Determining whether an engineering construction standard has been repealed: a four-scenario framework and official-announcement verification channels
Repeal must be confirmed by an announcement of the standard's approving department; absence of an official repeal/replacement announcement means the standard cannot be deemed repealed. Four scenarios must be distinguished: replaced by a new version (announcement stating simultaneous repeal), amended/partially revised (code unchanged and still valid), mandatory provisions superseded by fully-mandatory general codes (the original standard is not necessarily repealed), and repeal confirmed upon re-examination. Verification prioritizes MOHURD announcements and the National Public Service Platform for Standards Information, with dual-source cross-validation and locked citation versions.
Applicable Codes
- 建标〔2006〕221号 工程建设标准复审管理办法
- 建设部令第24号 工程建设国家标准管理办法
- GB 55001~55035 全文强制规范系列(强条替代≠标准废止)
Topic Positioning
A judgment framework and official verification method for determining whether a standard/specification cited by AI has been repealed, used for validity verification before citing standards.
Core Conclusions
- Repeal requires an official announcement: re-examination results are confirmed and announced by the standard's approving department (Jianbiao [2006] No. 221, Article 9); the effective time of repeal is determined by the approving department, and the announcement may come later than publication — during the transition period the old version remains lawful.
- Distinguish four scenarios: (1) replaced by a new version — the publication announcement states "the original standard is simultaneously repealed" (e.g., GB/T 50500-2024 replacing the 2013 version); (2) amended/partially revised — the code is unchanged and the standard remains valid; when citing, note "amended in year X" (e.g., MOHURD Order No. 37 remains valid after amendment by Order No. 47); (3) mandatory provisions superseded by the GB 55001~55035 series of fully-mandatory general codes — only the mandatory provisions are repealed, and the original standard's recommended provisions remain in force (e.g., GB 50010 is still current); (4) repeal confirmed upon re-examination — announced with an explicit effective time. The most easily misjudged is scenario (3): superseded mandatory provisions do not mean the entire standard is repealed.
- Verification channel priority: MOHURD/industry authority announcements -> status check on the National Public Service Platform for Standards Information -> old/new version comparison in the local library (old version does not equal repealed; historical reference only) -> government sources to confirm local implementation.
- Dual-source cross-validation (accept only when at least two independent sources agree on status); lock the citation version (dated reference, only the dated version applies), and retain a citation checklist of "standard name + code + year + verification date + basis announcement number".
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to validity judgment of national, industry, and local standards for engineering construction; re-examination of filed enterprise standards is formulated with reference by provincial construction authorities. Not applicable to product standards, patents, or other non-construction standards. "Historical version" labels in local libraries do not mean "repealed"; official announcements always govern.
Further Reading
Jianbiao [2006] No. 221 "Measures for the administration of re-examination of engineering construction standards" Articles 2, 8, 9 (re-examination definition, deliberation-opinion principles, announcement confirmation); Ministry of Construction Order No. 24 "Measures for the administration of national standards of engineering construction" Article 34 (re-examination opinions submitted for approval); "effective time of repeal" in Article 12 of the re-examination measures; dated reference rules in relevant standard-drafting provisions (only the dated version applies).
Keywords
- 规范废止
- 标准废止
- 标准复审
- 废止公告
- 规范有效性核查
- 现行有效
- 被新版替代
- 工程建设标准