies only where a contract still cites the old standard.
Core conclusions
1. Verbatim text of the 15% dividing rule (do not paraphrase) Article 8.2.1, item 1: 'Where BOQ errors cause changes to BOQ items (items added or deleted), or where the billed quantity increases or decreases by no more than 15% (15% included) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the corresponding BOQ item, the contract price shall be calculated and adjusted in accordance with Article 8.9.1 of this Standard.' Item 2: 'Where BOQ errors cause the billed quantity of a BOQ item to increase or decrease by more than 15% (15% excluded) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the corresponding BOQ item, the contract price shall be calculated and adjusted in accordance with Article 8.9.2 of this Standard.' That is: a change of exactly 15% does not enter the rate-adjustment tier (15% inclusive belongs to 8.9.1); only strictly more than 15% (15% excluded) triggers an upward or downward rate adjustment. The comparison base is 'the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the corresponding BOQ item', unlike the 2013 edition, which compared item by item against 'the quantity Q0 listed in the tender BOQ'.
2. Trigger table for the +/-15% threshold (unit-rate contracts, GB/T 50500-2024)
| Tier | Quantity change | Item description / construction conditions | Pricing outcome | Clause |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I | Change of no more than 15% (15% included), or BOQ items change (items added or deleted) | Same conditions + same item description | Retain the original price: adopt the corresponding contract rate | 8.9.1 item 1 |
| II | No more than 15% (15% included) | Same conditions + similar item description, or similar conditions + same item description | Rate conversion (partial adjustment): adopt the all-in unit rate obtained by converting the contract rate of an analogous BOQ item (only the differing elements are converted; the overhead and profit levels are retained) | 8.9.1 item 2 |
| IIIa | No more than 15% (15% included) | Same conditions + different item description, or different conditions + same item description | Derive new rates (negotiated): negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate with reference to the pricing rules and tender level of the contract rates of analogous items | 8.9.1 item 3 |
| IIIb | No more than 15% (15% included) | Different conditions + different item description | Derive new rates (negotiated): negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate with reference to the all-in unit rates of analogous BOQ items of similar works | 8.9.1 item 4 |
| IIIc | BOQ items reduced or cancelled | Construction conditions during execution significantly changed | Derive new rates (negotiated): negotiate the variation all-in unit rate according to the actual circumstances of the executed works, the market prices, the pricing rules of contract rates and the tender level | 8.9.1 item 5 |
| IVa | Change of more than 15% (15% excluded) | Quantity increase | Adjust the rate (downward): on the basis of 8.9.1, reasonably reduce the contract rate and the new all-in unit rates to reflect the labour and material procurement price discounts brought by the increased quantity | 8.9.2 item 1 (entry via 8.2.1 item 2) |
| IVb | Change of more than 15% (15% excluded) | Quantity decrease | Adjust the rate (upward): reasonably increase the contract rate and the new all-in unit rates to reflect the loss of the labour and material procurement price discounts brought by the decreased quantity | 8.9.2 item 2 |
3. Verbatim sentences of the decision logic (the expositions of Articles 8.9.1, 8.9.2 and 8.9.3 agree): 'The price of a worked-item BOQ entry is influenced mainly by such elements as the item description, the construction conditions and the quantity; by analysing and comparing these price-influencing elements, the employer and the contractor can judge whether the BOQ item is suited to applying the contract rate, or to adjusting the rate or deriving new rates.'
4. Triggers for deriving new rates (independent of quantity) New rates are derived only where at least one of the two dimensions, 'different item description' and 'different construction conditions', has changed and no analogous rate can be applied: a single-dimension change (item 3) leads to negotiation with reference to the pricing rules and tender level of the contract rates of analogous items; a two-dimension change (item 4) leads to negotiation with reference to the all-in unit rates of analogous BOQ items of similar works; the reduction or cancellation of items that significantly changes the construction conditions (item 5) leads to negotiation according to the actual circumstances and the market prices. The factors of changed description or conditions listed alongside Article 8.9.1: description-side factors include changes of materials, changes of construction method, and effects on other worked items; condition-side factors include changes to the foundations of the works, the height of the works, the specification of components (e.g. structural steel), the construction season, the protection of completed areas, restrictions on site access, the mode of material transport, the amount of plant used, and the coordination charge within the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions (increase or decrease of specialist subcontract quantities). Where neither the item description nor the construction conditions has changed, new rates may not be derived in place of the contract rate.
5. Lump-sum contracts (Article 8.9.3) Where the contract provides that the contract rates apply to the valuation of variations, and a variation causes changes to BOQ items and their quantities, the contract price may be adjusted under Articles 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 on the strength of the variation quantities calculated under Article 7.4.3; where the contract provides that the contract rates do not apply to the valuation of variations, the employer and the contractor negotiate the all-in unit rate according to the execution of the works and the market prices, with reference to the pricing rules and the tender level of the priced BOQ. Under a lump-sum contract the contract price and the time for completion are not adjusted for contract BOQ errors (except items priced at unit rates on provisional quantities).
6. Divergence from GB 50500-2013 Old standard, Article 9.6.2: 'For any tender BOQ item, where the quantity deviation exceeds 15% owing to the quantity deviation provided in this section and the variations provided in Section 9.3, an adjustment may be made. Where the quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the increased part of the quantity shall be reduced; where the quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the remaining part after the decrease shall be increased.' The 2013 edition expressly applies piecewise repricing to 'the increased part / the remaining part after the decrease' (S = 1.15Q0 x P0 + (Q1 - 1.15Q0) x P1; on a decrease, S = Q1 x P1), and Article 9.6.3 requires preliminaries priced by coefficient or as a single lump sum to be increased when quantities increase and decreased when they decrease. The 2024 edition's Article 8.9.2 deletes the word 'part' and says only that pricing follows 'after reasonably reducing (increasing) its contract rate and the new all-in unit rates', without indicating piecewise or whole-quantity repricing, so both readings exist in practice.
Boundaries of application
- Applies to determining all-in unit rates and adjusting the contract price for changes of item description, construction conditions or quantity under BOQ-priced contracts; GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard and agreed terms prevail: where the contract already provides 'no adjustment within the band', 'convert material price differentials only', or 'the contract rates do not apply to the valuation of variations', the agreed terms govern.
- The 15% test is applied item by item to each BOQ item; it must not be aggregated over a unit works or the whole BOQ; numerator and denominator must be on the same basis, the base being the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for that BOQ item.
- The changed quantities must be confirmed by the employer and the contractor under the procedures of Articles 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4 before pricing; unconfirmed quantities cannot be run through this table directly.
- Does not apply to price adjustment for fluctuation (Article 8.7 and the 5% risk band in Annex A), the determination of actual prices for provisional prices (Article 8.4), or changes of laws, regulations and policies (Article 8.8); each is an independent adjustment mechanism and must not be mixed with quantity-difference repricing.
- Rate conversion (8.9.1 item 2) is not repricing: only the differing elements are converted, and the levels of overheads and profit in the original contract rate are retained.
- Expert assessment position: under a unit-rate contract, where a party seeks adjustment of the all-in unit rates, the assessor assesses according to the agreed contract terms; where the tender and the construction used the same drawings and the actual quantity deviation exceeds the band agreed in the contract, the all-in unit rate of the part beyond the band may be adjusted, and where the contract sets no band, the national standard or industry practice applies.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024: Article 8.2.1 (re-measurement of unit-rate contracts and the 15% routing entry), Article 8.9.1 (five tiers for setting the all-in unit rate), Article 8.9.2 (direction of adjustment beyond 15%), Article 8.9.3 (valuation of variations under lump-sum contracts), Sections 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4 (confirmation of variations and BOQ errors, calculation of variation quantities), Articles 8.9.4 to 8.9.7 (linked preliminaries and the time limits for submission).
- GB 50500-2013: Articles 9.6.1 to 9.6.3 (including the pricing formulas for Q1 above 1.15Q0 and Q1 below 0.85Q0, and the definitions of S, Q1, Q0, P1 and P0), and Article 9.3.1 (three tiers of rates for variation items).
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Practice Guide for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Article 4.4.4 (assessment position on all-in unit rate adjustment caused by quantity deviation: the part beyond the band may be adjusted; where the contract sets no band, the national standard or industry practice applies).
Keywords
- 工程量偏差
- 15%阈值
- re-rating of unit rates
- derivation of new (built-up) rates
- 合同单价换算
- 8.9.1
- 8.9.2
- GB/T 50500-2024