Whether an extension-of-time claim can succeed without a site instruction record confirming the extension from the employer or the supervising engineer: the two-limb rule of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 10, the treatment of contract terms deeming no extension where no application is made in time, the two exceptions, and the linked 28-day claim procedure milestones
Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 10 paragraph 1: where the parties agree that an extension of time must be confirmed by the employer or the supervising engineer through a site instruction record or similar means, and the contractor has not obtained such confirmation but can prove that it applied to the employer or the supervising engineer for the extension within the period agreed in the contract and that the ground for the extension complies with the contract, the people's court shall support the contractor's claim for extension of time on that basis. Paragraph 2: where the parties agree that failure by the contractor to apply for an extension within the agreed period is deemed to mean no extension of time, the agreement governs, except where the employer agrees to the extension after the agreed period or the contractor raises a reasonable defence. So 'no extension site record' does not mean waiver of the extension: the keys are (1) an application was made within the agreed period (evidence of service required), and (2) the ground for the extension complies with the contract.
Applicable Codes
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》法释〔2020〕25号 第十条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》法释〔2026〕12号 第二十三条
- 《建设工程工程量清单计价标准》GB/T 50500-2024 第8.11.3条
- 《建设项目工程总承包合同(示范文本)》GF-2020-0216(建市〔2020〕96号)通用合同条件 第19.1~19.4条
Topic Positioning
Whether a contractor's extension-of-time claim can stand judicially where it failed to obtain the employer's or the supervising engineer's site instruction record confirming the extension (or the contract-agreed period has already lapsed): the rule itself, where the evidence must land, forfeiture terms and exceptions, and the linked 28-day claim procedure.
Core Conclusions
I. The rule itself (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 10)
Paragraph 1, original text: 'Where the parties agree that an extension of time shall be confirmed by the employer or the supervising engineer through a site instruction record or other means, and the contractor, although not having obtained confirmation of the extension of time, can prove that it applied for the extension of time to the employer or the supervising engineer within the period agreed in the contract and that the ground for the extension complies with the contract, the people's court shall support the contractor's claim for extension of time on that basis.'
Paragraph 2, original text: 'Where the parties agree that if the contractor fails to apply for an extension of time within the agreed period it is deemed that the works period will not be extended, the agreement shall be honoured, except where the employer agrees to the extension of time after the agreed period or the contractor raises a reasonable defence.'
Hence a two-limb test:
- Application made as agreed + ground complies with the contract -> extension stands even without a site record. The site instruction record is merely a means of confirmation, not a constitutive requirement of the right to extension; where it is missing, evidence that an application was duly made within the period substitutes for it.
- No application within the period + contract deems late application as no extension -> the agreement governs (no extension), with two exceptions: first, the employer agrees to the extension after the agreed period; second, the contractor raises a reasonable defence (e.g. causes not attributable to it made timely application impossible, or the employer separately confirmed the extension ground itself).
II. Linked procedural milestones (fallback where the contract is silent)
- GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.3: the contractor shall, within the period agreed in the contract after occurrence of the claim event (28 days where the contract is silent), submit to the employer a written Notice of Claim stating the cause of the event and the claim intention; where the contractor fails to issue the Notice of Claim in time, the matter may be dealt with as agreed in the contract. Within the contract-agreed period after the Notice of Claim is issued (28 days if silent), a written claim report shall be submitted detailing the cause of the event, the contract clauses on which the claim rests, the costs and/or days of extension claimed, together with the necessary records and supporting materials and a calculation schedule of the claimed costs. Where the event involves both additional costs and extension of time, they shall be claimed together. For events with continuing effect, continuation notices shall be submitted at the intervals agreed in the contract (no more than 28 days if silent) or at reasonable intervals, and the final claim report within the agreed period after the effect ends (28 days if silent). The article further provides: 'Where the party suffering loss fails to raise the claim within the agreed time after the event occurs, it may be deemed to have waived the relevant claim, except as otherwise agreed in the contract or otherwise provided by laws and regulations. Where the claiming party submits a claim report as agreed in the contract and the other party fails to reply within the agreed time or makes no reply, the relevant claim asserted by the claiming party may be deemed approved.'
- GF-2020-0216 Clause 19.1: the claiming party shall, within 28 days after it knew or ought to have known of the claim event, deliver a Notice of Claim to the other party; 'if the claiming party fails to issue the Notice of Claim within the said 28 days, it loses the right to demand additional or reduced payment, extension of the defects liability period and/or extension of time'; within 28 days after issuing the Notice of Claim it shall deliver the claim report; for events with continuing effect, continuation notices shall be delivered monthly; the final claim report shall be delivered within 28 days after the effect ends. Clause 19.2: where the Engineer fails to reply within 42 days after receiving the claim report or further proof, the claim is deemed approved.
- GF-2020-0216 Clause 19.4, on the time-bar consequences in the same direction: after the contractor receives the completion payment certificate, it may no longer raise any claim arising before issue of the taking-over certificate for the contract works.
III. Where the evidence must land (missing site record)
- Timely application: submission receipts, outgoing document registers, correspondence and emails, supervising engineer logs, minutes of site meetings and the like that lock in 'application made within the contract-agreed period';
- Ground complying with the contract: pointing to specific contract clauses (e.g. expiry of the employer's review period, employer default, constitution of a variation) and attributing the event to the employer side;
- Causation and days: supporting the claimed days with the approved construction programme, critical path and total float analysis;
- Counter-move: where the other party, having received the claim report or application, fails to reply in time, assert deemed approval (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.3, GF-2020-0216 Clause 19.2).
Scope and Limits
- This article resolves the procedural and evidentiary defence of 'claiming an extension without a confirmed site record'; it does not displace the substantive requirements: the ground must comply with the contract and causation between the event and delay to the overall works period must be proved, failing which the claim may still fail.
- Paragraph 2's 'the agreement governs' presupposes an express contract clause that late application means no extension; absent such a clause, forfeiture cannot simply be presumed.
- The two exceptions are asserted and proved by the contractor: employer consent after the period (written confirmation, later site records, records acknowledged in the final account) and reasonable defence (objective obstacles that made timely application impossible, etc.).
- The deemed-approval rule for failure to reply in time and the forfeiture clause cut both ways: the employer's own failure to reply in time may likewise result in the claim being deemed approved, though the scope is capped by the contract or by the clauses of the pricing standard relied upon.
- Where the claim for extension of time fails, a separate claim for the costs actually incurred remains available (the objects of proof differ).
Further Reading
- Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of Law in Cases of Construction Contract Disputes (I), Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 10 (rules on missing extension site records and late application).
- Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of Law in Cases of Construction Contract Disputes (II), Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 23 (effective 30 June 2026; applies to first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted after its entry into force; where earlier Supreme People's Court interpretations conflict with it after its entry into force, it prevails) - before invoking Interpretation (I) Article 10, check the case acceptance date against this effective-date boundary.
- GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for pricing on a bill of quantities basis for construction works, Article 8.11.3 (Notice of Claim -> claim report -> continuation notices -> final report and consequences of lapse).
- GF-2020-0216, Model General Contracting Contract for Construction Projects, General Conditions, Clauses 19.1 to 19.4 (raising, processing and time limits of claims).
Keywords
- 工期顺延申请
- 工期顺延签证
- 未取得确认
- 法释〔2020〕25号第十条
- 逾期视为不顺延
- 合理抗辩
- Notice of Claim
- 28 days