Railway 2024 quota system: the boundary rules between bridge/culvert pit excavation and the subgrade volume's earthworks (QY vs LY items) and detecting misapplication
Under the railway 2024 quota system, pit excavation for bridge/culvert open-cut foundations (pile caps, spread footings, culvert foundations) must use the bridge volume's QY-1~QY-7 items, with the cost entering the foundation masonry (TB 10801-2024 Appendix A, item 4); the subgrade volume's general notes expressly exclude pit excavation from its scope. The only express cross-volume interface: spoil haul beyond 10 m is booked separately per the subgrade volume; anchor/shotcrete/soil-nail support may use the subgrade volume. Applying subgrade LY items to excavation under bridges is a quota misapplication that review/audit will certainly correct.
Applicable Codes
- TB/T 10823-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 2 桥涵工程 Ch. 1下部工程 第一节挖基及抽水
- TB/T 10822-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 1 路基工程 第一部分综合说明
- TB 10801-2024 铁路基本建设工程设计概(预)算编制办法 App. A 第4条、第8条
Topic Positioning
The mandatory boundary rules between bridge/culvert pit excavation and the subgrade-volume earthworks quotas in the railway 2024 system (TB/T 10822-2024 Volume 1 subgrade, TB/T 10823-2024 Volume 2 bridge and culvert works, TB 10801-2024 compilation measures), and the compliance test for "can excavation under a bridge use subgrade items".
Core Conclusions
1. Three-layer basis (key sentences as written):
- TB/T 10822-2024 Volume 1 general notes, item 4: "Pit excavation and demolition works not contained in this volume shall use the relevant items of 'Railway works budget quota, Volume 2: bridge and culvert works' and 'Volume 13: station works'." — the subgrade volume expressly excludes pit excavation from its scope.
- TB/T 10823-2024 Volume 2, Chapter 1 substructure, Section 1 excavation and pumping: the pit-excavation work content is "excavate and haul 10 m beyond the pit, including manual digging and hauling of the soil within 0.3 m of the pit bottom, and trimming of pit walls and bottom" (QY-1~QY-7); "spoil haul in the pit-excavation quota is 10 m; longer haul is booked separately per the relevant items of 'Railway works budget quota, Volume 1: subgrade works'" — the only expressly permitted cross-volume interface between bridge pits and the subgrade volume.
- TB 10801-2024 Appendix A, item 4: "Earth and rock. Except for section subgrade earthworks and station-yard earthworks, it refers only to standalone cut-and-fill earthworks items and earthworks of ditches and channels not requiring masonry... Earth and rock excavation related to masonry and other works has its cost included in the main works. Thus the pit excavation and backfill of a retaining wall go into the retaining wall, and the pit excavation and backfill of bridge/culvert open-cut foundations go into the foundation masonry."
2. Attribution tests: excavation of pits for bridge/culvert open-cut foundations, pile caps and culvert foundations -> bridge/culvert chapters (into foundation masonry), using QY-1~QY-7 (selected by pit depth <=4 m/<=6 m, wet/dry); pit backfill -> the bridge volume's backfill items; spoil haul beyond 10 m -> subgrade volume haul/incremental-haul items booked separately; anchors, shotcrete, soil nails and other support -> subgrade volume items; steel sheet-pile support retains earth but does not waterproof (for waterproofing use a steel sheet-pile cofferdam). Subgrade-bridge boundary (Appendix A, item 8): without a bridge-subgrade transition section, the embankment gap behind the abutment belongs to the bridge; with one, the transition behind the abutment belongs to the subgrade.
3. No saving by using subgrade items: the subgrade volume's excavator dig/load base prices run about 1/3 of the bridge volume's pit excavation (e.g., QY-1 mechanical excavation, pit depth <=4 m dry, about 5 yuan/m3; QY-3 depth <=6 m dry about 8 yuan/m3; against subgrade LY excavator self-dig-self-dump/load about 1.3-1.8 yuan/m3 — all official base-period prices). That spread is the temptation, but cross-volume borrowing is misapplication: (1) the rules are mandatory (dual written basis: general notes + compilation measures); (2) work content differs (QY includes manual digging within 0.3 m of the pit bottom and trimming of walls and bottom; LY is only dig/load/haul); (3) whichever depth layer is being dug, the quota of the pit's total depth governs.
Applicable Boundaries
- Applies only to the railway 2024 quota system (effective 1 January 2025, replacing TZJ 1001-2017 and other old editions).
- Not applicable to building/municipal BOQ pricing (e.g., GB/T 50854), whose pit BOQ quantities include working space and exclude slope — a different caliber; do not mix.
- Dry excavation means above the groundwater table, wet below; excavating silt and flowing sand uses one quota regardless of wet/dry; after wellpoint dewatering, excavation counts as dry.
- Base prices cited are base-period and indicate magnitude only; actual pricing follows the current valid quota edition and compilation-period price documents.
Further Reading
- TB/T 10823-2024 "Railway works budget quota, Volume 2: bridge and culvert works", Chapter 1 substructure, Section 1 excavation and pumping (QY-1~QY-7 mechanical excavation of soil/silt/flowing sand; work content includes "haul 10 m beyond the pit", manual digging within 0.3 m of the bottom, and trimming).
- TB/T 10822-2024 "Railway works budget quota, Volume 1: subgrade works", Part 1 general notes (the pit-excavation exclusion clause and cross-volume pointer).
- TB 10801-2024 "Measures for compiling design estimates (budgets) of railway capital construction projects", Appendix A composite chapter table, item 4 (earthworks attribution) and item 8 (subgrade-bridge boundary).
- Related cards: pipe culverts under the railway 2024 quota (QY items of the same volume); TB 10801-2024 effective date and old-new interface; the three-tier scope of railway estimates; GB/T 50854 foundation earthworks BOQ measurement (cross-system comparison).
Keywords
- 桥涵基坑开挖
- subgrade earthworks (earth and rock)
- 定额划界
- 挖基及抽水
- QY子目
- 基础圬工
- railway works budget quota manual (China Railway)
- 弃方运距
- 错套定额