The compliant acceptance path for works failing quality after repair/strengthening, and the allocation of costs
Nonconforming work follows the four-step path of GB 50300-2013 Clause 5.0.6: re-accept after rework/repair → accept upon testing and appraisal meeting design → accept upon recalculation and recognition by the original designer → accept strengthened work satisfying safe use per the technical treatment plan and negotiated documents. Cost allocation follows "whoever causes it bears it": contractor-caused — borne by the contractor and not measured; employer/designer-caused — measured with price adjustment; warranty costs borne by the party responsible for the defect (Ministry of Construction Decree No. 80, Article 13). Strengthening is not a way to pass acceptance under disguised quality reductions.
Applicable Codes
- GB 50300-2013 建筑工程施工质量验收统一标准
- GB 55032-2022 建筑与市政工程施工质量控制通用规范
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- 建设部令第80号 房屋建筑工程质量保修办法
Topic Positioning
The compliant acceptance path, strengthening-cost bearing, and responsibility allocation for works failing quality but still usable after repair and strengthening — for construction quality acceptance of building and municipal works.
Core Conclusions
- The treatment path has an order (GB 50300-2013, Clause 5.0.6): ① inspection lots redone/repaired are re-accepted; ② where a qualified testing agency appraises conformity to design → accept; ③ where appraisal falls short of design but the original designer recalculates and recognizes safety and service function → acceptance may be granted; ④ repaired or strengthened sub-item/sub-divisional works satisfying safety and service function → accept per the technical treatment plan and negotiated documents. Red line: strengthening must not become an outlet for lowering quality requirements and passing acceptance in disguise — the responsible party still bears economic liability and penalties.
- Cost allocation, overall "whoever causes it bears it": the constructor not building to code/design → borne by the constructor; design error → borne by the designer (the employer deals with it first, then recovers); nonconforming materials per "whoever procures, whoever vets"; improper use → borne by the user; force majeure per the contract. Basis: Ministry of Construction Decree No. 80, Measures for Quality Warranty of Housing Construction Projects, Article 13 — warranty costs are borne by the party responsible for the quality defect.
- Measurement rules (GB/T 50500-2024, Clauses 7.6.1–7.6.4): rework/strengthening due to variation or employer causes → quantities measured, price adjusted, rework confirmation sheet signed; due to contractor causes → quantities not measured, costs borne by the contractor.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to building and municipal works under the GB 50300/GB 55032 system, on the premise that the strengthened works still satisfy safe use — otherwise demolition and rebuilding is required. Responsibility must rest on testing/appraisal and cause analysis first; specific proportions are affected by contract terms and evidence. Cases reaching quality-accident level must additionally follow accident reporting procedures, outside this card's scope.
Further Reading
- GB 50300-2013, Clause 5.0.6: four-step path for nonconforming work (with commentary).
- GB 55032-2022, Clause 4.1.1: acceptance hierarchy and mandatory requirements.
- Ministry of Construction Decree No. 80, Article 13: attribution of warranty costs.
- GB/T 50500-2024, Clauses 7.6.1–7.6.4: rework confirmation sheet and measurement rules.
- Local reference: DBJ50/T-077-2019, Clause 3.5.1 (treatment plans touching structural safety require recognition by the original designer).
Keywords
- 质量不合格处理
- 加固处理
- 返工返修
- 验收路径
- 责任划分
- 保修费用
- 返工计量
- GB 50300 5.0.6