Allocation of liability between rebar detailing wastage and stock-length wastage, the selection of wastage rates by splicing method, and the certification and claim route for wastage beyond the quota
Detailing wastage and stock-length wastage are both fabrication wastages already included in the quota; within the effective wastage rate they are borne by the contractor and may not be charged separately (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.3). The part beyond the effective rate is allocated by cause: for contractor-caused overruns the employer deducts, at the unit price of the relevant supply contract, from the price payable in the interim settlement by construction stage or the final account (Article 3.6.3); for employer-caused causes (such as supplied materials of the wrong specification driving the wastage rate over) the employer bears it. Stock-length laps are not measured (GB/T 50854-2024 Annex E note 11). Railway operating wastage: 1.5% for welded ribbed bar, 1% for mechanically spliced bar, plus 1.5% of lap length for non-coupler splices over 10mm in diameter (TB/T 10821-2024); building and municipal works take about 5% combining wastage and measures rebar (DB11/T 2382-2024 Articles 4.6.5 and 7.1.32). Wastage beyond the quota can be recovered only where the cause is not the contractor's, and must be raised in writing within the contractual time limit (where the contract is silent, 14 days for the employer to request particulars and 28 days to reply); a late claim may be deemed waived (Article 8.11.5).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50854-2024 App. E 钢筋及螺栓、铁件说明第1、9、10、11、12、13条
- GB/T 50857-2024 App. J 钢筋工程
- GB/T 50860-2024 第A.15.10条
- GB/T 50861-2024 第B.9.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.3.3条、第3.6.2条、第3.6.3条、第8.11.5条
- TB/T 10821-2024 Ch. 3钢筋说明二至五及附录《材料工地搬运及操作损耗率》
- DB11/T 2382-2024 第4.6.5条、第7.1.32条、第7.1.33条、第7.1.34条
- JGJ 366-2015 第5.1.1条
- T/BCAT 0001-2020 第2.0.10条、第4.4.4条
- GB/T 51262-2017 第5.9节
- 财建〔2004〕369号 第三章 工程价款结算
Positioning
Answers who bears the wastage from rebar detailing (cutting and bar scheduling) and stock-length wastage, how it is calculated, how the two differ in origin and quota treatment, the clause sources of the wastage rates by splicing method, and the procedural route by which wastage beyond the quota may be recovered through certification or claims.
Core conclusions
1. Allocation of liability: a three-step split
1 Wastage within the effective wastage rate is the contractor's technical and managerial risk, already contained in the quota material consumption and the all-in unit rate, and may not be charged separately. GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.3 lists the measurement and pricing risks borne by the contractor, item 5 being 'increases in construction costs caused by the contractor's own reasons of construction plant use, construction technology and organisational management level', and provides that 'unless otherwise agreed in the contract, the contract price and the time for completion shall not be adjusted'; its closing paragraph states that 'tenderers and contractors shall bear their own technical and management risks, such as overheads, and a degree of market risk... but not the risk of changes in laws, regulations and policies; the risks borne by the contractor shall be allowed for in the tender price'. 2 The part beyond the effective wastage rate is allocated by cause. GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.6.3: 'Where, for contractor-caused reasons, the quantity actually drawn exceeds the actual quantity calculated from the construction drawings under a unit-rate contract, or the reasonable quantity calculated from the contract drawings under a lump-sum contract, and the effective material wastage agreed in the contract, the material cost of the excess shall be borne by the contractor, and the employer may calculate the material cost of the over-drawn quantity at the unit price of the relevant supply contract and deduct it from the price payable to the contractor for the contract works in the interim settlement by construction stage or the final account. Where the actual material wastage rate exceeds the effective wastage rate because the specification and type of the materials actually supplied by the employer differ from those prescribed in the tender documents, the excess shall be borne by the employer.' The same article also provides that 'the drawn quantity of the materials supplied by the employer (excluding variations)' is calculated by separate formulas for unit-rate and lump-sum contracts to give the over-drawn quantity. 3 The duty to fix the effective wastage rate lies with the employer. Article 3.6.2: 'The employer shall state in the tender documents the effective wastage rate of the materials it supplies; that effective rate may reasonably follow the material wastage rates of similar items on analogous works, and Table G.1.1, Schedule of Employer-Supplied Materials, shall be filled in as required by Annex G.1 of this Standard; the material quantities in Table G.1.1 shall be calculated from the tender drawings and the national and industry measurement standards for the relevant works.'
2. Detailing wastage and stock-length wastage: both fabrication wastage, different origins and allocation
Neither is an independent pricing item; neither may be listed as a separate BOQ item or claimed separately. They differ in the stage where they arise, in allocation and in controllability:
- Detailing wastage: arises at cutting and scheduling, as short offcuts from the mismatch between cutting combinations and stock lengths, process wastage from hook growth and bending dimensional difference, re-fabrication caused by detailing errors and omissions, and the use of measures rebar such as chairs and positioning bars. Management targets: a rebar detailing error rate of five per thousand (T/BCAT 0001-2020 Article 4.4.4, computed with 'the sum of the errors and omissions on the detailing sheets of a single project as the numerator and the total sheet quantity as the denominator'); for processed rebar, 'the offcut length should be kept within 300mm and the offcut rate of processed rebar within 2%' (JGJ 366-2015 Article 5.1.1).
- Stock-length wastage: unusable offcuts arising from the mismatch between mill stock lengths and component length modularity (straight-bar stock lengths and coil length limits), plus the added lap length imposed by splice-position constraints (the splice ratio within one section, avoidance of the most highly stressed zones).
- Stock-length laps are not measured, uniformly across four sectors: GB/T 50854-2024 Annex E note 11, 'for each rebar item, apart from the laps indicated by the design (including those required by the codes), other construction laps (such as stock-length laps) are not measured'; GB/T 50857-2024 Annex J, 'apart from the laps made explicit by the design, other laps are not counted in the quantities'; GB/T 50860-2024 Article A.15.10, 'for each rebar item, apart from the laps indicated by the design (including those required by the codes), other construction laps (such as stock-length laps) shall not be measured'; GB/T 50861-2024 Article B.9.3, 'apart from the laps indicated by the current codes or the design, other construction laps are not measured'.
- Where the design is silent on laps, the quota-based measurement basis (used for rate build-up, not a basis for the contractor to charge extra wastage): DB11/T 2382-2024 Article 7.1.33, 'for rebar up to d10, one lap per 12m of length; for rebar above d10, one lap per 9m of length'.
- Measures rebar: chairs, diagonal brace bars, anti-floating bars and shims not required by the design are not measured in the BOQ quantities (GB/T 50854-2024 Annex E note 12; likewise GB/T 50857-2024 Annex J and GB/T 50861-2024 Article B.9.3); but 'the working content of each rebar item shall include the corresponding measures rebar' (Annex E note 1), the cost being absorbed into the all-in unit rate, which is exactly how 'not measured but included' is implemented.
3. The four quantities and the calculation chain
Net quantity (BOQ quantity) = the design bar lengths x the theoretical weights + anchorage + design (including code-required) laps. 'Anchorage bars extending out of cast-in-place elements shall have their lengths set as required by the design and included in the rebar quantity of that element' (GB/T 50854-2024 Annex E note 10); 'rebar at post-cast strips in cast-in-place concrete structures is not measured as a separate item; its quantity is included in the rebar quantity of the corresponding cast-in-place element' (note 9). Planned quantity (budget quantity) = net quantity x (1 + the wastage rate); in railway terms, = net quantity + operating wastage + separately counted laps. Detailing-sheet quantity = the sum of the cutting lengths x the theoretical weights (including hook growth, bending dimensional difference, splices and measures bars). Actual consumption = opening stock + delivered in the period - closing stock (by stocktake; it must not be replaced by the drawn quantity). Overrun rate = (actual consumption - planned quantity) / planned quantity x 100%; overrun quantity x the unit price under the supply contract (or the published price information, or as agreed in the contract) = the amount deductible (self-borne). Assessment and pricing are separate matters: the overrun rate is a management metric and does not of itself ground an adjustment of the price.
4. Wastage rates by splicing method (clause sources)
TB/T 10821-2024 annex, 'Site haulage and operating wastage rates of materials', part I 'Metal products', item 1 'Rebar and splices':
- Plain round bar under 10mm diameter, wire (tie wire), strand and wire rope: 1.5%
- Plain round bar 10mm diameter and over, ribbed bar (welded): 1.5%
- Plain round bar 10mm diameter and over, ribbed bar (mechanical splices): 1%
- Small finished and semi-finished products made of rebar: 0.5%
- Prestressing bar (wire), cold-drawn wire, prestressing strand, wire rope: 4% (note: excluding the working length required for tensioning outside the structure); steel mesh: 3%; structural sections: 5%; steel plate: 5% Lap treatment: TB/T 10821-2024 Chapter 3 note 4, 'the rebar fabrication items of this chapter do not contain the rebar consumption; when citing them, supplement by work position and bar type and add the operating wastage. For non-coupler spliced bar above 10mm in diameter, add a further 1.5% of lap length'; note 2, 'the rebar fabrication items of this chapter are compiled on centralised processing by CNC equipment; the quota unit is t, meaning the fabrication of 1t of processed rebar'; note 5, 'the mesh fabrication items of this chapter apply to bar under d10'. Building and municipal combined basis (DB11/T 2382-2024): Article 4.6.5 paragraph 1, 'the consumption of rebar fabrication, of mesh fabrication and fixing, and of diaphragm-wall rebar fabrication and fixing shall be determined in the light of the building function, the design grade of the building and other factors, measured to include measures rebar such as chairs, supports and positioning bars; where the data are insufficient, it is advisable to take wastage plus measures rebar together as 5% of the total rebar'; Article 7.1.32, municipal, 'for rebar wastage (except pile-cage rebar), allowing for fabrication wastage and for measures rebar such as chairs, supports and positioning bars, 5% is advisable'. The effect of the splicing method on laps: where the design requires mechanical splices, 'the splices shall be executed under the corresponding items and the quantities of lap rebar shall not be further calculated' (DB11/T 2382-2024 Article 4.6.5 paragraph 2 and Article 7.1.32); for parallel-thread coupler splices 'the quantities shall be calculated as the numbers shown on the design' (Article 7.1.34). That is, mechanical splicing replaces 'lap length' with 'number of splices'; both cannot be counted.
5. The certification and claim route for wastage beyond the quota
Premise: only overruns caused otherwise than by the contractor (the wrong specification of employer-supplied materials, design variations, employer instructions, stoppage and idleness) can be recovered; contractor detailing errors, fabrication squandering and poor management are outside the adjustable scope. 1 Written confirmation during execution: the site instruction record (site certification) applies to such situations as 'where the price of materials agreed in the contract changes on the market and the contractor must submit the procurement quantity and its unit price to the employer for certification' (GB/T 51262-2017 Section 5.9 lists six situations requiring certification). 2 Time limit for certifying sundry items outside the contract: the contractor shall, within 7 days of accepting the employer's request, submit to the employer a site instruction record stating the labour quantities and rates, the machine-shift quantities and rates, and the materials and amounts. 'Work proceeds after the employer certifies; where the employer has not certified and a dispute arises after the contractor has worked, the responsibility is the contractor's'; and 'all site instruction records signed by the site representatives authorised by the employer and the contractor, and all costs such as claims determined by negotiation between the employer and the contractor, shall be faithfully processed in the final account of the works, and their validity shall not be altered by a mid-course change of the site representatives of the parties' (Cai Jian [2004] No. 369, Chapter 3, settlement of project prices). 3 Time limits of claim processing (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.5): 'the employer shall, within the prescribed time after receiving the contractor's Notice of Claim, examine the records and the supporting material submitted by the contractor; where it considers supplementation necessary, it shall, within the period agreed in the contract (14 days where none is agreed), request the contractor in writing to submit further supporting material'; 'the employer shall, within the period agreed in the contract (28 days where none is agreed) after receiving the contractor's claim report or the supplementary supporting material, reply to the contractor in writing with its position on the claim. Where the employer replies late or makes no reply, the matter may be handled as agreed in the contract; where the contract does not so agree, the employer may be deemed to have approved the claim asserted by the contractor'; where cost and time are both involved, they shall be approved together; claim costs are paid in the current progress payment or interim settlement by construction stage at the payment percentage agreed in the contract, the balance being paid in the final account. 'Where the injured party fails to raise the claim within the agreed time after the event occurs, it may, except as otherwise agreed in the contract or otherwise provided by laws and regulations, be deemed to have waived the relevant claim.' 4 Backstop at settlement: where the employer raises no objection within the prescribed or agreed period after receiving the final account report and the complete supporting documents, it is deemed to have accepted them (Cai Jian [2004] No. 369, Article 16); after the report is confirmed, the contractor applies for payment and the employer shall pay the settlement money within 15 days of receiving the application, in default of which it bears liability for breach.
Boundaries of application
1 Quota wastage rates differ by sector, region and quota book: the building and municipal consumption standards mostly take 'wastage plus measures rebar together at about 5%'; the railway basis takes the annex operating wastage plus 1.5% of laps for non-coupler splices above 10mm; some local quotas take other values for rebar wastage (e.g. 2.5%); confirm the applicable quota book and edition before compiling. 2 BOQ measurement and wastage calculation are two separate bases and must not be mixed: BOQ quantities add no wastage and count no stock-length laps or non-design measures bars; wastage appears only at the level of the quota material consumption. 3 'Self-borne within the effective wastage rate' presupposes that the contract contains no special term; where the contract provides otherwise (wastage borne by the employer or measured separately), the agreement governs. 4 The five-per-thousand detailing error rate and the 2% offcut rate are enterprise-management metrics, and attribution by cause is qualitative analysis; neither grounds measurement or claims. 5 Railway, highway and other sector projects follow their own industry quota and measurement standards and do not take the building 5% basis. 6 The above clauses reflect the 2024 measurement and pricing standards (GB/T 50854 to 50861-2024, GB/T 50500-2024); where the 2013 measurement codes are used in parallel, first confirm the edition agreed in the contract.
Further reading
- GB/T 50854-2024, Measurement Standard for Building and Decoration Works, Annex E, concrete and reinforced concrete works, notes 1, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 to 'rebar, bolts and embedded pieces'.
- GB/T 50857-2024, Measurement Standard for Municipal Works, Annex J, rebar works; GB/T 50860-2024, Measurement Standard for Structures Works, Article A.15.10; GB/T 50861-2024, Measurement Standard for Urban Rail Transit Works, Article B.9.3.
- GB/T 50500-2024: Article 3.3.3 (contractor risks), Articles 3.6.2 and 3.6.3 (effective wastage rate of employer-supplied materials, over-drawn quantities and deduction), Article 8.11.5 (claim processing), Annex G.1 Table G.1.1, schedule of employer-supplied (free-issue) materials.
- TB/T 10821-2024, Basic Quota Manual for Railway Works, Chapter 3 'rebar', notes 2 to 5, and the annex 'site haulage and operating wastage rates of materials', item 1 'rebar and splices'.
- DB11/T 2382-2024, Consumption Standard for Construction Works: Article 4.6.5 (the building 5% basis; no laps counted for mechanical splices), Article 7.1.32 (municipal 5%), Article 7.1.33 (one lap per 12m up to d10, per 9m above d10), Article 7.1.34 (couplers counted by number).
- JGJ 366-2015, Technical Specification for the Application of Processed Rebar in Concrete Structures, Article 5.1.1 (combined cutting, offcuts within 300mm, offcut rate within 2%).
- T/BCAT 0001-2020, Standard for Lean Construction Management of Rebar Works, Article 2.0.10 (definitions and algorithms of quota and contractor in-house wastage rates), Article 4.4.4 (detailing error rate five per thousand).
- GB/T 51262-2017, Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Section 5.9 (assessment of site certification disputes).
- Cai Jian [2004] No. 369, Interim Measures for the Settlement of Construction Project Prices, Chapter 3 (7-day certification of sundry items, the validity of site instruction records, the settlement review period and 15-day payment).
Keywords
- 钢筋翻样损耗
- 定尺损耗
- 定尺搭接
- 定额损耗率
- 超定额损耗
- 材料超领扣款
- variation record / site instruction
- 工程索赔时限