Determining disputes over the supplied quantity of commercial (ready-mixed) concrete: measurement by total delivery of mixer trucks, per-truck delivery-note sign-off and the quantity objection period, drawing-based take-off as cross-check, and the paths of burden of proof and expert assessment
Ready-mixed concrete supply is measured by volume (m3) and calculated as the total delivered by mixer trucks (per-truck volume = actual truckload divided by the apparent density of the fresh concrete mix). In disputes the first-rank basis is the total of the per-truck delivery notes signed by the purchaser; drawing-based take-off serves only as a cross-check and must not outright replace the total-delivery basis (DB/T 29-184-2017 Clauses 6.4.1-6.4.3). Where the purchaser signs a delivery note stating quantity, type and specification, it is presumed to have inspected quantity and apparent defects (Civil Code Article 623); non-conforming quantity must be notified within the inspection period, and failure to notify in time is deemed conformity of quantity (Article 621). Where no signed evidence exists, the party may apply for an order that the other party produce documents under its control (Interpretation Article 112) or for judicial expert assessment (Civil Procedure Law Article 79); where an assessor refuses to attend the hearing despite notice, the opinion must not serve as the basis for finding facts (Article 81).
Applicable Codes
- DB/T 29-184-2017《天津市预拌混凝土质量管理规程》第6.4.1、6.4.2、6.4.3条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第621条、第623条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第67条、第79条、第81条
- 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(2022修正)第90、91、112条
- 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》(2019修正)第93、94、95条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第23条 https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
- 天津市住房和城乡建设委员会政府信息公开页 https://zfcxjs.tj.gov.cn/xxgk_70/xzfxxgk/xzfxxgknb/202301/t20230103_6067327.html
- 天津市住房和城乡建设委员会政府信息公开页 https://zfcxjs.tj.gov.cn/xxgk_70/xzfxxgk/xzfxxgknb/202401/t20240115_6509065.html
Scope of the Topic
How the quantity actually supplied is determined when a dispute arises over the supplied quantity of commercial (ready-mixed) concrete: the measurement basis (total delivery by mixer trucks versus solid volume from drawings), the elements and sign-off effect of the per-truck delivery note, the quantity objection period, and the paths of burden of proof and expert assessment. It applies to quantity disputes under concrete sale contracts between batching plants and purchasers (construction enterprises), and to measurement disputes over commercial concrete supplied within the construction contract.
Core Conclusions
I. Measurement basis: by volume, calculated as total delivery by mixer trucks
DB/T 29-184-2017, Tianjin Regulation on Quality Management of Ready-Mixed Concrete, Clause 6.4.3 'engineering and technical cooperation - supply quantity', original text:
- The supply quantity of ready-mixed concrete is measured by volume, in m3.
- The volume of ready-mixed concrete shall be obtained by dividing the actual load of the mixer truck by the apparent density of the fresh concrete mix.
- The supply quantity of ready-mixed concrete shall be calculated as the total quantity delivered by the mixer trucks.
That is: each truck's volume comes from (actual load divided by the apparent density of that load's mix), and the accumulated per-truck volumes give the total supplied; invoices and settlement sheets issued on that aggregate follow the same basis.
II. First-rank evidence: the per-truck delivery note (signed by the purchaser)
Clause 6.4.1 'delivery', key points of the original text: the supplier shall hand a delivery note to the purchaser with each mixer truck; the note shall include at least - contract number, delivery note number, purchaser, supplier, project name, pour position, concrete designation, quantity supplied on that truck (m3), mixer truck number, delivery place, delivery date, departure time and arrival time, special requirements, and the signatures of the handing-over personnel of supplier and purchaser (including the construction side); the purchaser shall confirm the above. 'Acceptance of ready-mixed concrete shall first check the relevant contents of the delivery note; where items failing the requirements are found, the construction enterprise has the right to refuse the load.'
Clause 6.4.2 'acceptance', key points of the original text: the purchaser shall assign dedicated personnel to accept promptly the concrete delivered to site (including slump and workability); 'after acceptance the personnel shall sign and confirm the delivery note and note the arrival and unloading times', so as to distinguish responsibility between supplier and purchaser and avoid disputes over unloading times.
Practice points: loads whose confirmation space is left blank, or which lack the truck number or that truck's volume, must not be mixed into the confirmed quantity - list them separately and prove them separately; where delivery-note numbers are discontinuous, skipped or back-filled, cross-check against the batching plant's production records (batches x mix design), weighbridge records, GPS tracks, invoices and payment reconciliations.
III. The legal effect of sign-off and the quantity objection period
Civil Code Article 623: where the parties have not agreed an inspection period and the buyer signs a delivery note or confirmation stating the quantity, type or specification of the subject matter, the buyer is presumed to have inspected the quantity and apparent defects, unless related evidence suffices to overturn the presumption.
Civil Code Article 621: where an inspection period is agreed, the buyer shall, within that period, notify the seller of any non-conformity of the quantity or quality of the subject matter; if the buyer delays notification, the quantity or quality is deemed conforming. Where no inspection period is agreed, the buyer shall notify the seller within a reasonable period after discovering, or being expected to discover, the non-conformity; if the buyer fails to notify within a reasonable period, or within two years from receipt of the subject matter, the quantity or quality is deemed conforming; however, where the subject matter has a quality guarantee period, that period applies and the two-year rule does not. Where the seller knew, or must have known, that the subject matter supplied was non-conforming, the buyer is not bound by the notification time limits of the preceding two paragraphs.
Inference: on-site sign-off plus a noted unloading time is the critical node for confirming quantity; a later claim of 'short volume' back-calculated from drawing quantities must be supported by contrary evidence sufficient to overturn the sign-off (calibration records of measuring instruments, records of other plants' loads mixed in, vouchers for returned loads not credited back, and the like).
IV. Drawing-based take-off is only a cross-check, not a substitute basis
Comparing the solid concrete volume calculated from the drawings (cast-in-place members not deducting the volume occupied by rebar and steel inserts) with the total delivered serves to reveal anomalies; where the difference exceeds the range allowed by the contract or the standard tolerance, first investigate the causes item by item (short loading, residues in transport and pumping, returned loads not credited back, other plants' loads mixed in, over-pouring past the formwork, structural dimension changes not synchronised) before characterising the difference; drawing quantities must not directly negate signed delivery quantities, nor may delivery quantities be used to infer inevitable short volume.
V. Burden of proof, orders to produce documents and expert assessment
Civil Procedure Law Article 67: a party has the responsibility to provide evidence for its own claims; evidence that a party or its agent ad litem cannot collect for objective reasons, or that the people's court considers necessary for the trial of the case, shall be investigated and collected by the people's court.
Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 90: a party shall provide evidence to prove the facts on which its own claims rest, or on which its rebuttal of the other party's claims rests; where a party fails to provide evidence, or the evidence is insufficient to prove its factual claim, the party bearing the burden of proof bears the adverse consequences. Article 91: a party asserting that a legal relationship exists shall bear the burden of proof for the basic facts giving rise to it; a party asserting that the legal relationship has changed or been extinguished, or that a right has been hindered, shall bear the burden of proof for those basic facts.
Article 112 (order to produce documents): where a document is under the control of the other party, the party bearing the burden of proof may, before the proof period expires, apply in writing to the people's court for an order that the other party produce it; where the application is well-founded, the people's court shall so order, and the costs thereby incurred are borne by the applicant; where the other party refuses to produce it without justified reason, the people's court may deem the contents of the document as asserted by the applicant to be true. Article 95 of the Evidence Rules is to the same effect: where a party controls evidence and refuses to produce it without justified reason, and the party bearing the burden of proof claims that its content is unfavourable to the person controlling it, the people's court may deem that claim established. -> The batching plant's production records, weighbridge records, delivery-note stubs and dispatching system data are all documents whose production may be sought.
The authenticity of electronic data is judged comprehensively under the seven factors of Article 93 of the Evidence Rules (whether the hardware and software environment of the system is complete and reliable; whether the system is in normal operation; whether effective error-monitoring and verification means exist; whether the data has been preserved, transmitted and extracted intact and by reliable methods; whether it was formed and stored in the course of ordinary dealings; whether the parties preserving, transmitting and extracting it are appropriate; other factors); Article 94 lists the situations where authenticity may be confirmed (data unfavourable to itself submitted or kept by a party; provided or confirmed by a neutral third-party platform; formed in normal business activity; kept by archive management; saved, transmitted or extracted in the agreed manner), and electronic data notarised by a notary office shall have its authenticity confirmed (unless contrary evidence suffices to overturn it).
Civil Procedure Law Article 79: a party may apply to the people's court for expert assessment of special questions of fact that need to be ascertained; where a party applies, the qualified assessor shall be agreed by both parties, failing which the people's court designates one; where no party applies but the people's court considers assessment of a special question necessary, the people's court shall entrust a qualified assessor. Article 81: where a party objects to the expert opinion, or the people's court considers it necessary for the assessor to appear, the assessor shall testify at the hearing; where the assessor, having been notified by the people's court, refuses to testify at the hearing, the expert opinion must not serve as the basis for finding facts, and the party that paid the assessment fee may demand its refund.
VI. Characterise first, then quantify: three relationship types, three rule sets
(1) the batching plant sues the purchaser (sale contract) - the 'delivered quantity' basis, centred on delivery-note sign-off and the quantity objection period; (2) settlement of employer-supplied concrete within the construction contract (employer-contractor relationship) - actual consumption verified as 'quantity actually drawn minus stock in hand', over-drawing deducted at the contract unit rates (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 3.6.3 and 3.6.4; T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.5.7), not on the sale-contract 'delivered quantity' basis; (3) internal responsibility costs of subcontractors and crews - per the contract, or per usage where the contract is silent.
Mischaracterisation (treating a sale contract as a works-payment dispute, or employer-supplied materials as a sale) is the commonest cause of defeat and of missed items in this class of case.
Applicability Boundaries
- The measurement and delivery-note rules address ready-mixed (commercial) concrete; concrete mixed on site, mortar and other materials are measured per the applicable standards and the contract.
- DB/T 29-184-2017 is a Tianjin local standard; its delivery-note elements and acceptance requirements apply directly within Tianjin's administrative area; other regions should check the local ready-mixed concrete management regulations and the contract, but 'by volume, calculated as total delivery by mixer trucks' is the basis in general industry use. The permissible deviation on delivered concrete quantity (whether within the agreed band) must be checked against the contract and the current text of GB/T 14902 and GB 50204 - clause numbers must not be cited from memory.
- The presumption from signing can be overturned by contrary evidence 'sufficient to overturn' it and is not absolute; but a quantity objection must be raised within the agreed or a reasonable inspection period; a late objection to quantity is deemed conformity, unless it can be shown that the supplier knew, or must have known, of the non-conformity.
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation (II), effective 30 June 2026, applies only to first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted by the people's courts after that date (Article 23) and does not apply directly to concrete sale contract disputes - the works-contract rules on quantity records and audit clauses must not be used to decide supply-quantity disputes.
- This card does not address the inspection and expert assessment of quality disputes such as concrete strength (handled under the quality-liability path), nor the determination of unit prices and settlement prices. With neither delivery vouchers nor production records nor any other chain of evidence, a claim of supplied quantity resting on drawing quantities alone is usually insufficient.
Further Reading
- DB/T 29-184-2017 Tianjin Regulation on Quality Management of Ready-Mixed Concrete, Clause 6.4.1 (delivery; delivery-note elements and refusal), Clause 6.4.2 (on-site acceptance, sign-off and unloading time), Clause 6.4.3 (calculation of supply quantity)
- Civil Code of the People's Republic of China, Article 621 (quantity and quality objection period and deemed conformity), Article 623 (signing the delivery note presumes inspection)
- Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment), Article 67 (burden of proof and collection by the court), Article 79 (applying for assessment and determining the assessor), Article 81 (the assessor's appearance and the consequences of refusal)
- Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law, Articles 90 and 91 (allocation of the burden of proof and adverse consequences), Article 112 (order to produce documents)
- Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, SPC Several Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure, Articles 85-97 (review and determination of evidence), Articles 93 and 94 (authenticity of electronic data), Article 95 (consequences of refusing to produce controlled evidence)
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation (II), Article 23 (effective date and applicability boundary), official text: https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
- Tianjin Municipal Housing and Urban-Rural Development Commission, government information disclosure pages (public channels for local regulations and normative documents): https://zfcxjs.tj.gov.cn/xxgk_70/xzfxxgk/xzfxxgknb/202301/t20230103_6067327.html and https://zfcxjs.tj.gov.cn/xxgk_70/xzfxxgk/xzfxxgknb/202401/t20240115_6509065.html
- For the quantity basis of settlement of employer-supplied concrete see also GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 3.6.3 and 3.6.4, and T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.5.7.
Keywords
- 商品混凝土供货数量
- 预拌混凝土发货单
- 以运输车发货总量计算
- 数量异议期与签收推定
- 按图算量复核
- 书证提出命令
- 司法鉴定申请
- DB/T 29-184-2017