The FIDIC Clause 1 term "Cost" (1999 Red Book 1.1.4.3 vs 2017 1.1.19/1.1.20) and the three payment calibers: Cost / Cost Plus Profit / 12.3 "reasonable cost plus reasonable profit"
Capitalized "Cost" is a Clause 1 defined term: all expenditure reasonably incurred (or to be incurred) by the Contractor, on or off Site, including overheads but excluding profit — a chargeable "payment unit" entering the Contract Price; the 2017 edition narrows it to "in performing the Contract" and defines Cost Plus Profit as Cost + the profit rate in the Contract Data (default 5%). It is not the domestic norm-based "engineering cost"; claims and accounts must first identify whether a clause gives Cost, Cost Plus Profit, or a 12.3 new rate built from "reasonable cost plus reasonable profit".
Applicable Codes
- FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction (Red Book), 1st Edition 1999, Sub-Clause 1.1.4.3
- FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction, 2nd Edition 2017, Sub-Clauses 1.1.19 & 1.1.20
- FIDIC Red Book 1999 Sub-Clause 12.3 [Evaluation]
- FIDIC Red Book 2017 Sub-Clause 12.3 [Valuation of the Works]
Topic Positioning
Explains the capitalized "Cost" in the FIDIC Clause 1 definitions (Red Book basis; Yellow analogous): a "payment unit" with legally fixed boundaries — chargeable, claimable, and added to the Contract Price — distinct from colloquial "cost" and from the domestic norm-caliber "engineering cost". Also clarifies the three payment calibers — Cost / Cost Plus Profit / 12.3 new rates from "reasonable cost plus reasonable profit" — and the 1999 vs 2017 definitional differences.
Core Conclusions
- 1999 Red Book 1.1.4.3 (verbatim): "'Cost' means all expenditure reasonably incurred (or to be incurred) by the Contractor, whether on or off the Site, including overhead and similar charges, but does not include profit." Four elements: (1) reasonably incurred — "reasonably" is the adjudicative word; unreasonable overspending and inefficiency losses are out; (2) incurred or to be incurred — future unavoidable expenditure claimable, not limited to amounts paid; (3) on or off the Site — head-office overhead etc. expressly in; (4) excludes profit — Cost is "profitless cost".
- 2017 changes (Red and Yellow 2nd Ed. 2017):
- 1.1.19 "Cost" adds the performance qualifier "in performing the Contract" and expressly includes taxes;
- new 1.1.20 "Cost Plus Profit" = Cost plus the profit percentage in the Contract Data (if not stated, 5%) — profit moves from 1999's undefined, case-by-case negotiation to a default 5%, variable in the Contract Data;
- both editions confirm: "Where the Contractor is entitled under a Sub-Clause of these Conditions to payment of Cost (Plus Profit), it shall be added to the Contract Price." — via the engineer's agreement/determination (3.5/3.7).
- The three "baskets" must be distinguished — the first line of any claim should be "does this clause give Cost or CPP":
- Cost only (some 1999 employer-risk and suspension cases): reimburses profitless cost — overheads in, profit out;
- Cost Plus Profit (many 2017 clauses): Cost + default 5% (or as stated);
- 12.3 new rates (Red 1999 and 2017): where an item has no BOQ rate and is unlike any BOQ item in nature or conditions, or (2017 expressly) measured quantity changes by more than 10% vs the BOQ, new rates derive from relevant BOQ rates reasonably adjusted; absent any, "derived from the reasonable Cost of executing the work, together with reasonable profit" — that "reasonable profit" has no fixed percentage and is a different computation outlet from the 5% CPP. 1999 also lets the engineer fix provisional rates for interim certificates pending agreement.
- Commentary view: Ben Beaumont (Yellow commentary) calls the definition "unwieldy" and suggests expressly including Daywork charges in Cost (his redraft adds "including any charge for Daywork"); he finds the 5% default (five percentum (5%)) in Cost Plus Profit clear.
Applicable Boundaries
- FIDIC only (1999 Red 1.1.4.3; 2017 Red/Yellow 1.1.19, 1.1.20). Wordings differ across editions and Particular Conditions (e.g., Silver on taxes) — check the signed edition clause by clause; never transplant Red definitions to other forms.
- Cost is "trigger-based": only where a sub-clause expressly entitles the Contractor to Cost or CPP is it measured and added to the Contract Price; absent a trigger, no claim lies.
- Cost is a defined international-contract term — not the domestic norm "engineering cost" nor financial accounting cost; no direct conversion.
- 5% is only the default absent Contract Data provision; alternative rates may be agreed.
- Agreement/determination of Cost/CPP runs under 2017 3.7 — the engineer's duty there is non-delegable and, when acting under 3.7, the engineer acts neutrally, not as the employer's agent (distinct from the 3.1 general position).
Further Reading
- FIDIC Red Book, 1st Ed. 1999: 1.1.4.3 "Cost", 1.1.4.2 "Contract Price", 12.3 [Evaluation], 14.1 (payment timing: 14.6 interim certificates 28 days, 14.7 payment periods, 14.13 final payment certificate).
- FIDIC Red Book, 2nd Ed. 2017: 1.1.19 "Cost", 1.1.20 "Cost Plus Profit", 3.7 [Agreement or Determination], 12.3 [Valuation of the Works] (text on >10% quantity change or differing nature/conditions for new rates).
- Yellow comparison: FIDIC Plant and Design-Build; commentary: Ben Beaumont, "FIDIC Yellow Book - A Commentary", Clause 1 ("unwieldy" and the Daywork suggestion).
Keywords
- International Federation of Consulting Engineers (FIDIC)
- Cost定义
- Cost Plus Profit
- 成本
- FIDIC Red Book (Conditions of Contract for Construction)
- 1.1.4.3
- 1.1.19
- 合同价格