Railway 2024 estimates and budgets: dividing the cost scope between labour cost and on-costs - attribution to production workers (all-in labour cost) vs management personnel (overheads) (TB 10801-2024 clauses 3.1/3.9)
Labour cost means the various costs incurred for the production workers directly engaged in the construction and installation of the works (TB 10801-2024 clause 3.1.1); on-costs mean the costs incurred by the construction enterprise in organising construction production and business administration to complete the contracted works, and on-costs = overheads + profit (clauses 3.9.1, 3.9.2). The test: money spent on production workers -> labour cost (all-in labour cost); spent on management personnel / the enterprise management layer -> on-costs (overheads). Wages, the "five social insurances and one housing fund", labour-protection articles, trade-union funds and staff education funds all have corresponding treatments on both sides. The 2024 edition has merged the workers' five insurances and one fund, formerly under statutory levies and fees, into labour cost: the base-period all-in daily labour rate includes the insurances and housing fund (pension 16%, medical 8%, unemployment 1%, work injury 1%, maternity 0.8%, housing fund 8%); the base-period rates for the seven classes of workers are 140.11 to 201.34 yuan per workday, adjustments over the base period being carried as a labour cost differential; on-costs = (base-period labour cost + base-period plant and small tools cost) x the on-cost percentage rate (TB 10811-2024 Table 2.9.1). The cost of protection personnel on in-service railway lines is carried in the statutory work safety levy, in neither labour cost nor on-costs.
Applicable Codes
- TB 10801-2024 · Measures for Compilation of Design Estimates and Budgets of Railway Capital Construction Projects
- TB 10811-2024 · Fee schedule for design estimates and budgets of capital railway works
Topic Positioning
Division of the cost scope between "labour cost" and "on-costs" in the 2024 railway estimate (budget) system (TB 10801-2024 "Measures for Preparing Design Estimates (Budgets) of Capital Railway Construction Projects" + TB 10811-2024 "Cost Norms for Design Estimates (Budgets) of Capital Railway Construction Projects"): the dividing principle, the composition of the all-in labour cost and of overheads, the key 2024 change of merging the five insurances and one housing fund into labour cost, and the boundary exceptions - answering attribution questions of the type "do the salaries, social insurance and labour-protection articles of on-site management personnel go into labour cost or on-costs?"
Core Conclusions
- Dividing principle (a one-sentence line): look at whom the money is spent on - "production workers directly engaged in the construction and installation of the works" -> labour cost; "organising construction production and business administration (management personnel / the enterprise management layer)" -> on-costs.
- TB 10801-2024 clause 3.1.1: labour cost means the various costs incurred for the production workers directly engaged in the construction and installation of the works.
- Clause 3.9.1: on-costs mean the costs incurred by the construction enterprise in organising construction production and business administration to complete the contracted works; clause 3.9.2: on-costs comprise overheads and profit.
Scope of labour cost (clause 3.1): labour cost = quota labour consumption x the all-in daily labour rate (clause 3.1.2); the difference between the preparation-period labour cost and the base-period labour cost is carried as a labour cost differential (clause 3.1.3). The all-in labour cost (clause 3.1.4) comprises basic wages, allowances and subsidies, auxiliary wages of production workers, staff welfare costs, labour-protection costs of production workers, basic pension insurance, basic medical insurance, work-injury insurance, unemployment insurance, maternity insurance, the housing provident fund, trade-union funds and staff education funds. The all-in daily labour rate follows TB 10811 (clause 3.1.5).
Scope of overheads (clause 3.9.2 paragraph 1, 12 items): salaries of management personnel, office expenses, travel and transport expenses, use of fixed assets, tools and appliances, inspection and testing costs, property insurance, taxes, mobilisation/demobilisation and site transfer of the construction enterprise, labour insurance, financial expenses, and others. Item 1), salaries of management personnel, is symmetrical with the composition of the all-in labour cost: the basic wages, allowances and subsidies, auxiliary wages, staff welfare, labour protection, basic pension, basic medical, work-injury, unemployment and maternity insurance, housing provident fund, trade-union funds and staff education funds of management personnel etc.; the commentary to 3.9.2 states that "the salaries of management personnel include the social insurance contributions and housing provident fund paid by the individual and the enterprise for management personnel, and the trade-union funds and staff education funds spent on management personnel". Inspection and testing costs exclude testing of new structures and new materials, tests on conforming materials and destructive tests of members required by the employer, inspection and testing entrusted by the employer, and testing beyond the construction quality acceptance standards required by the design.
Key 2024 change (a trap to avoid): commentary 3.1.4 - this revision "adds to the former labour cost the workers' five insurances and one fund formerly under statutory levies and fees, together with the trade-union funds and staff education funds spent on workers"; therefore, when preparing estimates under the 2024 edition, statutory levies / social insurance items must no longer be listed separately - they are already packaged into the all-in daily labour rate. Note also that the all-in daily labour rate and railway labour-market wages differ in basis and must not be compared directly: (1) the all-in daily rate is computed on an 8-hour workday; (2) the costs of workers' own small tools and auxiliary materials are carried in the quota norms (market labour wages generally already include them); (3) wages for work completed outside 8 hours or in excess of norm productivity through improved efficiency are carried in the estimate as additional quantities.
Base-period all-in daily labour rates (TB 10811-2024 Table 2.1.1-1, yuan/workday): Class I 140.11 (subgrade excluding the graded crushed stone and sand-gravel of the subgrade top layer and transition zones, culverts, ordinary production buildings and ancillary works, water supply and drainage, station yards etc.; treatment of borrow and spoil areas; heavy temporary works); Class II 143.13 (graded crushed stone and sand-gravel of the subgrade top layer and transition zones); Class III 149.18 (bridges excluding box-girder precasting, transport, erection and cast-in-place work and bridge decking; works of the "four electrical" systems (communication, signalling, power and electrification) and of the locomotive, rolling-stock, depot and track maintenance departments); Class IV 154.88 (equipment installation works excluding installation of the four-electrical equipment); Class V 160.93 (box-girder precasting, transport, erection and cast-in-place work, steel girders, steel-pipe arch erection, bridge decking, graded-aggregate ballast bed, station buildings (including station complexes), passenger subways, overpasses and canopies); Class VI 166.80 (track excluding the graded-aggregate ballast bed; installation of the four-electrical equipment); Class VII 201.34 (tunnels). Table notes: the base-period rates exclude special regional allowances and subsidies (computed per state and provincial provisions and carried as a labour cost differential); the rates include the enterprise's contributions to the five insurances and one fund at basic pension 16%, basic medical 8%, unemployment 1%, work injury 1%, maternity 0.8% and housing provident fund 8%; the design institute may adjust the preparation-period rate per local government and departmental provisions, the adjustment over the base period being carried as a labour cost differential; on plateaus at 3000 m elevation and above, the wage subsidy is computed on basic wages (= 20% of the base-period all-in daily labour rate) at the percentages of Table 2.1.1-2 (3000 (incl.) to 3500 (incl.) m: 70%; over 3500 to 4000 (incl.) m: 130%; over 4000 to 4500 (incl.) m: 185%; above 4500 m: 225%); once the plateau subsidy is applied, no further living-cost subsidy or hardship and remote-area allowance is computed for that region; transitional works apply the all-in daily labour rate of the same class of permanent works; works outside the classes listed apply the Class I rate.
Computation of on-costs (clause 3.9.3): on-costs = (base-period labour cost + base-period plant and small tools cost) x the on-cost percentage rate, the rates following TB 10811-2024 Table 2.9.1 (16 classes of works, rates 14.3%-58.6%, e.g. manually executed earth and rock works 14.3%, mechanically executed earth and rock works 20.6%, substructures of super-major and major bridges 17.7%, tunnels, open-cut tunnels and shed tunnels and self-produced sand and gravel 21.1%, track laying and turnout setting and erection of other concrete girders, steel girders, steel-pipe arches, steel structures and station buildings 58.6%, shield-driven tunnels 19.5%; heavy temporary works at 0.8 x the rate of the corresponding class of permanent works). That is, the labour cost base simultaneously determines the construction preliminaries and the on-costs.
Boundary exception (do not mis-classify): in works adjacent to in-service railway lines and in possession blocks on in-service lines, the labour costs of the safety officers, protection personnel, signalmen, telephone operators, watchmen etc. required for protection, and the repair and amortisation costs of protective equipment, are carried in the statutory work safety levy (commentary 3.7.5, 3.7.6) - in neither labour cost nor on-costs.
Applicable Boundaries
- Applies only to the preparation of design estimates (budgets) of capital railway construction projects (the 2024 TB 10801/TB 10811 system), not to other sectors or earlier editions (e.g. the 2017 edition) - under the old editions statutory levies were separate from labour cost; the 2024 edition has merged them into the all-in labour cost.
- The all-in daily labour rate is a packaged rate that must not be compared directly with market labour wages (three differences: the 8-hour workday basis, workers' own small tools and auxiliary materials, and quantities beyond the norms / outside 8 hours - see commentary 3.1.4).
- The base-period all-in daily labour rates already include the five insurances and one fund and must not be listed again in preparation; special regional allowances and plateau wage subsidies are carried separately as labour cost differentials.
- Protection personnel costs on in-service lines go to the statutory work safety levy and are outside the dividing rules of this card.
- The full table of on-cost percentage rates and the composition of construction preliminaries are in TB 10811-2024 Table 2.9.1 (not repeated here).
Further Reading
- TB 10801-2024 "Measures for Preparing Design Estimates (Budgets) of Capital Railway Construction Projects" clause 3.1 (labour cost), clause 3.9 (on-costs); commentary to clauses 3.1.4, 3.7.5, 3.7.6 and 3.9.2.
- TB 10811-2024 "Cost Norms for Design Estimates (Budgets) of Capital Railway Construction Projects" section 2.1 Table 2.1.1-1 (base-period all-in daily labour rates), Table 2.1.1-2 (plateau wage subsidy percentages), section 2.9 Table 2.9.1 (on-cost percentage rates).
- Further reading: composition, basis and rates of construction preliminaries and on-costs (card_2b8c2374); the difference between norm-based labour cost and actual wages (card_4fe6e8b2); how the costs of protection personnel and protection facilities for works on existing (in-service) lines are carried (card_904ccecb); the quota-manual system supporting railway works and the base-period price mechanism (card_252f964e); the dual track of percentage-rate and market-based build-up for overheads and profit (card_e14a146e).
Keywords
- labour cost
- on-costs (indirect costs)
- 综合工费
- overheads (company and site)
- 费用划分
- 五险一金
- 基期综合工费单价
- TB 10801
- TB 10811
- railway estimates and budgets (China Railway system)