Cost treatment of re-drilling after borehole collapse in cast-in-place piling: attribution of rework responsibility (employer cause / contractor cause / adverse physical conditions), the on-site confirmation evidence chain, the measurable cost heads, responsibility for concrete over-consumption coefficient excesses, and the 28-day claim procedure
Whether the cost of re-drilling after collapse can be measured depends on attribution of responsibility, not on the number of re-drills. Under GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 7.6.4, where the cause is a variation or employer responsibility, the rework items, quantities and written-off or scrapped materials listed in the rework confirmation sheet serve as the basis for measurement and price adjustment; rework quantities arising from contractor responsibility shall not be measured (cl. 7.1.4 item 5, 'other rework caused by contractor responsibility'). Where the sand stratum was disclosed by the ground investigation but the wall-protection measures were inadequate - the contractor's methods risk; where it was not disclosed, or is materially inconsistent with what was actually drilled - adverse physical conditions, with the cost and time borne by the employer under GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.8.4. Claims require a written Notice of Claim within 28 days of the event (where the contract is silent); late notice may be treated as waiver (cl. 8.11.3).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第7.1.4条、第7.6.4条、第8.11.3条
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第5.8.4条
- GB/T 50319-2013 建设工程监理规范 第5.2.11条及Table A.0.6
- JGJ 94-2008 建筑桩基技术规范 第6.3.30条
- DB42/T 1532-2019 旋挖成孔灌注桩施工安全技术规程 第7.3.26条、第11.2.1条
- SJG 111.1-2022 城市地下综合管廊工程消耗量标准(Vol. 1)第3.1.4条
- 陕西省新编消耗量定额(征求意见稿)桩基章说明及表3-3
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》第九条
Positioning
Settlement treatment where mechanically bored cast-in-place piles (rotary-excavation, rotary-circulation and percussion rigs, etc.) meet borehole collapse in sand strata and re-drill (repeat boring): whether it can be measured depends on attribution of responsibility, not on the number of re-drills - plus the on-site confirmation requirements, the measurable cost heads, the attribution of over-consumption coefficient excesses, and the claim time limits.
Core conclusions
1. The test is attribution of responsibility, not the number of re-drills. GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 7.6.4: 'For items involving rework, the responsibilities of the employer and the contractor shall be clarified as agreed in the contract, and the costs arising from the rework shall be borne by the responsible party. Where the cause is a variation or employer responsibility, the rework items in the rework confirmation sheet and their quantities, and the written-off or scrapped purchased and processed materials and their quantities, shall be the measured quantities of the rework concerned and the basis for computing the price of the rework under Chapter 8 of this standard; where the cause is contractor responsibility, the rework quantities shall not be measured.' Commentary: 'where the rework is caused by a variation or by the employer, the rework compensation shall be computed per the rework items and quantities and the written-off or scrapped materials and their quantities fixed in the rework confirmation sheet signed by both parties; where the rework is caused by the contractor's failure to perform as agreed, the costs shall be borne by the contractor itself, and the confirmation sheet cannot be used to compute rework compensation.'
2. Items excluded from measurement (cl. 7.1.4). 'The following works and work executed by the contractor shall not be measured: 1 temporary works executed by the contractor to complete the permanent works, except temporary works agreed in the contract as measurable; 2 works beyond the contract scope caused by the contractor; 3 works completed by the contractor but not conforming to the contract drawings and specifications; 4 works or work demolished and removed by the contractor as not conforming to the contract drawings and specifications; 5 other rework caused by contractor responsibility.' - Backfilling with clay or low-grade concrete after collapse to stabilise the hole wall, then re-drilling, falls under item 5 'other rework': where the responsibility is the contractor's it is not measured; but where the backfill is caused by adverse physical conditions within employer responsibility, it is handled as a claim.
3. Whether the sand stratum was disclosed by the ground investigation is the watershed. Investigation disclosed the sand but the wall-protection and stabilising-fluid measures were inadequate (e.g. insufficient fluid viscosity / relative density, casing not raised or deepened) - the contractor's methods risk, and the re-drilling is not priced. The investigation did not disclose it, or is materially inconsistent with what was actually drilled - adverse physical conditions, assessed under GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.8.4: 'where the contractor claims added costs and delay from adverse physical conditions or abnormally adverse climatic conditions, the assessor shall assess as follows: 1 where the contractor notified the employer in time and the employer, agreeing, promptly issued instructions consenting, the added costs of the reasonable measures taken and the delay are borne by the employer; where the parties have already reached agreement on the specific figure, the assessor shall adopt that figure; where the parties have not agreed on the figure, the assessor determines through professional discernment and judgment; 2 where the contractor notified the employer in time but the employer did not reply in time, the assessor may determine from a professional standpoint through discernment and judgment.' Supporting basis: Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects Article 9 - 'the employer must provide the survey, design, construction and supervision units with the original data relating to the construction project. The original data must be true, accurate and complete.'
4. Procedure and time limits (cl. 8.11.3; delay risks forfeiture). '1 The contractor shall, within the period agreed in the contract (28 days if none) after the claim event, submit to the employer a written Notice of Claim stating the cause of the event and the claim intention; where the contractor fails to issue the notice in time, the matter may be handled as agreed in the contract. 2 The contractor shall, within the period agreed in the contract (28 days if none) after the notice is issued, submit the written claim report, detailing the cause of the event, the contract clauses relied on, the costs and / or extension days claimed, with the necessary records and supporting material and the detailed claim cost computation schedule. 3 Claims involving both added cost and extended time shall be raised together. 4 For events with continuing effect, the contractor shall submit continuing notices at the agreed interval (no more than 28 days if none) or at reasonable intervals ... 5 The contractor shall, within the period agreed in the contract (28 days if none) after the event ends ... submit the final claim report.' And expressly: 'where the injured party fails to claim within the agreed time after the claim event, the claim may, save as otherwise agreed in the contract or provided by laws and regulations, be treated as waived.'
5. On-site confirmation requirements (an evidence chain with no missing link). (1) The rework confirmation sheet: signed by both parties, itemising the collapse location, the number of re-drills, the backfill volume, the written-off materials and quantities - it is the sole vehicle for computing rework compensation; where the cause lies with the responsible party, it 'cannot be used to compute rework compensation'. (2) The supervising engineer's standing-supervision records: GB/T 50319-2013 cl. 5.2.11 - 'the project supervision body shall, per the project's characteristics and the contractor's project execution plan, fix the key positions and key processes for standing supervision, arrange supervisors for standing supervision and record the situation in time; standing-supervision records shall be completed per Form A.0.6 of this code.' It also lists among the key positions 'positions whose quality cannot be tested after completion or whose rework would cause major loss, and their construction processes' - collapse and re-drilling is exactly such a case. (3) Boring and concreting records: DB42/T 1532-2019 cl. 7.3.26 - 'boring records shall be kept during drilling, mainly covering hole depth, stratum changes, drilling time and the handling of failures'; cl. 11.2.1 on collapse treatment - 'before treatment, analyse and understand the depth, extent, strata and in-hole stabilising-fluid indices of the collapse and identify its cause'; 'for minor collapse deeper than 6.0 m, the viscosity and relative density of the stabilising fluid should be increased'; 'for severe collapse deeper than 6.0 m, or collapse in complex strata, the collapsed section of the hole shall be backfilled with clay or low-grade concrete and drilling resumed once basically stable'; 'the collapse and its treatment shall be recorded truthfully' ('basically stable' is generally taken by experience as 8.0 hours or more). JGJ 94-2008 cl. 6.3.30 requires for underwater concreting that 'dedicated personnel measure the tremie embedment depth and the difference of concrete level inside and outside the pipe, and complete the underwater concreting record', and that failures during concreting 'shall be recorded and filed'. (4) Stratum comparison and imagery: comparison of the investigation borehole logs with the strata actually drilled and the slurry return; imagery of the collapsed section and delivery notes for the backfill materials.
6. Cost heads. The measurable part covers only content 'actually added and not covered by the original rates': the re-drilled bore length (bore length x design pile cross-section area, priced under the corresponding boring quota line items); collapse backfill materials (clay / low-grade concrete); abnormal casing increments (lengthened or deepened, or unrecoverable and adjusted as confirmed on site); and off-site transport of slurry (muck) and waste-fluid treatment. No double counting of included content: GB/T 50854-2024 Table C.2.1 work content already includes casing installation, borehole wall stabilisation, backfilling of empty holes, slurry preparation and on-site transport; SJG 111.1-2022 cl. 3.1.4 - 'the grab (percussion hammer) and rotary-excavation boring items are compiled for wet-operation boring, including slurry preparation but excluding slurry transport and the installation and removal of steel casing; in-pile slurry (muck) transport executes the slurry transport items of Chapter 1 of this volume'. Ordinary casing, slurry preparation and on-site transport therefore sit within the all-in unit rate; only abnormal increments and off-site transport are separately payable.
7. Attribution of over-consumption coefficient excesses. The quota material content already includes the over-consumption coefficient and wastage; where the actual differs, the usual treatment is 'adjust the material content only, not labour or plant': the new Shaanxi consumption quota (draft for comments), piling chapter notes item 3 - 'the material quantities of the various bored piles in the quota already include the over-consumption coefficient and material wastage ... where the actual design or construction differs from the coefficient in the table, the material content may be adjusted, but labour and plant are not adjusted' (the table's over-consumption coefficients for bored piles: rotary-circulation and auger rigs 1.20; rotary-excavation and percussion rigs 1.25; percussion-bored and hole-enlarging rigs 1.30; wastage rate 1%); the Jiangsu 2026 edition is aligned - 'at settlement the over-consumption coefficient is adjusted per the pour volume in the piling records, with operating wastage unchanged'. Hence: concrete over-consumption from ordinary over-pour or hole enlargement adjusts the material content per the coefficient; concrete over-consumption caused by collapse is attributed by responsibility - contractor-cause is not measured, employer cause (adverse physical conditions) is claimed.
Boundaries
- Applies to collapse, necking or trapped tooling in complex strata (sand, gravel, karst) for mechanically bored cast-in-place piles and their re-drilling and backfill treatment, and to rework and preliminaries treatment under the building, municipal and utility-tunnel consumption-quota systems.
- Not applicable or to be used with care: dry-operation boring (a different collapse mechanism and measures, and the boring items must deduct water and slurry pumps); pile length or diameter changes from design changes are priced as variations, not claimed as rework; signed interim settlement documents cannot be re-measured and re-priced.
- The responsibility line depends on the provable difference between 'disclosed by investigation' and 'actually drilled'; absent standing-supervision, boring and concreting records, the matter is usually treated as contractor responsibility (cl. 7.1.4 item 5).
- Provincial quotas differ in how they list re-drilling, backfill and slurry disposal; before settlement, check the piling chapter notes of the current consumption standard at the project location - no cross-provincial borrowing of coefficients.
Further reading
GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 7.1.4, 7.6.4 and 8.11.3 (the full claim procedure in section 8.11); GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.8.4; GB/T 50319-2013 cl. 5.2.11 and Form A.0.6; JGJ 94-2008 cl. 6.3.30; DB42/T 1532-2019 cl. 7.3.26 and cl. 11.2.1; GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix C Table C.2.1 work content; SJG 111.1-2022 cl. 3.1.4; the new Shaanxi consumption quota (draft for comments), piling chapter notes items 2-9 and Table 3-3; Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects Article 9. For Yunnan projects, also verify the quota treatment of boring, backfill and slurry disposal under Yunnan's current consumption standard and pricing basis.
Keywords
- 塌孔
- 复钻
- 返工
- concrete over-consumption coefficient (bored piles)
- 护筒
- 泥浆
- 不利物质条件
- Notice of Claim
- 旁站记录