Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Order of application between contract agreement and national pricing standards in construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal): contract prevails where agreed, standards as fallback (GB/T 51262-2017 Section 5.3 layered rules)

Construction cost expert assessment follows "contract prevails where agreed": where the contract is valid and its pricing basis clearly agreed, the appraiser must appraise per the contract and may not overturn the agreement on the ground that "national pricing standards are mandatory"; national pricing standards (the BOQ pricing standard, quota norms, etc.) serve only as fallback reference where the contract has no agreement or the agreement is unclear, and whether to adopt them is decided by the commissioning party (court/arbitral body). GB/T 51262-2017 Clauses 5.3.3-5.3.5 layer the handling: unclear agreement -> ascertain the facts of performance and appraise accordingly, or where unperformed suggest "appraising by reference to the pricing bases, pricing methods, and market price information at signing applicable at the project's location in the same period"; no agreement -> likewise propose the reference suggestion and appraise per the commissioning party's decision; contradictions -> refer the choice of applicable clause to the commissioning party, and where not yet clarified, issue separate appraisal opinions under the differing clauses for its judgment.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范(第5.3.3~5.3.5、5.5.1条)
  • GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范(第9.3.2条)
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引(第3.1.5、3.2.4条)
  • 中华人民共和国民法典 第七百九十三条
  • 建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法(住房和城乡建设部令第16号)第三条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号 建设工程施工合同司法解释(一)第24条
  • DB37/T 5130-2018 建设工程造价咨询服务规范(第9.3.5条)

Topic Positioning

Answers, in construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal), "which prevails where the contract's agreed pricing basis is inconsistent with, missing from, or contradictory to national pricing standards (the BOQ pricing standard, quota norms, etc.)": the hierarchy is statutory-first > contract-prevails > standards-fallback, plus GB/T 51262-2017 "Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment (Judicial Appraisal)" Section 5.3's layered rules for unclear, absent, and contradictory agreements.

Core Conclusions

  1. Hierarchy: where the contract is valid and its pricing basis clearly agreed, the appraiser shall appraise per the contract; national pricing standards are only fallback reference where the contract is silent or unclear, and the appraiser cannot decide alone — the commissioning party must decide.
  • GB/T 51095-2015 "Code for Construction Cost Consulting", Clause 9.3.2: "where the construction contract's agreement is valid, the appraisal shall adopt the pricing method agreed by the parties, except where the parties separately reach a consistent agreement". The commentary points out: the "Measures for the Administration of Pricing of Construction Contracting and Subcontracting" (MOHURD Order No. 16), Article 3, provides that construction contracting and subcontracting prices are "formed by market competition under government macro-control", so the assessment respects the parties' agreement; but the agreement must be lawful and valid — agreements violating mandatory provisions of laws or administrative regulations are void.
  1. GB/T 51262-2017 "Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment (Judicial Appraisal)", Section 5.3 layered handling:
  • Clause 5.3.3 (unclear agreement): the appraiser shall ascertain the facts of the contract's performance; where performed per the contract, propose appraising accordingly to the commissioning party; where unperformed, may propose the suggestion of "appraising by reference to the pricing bases, pricing methods, and market price information at signing applicable at the location of the appraised project in the same period", and appraise per the commissioning party's decision.
  • Clause 5.3.4 (no agreement): the appraiser may propose to the commissioning party the same "reference to the pricing bases, pricing methods, and market price information at signing applicable at the project's location in the same period" suggestion, and appraise per the commissioning party's decision.
  • Clause 5.3.5 (contradictions): the appraiser shall refer the applicable clause to the commissioning party for decision; where the commissioning party is not yet clear, the appraiser shall issue separate appraisal opinions under the differing agreed clauses for the commissioning party's judgment.
  1. Fallback positioning of national pricing standards: T/ZBD 100.4-2023 "Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice", Clause 3.2.4: "the appraiser's construction cost expert assessment principles, bases and methods shall conform to the contract agreement of the parties to the appraised project; where the agreement is unclear or not made, the following national standards may be selected for application:" including GB/T 50875 "Standard for Construction Cost Terminology", GB 50500, the China national pricing standard for BOQ, the GB 50854 to GB 50862 series of quantity take-off codes (from building and decoration works to blasting works), GB/T 50353 "Standard for Calculating Gross Floor Area of Building Construction", and GB/T 50531 "Standard for the Division of Equipment and Materials in Construction Cost Estimation".
  2. Handling of contract-basis disputes (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 3.1.5): where the parties submit two or more contract versions, appraise the version the commissioning party specifies; unspecified -> appraise each version separately and issue selective opinions; on validity disputes, appraise per the version the commissioning party determines valid, and where determined void, request the commissioning party to clarify the appraisal principles and bases — whether the price clauses, overheads rates, profit rates, and pricing bases of the void contract apply; where the commissioning party has not determined validity, appraise separately under both the valid and void scenarios with selective opinions; where supplementary agreements conflict with the contract or clauses are disputed in interpretation and the commissioning party has not decided, matters within cost-management expertise may be determined by the appraiser with definitive opinions, and matters outside expertise get selective opinions.
  3. Void contract but accepted works: Civil Code Article 793 — "where the construction contract is void but the works pass completion acceptance, the contractor may be compensated by reference to the contract's agreement on the project price"; where completion acceptance fails, the employer may claim repair costs after successful repair; where the repair still fails, the contractor has no right to compensation by reference to the contract, and a culpable employer bears corresponding responsibility. Determining contract invalidity rests with the people's courts and arbitral tribunals — the appraiser shall request their determination; where the commissioning party requires the assessment also to be made per "budget quota norms" or by reference to market prices, the appraiser shall issue two selective opinions and may claim additional expert assessment fees.
  4. Measurement rules likewise: GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.5.1: "where the appraised project's drawings are complete and the parties dispute the measurement basis, the appraiser shall measure the works per the method of measurement set out in the current relevant national measurement codes; absent national standards, per industry or local standards — except where the parties have agreed measurement rules in the contract."

Applicable Boundaries

  • Premise: the contract agreement is lawful and valid — agreements violating mandatory provisions of laws or administrative regulations (e.g., departing from the bid documents' substantive content, below-cost tendering) are void, reverting to the statutory/national-standard path.
  • "Contract prevails" applies both to the pricing basis and method and to the method of measurement (except where the contract prescribes its own measurement rules).
  • The appraiser has no power to determine contract validity — refer it to the commissioning party (court/arbitral body); where the commissioning party is unclear, the appraiser must not choose alone but shall issue selective opinions for judgment.
  • Where the contract is void but the works pass completion acceptance, the tendency is still compensation by reference to the contract's price provisions, not automatic re-pricing by quota norms — parties asserting invalidity often aim to escape unfavourable price terms and demand re-pricing per government quota norms; the appraiser should not endorse that path as the sole conclusion.
  • Local-standard corroboration (DB37/T 5130-2018 "Specification for Construction Cost Consulting Service", Clause 9.3.5, Shandong): where the commissioning party does not clarify, for void contracts or absent/unclear pricing bases, the appraiser shall ascertain the facts of performance and appraise per the actual performance; where unperformed, "appraisal by reference to the pricing bases, pricing methods, and market price information at signing applicable at the project's location in the same period" may be used; contradictions and differing signed texts -> separate appraisal opinions per differing clauses/texts for the commissioning party's judgment.

Further Reading

  • GB/T 51262-2017 "Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment (Judicial Appraisal)", Section 5.3 (Clause 5.3.3 unclear agreement; Clause 5.3.4 no agreement; Clause 5.3.5 contradictions), Clause 5.5.1 (measurement basis).
  • GB/T 51095-2015 "Code for Construction Cost Consulting", Clause 9.3.2 and commentary; "Measures for the Administration of Pricing of Construction Contracting and Subcontracting" (MOHURD Order No. 16), Article 3.
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 "Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice", Clause 3.1.5 (contract-basis dispute handling), Clause 3.2.4 (fallback national-standards list).
  • Civil Code of the PRC, Article 793; SPC "Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes" (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), Article 24 (several void contracts over one project: reference the actually performed contract, or failing determination, the last signed).
  • DB37/T 5130-2018 "Specification for Construction Cost Consulting Service" (Shandong local standard), Clause 9.3.5.

Keywords