Model Contract for Construction Projects (EPC) (GF-2020-0216), General Conditions Clause 19 [Claims]: the claims procedure - Notice of Claim within 28 days, claim report within 28 days, deemed approval where no reply is given within 42 days, and expiry of the right to claim after the completion payment certificate
Under GF-2020-0216 Sub-Clause 19.1, the claiming party shall submit a Notice of Claim within 28 days after it knew or ought to have known of the claim event, and a formal claim report within the following 28 days; for continuing effects, a continuing claim notice each month and a final claim report within 28 days after the effect ends; if the Notice of Claim is not issued within the 28 days, the right to additional or reduced payment, extension of the defects liability period and (or) extension of time is lost. Under Sub-Clauses 19.2 and 19.3, failure to reply within 42 days after receipt of a claim report or further supporting material is deemed approval of the claim. Under Sub-Clause 19.4, on accepting the completion payment certificate under the final account provisions the contractor is deemed no longer entitled to raise any claim arising before the issue of the taking-over certificate for the works; the application for final closure of accounts is limited to claims arising after the issue of the taking-over certificate, and the time limit for claims expires on acceptance of the certificate of final closure of accounts.
Applicable Codes
- 建市〔2020〕96号《建设项目工程总承包合同(示范文本)》GF-2020-0216 通用合同条件第19条(19.1~19.4)
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.11.2、8.11.3、8.11.4、8.11.5、8.11.6、8.11.21条
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第9.13.2、9.13.3条(已废止)
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》通用条款第19.1款
Positioning of the topic
Clause 19 [Claims] of the General Conditions of the Model Contract for Construction Projects (EPC) (GF-2020-0216, promulgated by Jian Shi [2020] No. 96): the two-way claims procedure, reply and time-bar periods, applicable to claims and defences under EPC contracts concluded on, or agreeing to follow, this model text.
Core conclusions
I. Raising a claim (Sub-Clause 19.1)
(1) The claiming party shall, within 28 days after it knew or ought to have known of the claim event, submit to the other party a Notice of Claim stating the grounds of the claim event; if the claiming party fails to issue the Notice of Claim within those 28 days, it loses the right to additional or reduced payment, extension of the defects liability period and (or) extension of time.
(2) The claiming party shall, within 28 days after issuing the Notice of Claim, submit a formal claim report to the other party; the claim report shall state in detail the grounds of the claim, the amount of additional payment claimed, the extension of the defects liability period and (or) the extension of time claimed, with the necessary records and supporting material.
(3) Where the claim event has a continuing effect, the claiming party shall submit a continuing claim notice each month, stating the actual situation and records of the continuing effect and listing the cumulative additional payment, extension of the defects liability period and (or) days of extension of time.
(4) Within 28 days after the effect of the claim event ends, the claiming party shall submit a final claim report stating the final additional payment claimed, extension of the defects liability period and (or) extension of time, with the necessary records and supporting material.
(5) Where the contractor is the claiming party, the Notice of Claim, the claim report and related claim documents shall be submitted to the Engineer; where the employer is the claiming party, it may submit them to the contractor itself or through the Engineer.
II. Procedure for handling the contractor's claims (Sub-Clause 19.2)
(1) On receipt of the contractor's claim report, the Engineer shall promptly review its content and examine the records and supporting material, and may where necessary require the contractor to submit copies of all original records.
(2) The Engineer shall agree or determine the additional payment and (or) extension of time under Sub-Clause 3.6 [Agreement or Determination], promptly notify the employer in writing on receipt of the claim report or further supporting material, and within 42 days reply to the contractor with the claim result as approved in writing by the employer; if the Engineer fails to reply within 42 days after receipt of the claim report or further supporting material relating to the claim, the claim is deemed approved.
(3) If the contractor accepts the claim result, the employer shall complete payment within 28 days after replying with the claim result; if not, the matter is handled under Clause 20 [Dispute Resolution].
III. Procedure for handling the employer's claims (Sub-Clause 19.3)
(1) On receipt of the employer's claim report, the contractor shall promptly review its content and examine the employer's supporting material.
(2) The contractor shall reply within 42 days after receipt of the claim report or further supporting material; failing a reply within 42 days, the claim is deemed approved.
(3) If the employer accepts the result, it may deduct the amount payable from the contract price payable to the contractor or extend the defects liability period; if not, the matter is handled under Clause 20 [Dispute Resolution].
IV. Time limits for claims (Sub-Clause 19.4)
(1) After the contractor accepts the completion payment certificate under Sub-Clause 14.5 [Final Account], it is deemed no longer entitled to raise any claim arising before the issue of the taking-over certificate for the works.
(2) In the application for final closure of accounts submitted under Sub-Clause 14.7 [Final Closure of Accounts], the contractor may only raise claims arising after the issue of the taking-over certificate for the works; the time limit for raising claims expires on acceptance of the certificate of final closure of accounts.
Boundaries of application
- The 28-day / 42-day periods above are those of the General Conditions of the model text and may be varied in the Particular Conditions; where the contract does not adopt this model text or agrees no claim period, the contract governs, or Section 8.11 of GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ, applies (the period is 'the period agreed in the contract, or 28 days if none is agreed', and the strength of the consequence of default is as agreed in the contract).
- Difference from the construction contract model text GF-2017-0201 General Conditions Sub-Clause 19.1: under GF-2017-0201 claim documents are submitted to the supervisor, while under GF-2020-0216 (EPC) they go to the Engineer, and the EPC model adds a parallel procedure where the employer is the claiming party (Sub-Clause 19.3); do not mix up the clause numbering of the two sets when citing.
- The scope of the time bar in Sub-Clause 19.1 is limited to 'the right to additional or reduced payment, extension of the defects liability period and (or) extension of time'; it does not extinguish the substantive basis, and other defences (fault of the other party, allocation of quality and defects liability) may still be raised in the final account, expert assessment or litigation.
- 'No reply within 42 days is deemed approval' applies to the claim result, and is a different rule from 'no reply to the final account documents in time is deemed approval of the submitted price'; the latter requires express contractual agreement and review of its validity requirements, and the two cannot be applied to each other.
- The employer may deduct directly from payment due for its claim, but only after the claims procedure is completed or with the parties' confirmation; disputed amounts remain subject to Clause 20 [Dispute Resolution].
- A claim also requires, cumulatively, a basis (contractual or statutory liability), evidence (records, certified site records, reports, photos and the like) and procedure (periods and form of documents); procedural compliance cannot substitute for a substantive basis.
- Force majeure, variations, suspension of the works and other special clauses have their own notice periods, which run in parallel with Clause 19; the respective notice obligations must be satisfied at the same time.
Further reading
- GF-2020-0216 (Jian Shi [2020] No. 96): General Conditions Sub-Clauses 19.1-19.4 [Claims], 3.6 [Agreement or Determination], 14.5 [Final Account], 14.7 [Final Closure of Accounts], Clause 20 [Dispute Resolution]; supplementary agreements on periods and replies in the Particular Conditions.
- Cross-references: GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ, Section 8.11 (claims: time limits for Notice of Claim, claim report, review and reply, confirmation and payment) and Section 10.3 (final account and final closure of accounts); Model Contract for Construction Works GF-2017-0201, General Conditions Sub-Clause 19.1 (claims handled by the supervisor).
Keywords
- 工程索赔
- 工程总承包合同示范文本
- GF-2020-0216
- Notice of Claim
- 42天答复期
- 视为认可索赔
- 竣工付款证书
- final closure of accounts after the defects period