Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Cost bearing for material scrap caused by design changes: employer compensation rules and three premises (GB/T 50500-2024 Sections 7.6, 8.11)

Where a design change (employer cause) scraps qualified materials already purchased, processed, or delivered by the contractor, the employer compensates, computed as "main-material cost within the contract unit price x scrapped quantity − recovered residual value"; the premises are that the materials are qualified, a written rework confirmation request is submitted within the contractually agreed time, and best efforts at loss mitigation are made — failure to confirm in writing within the time limit deems no scrap caused and no compensation.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准

Topic Positioning

Who bears the cost and how compensation is made when a design change (employer cause) scraps the contractor's qualified materials already purchased, processed, or delivered — responsibility attribution and claim basis under GB/T 50500-2024.

Core Conclusions

The employer should compensate, subject to the simultaneous satisfaction of the three premises "qualified materials + time-limited written confirmation + best-efforts mitigation": 1 Responsibility attribution: where a work variation or employer-responsibility event causes scrap of materials already purchased or processed by the contractor, the employer shall compensate the relevant losses and/or direct costs (Clause 7.6.1); the contractor may also claim per Clause 8.11.9 the direct costs of rework and demolition-modification, the direct loss of scrapped materials, and stoppage and machinery idle losses; for rework caused by the employer, profit may additionally be claimed (Clause 8.11.10). 2 Compensation caliber: the unit price of scrapped materials is the main-material cost included in the contract unit price (excluding management fee and profit), deducted by recovery or discount (Clause 7.6.3) — compensation = main-material cost x scrapped quantity − recovered residual value. 3 Three red lines: (1) scrap of unqualified materials is borne by the contractor itself (Clause 3.7.3); (2) scrap of over-requisitioned materials due to contractor causes is borne by itself (Clause 3.6.3); (3) failure to submit a written rework confirmation request within the contractually agreed time deems no scrap caused and no compensation (Clause 7.6.1 time-bar). 4 Mitigation duty: where return to suppliers or transfer to other projects was possible but not done, a corresponding deduction applies (Clause 8.9.8).

Applicable Boundaries

Applies only to qualified materials or processed semi-finished products already delivered on site and conforming to the contract; the compensation scope excludes materials not conforming to contract requirements (Clause 2.0.28). Extra losses of employer-supplied materials caused by specifications/models mismatching the tender are borne by the employer (Clause 3.6.3). Pure variation compensation generally excludes profit, depending on the variation's nature and contractual agreement. Failure to declare within the time limit forfeits the right; purchase vouchers, delivery acceptance records, and photos are essential evidence.

Further Reading

See GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 2.0.28, 3.6.3, 3.7.3, 7.6.1, 7.6.3, 8.9.8, 8.11.9, 8.11.10; for the time limits and procedure of the notice of claim intention and claim report see Clause 8.11.3 (28-day twin nodes).

Keywords

Cited By