Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Proving the authenticity of WeChat chat records as evidence in construction price disputes: the statutory status of electronic data, recognition of the original, the seven-factor authenticity review, situations of presumed authenticity, downgrading to uncorroborated evidence, and exclusion of unlawfully obtained records

WeChat chat records are electronic data under item (5) of Article 66(1) of the Civil Procedure Law (Article 116 of the SPC Interpretation on the Civil Procedure Law covers 'online chat records') and may serve as evidence in construction price disputes, but authenticity is proven by the party relying on the records to establish the facts of the case (Civil Procedure Law Article 67; Interpretation Article 90). Proof must close the four-link chain 'authentic medium -> same account -> complete content -> attribution of intent': records demonstrated in court on the original device, or exports derived directly from the original medium, are treated as the original (Evidence Rules Article 15(2)); authenticity is reviewed against the seven factors of Article 93; under Article 94 (provided or confirmed by a neutral third-party platform, formed in the ordinary course of business, kept by archive management, notarised, etc.) authenticity may be confirmed outright; where only screenshots exist and cannot be checked against the original medium, items (4) and (5) of Article 90 bar them from serving alone as the basis for finding facts, and the party failing to prove bears the adverse consequences; records obtained by means seriously infringing others' lawful rights or violating prohibitive rules (such as logging into or cracking another person's WeChat without authorisation) must not be used as the basis for finding facts.

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第六十六条、第六十七条、第七十二条
  • 《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(法释〔2015〕5号,2022修正)第九十条、第一百零六条、第一百一十六条
  • 《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》(法释〔2019〕19号,2019修正)第十一条、第十四条、第十五条、第八十五条、第八十七条、第八十八条、第九十条、第九十二条、第九十三条、第九十四条、第九十五条
  • 《中华人民共和国电子签名法》(2019修正)第八条
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百七十条、第四百六十九条
  • 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》(法释〔2020〕25号)第二十条
  • 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号)第二十三条
  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第五十六条、第五十七条、第五十八条
  • GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.4.2条

Scope of the Topic

This card answers: how authenticity is proven when WeChat chat records (text, voice, images, files, transfers and location records) are used as evidence in construction price disputes - by what rules courts review them, what proof materials the parties must submit, which situations allow authenticity to be presumed outright, which situations downgrade the records to uncorroborated evidence that cannot found a case alone, and which collection methods lead to outright exclusion. It serves proof preparation, cross-examination response and evidence self-checks for settlement disputes in litigation and arbitration.

Core Conclusions

I. Evidentiary status: statutory electronic data, not excluded for being electronic

Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) Article 66: 'Evidence includes: (1) statements of the parties; (2) documentary evidence; (3) physical evidence; (4) audio-visual material; (5) electronic data; ... Evidence must be verified as true before it may serve as the basis for finding facts.'

SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, 2022 amendment) Article 116: 'Electronic data means information formed or stored in electronic media through email, electronic data interchange, online chat records, blogs, microblogs, mobile text messages, electronic signatures, domain names and the like. Sound recordings and image recordings stored in electronic media are governed by the provisions on electronic data.'

Accordingly: WeChat chat records are 'online chat records'; WeChat voice messages and short videos are 'sound recordings and image recordings stored in electronic media'; all are reviewed under the electronic data rules, not under the old audio-visual-material approach centred on the original carrier.

Civil Code Article 469(3): 'Where a data message can tangibly represent the content it carries and can be accessed and used for reference at any time, such as through electronic data interchange or email, it is deemed to be in written form.' Hence variations, confirmations and price agreements reached over WeChat carry the appearance of 'written form', but this does not relieve the burden of proving authenticity.

SPC Several Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19) Article 14 lists the scope of electronic data: item (2) communication information from network services (mobile text messages, email, instant messaging, communication groups); item (3) user registration and identity authentication information, electronic transaction records, communication records, login logs; item (4) electronic files (documents, images, audio, video, digital certificates, computer programs).

II. Gate one - form of the original: printed screenshots are not automatically invalid

Evidence Rules Article 15(2): 'Where a party produces electronic data as evidence, it shall provide the original. A duplicate made by the maker of the electronic data that is identical to the original, or a printout or other output medium that can display and identify the data and derives directly from it, is deemed the original of the electronic data.'

Article 11 of the same provisions: a party producing evidence shall provide the original or original thing; where it needs to keep the original itself, or providing it is genuinely difficult, it may provide a copy or replica verified by the people's court as identical.

Key points: (1) the substance of the 'original' is whether it derives directly from the original medium and can be checked - not paper versus screen; (2) logging in live at the hearing on the phone and scrolling through the original conversation item by item is the most direct way of 'providing the original'; (3) chat records exported from the original medium and printed are deemed the original, but the party must be able to state the extractor, the extraction time, the method and the whereabouts of the original medium (recording the extraction process on video, or notarising it, is recommended).

III. Gate two - authenticity of content: comprehensive judgement on seven factors

Evidence Rules Article 93: 'In reviewing the authenticity of electronic data the people's court shall weigh comprehensively: (1) whether the hardware and software environment of the system on which its generation, storage and transmission depend is complete and reliable; (2) ... whether the system is in normal operation, and whether abnormal operation affects the data; (3) ... whether effective error-monitoring and verification means exist; (4) whether the data has been preserved, transmitted and extracted intact and by reliable methods; (5) whether it was formed and stored in the course of ordinary activity; (6) whether the parties preserving, transmitting and extracting it are appropriate; (7) other factors affecting its integrity and reliability. Where necessary, the court may review authenticity through expert examination or inspection.'

Electronic Signature Law of the People's Republic of China (2019 amendment) Article 8 gives parallel reliability criteria: 'In reviewing the authenticity of a data message as evidence, the following factors shall be considered: (1) the reliability of the method of generating, storing or transmitting the data message; (2) the reliability of the method of keeping its content intact; (3) the reliability of the method used to identify the sender; (4) other relevant factors.'

For review of a single item see Evidence Rules Article 87 (original or original thing and whether copies match; relevance; legality of form and source; truthfulness; interest between witness or provider and a party); for comprehensive review see Article 88 (judged by degree of connection and the links between items); judgment reasoning must be public under Articles 85 and 97.

IV. Gate three - presumed authenticity: six situations where confirmation may be outright

Evidence Rules Article 94: 'Where electronic data falls under any of the following situations the people's court may confirm its authenticity, unless sufficient contrary evidence refutes it: (1) data unfavourable to the submitting or keeping party itself; (2) data provided or confirmed by a neutral third-party platform that records and keeps it; (3) data formed in the course of normal business activity; (4) data kept by archive management; (5) data saved, transmitted or extracted in the manner agreed by the parties. Notarised content shall be confirmed as authentic, unless contrary evidence sufficient to overturn it exists.'

Read with Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) Article 72: legal facts and documents proved by notarisation through statutory procedures are taken by the people's court as the basis for finding facts, unless contrary evidence sufficient to overturn them exists. Notarisation thus shifts the burden to the other side and is the surest way to fix WeChat records; recommended sequence: as soon as a dispute arises, notarise the login, screenshots and screen recording on the original phone (or use a trusted timestamp), then file the exported printout.

Article 95 of the Evidence Rules helps against non-cooperation: where a party controls evidence and refuses to produce it without justified reason, and the party bearing the burden of proof claims its content is unfavourable to the controller, the people's court may deem that claim established - so when the other side answers that the phone was replaced or the records deleted, an adverse presumption may be requested.

V. Downgrading and exclusion: the uncorroborated-evidence rule and unlawful collection

Evidence Rules Article 90: 'The following evidence cannot serve alone as the basis for finding facts: (1) statements of the parties; (2) testimony of persons without or with limited civil capacity inconsistent with their age, intelligence or mental condition; (3) testimony of witnesses with an interest in a party or its agent; (4) audio-visual material and electronic data with doubtful points; (5) copies and replicas that cannot be checked against the original or original thing.'

Interpretation Article 106: evidence formed or obtained by methods that seriously infringe another person's lawful rights, violate prohibitive provisions of law or seriously offend public order and good morals must not serve as the basis for finding facts - records obtained by logging into, cracking or stealing another's WeChat account risk outright exclusion, and another person's deleted content must not be recovered and collected unilaterally.

Burden of proof and consequences: Civil Procedure Law Article 67, 'a party has the responsibility to provide evidence for its own claims'; Interpretation Article 90, '... where before judgment is rendered a party fails to produce evidence or the evidence is insufficient to prove its factual claim, the party bearing the burden of proof bears the adverse consequences'. Where the records are held by the party relying on them and their authenticity cannot be determined, the risk lies with that party; Evidence Rules Article 92 on private documents applies by analogy: the authenticity of a private document is proven by the party relying on it; a document bearing its maker's or agent's signature, seal or fingerprint is presumed authentic; one showing deletions, alterations, additions or other formal defects has its probative value judged in light of the circumstances. Applied to WeChat records: spliced screenshots, cropped avatars or deleted unfavourable context are 'formal defects / doubtful points', and probative value drops at once.

VI. 'Who is on the other side' and attribution of intent

Account identity (who is actually using the WeChat account) and attribution of intent (whether a statement can be attributed to the other party's organisation) are two independent steps. Civil Code Article 170: civil juristic acts performed by persons carrying out the work tasks of a legal person or unincorporated organisation, on matters within their authority and in its name, are effective against it; restrictions imposed on their authority cannot be set up against a counterparty in good faith. Hence matters confirmed within their authority in the unit's name by project managers, site leading hands and measurement staff can be attributed to the unit; internal limits on authorisation cannot defeat a good-faith counterparty.

VII. Substantive position in construction price disputes

SPC Interpretation on Construction Contract Disputes (I) (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) Article 20: 'Where the parties dispute the quantities of the works, they shall be determined per written documents such as site instruction records formed during construction. Where the contractor can prove the employer consented to its carrying out the works but cannot produce site instruction records proving the quantities occurred, the quantities actually carried out may be determined per other evidence provided by the parties.' - WeChat records fall under 'other evidence' in the second sentence, ranking below written documents such as site instruction records, and the threshold for invoking them is being 'able to prove that the employer consented to the works' (an instruction, approval or on-site confirmation); unilateral report-style messages alone do not suffice.

For the expert-assessment treatment of sundry works without site instruction records see GB/T 51262-2017, Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment of Building Works, Clause 5.4.2: 1 where the employer approves, or other evidence provided by the contractor can prove the works, the assessor shall issue an affirmative opinion for the commissioning party to judge; 2 where the employer does not approve but the works admit site inspection, the assessor shall propose that the commissioning party organise a site inspection and assess per its results.

The counterpart rules in arbitration: Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Article 57 (evidence produced at the hearing and cross-examined by the parties); Article 56 (expert assessment of special issues; the assessor attends the hearing); Article 58 (evidence preservation where evidence may be lost; the arbitration institution forwards the application to the basic people's court at the place of the evidence).

VIII. Element x legal basis x proof materials

# Element to establish Legal basis Proof materials
1 Proper category; lawful collection Civil Procedure Law Art. 66(1)(5); Interpretation Arts. 116, 106 (reverse exclusion) Collection-process statement (own device, own account); device-account binding proof; cracked or stolen-login records barred
2 Original form, checkable Evidence Rules Arts. 15(2), 11 Live in-court login and display on the original phone or computer; exports and printouts derived directly from it (extractor, time, method, medium stated)
3 Reliable medium and extraction Evidence Rules Art. 93 items (1)(2)(3)(4)(6); Electronic Signature Law Art. 8 Screen recording; notarised login with certificate; forensic opinion (existence, integrity, tampering); hash values; device sealing records
4 Account-holder identity Evidence Rules Art. 93(6), 94(2) WeChat real-name data; account-to-phone/ID mapping; WeChat Work entity data; group notices and member cards; call recordings; real-name transfers; court retrieval or in-court login
5 Complete, unaltered content Evidence Rules Art. 93(4), 90(4)(5), 92(3) Continuous conversations (context, timestamps, avatars, nicknames); live scrolling of the original medium; cross-check with voice/file/transfer records; no cropping or splicing
6 Attribution to the other unit Civil Code Art. 170; Evidence Rules Art. 88 Staff-position proof (appointment, authorisation, roster, sign-in); corroboration by documents and conduct (payments, access, acceptance)
7 Corroboration; no lone item Evidence Rules Arts. 90, 88; Interpretation (I) Art. 20 Supervisor logs, minutes, concealed-works acceptance, measurement and payment records, photos, delivery and retest reports
8 Reinforced presumption (optional) Evidence Rules Art. 94; Civil Procedure Law Art. 72 Notarial certificate; neutral third-party platform records; archive-managed records

Applicability Boundaries

  • WeChat records can serve as evidence but only as 'other evidence': confirmation of quantities and price still ranks written documents such as site instruction records first (Interpretation (I) Article 20); WeChat records generally corroborate prior facts such as 'the employer consented to the works', 'the instruction was issued' or 'the price was agreed', and chat content alone cannot replace the settlement basis.
  • The uncorroborated-evidence rule is a hard constraint: where only screenshots exist and cannot be checked against the original medium, or the screenshots show cropping, splicing or missing context, they cannot serve alone as the basis for finding facts and must form a corroboration chain with other evidence; where reinforcement is insufficient and authenticity remains undetermined, the party bearing the burden of proof suffers the adverse consequence.
  • The red line of lawful collection: records obtained by methods that seriously infringe another person's lawful rights and interests, violate prohibitive provisions of law or seriously offend public order and good morals (cracking, stolen login, unilaterally recovering another person's deleted data or intruding into that person's devices) must not serve as the basis for finding facts.
  • Versions: this card cites the Civil Procedure Law as amended in 2023 (evidence categories in Article 66, burden of proof in Article 67, probative force of notarisation in Article 72), the Interpretation as amended in 2022, the Evidence Rules as Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 (2019 revision) and the Electronic Signature Law as amended in 2019; article numbers have shifted across versions - do not mix them when citing older judgments.
  • Temporal effect: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation (II), Article 23 - 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. For first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect, this Interpretation applies. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails.' The evidence rules on the authenticity of electronic data are fixed by the Civil Procedure Law, its Interpretation and the Evidence Rules and do not change with the succession of construction interpretations; but the adjudication rules on substantive disputes over quantities and price are affected by the above temporal boundary, and first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026 are governed by the new interpretation.
  • Presumptions of authenticity (notarisation, confirmation by a neutral third-party platform, etc.) can all be overturned by contrary evidence and are not final; a presumption resolves only the initial burden and does not preclude the other side from rebutting with evidence of tampering or impersonation.

Further Reading

  • Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 SPC Evidence Rules: Arts. 1-19 (proof by parties; esp. 11 originals, 14 scope of electronic data, 15 originals of electronic data) and Arts. 85-97 (review and determination; esp. 85, 87, 88, 90, 92-95).
  • Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) Arts. 66, 67, 72; Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Interpretation Arts. 90, 106, 116.
  • Electronic Signature Law (2019 amendment) Art. 8 (factors for reviewing the authenticity of data messages); Civil Code Arts. 170, 469(3).
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Interpretation (I) Art. 20; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Interpretation (II) Art. 23; Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Arts. 56-58.
  • GB/T 51262-2017 Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment of Building Works, Clause 5.4.2 (sundry works without site instruction records).
  • Related cards: 'Fixing on-site evidence and hard-fixing measures in construction disputes'; 'Procedural rules for quantity disputes'.

Keywords

  • 微信聊天记录
  • 电子数据
  • 证据真实性
  • 原始载体
  • 公证
  • 民事诉讼证据规定
  • 私文书证
  • 工程价款争议