Validity of a construction contract concluded without tendering where the project was subject to compulsory tendering at contracting but no longer falls within the compulsory tendering scope when suit is filed (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 1: invalidity shall not be found merely for the absence of tendering), with the criteria for the compulsory tendering scope and the temporal cut-off
Valid in principle: Article 1 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 provides that 'where the parties conclude a contract without tendering and the project no longer falls within the scope of compulsory tendering when the suit is filed, the people's court shall not find the contract invalid merely for the absence of tendering'. The elements are the three cumulative steps: subject to compulsory tendering at contracting + no tendering + no longer subject at filing. The wording is 'not ... merely': where the project is still within the compulsory tendering scope at filing (Item (3) of Article 1 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), or grounds such as lack of qualification or borrowed qualification, transfer of the whole contract or unlawful subcontracting coexist, the contract remains invalid.
Applicable Codes
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第一条、第二十三条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第一条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百五十三条、第一百五十七条、第七百九十一条、第七百九十三条
- 《中华人民共和国招标投标法》第三条、第四十九条
- 《必须招标的工程项目规定》(国家发展改革委令第16号)第二条至第五条
- 《必须招标的基础设施和公用事业项目范围规定》(发改法规规〔2018〕843号)第二条
- 《中华人民共和国行政处罚法》(2021修订)第三十七条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第一百二十二条、第一百二十六条
Positioning
Determining the validity of a construction contract: the project belonged to the works subject to compulsory tendering by law when the contract was concluded, the parties concluded the contract without tendering, and by the time suit is filed the project no longer falls within the scope of compulsory tendering - is the contract still invalid? The question engages the transition between Article 1 of the SPC Interpretation on the Application of Law in Construction Contract Dispute Cases (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) and Item (3) of Article 1 of the Construction Contract Interpretation (I) (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), together with the criteria for determining the compulsory tendering scope and the temporal cut-off.
Core conclusion
1. Conclusion: not invalid for that reason; the contract is valid in principle. Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 1, reads: 'Where a construction contract is concluded for a project that was subject to compulsory tendering at the time the contract was concluded, the parties conclude the contract without tendering, and the project no longer falls within the scope of compulsory tendering when the suit is filed, the people's court shall not find the contract invalid merely for the absence of tendering.'
Core reasoning: the normative basis of invalidity would be the compulsory-tendering mandatory provision pointed to by Article 153(1) of the Civil Code - 'A civil juristic act that violates a mandatory provision of a law or administrative regulation is invalid, except where that mandatory provision does not render the civil juristic act invalid.' By the time of filing, the compulsory tendering requirement no longer exists (the project no longer falls within the scope of Articles 2 to 5 of the Provisions on Projects Subject to Compulsory Tendering (NDRC Order No. 16) or of Article 2 of the Provisions on the Scope of Infrastructure and Public Utility Projects Subject to Compulsory Tendering (NDRC [2018] No. 843)); the unlawfulness has ceased to exist, and invalidating the contract merely for the absence of tendering back then has no normative basis; it also accords with the lighter-penalty orientation of Article 37 of the Administrative Penalty Law: 'An administrative penalty shall be imposed in accordance with the provisions of the law, regulation or rule in force at the time the unlawful act occurred. However, where, by the time the penalty decision is made, the law, regulation or rule has been amended or repealed and the new provisions prescribe a lighter penalty or do not treat the act as unlawful, the new provisions shall apply.'
2. The three-step test (all steps indispensable)
- Subject to compulsory tendering at the time of contracting - judged by the norms and standards in force at that time (project nature and funding source under Article 3 of the Tendering and Bidding Law: '(1) large infrastructure and public utility projects concerning the public interest or public safety; (2) projects financed wholly or partly with state-owned funds or state financing; (3) projects using loans or aid funds from international organisations or foreign governments'; the concrete scope is in the five categories of Article 2 of Document No. 843 - energy, transport, communications, water conservancy and urban rail transit; the size thresholds are in Article 5 of NDRC Order No. 16: '(1) construction single contracts estimated at RMB 4 million or more; (2) procurement of important equipment or materials, single contracts estimated at RMB 2 million or more; (3) procurement of survey, design, supervision or other services, single contracts estimated at RMB 1 million or more'; where the procurements of one project may be combined, a combined estimate reaching the threshold likewise triggers compulsory tendering).
- Contract concluded without tendering - including not tendering, splitting a project into pieces, or evading tendering by other means (the forms listed in Article 49 of the Tendering and Bidding Law).
- No longer subject to compulsory tendering when suit is filed - 'when the suit is filed' is anchored to the time of docketing and acceptance: Article 122 of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) sets the conditions for filing suit, and Article 126 provides that 'the people's court must accept a suit conforming to Article 122 of this Law; where the conditions for filing suit are met, the case shall be docketed within seven days and the parties notified'; whether the new interpretation applies is further judged under Article 23.
3. Temporal cut-off (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 23) The text reads: 'This Interpretation takes effect from 30 June 2026. First-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect shall apply this Interpretation. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this Interpretation after the latter takes effect, this Interpretation prevails.' That is, the cut-off is judged by the time of docketing and acceptance, not by the time of contracting or of construction; first-instance cases accepted before 30 June 2026 (including their appeal and retrial stages) are still handled under Item (3) of Article 1 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 ('a construction project that must be tendered by law was not tendered, or the winning of the tender was invalid').
4. Scenarios still invalid or outside this Article (for contrast)
- Project still within the compulsory tendering scope at filing and not tendered -> invalid: Article 153(1) of the Civil Code plus Article 1(3) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (Interpretation II changes nothing for this scenario).
- No longer within the scope at filing, but coexisting grounds - the contractor has not obtained a construction enterprise qualification or exceeds its grade, or an actual constructor without qualification borrows the name of a qualified enterprise -> still invalid, under Items (1) and (2) of Article 1 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 plus Article 153(1) of the Civil Code; unrelated to the tendering scope.
- Transfer of the whole contract or unlawful subcontracting -> invalid: Article 1(2) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 plus Article 791(2) and (3) of the Civil Code.
- Not subject to compulsory tendering at contracting, within the scope only at filing -> contract valid (validity is assessed under the law in force at the time of the act; invalidity cannot be derived backwards).
- Still within the compulsory tendering scope at docketing, the scope being adjusted only during the proceedings -> the requirement 'no longer subject at filing' fails; invalid in principle.
5. Legal consequences A valid contract is priced and settled under its agreed terms; it does not enter the discounted-price compensation path of Article 793 of the Civil Code, and 'no tendering' cannot be invoked to claim re-derivation of built-up rates under the quota norms. Only where the contract is invalid for other grounds does Article 793 apply: 'Where a construction contract is invalid but the construction works have passed acceptance, the contractor may be compensated at a discounted price by reference to the agreement on the construction price. Where a construction contract is invalid and the construction works have failed acceptance, the following applies: (1) where the repaired works pass acceptance, the employer may request the contractor to bear the repair cost; (2) where the repaired works fail acceptance, the contractor has no right to request discounted-price compensation by reference to the agreement on the construction price. Where the employer is at fault for losses caused by the unqualified works, it shall bear the corresponding liability.' Restitution and compensation after invalidity further follow Article 157 of the Civil Code.
6. Administrative liability and civil validity run on separate tracks Declining civil invalidity does not lift administrative liability: Article 49 of the Tendering and Bidding Law provides that for a project that must be tendered but is not tendered, is split into pieces or otherwise evades tendering, the authority 'orders correction within a time limit and may impose a fine of no less than 0.5% and no more than 1% of the project contract value; for projects financed wholly or partly with state-owned funds, execution of the project or disbursement of the funds may be suspended; the persons directly in charge and the other persons directly responsible of the entity shall be sanctioned according to law'. An administrative penalty imposed, or liable to be imposed, does not translate into invalidity of the contract.
Boundaries of application
- The wording is 'shall not ... merely for the absence of tendering' - this closes only the 'no tendering' ground of invalidity and waives nothing as to lack of qualification, borrowed qualification, transfer or unlawful subcontracting, invalid winning of tender and the like; the other side may still assert invalidity on those grounds.
- The Article applies only where the project was subject to compulsory tendering at contracting and is no longer so at filing; 'when the suit is filed' is fixed at the docketing of the case, and evidence should address the scope and size standards in force at that point (including changes in funding source or project nature).
- Whether Article 1 of Interpretation II applies must first pass the Article 23 temporal gate: only first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026; earlier-accepted cases apply Item (3) of Article 1 of Interpretation I.
- Finding a contract invalid is within the power of the people's court (or the arbitral tribunal); an expert assessor may not determine validity on its own initiative.
- Whether a specific project was 'subject to compulsory tendering' must also be checked against the version of the State Council and ministerial provisions in force at the time of contracting (the thresholds of Order No. 3 before NDRC Order No. 16, and the adjustment documents after Document No. 843); the current scope must not be projected back onto an earlier date.
Further reading
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: Article 1 (no longer per se invalid for absence of tendering), Article 23 (effective date and the gate of newly accepted first-instance cases).
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, the Construction Contract Interpretation (I): Article 1 (four invalidity scenarios); from Article 24 onwards, the rules on settlement of invalid contracts.
- Civil Code: Article 153 (validity where mandatory provisions are violated), Article 157 (consequences of invalidity), Article 791 (prohibition of transfer of the contract and unlawful subcontracting), Article 793 (discounted-price compensation for invalid contracts).
- Tendering and Bidding Law: Article 3 (compulsory tendering scope), Article 49 (administrative liability for non-tendering or evasion of tendering); Provisions on Projects Subject to Compulsory Tendering (NDRC Order No. 16), Articles 2 to 5 (funding-source scope and the RMB 4 million / RMB 2 million / RMB 1 million size thresholds); Provisions on the Scope of Infrastructure and Public Utility Projects Subject to Compulsory Tendering (NDRC [2018] No. 843), Article 2 (the five project categories).
- Administrative Penalty Law (2021 revision), Article 37 (old act, lighter penalty rule); Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision), Articles 122 and 126 (conditions for filing suit and docketing within seven days; the anchoring of 'when the suit is filed').
Keywords
- 必须招标
- 未招标合同无效
- 法释〔2026〕12号
- 建工解释二第一条
- 起诉时不再属于必须招标
- 民法典第153条
- 招标投标法第49条
- 发改委16号令