Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Pricing path for variation items with no applicable or analogous all-in unit rate: agreeing a market-reasonable all-in rate, the cost-plus-profit fallback, and the expert-assessment position (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.9 and 8.6.3; GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3; T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2)

When a variation item has neither an identical nor an analogous all-in unit rate in the contract, the employer and the contractor shall agree a market-reasonable all-in rate in light of the execution of the works, market prices, the contract rate-pricing rules and the tendered rate level (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1, bands 3 to 5); where agreement fails, the Engineer (chief supervising engineer) determines a reasonable rate or price on the cost-plus-profit principle (GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3), and once the matter enters construction cost expert assessment the new all-in rate is fixed as the reasonable cost of the executed works plus the overhead rate and profit margin agreed in the contract, the contractor bearing the burden of proof (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2). Where the change in quantity exceeds 15% (15% excluded), clause 8.9.2 adjusts the rate up or down in combination with the effect of bulk-procurement discounts. Pricing of labour, materials and plant may follow the order of clause 8.6.3: price information sources agreed in the contract; then the tax-exclusive published price information issued by the construction cost administration or the industry at the location of the works, plus the priced build-up details of analogous billed items in the BOQ; then the contractor's procurement prices confirmed by both parties.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.9.1条、第8.9.2条、第8.9.3条、第8.6.3条
  • GB/T 50319-2013 · Code for Construction Project Supervision 第6.3.3条
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 · Work Guideline for Construction Cost Appraisal 第4.6.2条

Topic Positioning

How to determine the all-in unit rate and adjust the contract price when a variation (including errors and omissions in the bill of quantities) creates billed work items for which the priced BOQ contains neither an identical nor an analogous all-in unit rate. The card covers re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2), lump-sum contracts (clause 8.9.3), the pricing sources for rate build-up (clause 8.6.3), the supervising-engineer fallback (GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3) and the construction cost expert assessment position (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2).

Core Conclusions

1. Exhaust the "identical / analogous" ladder before entering negotiated rate build-up - GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1 (re-measurable contracts; quantity change not exceeding 15%, inclusive) Original text: for works under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract, where a variation or BOQ errors and omissions cause billed work items of the divisional works to change (items added or omitted), or the billed quantities to change by not more than 15% (inclusive), the employer and the contractor shall determine the all-in unit rate and adjust the contract price as follows, based on the varied quantities confirmed under clauses 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4: 1 for a billed item with an identical item description executed under identical construction conditions, the corresponding contract rate applies; 2 for a billed item with an analogous item description under identical construction conditions, or an identical item description under analogous construction conditions, the all-in rate converted and adjusted from the contract rate of the analogous billed item applies; 3 for a billed item with a different item description under identical construction conditions, or an identical item description under different construction conditions, a market-reasonable all-in rate may be negotiated on the basis of the execution of the works, the rate-pricing rules and the tendered rate level of analogous items; 4 for a billed item with a different item description under different construction conditions, a market-reasonable all-in rate may be negotiated on the basis of the execution of the works and the all-in rates of analogous billed items of similar works; 5 where a variation reducing or cancelling billed items significantly changes the construction conditions of the works being executed, the all-in rate of the variation may be negotiated according to the specific circumstances of the executed works, market prices, the contract rate-pricing rules and the tendered rate level. Whether a billed item takes the contract rate, an adjusted rate or a fresh rate build-up is judged by comparing two groups of price-influencing factors: (1) change of item description - change of materials, change of construction method, effects on other divisional work items, other changes of the item description; (2) change of construction conditions - change of foundations, change of height, change of member sizes (e.g. steel structures), change of construction season, change of finished-work protection measures in completed areas, change of construction under site access restrictions, change of material transport mode, change of plant utilisation, change of attendance within the main contractor's provisions (e.g. increase or decrease of specialist subcontract quantities), and other changes of construction conditions. The correct reading of "no applicable all-in unit rate" is therefore bands 3 to 5: negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate.

2. Linkage when the quantity change exceeds 15% - clause 8.9.2 (re-measurable contracts) Original text: where the billed quantity of a divisional work item changes by more than 15% (15% excluded) due to a variation or BOQ errors and omissions, the contract price is adjusted on the confirmed varied quantities as follows: 1 where a variation or BOQ errors and omissions add billed items and quantities, the contract rate and the new all-in rate may be reasonably reduced (in addition to clause 8.9.1), taking account of the labour and material procurement discounts brought by the increased quantity, before computing the price of the billed items and adjusting the contract price; 2 where a variation or BOQ errors and omissions reduce billed items and quantities, the rates may be reasonably increased, taking account of the loss of such procurement discounts brought by the decreased quantity.

3. Lump-sum contract path - clause 8.9.3 Original text: under a lump-sum contract where the contract rates are agreed to apply to variation pricing, the varied quantities computed under clause 7.4.3 adjust the contract price under clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2; where the contract rates are agreed not to apply to variation pricing, the all-in rate of the billed items arising from the variation may be negotiated by the employer and the contractor according to the execution of the works and market prices, in combination with the pricing rules and tendered rate level of the priced BOQ.

4. Pricing sources for rate build-up - clause 8.6.3 (order for fixing dayworks all-in rates, usable as reference for pricing labour, materials and plant of items without an applicable rate) Original text: where the priced BOQ contains no dayworks items, or its dayworks items contain no applicable all-in rate, the dayworks all-in rate may be determined as follows: 1 the labour, material and plant costs may be determined from the engineering price information published by the market-price information sources agreed in the contract; where the contract is silent or unclear, from the tax-exclusive labour, material and plant hire market price information in the engineering price information published by the construction cost administration or the relevant industry at the location of the works, together with the priced composition details in the all-in rate build-up schedules of analogous billed items of the BOQ. 2 where the engineering price information published by the construction cost administration and the industry contains no relevant market prices, the rate may be built from the contractor's procurement prices confirmed by the employer and the contractor, together with the priced composition details in the all-in rate build-up schedules of analogous billed items.

5. Two fallback positions when negotiation fails

  • Supervision position, GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3: the project supervision body may, before a variation is executed, agree with the employer, the contractor and the other parties the pricing principle, pricing method or price of the variation. 1 where the contract already contains a price applicable to the varied work, the varied contract price is computed at that existing price. 2 where the contract contains a price analogous to the varied work, the varied contract price may be set with reference to that analogous price. 3 where the contract contains neither an applicable nor an analogous price, the chief supervising engineer shall seek full agreement between the employer and the contractor on the variation price; failing agreement, the chief supervising engineer determines the reasonable rate or price of the variation on the cost-plus-profit principle, and any objection is handled under the dispute procedure agreed in the construction contract.
  • Expert assessment position, T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2: unless the contract provides otherwise, the assessor values variation items under the following pricing principles: 1 where the varied work has an identical item in the contract, the all-in rate or percentage rate of that identical item applies. 2 where the varied work has no identical item in the contract, the all-in rate or percentage rate of an analogous item may be applied. 3 where the varied work has neither an identical nor an analogous item in the contract, the new all-in rate is determined from the reasonable cost of the executed works computed from the assessment materials submitted by the contractor plus the overhead rate and profit margin agreed in the contract, or from the pricing basis of the building administration or the relevant industry at the location of the works plus the agreed overhead rate and profit margin. The note to the clause states that this adjustment responds to the government's phased withdrawal from publishing budget quota manuals or downplaying their role; where the contract contains no identical or analogous all-in rate, the contractor must be able to discharge the burden of proof, and the assessor conducts the assessment on the basis of the assessment materials, the overhead rate and profit margin agreed in the contract, and the actual circumstances of the execution of the works.

Applicability Boundaries

  • Premise: where the contract provides otherwise, its provisions prevail; the rules apply to contract price adjustment of works priced on a bill of quantities basis.
  • Clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 presuppose a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract and both target billed item changes of the divisional works caused by variations or BOQ errors and omissions; quantity changes not exceeding 15% (inclusive) go to clause 8.9.1, those exceeding 15% (excluded) to clause 8.9.2.
  • Lump-sum contracts follow the two paths of clause 8.9.3, distinguished by whether the contract rates apply to variation pricing.
  • The GB/T 50319-2013 position governs variation pricing handled by the supervision body during construction; the T/ZBD 100.4-2023 position governs disputes that have entered construction cost expert assessment; GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended standard - contractual agreement prevails, and it must not violate the mandatory provisions of laws and regulations.
  • This card states general rules and contains no project-specific rate build-up; actual on-cost rates and profit levels follow the contract agreement and the all-in rate build-up schedules of analogous billed items.

Further Reading

GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1 (five-band determination rule), clause 8.9.2 (upward and downward adjustment above 15%), clause 8.9.3 (lump-sum path), clause 8.6.3 (dayworks rate pricing order), read against sections 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4 (confirmation of variations and BOQ errors and omissions, computation of varied quantities, including clause 7.4.3); GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3; T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.2 and its note.

Keywords

Cited By