Pricing principles for variation works in construction cost expert assessment: identical contract items take their rates, similar items take similar rates, and absent both, a new all-in unit rate from reasonable cost per the appraisal records plus the contract overheads and profit rates, or per the pricing basis (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Article 4.6.2)
Unless the contract provides otherwise, the expert appraiser assesses variation works on three tiers: 1 where the varied work has an identical item in the contract, apply the all-in unit rate or percentage rate of that identical item; 2 where there is no identical item, an analogous item's all-in unit rate or percentage rate may be applied; 3 where there is neither an identical nor an analogous item, determine a new all-in unit rate from the reasonable cost of executing the work calculated per the appraisal records submitted by the contractor plus the contract overheads and profit rates, or from the pricing basis of the construction authority or the relevant industry at the project's location plus the contract overheads and profit rates. Item 3 marks a major adjustment responding to governments phasing out budget quota publication: the contractor must be able to evidence cost where no identical or similar all-in unit rate exists, and the appraiser assesses from those records together with the contract rates and the works as actually executed.
Applicable Codes
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.6.2条(鉴定技术要求)
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9.1~8.9.3条、第2.0.24条
- GB/T 50319-2013 建设工程监理规范 第6.3.3条
Scope of the question
What pricing principle applies to variation works in construction cost expert assessment: first whether the contract has an identical item, then an analogous item, and how to build the price where neither exists. Basis: T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Work Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Article 4.6.2 (Chapter 4 technical requirements); applies to settlement disputes and assessments in litigation and arbitration.
Core conclusions
Unless the contract provides otherwise, the appraiser assesses variation works on three tiers: 1 Where the varied work has an identical item in the contract, apply that item's all-in unit rate or percentage rate. 2 Where there is no identical item, an analogous contract item's all-in unit rate or percentage rate may be applied. 3 Where there is neither an identical nor an analogous item, determine a new all-in unit rate from the reasonable cost of executing the works calculated per the contractor's appraisal records plus the contract overheads and profit rates, or from the pricing basis of the local construction authority or the relevant industry plus those contract rates. Standard commentary: item 3 was substantially adjusted, mainly in response to governments gradually ceasing to publish budget quotas or downplaying them. It requires the contractor, on a variation, to be able to produce evidence where the contract has no identical or similar all-in unit rate; to avoid over-adversarial procedure the drafting keeps the term appraisal records. The appraiser assesses from those records together with the contract overheads and profit rates and the actual execution. Key points: 1 the three-tier keywords are identical - analogous - neither; unlike GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.9.1's quantitative item-description x site-conditions dimensions, the contract's BOQ items can be compared directly; 2 tier 3 is dual-path - reasonable cost from appraisal records plus agreed rates, or the local / industry pricing basis plus agreed rates, both taking the contract overheads and profit rates as the charging basis (not quota rates); 3 the burden of proof sits with the contractor.
Applicability limits
Applies to pricing variation works in expert assessment (settlement disputes, litigation / arbitration); express contract terms prevail. Tier 3's reasonable cost needs appraisal-record support - where the contractor provides no valid records, the appraiser may not assume cost. Where the government has ceased publishing budget quotas, quotas should no longer be the preferred build-up basis. This card is an assessment-basis guide and does not replace procedural and evidentiary rules.
Further reading
T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Work Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Article 4.6.2 and its commentary (Section 4.6 technical requirements); companion comparison GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.9.1 to 8.9.3 (the three- and five-tier rules of contract rates, conversion and negotiated build-up) and Article 2.0.24 (contract rates include accepted corrected all-in unit rates); the supervision-side principle in GB/T 50319-2013 Article 6.3.3 (the chief supervising engineer sets cost plus profit where nothing identical or analogous exists).
Keywords
- 造价鉴定计价原则
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 4.6.2
- 变更工程鉴定
- 相同项目类似项目
- 合理成本加管理费利润
- 承包人举证
- 鉴定资料