Allocation of liability where materials supplied by the employer (free-issue) or purchased on its nomination fail to meet the contract requirements or mandatory standards: the employer may not nominate suppliers where the contractor purchases, the construction unit must ensure quality in its own procurement, fault-based liability for quality defects, and the contractor's claims to added costs, extension of time and reasonable profit (including the pricing of substitute materials)
Where employer-supplied or employer-nominated materials fail to meet the contract requirements or mandatory standards: where the contract provides that the contractor purchases the materials, the employer may not nominate the supplier or manufacturer (Construction Law, Art. 25); where the construction unit purchases them, it must ensure conformity with the design documents and the contract requirements and may not expressly or impliedly direct the use of non-conforming materials (Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, Art. 14); where quality defects result, the employer bears fault-based liability under Article 13 of Interpretation (I) (including 'building materials, components or equipment supplied or nominated for purchase that fail to meet mandatory standards'). The contractor may claim against the employer the costs thereby increased and (or) the delay thereby caused, with a reasonable profit payable by the employer (GB/T 50500-2024, Art. 3.6.1); where the materials fail the contract requirements or the delivery plan, or delivery dates, places or methods change for reasons of the employer and the period is extended, time is reasonably extended under Chapter 8 and losses including profit are compensated (Art. 3.6.5); Art. 8.5.3 of the model contract adds a right to reject and a right to require replacement. The contractor remains bound by the inspection duty of Article 29; use without inspection, or with knowledge of non-conformity, leads to apportionment by fault and to administrative penalties.
Applicable Codes
- 《建筑法》(2019修正,主席令第29号)第25条
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(2019修订,国务院令第714号)第14条、第29条、第64条、第65条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第13条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第3.6.1条、第3.6.5条及Ch. 8
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》第8.5.3条、第8.7条
Topic scope
Where building materials, components and equipment procured by the employer itself (free-issue) or purchased on the employer's nomination fail to meet the contract requirements or mandatory standards: the statutory red lines, the allocation of liability, and the cost, time and profit the contractor may claim against the employer, with their contractual and pricing bases. This card covers the 'non-conforming quality' side; claims for suspension losses caused by late delivery of employer-supplied materials and the contractor's recourse against the supplier are covered in adjacent cards.
Core conclusions
1. Statutory red lines: the employer may not nominate suppliers where the contractor purchases, and may not supply non-conforming materials
- Construction Law (2019 revision), Article 25: 'Construction projects shall, as required by law, be awarded by tendering; projects unsuitable for award by tendering may be awarded directly. ... General contracting is encouraged, and dismembered awarding of construction projects is prohibited.' The key final paragraph: 'Where, under the contract, building materials, components and equipment are to be procured by the works contractor, the awarding party shall not require the contractor to purchase designated building materials, components or equipment for the works, nor designate the manufacturer or supplier.'
- Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision, State Council Order No. 714), Article 14: 'Where, under the contract, the construction unit procures building materials, components and equipment, it shall ensure that the building materials, components and equipment conform to the design documents and the contract requirements. The construction unit shall not expressly or impliedly require the contractor to use non-conforming building materials, components and equipment.'
2. The employer's fault-based liability where quality defects result
Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Interpretation (I), Article 13: where the employer, in any of the following circumstances, causes a quality defect of the construction project, it shall bear fault-based liability: '(1) the design it supplied is defective; (2) the building materials, components or equipment it supplied or nominated for purchase fail to meet mandatory standards; (3) it directly nominated the subcontractor for specialist works.' Where the contractor is also at fault, it shall likewise bear corresponding fault-based liability.
3. Cost, time and profit claimable by the contractor (contractual and pricing bases)
- GB/T 50500-2024, Art. 3.6.1: where employer-supplied materials exist, the employer shall state in the tender documents the names, grade, specification and model, delivery method and place of the employer-supplied materials, and describe them in the item descriptions of the tender bill of quantities; the employer shall make clear in the tender documents the quality and delivery conditions of the materials it supplies, and when the contractor prices its tender the price of the employer-supplied materials is not included in the all-in unit rate of the corresponding items; 'where the employer-supplied materials fail to meet the contract requirements, or the delivery conditions change for reasons attributable to the employer, the employer shall bear the costs thereby increased and (or) the delay thereby caused, and shall pay the contractor a reasonable profit.'
- GB/T 50500-2024, Art. 3.6.5: where the employer-supplied materials fail to meet the contract requirements (e.g. specification, model, quality) or fail to satisfy the delivery plan, or the delivery date is delayed or the delivery place or method is changed for reasons attributable to the employer, the contractor shall assist the employer in coordinating with the supplier to withdraw the non-conforming materials from the site and to supply conforming materials under the delivery plan; where the contractor's period is thereby extended, the time affected shall be reasonably extended under the relevant provisions of Chapter 8 of this standard, 'and the contractor's losses, including profit, shall be compensated'.
- GF-2017-0201, model construction contract, Art. 8.5.3: 'Where the materials or goods provided by the employer fail to meet the contract requirements, the contractor is entitled to reject them and may require the employer to replace them; the costs thereby increased and (or) the time thereby delayed are borne by the employer, and the employer shall pay the contractor a reasonable profit.'
- Pricing of substitute materials (model contract, Art. 8.7): substitution arises where laws taking effect after the base date prohibit use, where the employer requires the use of substitutes, or where substitutes must be used for other reasons; the contractor shall notify the supervising engineer in writing 28 days before use, enclosing documents on the names, quantities, specifications, models, brands, performance and prices of the replaced and substitute items and other materials, the differences between the two and their effect on the works, the price difference, and the reasons for use; the supervising engineer shall, within 14 days of receipt, issue a written instruction countersigned by the employer, and failing a written instruction within that time the employer and the supervising engineer are deemed to have agreed to the substitute; Art. 8.7.3: where the employer approves the use of substitute materials and goods, the price is determined by the price of the same item in the priced bill of quantities or the budget; where no identical item exists, by reference to the price of a similar item; where neither identical nor similar items exist, by the principle of reasonable cost plus profit, the price being determined by the parties under Clause 4.4 [agreement or determination].
- The contractor's corresponding duty: even where the materials are supplied by the employer, the contractor must still inspect them under Article 29 of the Regulation on Quality Management: building materials, components, equipment and ready-mixed concrete shall be inspected, the inspection shall be recorded in writing and signed by a designated person, and materials not inspected or failing inspection shall not be used; otherwise administrative liability follows under Article 64 (fine of 2% to 4% of the contract price of the works for use of non-conforming materials, with rework and repair and compensation of losses) and Article 65 (fine of RMB 100,000 to 200,000 for failure to inspect), and quality liability is shared by fault under Article 13(2) of Interpretation (I).
Boundaries of application
- 'Failing to meet the contract requirements' and 'failing to meet mandatory standards' must be distinguished: the former runs on the contractual and pricing-adjustment path (added costs, extension of time, reasonable profit); the latter superadds the fault-based liability of item (2) of Article 13 of Interpretation (I); the two paths may be pursued together.
- Where the contractor had the contractual right to reject but accepted, or knew of the non-conformity and still used the materials, mitigation and set-off for contributory fault apply, the claims to cost, time and profit are reduced accordingly, and the administrative penalty is not remitted.
- The price of employer-supplied materials is excluded from the all-in unit rate (2024 edition), so the value of the materials themselves is not part of the contractor's recoverable expectation; what may be claimed are the costs thereby increased, the time and the profit.
- Where the contractor purchases the materials itself and the employer merely nominates the brand or manufacturer, the free-issue provisions and Section 3.6 of GB/T 50500-2024 do not apply, and claims proceed on the sale-and-purchase path.
- The model text is recommendatory: the effect of its clauses depends on actual adoption in the contract; GB/T 50500-2024 is likewise a recommendatory standard, and express contractual agreements prevail, without prejudice to the mandatory provisions of law.
Further reading
Construction Law (2019 revision), Article 25; Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision, State Council Order No. 714), Articles 14, 29, 64 and 65; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 13; GB/T 50500-2024, Arts. 3.6.1 and 3.6.5 and the delay and claim provisions of Chapter 8; GF-2017-0201, Art. 8.5.3 (employer-supplied materials failing the requirements), Art. 8.6 (submission, sealing and custody of samples), Art. 8.7 (substitution of materials and goods).
Keywords
- 发包人提供材料不合格
- 甲供材料不符合合同要求
- 不得指定生产厂供应商
- 建筑法第二十五条
- 建工解释一第十三条
- 工期延长与合理利润
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.6节
- 示范文本8.5.3
- 替代材料价格认定