Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-31

Allocation of liability and the boundary of recoverable loss for quality accidents caused by design defects in EPC (general contracting) projects: how responsibility is shared among the main contractor, consortium members, subcontractors and the employer where the employer is itself at fault, and how causative force, contributory fault, the foreseeability rule, the duty to mitigate and the repair-first requirement limit a claim for 'total loss'

A claim can be made, but 'total loss' is not automatic: design is within the EPC contractor's contractual duties, so a design defect causing quality not to conform is a breach, and the employer may demand free repair, rework or alteration plus damages (Civil Code Art. 801); the damages must pass four tests - causative-force proportion, contributory fault (Art. 592(2)), foreseeability (Art. 584), and duty to mitigate with repair-first (Art. 591; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 16). As to parties, consortium members and subcontractors are jointly and severally liable with the main contractor to the employer (Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Arts. 10(2) and 22(2); Civil Code Art. 791(2)), while under traditional parallel award of design and construction each answers for itself with no statutory joint liability (Civil Code Arts. 800 and 801).

Applicable Codes

  • 中华人民共和国民法典(主席令第45号)第一百七十八条、第五百八十四条、第五百九十一条、第五百九十二条、第七百九十一条、第八百条、第八百零一条、第八百零二条、第一千二百五十二条
  • 中华人民共和国建筑法(2019修正)第五十五条
  • 建设工程质量管理条例(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第二十六条、第二十八条
  • 房屋建筑和市政基础设施项目工程总承包管理办法(建市规〔2019〕12号)第十条、第十五条、第十六条、第二十二条、第二十五条
  • 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)(法释〔2020〕25号)第十三条
  • 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)(法释〔2026〕12号)第十六条、第二十三条
  • 建设项目工程总承包合同(示范文本)GF-2020-0216 通用合同条件 5.1.1、5.1.3、5.2.1

Topic positioning

Quality-accident claims in EPC (general contracting) projects: where a design defect causes a quality accident, whether the employer can claim 'total loss' from the EPC contractor, how liability divides among the main contractor, consortium members, subcontractors and the employer, and where the boundary of recoverable loss lies. Distinguishes EPC single-point design-and-build responsibility, consortium joint liability, subcontractor joint liability and the separate liability of traditional parallel award.

Core conclusions

I. The claim lies, but 'total loss' must pass four tests

Design is within the EPC contractor's contractual duties. GF-2020-0216 Model Contract for Construction Project EPC, General Conditions 5.1.1: 'The contractor shall perform the design work and other design-related services in accordance with the law, national, industry and local standards and codes, the Employer's Requirements and the contract, and shall be responsible for the design of the works.' A design defect causing quality not to conform is therefore a breach, and the employer may demand free repair, rework or alteration plus damages. But the damages usually do not equal the contract price, the construction cost or the employer's entire outlay; four tests apply in turn:

  1. Causative force: the design defect must be one cause of the accident, and the loss is shared per the causative-force proportions found on assessment; where the internal shares are hard to fix, Civil Code Art. 178(2) applies - the share of each jointly liable party follows the size of its responsibility, and where that is hard to determine the parties bear it equally.
  2. Contributory fault: Civil Code Art. 592(2): 'Where one party's breach causes the other party loss and the other party is at fault in the occurrence of the loss, the compensation payable may be reduced accordingly.'
  3. Foreseeability: Civil Code Art. 584: 'Damages shall equal the loss caused by the breach, including the benefits obtainable after performance of the contract, but shall not exceed what the breaching party foresaw or ought to have foreseen at the time of contracting as losses likely to be caused by the breach.'
  4. Duty to mitigate and repair-first: Civil Code Art. 591: 'After one party breaches, the other party shall take appropriate measures to prevent aggravation of the loss; where it fails to take them and the loss is aggravated, it may not claim damages for the aggravated part. Reasonable expenses incurred by the party in preventing aggravation are borne by the breaching party.' Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 16: 'Where quality non-conformity is caused by the contractor and the employer, without notifying the contractor to repair, asks the court to order the contractor to pay repair costs up front, the court will not support the claim. Where the contractor refuses to repair, or fails within a reasonable period to repair to conformity, and the employer repairs and then claims the reasonable repair costs from the contractor, the court shall support the claim.'

II. Liable parties and the nature of their liability

  1. Integrated EPC (one contractor holding the design qualification): the EPC contractor is responsible for design and quality as a whole, and the liability is contractual. Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision) Art. 26: 'The construction unit is responsible for the construction quality of construction projects... where general contracting applies to a construction project, the general contractor is responsible for the quality of the whole construction project.' Construction Law Art. 55: 'Where general contracting applies to a construction project, the quality is the responsibility of the general contractor; where the general contractor subcontracts parts of the project to other units, it is jointly liable with the subcontracting units for the quality of the subcontracted parts.' Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 22(2) and (3): 'The EPC contractor is responsible for the quality of all the works it contracts; subcontractors are responsible for the quality of the parts they subcontract, and subcontracting does not relieve the EPC contractor of its quality responsibility for the whole of the works it contracts. The EPC contractor and the EPC project manager bear lifetime quality responsibility under the law.' Recoverable: free repair / rework / alteration + repair costs + breach liability for late delivery (Civil Code Art. 801) + foreseeable direct losses. The employer's review and approval of contractor documents is no discharge - GF-2020-0216 General Conditions 5.2.1, final sentence: 'The employer's review and approval of contractor documents shall not be construed as a modification or alteration of the contract, nor do they reduce or discharge any of the contractor's responsibilities and obligations.'
  2. EPC consortium (design institute + construction company): joint and several liability outward; the internal division of work cannot be set up against the employer. Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 10(2): 'The consortium parties shall jointly sign the EPC contract with the employer and bear joint and several liability for the EPC project.' Civil Code Art. 178(1) and (3): the creditor may demand performance from some or all of the jointly liable parties; a party that performs beyond its own share may seek contribution from the other jointly liable parties.
  3. Design / construction subcontracting under EPC: the subcontractor is jointly liable with the main contractor to the employer for its work results. Civil Code Art. 791(2): '... the third party is, together with the general contractor or the survey, design or construction contractor, jointly liable to the employer for the work results it completes.' Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 25: within the warranty period the EPC contractor may not refuse to perform its warranty responsibilities on the ground of the division of warranty liability between it and its subcontractors. The main contractor cannot plead that 'design was subcontracted to a design institute'.
  4. Traditional parallel award (design and construction contracted separately): each party answers to its own counterparty and there is no statutory joint liability. Civil Code Art. 800: where survey or design quality does not meet requirements or survey or design documents are submitted late and delay the works, causing the employer loss, the surveyor or designer must continue and complete the survey or design, reduce or waive the survey or design fee and pay damages. Art. 801: where quality non-conformity is due to the builder, the employer may demand that the builder repair, rework or alter free of charge within a reasonable period; where delivery is delayed after repair, rework or alteration, the builder bears breach liability. Quality Regulation Art. 28: 'The construction unit must construct according to the design drawings and construction technical standards, must not alter the design without authorisation and must not skimp on materials and work... where it finds errors in the design documents and drawings during construction, it shall promptly raise comments and proposals.' A construction unit that knowingly continues to build against a design error shares fault-based liability.
  5. Accident cause pointing at the employer (defective design supplied, substandard employer-supplied or nominated materials, directly nominated subcontractors): Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Art. 13: 'Where the employer has one of the following circumstances causing a quality defect of the construction project, it bears fault-based liability: (1) supplying a design with defects; (2) supplying or directing the purchase of building materials, components or equipment that do not meet mandatory standards; (3) directly nominating a subcontractor for specialist works. Where the contractor is also at fault, it bears corresponding fault-based liability.' Together with the employer risk list of Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 15: fluctuations in key materials, equipment and labour prices beyond the agreed band against the base-period prices at tendering; contract price changes caused by changes in national laws, regulations or policies; changes in cost and time caused by unforeseeable geological conditions; changes in cost and time caused by the employer; changes in cost and time caused by force majeure.
  6. Personal injury / property damage to third parties: Civil Code Art. 802: 'Where the works cause personal injury or property loss within their reasonable service life for reasons attributable to the contractor, the contractor is liable.' Art. 1252: 'Where a building, structure or other installation collapses or caves in and harms others, the employer and the construction unit bear joint liability, unless they can prove there is no quality defect. After paying, the employer and the construction unit may seek recourse from other responsible persons.'

III. Boundary of the recoverable scope

  • Fully recoverable: repair / rework / alteration costs, breach liability for late delivery caused by rework (Art. 801), direct property loss.
  • Repair costs must follow the procedure: first notify the contractor to repair within a reasonable period; a request for up-front repair costs without notice is unsupported (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 16(1)); where the contractor refuses to repair or fails within a reasonable period to repair to conformity, the reasonable costs of repair carried out by the employer or a third party are supported (Art. 16(2)).
  • Indirect loss is constrained: production shutdown, financing costs, goodwill and the like beyond what was foreseeable at the time of contracting are often reduced or rejected (Art. 584).
  • Aggravated loss is not compensated: the part not prevented by appropriate measures (Art. 591(1)); the reasonable expenses incurred for that purpose are borne by the breaching party (Art. 591(2)).
  • Mixed causes: where design, construction and employer-caused defective data or misuse interweave, the loss is converted by the assessed causative-force proportions; the outward joint liability is not narrowed by the internal proportions (Art. 178(2), Art. 592(2)).

Scope and limits

  • Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 applies to EPC in housing construction and municipal infrastructure projects; highway, water conservancy and railway EPC is governed by separate rules, and these responsibility clauses cannot be applied to them directly.
  • Under integrated EPC, design is a contractual duty of the contractor: pursue liability along the breach route (Art. 801 + Model Contract Clause 5); only where design and construction are contracted separately under parallel award is the surveyor or designer separately pursued under Art. 800.
  • 'Full recovery' presupposes that a causation assessment of the quality accident stands: a claim for full damages without such an assessment is usually not supported in full because the causative force is unproven.
  • Contract price form and damages liability are two ledgers: Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 16 - EPC of enterprise-invested projects should use lump-sum contracts, and under a lump-sum contract the contract price is generally not adjusted except for circumstances agreed as adjustable - governs price adjustment and does not cut off liability for quality breach.
  • Transition between interpretations: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 23 - 'This interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. For first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by courts after this interpretation takes effect, this interpretation applies. Where SPC interpretations issued before this interpretation are inconsistent with it, this interpretation prevails.' The repair-first rule applies only to first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026.
  • Where new mandatory national codes or standards issued after the base date cause cost changes, the employer shall reasonably adjust the contract price and reasonably extend the duration (GF-2020-0216 General Conditions 5.1.3); that is a statutory defence or mitigation direction for the contractor and must be kept apart from quality liability.

Further reading

  • Civil Code (Presidential Decree No. 45), Contract Part, chapter XVIII construction project contracts (Arts. 788-808); Arts. 178, 584, 591, 592; Tort Part Art. 1252.
  • Measures for the Management of Housing Construction and Municipal Infrastructure Project EPC (Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12): Chapter II (Arts. 6-16, incl. Art. 10 consortium joint liability, Art. 15 risk allocation, Art. 16 contract price form); Chapter III (Arts. 17-27, incl. Art. 22 quality responsibility and lifetime responsibility, Art. 23 work safety, Art. 25 warranty).
  • SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) Art. 13; Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) Arts. 16 and 23.
  • Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision) Arts. 26 and 28; Construction Law of the PRC (2019 amendment) Art. 55.
  • Model Contract for Construction Project EPC (GF-2020-0216), General Conditions: Clause 5 (5.1.1 general design obligations, 5.1.3 changes in law and standards, 5.2.1 review of contractor documents), Clause 13 (variations and adjustments), Clause 20 (dispute resolution).

Keywords

  • EPC
  • 工程总承包
  • 设计缺陷
  • 质量事故赔偿
  • 连带责任
  • 民法典第八百零一条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号第十三条
  • 赔偿范围可预见规则