Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-11-01

Evidentiary weight layering of four kinds of process records - site instruction records, acceptance records, construction diaries and minutes of meetings (object of proof x unilateral/bilateral x weight tier) - and the conditions under which unilateral records are corroborated into valid settlement evidence

The four record types carry no statutory hierarchy of evidence; their weight turns on 'whether bilateral agreement was formed -> whether statutory procedure was followed -> whether they corroborate one another': site instruction records (signed off by both parties, within the scope of duty) are tier 1, a direct pricing basis (GB 50500-2013 15.1.1, 15.1.2; 9.14.1~9.14.6 set the instruction - record - submission - verification procedure); acceptance records are tier 2, proving only the completion facts and quality confirmed by statutory procedure, not entitlement to extra payment outside the contract (GB 50300-2013 3.0.6, 6.0.1; Article 30 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works); construction diaries are tier 3, the contractor's unilateral entries, usable only as auxiliary corroboration (kept day by day by a dedicated person, no retrospective entries); minutes of meetings float between tier 1 and tier 3 by sign-off level (chief supervising engineer review + joint sign-off by all parties = a carrier of agreement; without joint sign-off = a unilateral record). Corroboration of a unilateral record requires certification by the employer or an authorised supervisor within the contractual scope of duty (GB/T 50500-2024 12.2.1); absent certification, the expert assessor grades pricing by record completeness under GB/T 51262-2017 5.9.1~5.9.3, and a verbal instruction without material evidence leads to a negative assessment.

Applicable Codes

  • 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》第85条、第87条、第88条、第90条、第92条、第95条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第二十条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第12.2.1条、第12.2.2条
  • GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.9.1条、第5.9.2条
  • GB 50300-2013 · Unified Standard for Constructional Quality Acceptance of Building Engineering 第3.0.6条
  • T/GAEC 201-2018 · Guideline for Compilation and Management of Supervision Documents of Construction Projects 第5.1.4条
  • T/SCIA 001-2020《建筑工程资料管理规程》第5.3.2条

Topic scope

This card addresses a frequent problem in settlement and cost disputes: what each of the four process record types - site instruction records, acceptance records, construction diaries and minutes of meetings - can prove, how their evidentiary weight is layered, and what conditions a unilateral record without counterparty certification must meet to be admitted as valid settlement evidence.

Core conclusions

I. Locating the clauses (correct the citation first)

  • In GB 50500-2013, site instruction records sit in clause 9.14 'site instruction records' (9.14.1~9.14.6); pricing records and archives sit in chapter 15 (15.1 pricing records, 15.2 pricing archives). Do not mis-cite them as clause 9.10 or chapter 13.
  • GB 50500-2013 has been replaced by GB/T 50500-2024 'Pricing Standard for BOQ Works'; the rule that 'written documents signed by both parties' site management personnel within their scope of duty are valid vouchers for construction cost accounting' survives in the 2024 edition at clause 12.2.1. Contracts newly signed and disputes from 2026 onward should be checked against the current clause numbers.

II. Comparison of evidentiary weight across the four record types

Record type Object of proof (can / cannot prove) Unilateral / bilateral Weight tier Basis and common failure points
Site instruction record Proves the occurrence, responsibility attribution, quantities and price of sundry items outside the contract, events not attributable to the contractor, and inconsistencies of contract conditions (site conditions, geology and hydrology, employer requirements); does not prove uncertified work actually performed Bilateral: signed off by the employer's site representative (or its authorised supervisor or cost consultant) and the contractor's site representative Tier 1 - a direct pricing basis; valid certification locks quantity and price GB 50500-2013 15.1.1: written documents signed within the scope of duty 'are valid vouchers for construction cost accounting, except where other valid evidence or verification proves them false'; 15.1.2: approvals, instructions and confirmations shall be in writing, and 'verbal instructions shall not serve as pricing vouchers'; the record procedure of 9.14.1~9.14.6. Failure points: certification beyond authority, no calculation sheet or attached drawing, late submission, quantities off the facts
Acceptance records (concealed works, inspection lots, sub-items, sub-works) Prove the part or process is complete, matches the drawings in scope, and is of acceptable quality; does not prove the work merits added payment outside the contract Multi-party, procedural: inspection lots organised by the trade supervision engineer with the contractor's trade quality inspector and foreman; the supervisor notified before concealment (the employer where no supervisor is engaged) Tier 2 - evidence of 'completion facts' confirmed by statutory procedure; complements the site instruction record but never replaces it GB 50300-2013 3.0.6 item 5: 'concealed works shall be notified by the contractor to the supervision unit for acceptance before concealment, and acceptance documents shall be formed; construction may continue only after passing acceptance'; 6.0.1 on organising inspection-lot acceptance; Article 30 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works: the contractor shall 'keep quality checks and records of concealed works, and before concealment notify the employer and the construction quality supervision agency'. Failure point: object of proof mismatched - claims for incremental payment built on acceptance records are usually unsupported
Construction diary Proves process facts (daily weather, work locations and content, problems and their handling, arrivals and departures of main materials, equipment, components and large plant, acceptance and quality-safety activities, subcontractor mobilisation and demobilisation); cannot alone prove quantities and price Unilateral: kept day by day by a dedicated contractor person, no counterparty certification Tier 3 - a unilateral process record, auxiliary and corroborative only DB11/T 1448-2017 5.3.2 sets the record content and responsibility; the commentary states 'no retrospective entries'. Failure points: post-hoc entries, no echo from photographs, machine-shift records or test reports, contradiction with the supervisor's diary
Minutes of meetings Set by sign-off level: jointly signed minutes can prove the parties reached agreement on specific matters (including variations and cost-handling principles); unsigned minutes prove only that a matter was 'raised or claimed' Layered: (1) review signature of the chief supervising engineer + joint sign-off by the attending parties' representatives = a carrier of agreement; (2) compiled by the supervisor alone and not jointly signed = a unilateral process record; (3) attendance sheet only, no signatures on the minutes = no agreement Floating tier: the jointly signed version approaches tier 1 (price matters should still draw a site instruction record); the unsigned version approaches tier 3 T/GAEC 201-2018 5.1.4: minutes 'shall be reviewed and signed by the chief supervising engineer and reviewed by the contractor's project manager and the employer's representative before signing in the joint sign-off column', 'issued to all attending parties with proof of receipt', the attendance sheet filed as an annex; T/CAEC 006-2024 4.2.2: minutes recorded and compiled by a person designated by the chief supervising engineer, jointly signed by the attending representatives and issued promptly, and 'frequently used for liability determination and legal disputes'. Failure points: no joint sign-off, wording of 'agreed in principle' without quantity or price

Typical use in settlement negotiations: first check for bilaterally certified records or pricing documents (tier 1), then lock completion facts with acceptance records and traces of agreement with jointly signed minutes, and finally reinforce the chain with construction diaries, photographs and supervision records.

III. The time-limit chain of the record procedure (whether a record stands at all)

  • 9.14.1: where the contractor, at the employer's request, performs sundry items outside the contract or work arising from events not attributable to the contractor, the employer shall promptly issue a written instruction and provide the needed information; the contractor, on receipt, shall promptly raise a site instruction record request.
  • 9.14.2: the contractor shall submit the site instruction record report within 7 days of receiving the instruction; the employer shall verify it within 48 hours, confirming it or returning comments; if within 48 hours the employer neither confirms nor comments, the submitted record report is deemed approved by the employer.
  • 9.14.3: where dayworks rates exist for the recorded work, the report shall list the labour, materials, equipment and machine-shifts needed; where no dayworks rate exists, it shall also list quantities and rates.
  • 9.14.5: within 7 days after the recorded work is completed, the contractor shall compute the price per the record and submit it to the employer for confirmation as an addition to the contract price, paid alongside the progress payment.
  • 9.14.6: where the contractor finds on site that the contracted works are inconsistent with site conditions, geology, hydrology or employer requirements, it shall provide the relevant information and submit it to the employer for certification as the basis of contract price adjustment.

IV. Conditions for corroborating a unilateral record into valid settlement evidence

  1. The certifying party must act within the contractual scope of duty: the 'valid voucher' of GB 50500-2013 15.1.1 / GB/T 50500-2024 12.2.1 is bounded by the scope of duty and can be overturned by other valid evidence or proof of falsity; verbal instructions are never pricing vouchers (15.1.2).
  2. Quantities certified by one side only (the supervisor or designer included): if the other side neither accepts nor produces valid contrary evidence, the certified result stands as the assessed quantity; if it objects together with specific evidence, re-examine or survey on site and decide accordingly, and where re-examination is impossible the certified result still stands as the assessed quantity (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 4.3.6, for unit-rate contracts where no drawings exist or the drawings cannot show the disputed quantities).
  3. Objection to a certified measurement result: bare objection without specific evidence - assess by the original measurement; objection together with specific evidence - re-examine the original result, on site if necessary, and assess by the re-examined result (GB/T 51262-2017 5.5.2).
  4. Defective records: where labour, material and machine-shift quantities and their prices are stated, compute per the stated quantities and prices; where only labour quantities are given without rates, price by the comparable labour rate of the assessment project with an appropriate uplift (commentary: about 20%, by trade practice and past data); where only material and machine-shift quantities are given without prices, price at the applicable material and machine-shift rates of the works; where only a lump sum is stated without detail, take the lump sum; where the sundry-work quantities differ from actual completion, take the actual completion (GB/T 51262-2017 5.9.1).
  5. The employer signs receipt only, without assent: where the contractor can prove the recorded work was completed, the assessor may issue an opinion listed separately for the instructing party to weigh; where neither quantities nor prices are given, only the task itself, the parties negotiate first and, failing agreement, the assessor analyses professionally under the principles and methods agreed in the contract and issues an inferential opinion (5.9.2).
  6. Verbal instruction only, the employer disputes it and no material evidence exists: a negative assessment follows for want of legal evidence (5.9.3) - the outer bound of corroboration.
  7. Sundry works outside the contract scope with no record: where the employer accepts them or other contractor evidence can prove them, a positive assessment; where the employer disputes them but a site survey is possible, ask the instructing party to organise the survey and assess by its results (5.4.2).
  8. Joint sign-off for price records: a price record carries the review opinion of the cost supervision engineer and the checking opinion of the chief supervising engineer before going to the employer; its content should cover the reason, the basis, the priced content and quantities and the parties' review opinions, its annexes the price build-up, the approved variation or claim documents and supporting papers, and it takes joint sign-off by the employer, the contractor and the supervisor to take effect (T/CAEC 006-2024 7.2.9).

Applicable boundaries

  • The four record types carry no statutory hierarchy of evidence (in the civil-evidence taxonomy most are documentary evidence, and the construction diary is close to a party's own statement); the 'tiers' in this card rank probative force in settlement and assessment practice, not legal grades of evidence.
  • Tier 1 weight presupposes certification 'within the contractual scope of duty': certification beyond authority, signatures by ad-hoc personnel, or retrospective certification without other corroboration does not qualify.
  • Acceptance records, diaries and minutes cannot replace a record when claiming incremental payment: acceptance settles 'completed and conforming', the record settles 'outside the contract and payable' - different objects of proof.
  • Versions: GB 50500-2013 is withdrawn and replaced by GB/T 50500-2024; the assessment wording comes from GB/T 51262-2017 and T/ZBD 100.4-2023; when citing old clause numbers, state the corresponding rule of the current version alongside.
  • DB11/T 1448-2017 is a Beijing local standard; T/CAEC 006-2024 and T/GAEC 201-2018 are association standards whose reach is limited to the region or association - elsewhere they serve only as management reference.
  • The assessment rules apply in assessment proceedings; admissibility in litigation remains governed by the civil-evidence rules and the judge's evaluation.

Further reading

  • GB 50500-2013 'Pricing Code for BOQ Works', clause 9.14 (9.14.1~9.14.6 site instruction records) and chapter 15, 15.1.1, 15.1.2 (pricing records and valid vouchers, written form); replaced by GB/T 50500-2024 'Pricing Standard for BOQ Works', whose corresponding rule sits at 12.2.1.
  • GB/T 51262-2017 'Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment', 5.4.2 (sundry works without a record), 5.5.2 (objections to certified measurement results), 5.9.1~5.9.3 (graded pricing of record-cost disputes, defective records, verbal instruction without material evidence); the 20% uplift in 5.9.1 item 2 sits in the commentary.
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 'Guidance for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice', 4.3.6 (the five-step determination for quantity disputes without drawings under unit-rate contracts).
  • GB 50300-2013 'Unified Standard for Acceptance of Construction Quality', 3.0.6 item 5 and 6.0.1; the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (2019 revision), Article 30.
  • T/CAEC 006-2024 'Standard for Management of Supervision Documents', 4.2.2 (content and joint sign-off of meeting minutes) and 7.2.9 (content, annexes and tripartite sign-off of price records); T/GAEC 201-2018 'Guide to Compiling and Managing Supervision Documents', 5.1.4 (joint sign-off and proof of receipt of minutes); DB11/T 1448-2017 'Regulation for Management of Urban Rail Transit Works Records', 5.3.2 (daily diary entries, no retrospective entries).

Keywords