Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Technical dependency order and layered commissioning of the three types of expert assessment in construction quality defect repair disputes: quality assessment -> repair scheme (scope/content/standard) -> repair cost assessment; the order must not be reversed or merged into one step, and the cost assessment must not determine quality liability on its own

Repair cost assessment must be positioned last: first obtain the results of the construction quality assessment accepted by the commissioning party (court/arbitral tribunal), then determine the repair scope, repair scheme and repair standard, and only then assess the repair cost (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clauses 2.1.3 and 4.9.9). The core reason is that repair cost is a derived quantity calculated 'on the determined repair scope, scheme, content and standard'; until the upstream basis is fixed, the cost assessment can only issue alternative or hypothetical opinions. In quality disputes, 'the employer shall be advised to apply for a construction quality assessment, and after the commissioning party has sorted out the parties' quality liabilities, the construction cost assessment opinions shall be applied and adopted accordingly' (GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.6.5(2)); and 'determination of the allocation of liability between the parties' is not a commissionable assessment matter (Fa [2020] No. 202, item I.1(6)). This is a technical dependency order; one commission letter may list the matters in layers, but each later step must take as its input the results of the previous step accepted by the commissioning party.

Applicable Codes

  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 · Work Guideline for Construction Cost Appraisal 第2.1.3条、第3.6.1条、第4.9.8条、第4.9.9条
  • GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第3.6.1条、第5.6.5条
  • GB 50300-2013 · Unified Standard for Constructional Quality Acceptance of Building Engineering 第5.0.6条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十六条、第二十三条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第三十二条
  • 法〔2020〕202号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事诉讼中委托鉴定审查工作若干问题的规定》一、1、2;二、3、4、5
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第七十九条、第八十一条
  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第五十六条
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第八百零一条
  • 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》第四十条

Topic Positioning

In repair cost disputes arising from construction quality defects (non-conforming work, rework, strengthening), the sequence of, and layered commissioning approach to, three types of expert assessment matters - quality assessment, determination of the repair scheme (technical scheme) and repair cost (construction cost) expert assessment - together with the admissibility boundary for assessment matters, cross-examination of assessment materials, the expert's appearance in court and re-assessment as procedural remedies.

Core Conclusions

1. Conclusion: quality assessment first -> then the repair scheme (technical scheme) -> and only then the repair cost (construction cost) expert assessment; the order cannot be reversed, nor can the three be merged into a single step.

Core reason: the repair cost is a derived quantity calculated on the basis of the 'determined repair scope, repair scheme, repair standard and content'. Whether the disputed part is non-conforming, whether repair is needed, what to repair and to what standard - until the quality assessment and the repair scheme are determined, the cost assessment has no usable measurement basis and can only produce hypothetical or alternative opinions that cannot ground an award.

2. Original texts of the three layers of technical basis

  1. Quality assessment is a preliminary assessment for the repair cost assessment (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 'Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice', Clause 2.1.3): Original text: 'Construction engineering assessment matters include construction cost assessment, duration assessment, quality assessment, repair scheme assessment, etc. Where a project commissioned for construction cost assessment also involves duration assessment, quality assessment or repair scheme assessment, the expert shall first obtain the results of the duration, quality and repair scheme assessments accepted by the commissioning party and carry out the construction cost assessment on that basis. For an expert who concurrently undertakes the construction cost assessment together with the duration, quality and repair scheme assessments, the construction cost assessment results shall likewise be based on the results of the duration, quality and repair scheme assessments accepted by the commissioning party.' Explanatory text: 'Where the parties are in dispute over the contract duration, the quality of the works or the repair scheme, a third party must be commissioned to determine these preliminary bases of the construction cost assessment. An expert who has concurrently accepted assessments of contract duration, quality of the works and repair scheme shall first carry out those preliminary assessments and, after acceptance by the commissioning party, then carry out the construction cost assessment.' -> Even where the same institution takes on all three matters - quality, scheme and cost - it must not 'do everything in one pass': it must first issue the preliminary assessment results, have them accepted by the commissioning party, and only then carry out the cost assessment.

  2. The starting point of the repair cost assessment is that the repair scope, scheme and standard are determined (same Guidelines, Clause 4.9.9): Original text: 'An expert undertaking a construction cost assessment arising from a works repair dispute shall proceed on the basis that the technical scheme - the repair scope, repair scheme, content and standard - has been determined, and shall first request the commissioning party to determine the repair scope, repair scheme and standard. The expert may conduct the assessment with reference to the following principles and methods: 1 Where repair design drawings and a repair scheme confirmed by the commissioning party are available, calculate on the scope, scheme, content and standard of the repair design. 2 Where no repair design drawings or repair scheme confirmed by the commissioning party are available but the repair scope, scheme, content and standard can be obtained through site inspection, calculate on the results of the site inspection. 3 Where the repair requires demolition of the original non-conforming or completed parts, the demolition cost and the spoil haulage cost shall be calculated. Where the original technical measures cannot be utilised during the repair and preliminaries must necessarily be incurred, those costs may be calculated together. 4 For emergency repair works requiring night work, continuous work or the preparation of multiple schemes, the reduced-efficiency cost of construction and other costs may be calculated as circumstances require.' In addition: 'For disputes over repair costs, the expert shall, at the request of the commissioning party, calculate taking into account the contractually agreed pricing method, the actual site conditions and other factors. Where the commissioning party requires further analysis of the specific amounts and composition of direct costs and on-costs, the expert shall provide the analysis as requested and state it in the assessment opinion for the commissioning party's use.'

  3. In quality disputes the construction cost assessment can only proceed on the basis of the quality conclusions (same Guidelines, Clause 4.9.8, four scenarios): (1) Where a quality assessment report or the commissioning party determines that the quality of the works conforms to the contract, partially conforms to the agreed standard, has reached the agreed standard after repair or rework, or the non-conformity was not caused by the contractor, the cost of the disputed part of the works shall be calculated; (2) Where the non-conformity was caused by the contractor and the contractor refuses to repair, rework or rebuild, the cost of the disputed part of the works shall, where calculable, be included in the alternative opinions, with explanation; (3) Where defects in the design documents provided by the employer, building materials, components or equipment provided or purchased by the employer that fail to meet mandatory standards, or specialist works directly subcontracted to a subcontractor nominated by the employer, cause the contractor additional repair, rework or rebuilding costs, those costs shall be calculated and explained; (4) Where, after the employer uses the works prematurely without taking-over, the contractor incurs protection costs for the unfinished works or secondary repair costs, those costs shall be calculated.

3. The construction cost expert must not determine quality liability on its own

GB/T 51262-2017 'Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment', Clause 5.6.5: 'Where the employer refuses to process the settlement of the works on the ground that the quality is non-conforming and a dispute arises, the expert shall assess as follows: 1 For works that have passed taking-over, or that are complete but not accepted and have already been put into use by the employer, the settlement shall be assessed in accordance with the contract; 2 For works that are complete but not accepted and not put into use by the employer, and for suspended or halted works, the expert shall assess the undisputed and disputed items separately in accordance with the contract. For quality disputes, the employer shall be advised to apply for a construction quality assessment; after the commissioning party has sorted out the parties' quality liabilities, the construction cost assessment opinions shall be applied and adopted accordingly.' -> The cost expert's action is to 'advise an application for quality assessment', not to judge quality liability itself; until liability is sorted out, the cost opinion can only be 'held in reserve, unused'.

4. Procedural boundaries of commissioning matters and assessment materials

  1. Matters that may not be commissioned for assessment (Fa [2020] No. 202, 'Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Review of Commissioned Assessment Work in Civil Proceedings', I.1): the people's court shall strictly review whether the proposed assessment matter is a specialised issue necessary for ascertaining the facts of the case; in any of the following circumstances, the court shall not commission an assessment: (1) facts that can be presumed from common general knowledge or the rules of experience; (2) issues unrelated to the facts to be proven; (3) issues of no significance for proving the facts to be proven; (4) non-specialised issues to be proven by the parties themselves; (5) facts that can be ascertained through court investigation, site inspection and other means; (6) determination of the allocation of liability between the parties; (7) issues of application of law; (8) lie detection; (9) other circumstances unsuitable for commissioned assessment.
  2. Prior review of technical methods (same Provisions, I.2): where the assessment techniques and methods involved in the proposed matter are seriously disputed, their scientific reliability shall be reviewed first; if they lack scientific reliability, no assessment shall be commissioned.
  3. Assessment materials must be cross-examined first (same Provisions, II.3 to II.5): whether the assessment materials meet the assessment requirements shall be strictly reviewed, and the court shall notify the parties of the legal consequences of failing to provide materials that meet the requirements; materials (including supplementary materials) that have not been cross-examined in court may not serve as assessment materials (where a party cannot be contacted, is served by public announcement or waives cross-examination, the assessment materials shall be confirmed by the collegial panel); materials disputed between the parties shall be determined by the people's court and may not be handed directly to the assessment institution or the expert for selection.
  4. Handling where the assessment matters are unclear (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 3.6.1 / GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 3.6.1): the expert shall fully understand and familiarise itself with the assessment project, study the evidence submitted, and grasp the dispute focus and the commissioning party's requirements; where the commissioning party has not specified the assessment matters, the assessment institution shall request the commissioning party to determine them.

5. Practical sequence (step x point x basis)

Step Core points Basis
(1) Fix the defect facts and complete 'notice to repair' Give written notice of the defect locations and a reasonable repair period, and keep proof of service, images and supervision records; this is a constitutive requirement of the claim to repair costs, not a procedural formality Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16; Civil Code Article 801
(2) File the assessment application within the evidence period, listing the matters in layers One application drafted in layers is recommended: (a) whether the quality conforms to the contract or mandatory standards; (b) technical analysis of the defect causes; (c) whether repair is needed, and the repair scope and standard; (d) the repair scheme (process, materials, detailing, whether demolition is needed); (e) the repair cost. Avoid the blanket 'assess the quality and the repair cost' Civil Procedure Law Article 79; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 32
(3) Ask the adjudicator to strike out 'liability allocation' matters The quality assessment answers technical facts only; the allocation of legal liability is made by the adjudicator Fa [2020] No. 202 I.1(6); I.2
(4) Cross-examine and determine the assessment materials first Materials not cross-examined may not serve as assessment materials; disputed materials are determined by the court and may not be handed directly to the assessment institution Fa [2020] No. 202 II.3 to II.5
(5) First tier: quality assessment (by an institution with the corresponding qualification) The conclusion must land on an operable treatment path, not merely the word 'non-conforming' GB 50300-2013 Clause 5.0.6
(6) Second tier: confirmation of the repair scheme The repair design drawings and scheme define the scope, content, standard, process and whether demolition is needed; absent drawings and scheme, determine by site inspection T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.9.9 items 1 and 2
(7) Third tier: repair cost (construction cost) assessment Take the accepted scheme as the measurement basis and price per the contractually agreed pricing method; include the demolition cost, the spoil haulage cost and the unavoidable preliminaries; reduced-efficiency costs may be included for emergency repairs T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.9.9 items 3 and 4; GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.6.5
(8) Cross-examination, court appearance and remedies The assessment opinion must be cross-examined in court; a party may require the expert to appear, and the opinion of an expert who refuses to appear after notice may not serve as the basis for finding facts; where the expert lacks qualification, the procedure is seriously unlawful, or the opinion is manifestly insufficiently grounded, re-assessment may be sought Civil Procedure Law Article 81; Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 Article 40

6. Landing paths of the quality assessment conclusion (determining the repair scheme and the cost basis)

GB 50300-2013 'Unified Standard for Acceptance of Construction Quality of Building Works', Clause 5.0.6: where the construction quality of a building works does not meet the requirements, the following applies: 1 inspection lots that have been reworked or repaired shall be re-accepted; 2 inspection lots that a qualified testing institution certifies as reaching the design requirements shall be accepted; 3 inspection lots that a qualified testing institution certifies as not reaching the design requirements but that the original designer verifies and acknowledges as satisfying safety and service functions may be accepted; 4 sub-divisional and divisional works that, after repair or strengthening, satisfy the safety and service function requirements may be accepted in accordance with the technical treatment scheme and the negotiated documents.

Scope of Application

  • The sequence does not mean three lawsuits or three commissions. The sequence above is a technical dependency between assessment matters; one commission letter may engage an institution with dual capability, but the letter must list the matters in layers and specify their order, and each later step must take as its input the results of the previous step accepted by the commissioning party.
  • Old/new rule boundary: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 23 - 'These Interpretations take effect from 30 June 2026. For construction contract dispute cases at first instance newly accepted by the people's courts after these Interpretations take effect, these Interpretations apply. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with these Interpretations, these Interpretations prevail.' First-instance cases accepted before 30 June 2026 therefore do not fall under these Interpretations (the claim to repair costs follows the existing rules of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25); second-instance and retrial cases follow their own rules of acceptance and application.
  • Substantive preconditions first: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16(1) - 'Where the quality of the construction works fails to conform to the agreement due to the contractor's fault, and the employer claims that the contractor first pay repair costs without having notified the contractor to repair, the people's court shall not support the claim.' Paragraph 2 - 'Where the contractor refuses to repair or fails to repair to conformity within a reasonable period, and the employer, having carried out the repair, claims the reasonable repair costs from the contractor, the people's court shall support the claim.' Civil Code Article 801 - 'Where the quality of the construction works fails to conform to the agreement due to the constructor's fault, the employer may require the constructor to repair, rework or rebuild gratuitously within a reasonable period. Where delivery is delayed as a result of the repair, rework or rebuilding, the constructor shall bear liability for breach.' Without the notice-to-repair procedure, the repair cost assessment often loses practical significance (the claim has not yet arisen).
  • Scenarios where the quality-first rule does not apply: works that have passed taking-over, or are complete but not accepted yet already put into use by the employer - the settlement is assessed directly in accordance with the contract, without the 'quality assessment before cost assessment' path (GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.6.5(1)).
  • Matters not commissionable for assessment: determination of liability allocation, application of law, specialised issues to be proven by the parties themselves, and facts ascertainable by site inspection or court investigation.
  • Consequences of failure of proof: a party who, after the court's elucidation, does not apply for assessment, or applies but does not pay the assessment fee or refuses to provide relevant materials, bears the legal consequences of failure of proof (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 32).
  • This card addresses the technical and procedural sequence of assessment matters, not specific repair methods or unit rate levels; the repair cost must still be calculated per the contractually agreed pricing method and the pricing basis current at the time.

Further Reading

  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clauses 2.1.3 (preliminary assessments), 3.6.1, 4.9.8 (quality disputes), 4.9.9 (repair disputes).
  • GB/T 51262-2017 Clauses 3.6.1, 5.6.5 (employer refuses the settlement on quality grounds).
  • GB 50300-2013 Clause 5.0.6 (four treatment paths for non-conforming inspection lots).
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Articles 16 (notice precondition, bearing of repair costs), 23 (effective date, old/new transition).
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 32 (assessment elucidation, failure of proof).
  • Fa [2020] No. 202 I.1, I.2, II.3 to II.5 (review of commissioned assessment).
  • Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) Articles 79, 81.
  • Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Article 56.
  • Civil Code Article 801.
  • Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 Article 40 (re-assessment, refund of fees).

Keywords

  • 修复费用鉴定
  • 质量鉴定
  • 修复方案鉴定
  • 鉴定顺序
  • 鉴定事项分层委托
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023
  • GB/T 51262-2017
  • 法〔2020〕202号