Whether varied works may be given newly built-up rates when the priced BOQ already contains an applicable rate: the three-tier decision table for variation valuation, the tests for 'applicable' and 'similar', and a clause-by-clause comparison of GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.1 with GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1
For BOQ items whose applicable rate already exists in the contract, varied works may not be re-rated with newly built-up rates; the original contract all-in unit rate applies directly (GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.1 item 1: 'the rate of that item shall be adopted'; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1 item 1: 'for BOQ items executed under the same construction conditions with the same item descriptions, the corresponding contract unit rate shall be adopted'). The three tiers of variation valuation step down in order and stop once one is hit: (1) an applicable rate exists - apply the contract rate directly (only where the quantity deviation exceeds 15% is the rate adjusted up or down under clause 9.6.2 / clause 8.9.2, which is price adjustment, not new rate build-up); (2) only a similar rate exists - convert by reference to the similar item's rate (the 2024 edition: 'the all-in unit rate converted and adjusted from the contract rate of a similar BOQ item', converting only the differing elements while the levels of overheads and profit are retained); (3) neither applicable nor similar - the contractor proposes a new rate on the basis of the variation documents, executed after the employer confirms it (the 2024 edition: negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate). Quantity-only changes and minor adjustments of secondary item description elements do not constitute re-rating; only substantive changes of material specification, construction method or construction conditions (differing in both the description and the conditions dimensions) trigger new rate build-up.
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.3.1条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.6.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.24条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9.1条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9.3条
- GB/T 50319-2013 建设工程监理规范 第6.3.3条
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.6.2条
Topic positioning
This card answers a specific classification question: where the priced BOQ already contains an applicable (identical) all-in unit rate for an item, can that item be re-rated after a variation? It gives the three-tier decision table for variation valuation ('applicable rate exists - only similar - neither applicable nor similar') and the criteria for 'applicable' and 'similar' by degree of change in item description and construction conditions, based on GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.1 and GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.9.1 to 8.9.3.
Core conclusions
1. The explicit conclusion. For BOQ items whose applicable rate already exists in the contract, varied works may not be re-rated; the original contract all-in unit rate applies directly. GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.1 item 1 is mandatory in its wording ('shall'): 'where the priced BOQ contains an item applicable to the varied work, the rate of that item shall be adopted; but where the variation causes the quantity of that BOQ item to change and the quantity deviation exceeds 15%, the rate of that item shall be adjusted in accordance with clause 9.6.2 of this code.' GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1 item 1 is to the same effect: 'for BOQ items executed under the same construction conditions with the same item descriptions, the corresponding contract unit rate shall be adopted.' Only two channels can break through direct application: first, price adjustment for a quantity deviation exceeding 15% (2013 clause 9.6.2 / 2024 clause 8.9.2), which is price adjustment, not re-rating; second, where both the item description and the construction conditions differ (or reducing or cancelling BOQ items materially changes the construction conditions) and no similar rate can be applied, new rate build-up begins.
2. Three-tier decision table for variation valuation (step down in order, stop once a tier is hit)
| Tier | Trigger situation | Pricing treatment | GB 50500-2013 | GB/T 50500-2024 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1: applicable rate exists | Same item description and same construction conditions (the 2013 wording: 'applicable to the varied work') | The original contract all-in unit rate shall be adopted; re-rating and fresh pricing are not allowed. Sole exception: where the quantity deviation of that BOQ item exceeds 15%, the rate is adjusted up or down under the quantity deviation clause (price adjustment, not re-rating) | Clause 9.3.1 item 1, read with clause 9.6.2 | Clause 8.9.1 item 1; beyond 15% (15% itself excluded) read with clause 8.9.2; the definition of 'contract unit rate' is in clause 2.0.24 |
| Tier 2: only similar | Same construction conditions plus similar item description, or similar construction conditions plus same item description (differences confined to secondary elements: minor adjustment of material grade, secondary changes in haul distance, thickness or specification, not changing the composition of labour, materials and plant or the consumption levels) | Reference to the similar item's rate within a reasonable range; the 2024 edition states it as 'the all-in unit rate converted and adjusted from the contract rate of a similar BOQ item' - only the differing elements are converted (material prices, plant or method differences), while the overheads and profit levels in the original contract rate are retained; it is neither a fresh offer nor a rebuilt rate | Clause 9.3.1 item 2 | Clause 8.9.1 item 2 |
| Tier 3: neither applicable nor similar | Different construction conditions plus different item descriptions; or reduction or cancellation of BOQ items that materially changes the construction conditions during execution | The contractor proposes a new rate on the basis of the variation documents, executed after the employer confirms it; the rate is built up from the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing method, the published price information issued by the government cost agency, and the contractor's tender price fluctuation rate (where the published price information lacks a price, market prices obtained by market enquiry with a lawful basis apply); the 2024 edition: determine a market-reasonable all-in unit rate by negotiation, drawing on the contract rate rules and tender level of similar items, or the all-in unit rates of similar BOQ items in works of the same type | Clause 9.3.1 items 3 and 4 | Clause 8.9.1 items 3, 4 and 5 |
3. Gist of the standard's text (the remaining tiers of 2013 clause 9.3.1). Item 2: 'where the priced BOQ contains no item applicable but items similar to the varied work, the rates of similar items may be referenced within a reasonable range.' Item 3: 'where the priced BOQ contains neither applicable nor similar items, the contractor shall propose the rate of the varied item on the basis of the variation documents, the measurement rules and the pricing method, the published price information issued by the government cost agency and the contractor's tender price fluctuation rate, and shall adjust it after the employer confirms it. The contractor's tender price fluctuation rate may be calculated by the following formulas: tendered works / non-tendered works (formulas in the clause).' Item 4: 'where the priced BOQ contains neither applicable nor similar items and the published price information issued by the government cost agency lacks a price, the contractor shall propose the rate of the varied item on the basis of the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing method and lawful market prices obtained through market enquiry and other means, and shall adjust it after the employer confirms it.'
4. Tests for 'applicable' and 'similar'. The 2013 edition's clause 9.3.1 gives no definition of 'applicable'; in practice the question is whether the item descriptions are identical: an identical item description means 'applicable' (direct application only), descriptions close but with secondary differences means 'similar' (conversion by reference), and descriptions materially different means neither (re-rating). The 2024 edition upgrades this to a two-dimensional test of 'item description x construction conditions': only 'the same item descriptions executed under the same construction conditions' counts as 'applicable'; where either the conditions or the description drops to 'similar', conversion applies; only when both dimensions differ is the price negotiated.
Factors for judging changes in description or conditions (listed with GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1): related to item description changes - changes of materials; changes of construction method; changes to other elemental work items; other item description changes. Related to construction condition changes - changes of the works' foundation; changes of the works' height; changes of component specification (e.g. structural steel); changes of construction season; changes of protection measures for completed works when constructing in finished areas; changes of construction under site access restrictions; changes of material transport mode; changes of plant utilisation; changes of the attendance fee within main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions (e.g. increase or decrease of nominated specialist subcontract quantities); other construction condition changes.
Situations that do not constitute re-rating: (1) quantity changes (including deviations beyond 15%) only trigger rate adjustment up or down - GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.2: 'where a quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the increased quantity shall be adjusted down; where a quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the remaining quantity after the decrease shall be adjusted up.' GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.2 correspondingly provides that increases are priced 'after reasonably adjusting down the contract rate and the new all-in unit rate' in light of labour and material purchase price discounts, and decreases 'after reasonably adjusting up' in light of the loss of discounts. (2) Secondary adjustments of item descriptions (small changes of material grade, secondary changes of haul distance or thickness) are 'similar' and go through conversion. (3) Only substantive changes of material specification or construction method, or substantive changes of construction conditions (foundation, height, component specification, season, access restrictions, transport mode, plant utilisation, etc.) trigger re-rating.
5. Definition of 'contract unit rate'. GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.24: 'contract unit rate: the all-in unit rates quoted by the contractor in the priced BOQ, and the corrected all-in unit rates accepted by the employer in the clarification or explanation of the contractor's tender.' It further states: 'corrected all-in unit rates accepted by the employer (including supplementary all-in unit rates for BOQ items omitted from the tender) may be applied to the pricing of increases or decreases in the quantities of BOQ items listed in the priced BOQ and to the valuation of variations.' That is, corrected rates confirmed through clarification equally count as contract unit rates available for adoption, without separate rate build-up.
6. Fallback positions when negotiation fails and in expert assessment. GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3: where the contract already contains a price applicable to the varied work, that price applies; where a similar price exists it may be referenced; where neither exists, the chief supervising engineer shall consult fully with the employer and the contractor to reach agreement, and failing agreement the chief supervising engineer determines a reasonable rate or price for the variation on a cost-plus-profit basis, with objections handled under the dispute procedure agreed in the construction contract. T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2 (construction cost expert assessment): for varied works, where the contract contains an applicable all-in unit rate or percentage rate for an identical item, that rate applies; where no identical but a similar item exists, the similar item's all-in unit rate or percentage rate may be applied; where neither identical nor similar items exist, a new all-in unit rate is determined from the reasonable cost of executing the works calculated from the assessment materials submitted by the contractor and the management fee and profit rates agreed in the contract, or in accordance with the pricing basis of the construction administration authority at the location of the works or of the relevant industry and the contractually agreed management fee and profit rates; the contractor bears the burden of proof.
Applicable boundaries
Applies to the determination of all-in unit rates for BOQ items and the re-rating decision where variations (including BOQ errors) arise under re-measurable (unit-rate) and lump-sum contracts priced on a BOQ basis. For lump-sum contracts see also GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.3: 'where the contract provides that the contract unit rate applies to variation pricing, the contract price may be adjusted under clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 on the strength of the varied quantities calculated under clause 7.4.3; where the contract provides that the contract unit rate does not apply to variation pricing, the BOQ items arising from variations may be priced by the employer and the contractor negotiating an all-in unit rate in light of the execution of the works and market prices, drawing on the priced BOQ pricing rules and the tender level.' Where the contract expressly provides otherwise for variation pricing, the contract prevails (GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended standard). The 15% boundary is inclusive: at 15%, clause 8.9.1 applies; beyond (excluding) 15%, clause 8.9.2's directional adjustment is added. This card does not apply to price adjustment for cost fluctuation, the determination of actual prices for provisional price items, or adjustments for changes in laws, regulations and policy, each of which has its own rules; nor does it resolve the specific charging bases of overheads and profit in conversion. Old and new editions: the current effective edition is GB/T 50500-2024 (replacing GB 50500-2013); existing contracts and projects still on the old basis follow section 9.3 of the 2013 edition; the main difference between the two editions is whether 'applicable' introduces the construction-conditions dimension (the 2024 test is two-dimensional).
Further reading
GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.1 (four tiers of varied rates) and clause 9.6.2 (rate adjustment up or down for quantity deviation beyond 15%); GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.24 (definition of contract unit rate), sections 7.1 / 7.2 / 7.4 (confirmation of variations and BOQ errors, calculation of varied quantities), clause 8.9.1 (five-tier rule for determining all-in unit rates), clause 8.9.2 (upward or downward adjustment beyond 15%) and clause 8.9.3 (variation pricing under lump-sum contracts); with GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3 (the supervising engineer determining variation prices and the cost-plus-profit fallback) and T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2 (variation pricing principles and burden of proof in cost expert assessment). For the cost composition of the all-in unit rate see clause 2.0.9; for differential correction when additional works adopt contract rates see clause 8.10.3.
Keywords
- valuation of variations
- 合同单价
- 适用与类似
- derivation of new (built-up) rates
- 变更估价三层级
- 工程量偏差15%
- GB 50500-2013 第9.3.1条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.1条