Pricing comparison method for prefabricated supports versus site-fabricated supports: precondition test of the billing itemisation basis, item-by-item comparison of cost components (principal materials / wastage / fabrication labour and plant / anti-corrosion and galvanising / installation labour), comparison of fabrication and installation quota line items, and the code-based selection rule that favours prefabrication
Prefabricated supports (billed per set) and site-fabricated supports (steel sections priced by kg through fabrication plus installation quota line items) cannot be compared directly as CNY/kg against CNY/set. The billing itemisation basis must first be tested under GB/T 50856-2024 clause 3.0.10: without a special design requirement, supports and hangers are already included in the all-in unit rate for pipe installation and must not be listed separately; with a special design requirement (Annex N, code 031301), prefabricated supports are billed per set and supports and hangers per kg, while seismic supports are always coded as prefabricated supports per set and must not be converted into kg to apply fabrication line items. The cost component differences concentrate in four points: whether the principal materials include fittings, anchors and galvanising; site fabrication labour and hot-work cutting plant; consumables such as welding materials and gases; and the anti-corrosion grade (fabrication line items include ordinary anti-rust paint plus ready-mixed paint only, and hot-dip galvanising must be priced separately).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50856-2024 通用安装工程工程量计算标准 第3.0.10条、App. N(031301)、App. M
- SJG 77-2020 房屋建筑工程造价文件分部分项和措施项目划分标准 第6.10.1条
- GB 50981-2014 建筑机电工程抗震设计规范 第8.3.1条、第8.3.14条
- DB11/T 2382-2024 建设工程施工消耗量标准(安装册:一般管架制作/安装、成品抗震支架安装、成品管卡、铁构件金属支架制作/安装)
- DB11 1505-2017 城市综合管廊工程设计规范 第5.6.1条
- T CCES 28-2021 工业化建筑机电管线集成设计标准 第3.1.8条
- DB11/T 1832.22-2023 建筑工程施工工艺规程 第22部分:装配式装修工程 第12.4.9条
- T CIAS 2-2020 建筑机电施工图深化设计技术标准 第6.2.5条
- GB/T 13912 金属覆盖层 钢铁制件热浸镀锌层 技术要求及试验方法
- https://zjw.ningbo.gov.cn/art/2025/8/26/art_1229325543_1815507.html
- https://jst.zj.gov.cn/col/col1229129246/art/2023/art_d6a55ef8b954087b628902c940198600.html
- https://js.zibo.gov.cn/art/2019/4/15/art_3078_1696966.html
Topic positioning
Pricing comparison between prefabricated supports (factory-made, billed per 'set') and site-fabricated supports (steel sections priced by kg through fabrication plus installation quota line items): first test whether the two can be compared at all (the billing itemisation basis), then compare the cost components item by item, and finally fix the selection under the code rule favouring prefabrication. Applicable to BOQ preparation, rate build-up and quantity reconciliation for MEP piping, cable trays and seismic supports and hangers.
Core conclusions
1. Precondition: whether parallel comparison is possible depends on the billing itemisation basis
GB/T 50856-2024 'General Installation Works Measurement Standard' clause 3.0.10: 'The work content of the equipment, piping and fitting installation items in this standard all includes the fabrication, installation and painting of supports, hangers and base steel sections; where special design requirements exist, items shall be coded and listed under the corresponding items of Annex N Other and Ancillary Works or of Annex M Painting, Anti-corrosion and Insulation Works.'
- No special design requirement -> supports and hangers are not listed separately; their cost is already inside the all-in unit rate of the piping (equipment, fittings) installation item; the prefabricated-versus-site difference must not be billed as a separate item and can only go through material substitution, a design variation or the price approval procedure.
- Special design requirement -> listed separately under Annex N (code 031301): prefabricated supports are measured per 'set' (quantities shown on the design drawings), and supports, hangers and base steel sections per 'kg' (mass computed from the design dimensions); dedicated painting and anti-corrosion is listed under Annex M.
- Seismic supports -> under Annex N, 'seismic supports shall be coded and listed as prefabricated support items', measured per set, and must not be converted into kg to apply fabrication line items.
- Division attribution affects charging and quantity reconciliation: SJG 77-2020 clause 6.10.1, 'the support and hanger works division shall include seismic support and hanger works and combined support and hanger works, and shall not include general supports and hangers or prefabricated supports'; 'combined supports and hangers are supports and hangers shared compatibly by the various disciplines; general or prefabricated supports and hangers of each discipline shall be listed under the corresponding discipline of installation works.'
- Conclusion: only the portion of supports 'separately listed in the design and quotable either per set or per kg' admits a genuine prefabricated-versus-site-fabricated comparison.
2. Item-by-item comparison of cost components (pipe supports and hangers; consumption basis from the Beijing DB11/T 2382-2024 installation volume)
| Cost component | Prefabricated support (per set) | Site-fabricated support (per 100kg) | Key difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal materials | Prefabricated seismic support (with anchors) 1.000 sets per set; prefabricated pipe clamps 1.050 sets per unit | Steel sections 105 kg per 100kg (sub-item consumption), comprehensive steel 1.0505 kg/kg | Prefabricated includes fittings, anchors and packaging; site work buys black steel sections, with expansion bolts and connectors priced separately |
| Material wastage | Supports 0% (wastage already inside the prefabricated unit price); pipe clamps about 5% | Comprehensive steel wastage 5.05% | Site wastage is a quantifiable increment; prefabricated wastage is borne by the manufacturer |
| Fabrication labour | No fabrication process (factory cost already amortised into the unit price) | Fabrication of general pipe supports 4.27 workdays/100kg (comprehensive labour class II) | Site work adds a whole fabrication labour block: about 62% of the total site labour of 6.916 workdays/100kg |
| Fabrication plant | None (transport and lifting included) | Welding machines 2.062 + 1.805 = 3.867 machine-shifts/100kg; abrasive cut-off saws 2.707 machine-shifts/100kg; electric bending machine 0.010 machine-shifts/100kg | Site work needs hot-work, cutting and bending plant and the related energy |
| Fabrication consumables / welding materials | Inside the prefabricated price (connectors, locking clips) | Welding electrodes 2.93 kg/100kg, oxygen 2.34 m3/100kg, acetylene etc. | Welding materials and gases are hidden costs of site fabrication |
| Anti-corrosion / galvanising | Prefabricated normally hot-dip galvanised (GB/T 13912), galvanising cost inside the unit price | Fabrication line items carry ordinary paint only (anti-rust paint 0.0177 kg/kg plus ready-mixed paint 0.0146 kg/kg) | Hot-dip galvanising must be priced separately (per t/kg or by galvanised area); fireproof coating is listed separately under Annex M |
| Installation labour | Prefabricated single-pipe lateral 0.78 workdays/set; prefabricated portal-frame lateral 1.06 workdays/set | Installation of general pipe supports 2.646 workdays/100kg (fabrication plus installation totals 6.916 workdays/100kg) | Prefabricated installation labour is per set; it must be converted to the same physical-quantity basis as per-kg installation labour before comparison |
| Electrical volume reference | Prefabricated supports / seismic supports per piece or per set, not converted to mass | Iron-component metal support fabrication 0.056 workdays/kg (5.6 workdays/100kg), installation 0.023 workdays/kg (2.3 workdays/100kg) | The contents of the two systems must not be cross-borrowed; pricing follows the labour, material and plant composition of the line item actually applied |
Dimensional conversion: prefabricated 'workdays per set' and site 'workdays per 100kg' must be converted through the actual mass per set (e.g. at 10 kg per set on a 100kg basis: 0.78 x 10 = 7.8 workdays/100kg, 1.06 x 10 = 10.6 workdays/100kg) before comparison; the conversion mass must follow the actual designed mass per set, otherwise the comparison conclusion is distorted.
3. Ranking the sources of difference (four items, largest impact first)
- Different work chains (largest item): site fabrication adds a whole fabrication labour block (about 4.27 workdays/100kg) and hot-work cutting plant (welding machines 3.867, abrasive cut-off saws 2.707 machine-shifts/100kg); the factory cost of prefabricated items is invisible but already implicit in the unit price - a comparison must not look at the 'installation' line items alone.
- Different principal-material scope: prefabricated principal materials include fittings, anchors, packaging and galvanising; site work uses black steel sections, with connectors and anchors to be listed as separate materials.
- Anti-corrosion grade difference (the most easily missed item): the fabrication line items carry ordinary anti-rust paint plus ready-mixed paint only; where the design or the code requires hot-dip galvanising, the galvanising cost must be added, otherwise the site-fabricated option is systematically understated.
- Wastage transfer: site steel wastage of 5.05% is quantifiable into the rate, while prefabricated wastage (supports 1.000 sets per set) is borne by the manufacturer and shows only as about 5% in items such as pipe clamps.
4. Selection test: prefabrication is a code constraint, not a price preference
- Seismic supports: within the applicable fortification intensity zones they are always coded as prefabricated supports and priced per set; no 'site fabrication' tender route exists (GB/T 50856-2024 Annex N; for locations and quantities see GB 50981-2014 clause 8.3.1, 'every horizontal straight pipe run shall have lateral seismic supports and hangers at both ends', and clause 8.3.14, 'the first seismic hanger on a horizontal pipe connected to a riser shall be within 0.6m of the riser; where the riser is longer than 1.8m, four-way seismic supports and hangers shall be set at the top and bottom, with additions in between beyond 7.6m; where an inline fitting itself weighs more than 25kg, lateral and longitudinal seismic supports and hangers shall be set').
- Utility tunnels: 'Supports and hangers for pipes and cables in utility tunnels shall be prefabricated supports and hangers, factory-made and site-installed, avoiding site fabrication.' (DB11 1505-2017 clause 5.6.1, a 'shall' level requirement)
- Industrialised buildings: 'Support and hanger systems adopted in integrated MEP design shall preferably use assembled supports and hangers; assembled supports and hangers shall use standardised connection components and should allow adjustment of height and horizontal distance on site. Assembled support and hanger systems shall be load-checked and shall meet load-bearing requirements; where seismic design requirements apply, the provisions of the current national standard GB 50981 Code for Seismic Design of Building MEP Engineering shall be observed.' Products need test reports, and the detailing and calculations are usually done by the supplier (T CCES 28-2021 clause 3.1.8).
- Prefabricated decoration: 'Installation of equipment and pipework should use prefabricated supports and hangers; where seismic requirements apply, seismic supports and hangers shall be used.' (DB11/T 1832.22-2023 clause 12.4.9)
- Detailing design basis: 'Determine from the combined pipework layout the sizes, levels and positions of supports and hangers, sleeves, blockouts, equipment foundations and embedded fixings; MEP services should use one common set of combined supports and hangers or seismic supports and hangers.' Detailing should preferably precede civil construction (T CIAS-2-2020 clause 6.2.5) - one common set of combined supports integrating the disciplines is the technical precondition for raising the prefabrication ratio (prefabricated support sets / total support sets).
- Order of operations for the comparison: 1) first test under the codes whether the portion of supports is compulsorily or preferably prefabricated (seismic, utility tunnels = compulsory; industrialised buildings = preferred; prefabricated decoration = should); 2) the compulsory portion leaves no room for comparison - price it per set directly; 3) only for the freely selectable portion, compare cost components item by item per section 2 and bring both sides onto the same physical basis (per 100kg or per position); 4) finally size the total effect through the detailing-stage prefabrication ratio.
Applicability boundaries
- The consumption data come from the Beijing DB11/T 2382-2024 installation volume (and the same line items in Chapter 13 of Volume 4 of the 2021 Beijing budget consumption standard); other regions and sectors must recompute from the current local quota line items - codes and contents differ and figures must not be applied across regions.
- 'Converting 10 kg per set to a 100kg basis' is a dimensional estimate only; real comparison must convert by the designed mass per set; prefabricated and site-fabricated options must never be priced head-on as CNY/kg against CNY/set.
- If hot-dip galvanising is required for the site-fabricated option, the galvanising must be priced separately or listed under Annex M; the anti-rust paint plus ready-mixed paint inside the fabrication line items is no substitute.
- Where the work content of installation line items such as cable trays already includes 'installation of supports and hangers', the site-fabricated route adds the fabrication line item only and installation must not be counted twice - always check the work content of the applied line items before pricing.
- The number of seismic supports depends on the seismic design documents (layout drawings); obtain the layout drawing before comparing - support counts estimated from pipe length alone are no basis for pricing.
- Regional and sector differences: the Jilin DB22/T 5138-2023, railway TB/T 10832-2024 and other systems have their own provisions; follow the applicable system.
Further reading
- GB/T 50856-2024 'General Installation Works Measurement Standard' clause 3.0.10; Annex N Other and Ancillary Works (031301: prefabricated supports per set, supports and hangers per kg, seismic supports coded as prefabricated support items, liner and damping test in the item description); Annex M Painting, Anti-corrosion and Insulation Works.
- SJG 77-2020 'Standard for the division of billed work sections and preliminaries in building works cost documents' clause 6.10.1 (composition of the support and hanger works division).
- Beijing DB11/T 2382-2024 'Construction Consumption Standard', installation volume: fabrication of general pipe supports (comprehensive labour class II, 4.27 workdays/100kg), installation (2.646 workdays/100kg), prefabricated seismic support single-pipe lateral (0.78 workdays/set), prefabricated portal-frame lateral (1.06 workdays/set), prefabricated pipe clamp installation; iron-component metal support fabrication (0.056 workdays/kg) and installation (0.023 workdays/kg).
- GB 50981-2014 'Code for Seismic Design of Building MEP Engineering' clauses 8.3.1 and 8.3.14 (locations and numbers of seismic supports and hangers); GB/T 13912 (technical requirements for hot-dip galvanised coatings).
- DB11 1505-2017 'Code for Design of Urban Utility Tunnels' clause 5.6.1; T CCES 28-2021 'Standard for Integrated MEP Design of Industrialised Buildings' clause 3.1.8; DB11/T 1832.22-2023 'Construction Work Procedures, Part 22: Prefabricated Decoration Works' clause 12.4.9; T CIAS 2-2020 'Technical Standard for MEP Construction Drawing Detailing' clause 6.2.5.
- Local cost and quota policy release pages (for verifying prefabricated and seismic support pricing and quota treatment):
Keywords
- 成品支架
- 现场制作支吊架
- 抗震支架 按套
- 支架制作安装子目
- 热浸镀锌 防腐
- 成品化率
- GB/T 50856-2024
- 支吊架 计价对比