Fixing the rent-commencement point in leases of tower cranes and other construction hoisting machinery, and the nature of the charge for the delivered-but-not-installed period: rent versus occupation charges, three fault scenarios, points of proof, and the Civil Code and Decree No. 166 basis
Rent is consideration for use and income (Civil Code Arts. 703 and 708), and under Art. 16 of the Rules on Safety Supervision and Administration of Construction Hoisting Machinery (MOC Decree No. 166) such machinery may not be used before passing acceptance, so the period when the machine is on site but not installed, tested or accepted in principle carries no rent: where the delay is the lessor's, no rent accrues and delay damages may be claimed on top; where it is the lessee's, only a machinery occupation or custody charge runs (depreciation or a set proportion of the daily rate + on-site custody and watchkeeping labour + capital occupation, excluding power and maintenance costs); where neither party is at fault, the loss is shared per the agreement or by equity. With no agreement, rent starts on the day the machine is installed, tested, accepted and fit for use; 'rent from delivery' stands only where the contract expressly says so and the machine was ready for installation on schedule. On proof, the delivery receipt evidences only transfer of possession and the start of custody, not the rent-commencement date; the start and rent-free periods must be proved by chaining installation records, the supervision-inspection report, the acceptance form and the use-registration date.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第七百零三条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第七百零八条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第七百一十三条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第七百二十一条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第七百二十三条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第七百二十九条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百零九条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百九十一条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一千二百六十条
- 《建筑起重机械安全监督管理规定》(建设部令第166号)第六条、第十六条、第十七条
- 《建设工程安全生产管理条例》(国务院令第393号)第三十五条
- JGJ 196-2010 第3.4.16条、第3.4.18条及App. B
- GB 50870-2013 第8.3.7条
- DBJ41/T 228-2019 第8.3.3条
Topic positioning
In leases of tower cranes and other construction hoisting machinery (and of plant and tools), where the machine has arrived on site but is not yet installed, not yet supervision-inspected and not yet accepted, can the lessor claim rent for that period; how the rent-commencement point is fixed; whether the charge for that period is rent or an occupation charge; and what each side must prove.
Core conclusions
I. One test only: rent is consideration for use and income; arrival on site completes only delivery of possession, not delivery of a machine fit for use. Civil Code Art. 703: a lease contract is one by which the lessor delivers the leased property to the lessee for use and income and the lessee pays rent. Art. 708: the lessor shall deliver the leased property as agreed and keep it fit for the agreed use throughout the lease term. An uninstalled, unaccepted machine is objectively unfit for the agreed use; the lessor has not performed its duty to deliver the property fit for the agreed use.
II. During that period the machine is in law not allowed to be used at all, so no use-income arises. Rules on Safety Supervision and Administration of Construction Hoisting Machinery (MOC Decree No. 166) Art. 16: 'After a construction hoisting machine is installed, the user unit shall organise the lessor, the erector, the supervising unit and other relevant units to carry out acceptance, or entrust an inspection agency with the corresponding qualification to do so. The machinery may be put into use only after passing acceptance; it may not be used where acceptance has not been carried out or has not been passed. Where construction general contracting is used, the general contractor organises the acceptance. Before acceptance, the machinery shall have passed supervision inspection by an inspection agency with the corresponding qualification. The inspection agency and its personnel bear legal responsibility for the inspection results and assessment conclusions.' Regulation on Work Safety of Construction Projects (State Council Decree No. 393) Art. 35 is to the same effect: before using construction hoisting machinery, integral-lift scaffolds, formwork and other self-climbing rigs, the construction unit shall organise acceptance - 'for machinery, plant, tools and fittings taken on lease, the general contractor, the subcontractors, the lessor and the erector carry out acceptance jointly; only what passes acceptance may be used' - and registration with the construction administrative authority within 30 days of passing acceptance, with the registration mark displayed prominently on the machine. The tower-crane erection procedure likewise requires: after the erector's self-inspection passes, commission a qualified inspection agency to test and issue a test report (JGJ 196-2010 Clause 3.4.16); after self-inspection and testing pass, the general contractor organises the lessor, erector, user and supervising units for acceptance, filling the acceptance form per Annex B of that ruleset, and only after passing may the crane be used (Clause 3.4.18).
III. Three fault scenarios; no blanket answer:
- Delay on the lessor's side (machine documents missing, erector or erection crew not mobilised, machine failing checks and needing rectification, installation notification not filed) -> no rent for the period, and the lessee may separately claim its delay losses (lessor breach).
- Delay on the lessee's side (site not handed over, foundation not cast, permits or drawings lagging, schedule changed so the machine is not yet needed) -> the lessor may claim a charge, but its nature is a machinery occupation or custody charge, not rent, and it should be below full rent.
- Neither side at fault (government stop-work orders, extreme weather, third-party causes) -> borne per the agreement or by equity, usually as an occupation charge or with the lease term extended accordingly. In one sentence: 'rent runs from delivery' holds only where the contract expressly so agrees and the machine was fit for installation on schedule; absent such a term, a lessor claiming full rent on a delivery receipt alone lacks a cause of action.
IV. Rent-commencement determination table
| Scenario | Rent-commencement date | Main basis | Consequence for the idle period |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract expressly agrees rent runs from the machine's arrival on site | Per the agreement: the arrival date | Civil Code Art. 721: 'the lessee shall pay rent as agreed' | The lessor's claim has a basis; but check whether the wording truly covers the uninstalled period, and whether it is a standard term the lessor supplied without drawing attention (which may be excluded from the contract content) |
| Contract agrees rent runs from the date of passing installation, commissioning, testing and acceptance (the most common in the industry) | The date of passing acceptance | Art. 721 plus trade usage in the industry | No rent for the period; the start moves to the day of passing acceptance |
| Contract agrees a fixed commencement date | That agreed date | Art. 721 | If on that date the machine is objectively unfit for use for reasons attributable to the lessor, postponement may be claimed under Art. 708 |
| Contract agrees no rent-start condition | The day the machine is installed, tested, accepted and fit for use | Art. 703 (consideration for use and income) plus Art. 708 plus Art. 509 (the parties shall perform their obligations fully per the agreement; observe good faith and perform the duties of notice, assistance and confidentiality per the nature, purpose and usage of the contract) | The arrival date proves only transfer of possession and the start of custody; it is not automatically the rent start |
| No agreement, and the machine is handed to the lessee for custody on arrival | The uninstalled period is charged as an occupation or custody charge, not rent | Art. 703 by converse inference, plus Art. 509 good faith and usage | The lessor may obtain partial compensation but has no claim in the name of 'rent' |
The fallback on rent-payment timing, Art. 721: where no term is agreed or the agreement is unclear and Art. 510 still cannot determine it, rent for a lease under one year is paid when the term expires; for a lease of one year or more, at the expiry of each year, and the remainder under one year when the term expires.
V. The nature of the charge for the delivered-but-not-installed period: not rent but an occupation charge.
- Rent = consideration for use and income (Art. 703); no use is allowed before acceptance passes (Decree No. 166 Art. 16); no use and income, no consideration.
- An occupation or custody charge = compensation for the lessor's machine and accompanying crew being tied up on the lessee's site and unable to be re-let elsewhere; its build-up is typically machine depreciation (or a set proportion of the daily rate) + on-site custody and watchkeeping labour + capital occupation; excluding power costs and repair and maintenance costs - the same logic as the make-up of standby costs during suspension.
- Rent-free-period usage: the installation, testing and acceptance operations (routinely several days to ten-odd days for tower cranes, longer where wall-ties and climbing are involved) are by trade usage not charged; periods of rectification, re-inspection or return to factory for the machine's own defects are likewise not charged; some contracts add a 7-day free erection period after arrival. Usage is not statute: it serves only as trade usage where the contract is silent (Art. 510: unclear terms may be determined by the related clauses of the contract or by usage).
- Statutory routes to reduced rent or an extended term: Art. 713 (where the lessor fails to perform its repair duty, the lessee may repair itself at the lessor's cost; where repairs affect use, rent is reduced or the term extended accordingly); Art. 723 (where a third party's asserted rights prevent use and income, the lessee may ask for reduced or no rent); Art. 729 (where the property is partly or wholly destroyed or lost for causes not attributable to the lessee, it may ask for reduced or no rent; where the contract purpose cannot be achieved, it may terminate).
VI. Points of proof.
- A lessor asserting 'rent from arrival': it must prove (i) an express agreed rent-start term, and (ii) that the machine was fit for installation on schedule after arrival (its own documentation and erection resources in place).
- The lessee's defence: the delivery receipt proves only transfer of possession and the start of custody, not the rent start; chain the installation notification and records, the issue date of the supervision-inspection report, the acceptance form (JGJ 196-2010 Annex B) and the use-registration date (Decree No. 166 Art. 17: register within 30 days of the installation passing acceptance) into a showing of 'the day the machine became fit for use', supported by site and foundation handover records, supervision logs, schedule-change documents and correspondence to fix where the delay lies.
- Duty to mitigate: Art. 591 - after one party breaches, the other shall take appropriate measures to prevent aggravation of the loss; it may not claim for the aggravated part it failed to prevent; reasonable expenses incurred in prevention are borne by the breaching party.
- Vet the lessor's entry documents on the same day: the lessor shall define the safety responsibilities of both sides in the lease contract and produce the special-equipment manufacturing licence, the product certificate of conformity, the manufacturing supervision-inspection certificate, the filing certificate and the self-inspection certificate, and submit the erection and use instructions (Decree No. 166 Art. 6) - missing documents are often direct proof of lessor-attributable delay.
VII. Required columns of the handover-acceptance form (the written grip that stops the arrival date being read as the fit-for-use date). GB 50870-2013 Clause 8.3.7: machinery and construction tools shall undergo handover acceptance before use, covering (1) the machine foundation; (2) electrical installations; (3) safety devices; (4) metal structure and connectors; (5) protective devices; (6) transmission mechanisms, power units and hydraulic systems; (7) lifting gear and slings. The commentary to that clause notes that leased machinery and tools are widely used on construction sites and user units change during the works, so handover acceptance is required for machinery, tools and changed users entering the site, fixing safety responsibility in use. Handover of leased property further follows DBJ41/T 228-2019 Clause 8.3.3: at handover of leased property and its documents, the leasing unit and the lessee inspect and accept and complete handover formalities, and the arrival and exit times of each batch are registered. So the arrival handover form should state the nature of the handover (custody / awaiting erection / erection completed), the attached document list and the arrival and exit times - do not let it merge into 'rent commences'.
VIII. Versions of the law and effective dates. Civil Code Art. 1260: 'This Code takes effect on 1 January 2021. The Marriage Law, the Inheritance Law, the General Principles of the Civil Law, the Adoption Law, the Security Law, the Contract Law, the Property Law, the Tort Liability Law and the General Provisions of the Civil Law are repealed at the same time.' So lease disputes before 1 January 2021 follow the former Contract Law; from that date the Civil Code lease chapter (Arts. 703-734) applies.
Scope and limits
- This card addresses rent-charge disputes over leases of construction hoisting machinery (tower cranes and the like) and plant and tools; sales contracts, finance leases and work-and-materials contracts are outside it.
- Where the contract has an express, valid rent-start term, the term governs; the 'rent from passing acceptance' rule here is only the fallback for silence or unclear terms; to exclude a standard term from the contract content requires separate proof that it was not pointed out and explained.
- Rent-free periods and occupation-charge rates belong to trade usage and agreement, not statutory standards; the specific rate or daily-rent proportion must follow the contract and the project.
- If the lessee uses the machine without authorisation before acceptance, that both changes the analysis of the charge's nature and independently triggers safety and administrative liability, to be assessed separately.
- The occupation charge excludes power and maintenance costs; the corresponding elements within plant machine-shift rates must not be charged again on top.
Further reading
- Civil Code (Presidential Decree No. 45), Contract Part, lease chapter: Arts. 703, 708, 713, 721, 723 and 729; also Arts. 509, 591 and 1260.
- Rules on Safety Supervision and Administration of Construction Hoisting Machinery (MOC Decree No. 166): Art. 6 (the lessor's five certificates and defined safety responsibilities), Art. 16 (acceptance organised after erection; supervision inspection before acceptance; use only after passing), Art. 17 (use registration within 30 days of passing acceptance; registration mark displayed prominently).
- Regulation on Work Safety of Construction Projects (State Council Decree No. 393), Art. 35 (acceptance before use; four-party joint acceptance of leased equipment; registration within 30 days).
- JGJ 196-2010 Technical Rules for Safety of Erection, Use and Dismantling of Tower Cranes in Building Construction: Clause 3.4.16 (testing commissioned after self-inspection; test report issued), Clause 3.4.18 (general contractor organises lessor, erector, user and supervising units for acceptance; form per Annex B).
- GB 50870-2013 Unified Code for Construction Safety Technology, Clause 8.3.7 (seven handover-acceptance items and commentary).
- DBJ41/T 228-2019 Standard for Safety Documentation Management at Building Construction Sites, Clause 8.3.3 (inspection and acceptance of leased property and documents; handover formalities; arrival and exit time registration).
Keywords
- 塔吊租赁
- 起租时点
- 设备占用费
- 免租期
- 进场未安装
- 租金对价
- 民法典租赁合同
- 验收合格方可使用
- 建筑起重机械
- 交接验收单