Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Evidence preservation in arbitration (including construction contract disputes) where on-site evidence faces destruction: the referral channel from the arbitral institution to the court and its jurisdiction, application conditions and documentary requirements, security and application fees, reconsideration relief, the window before the contractor exits the site, and liability for wrongful preservation

Evidence preservation in arbitration cannot be applied for directly to the court: under Article 58 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision), where a party applies for evidence preservation, the arbitral institution shall submit the application to the primary people's court at the place where the evidence is located (in foreign-related arbitration it is submitted to the intermediate people's court under Article 79); where the situation is urgent and no arbitration application has yet been filed, pre-action evidence preservation may be sought under Article 58(2) of the Arbitration Law and Article 84(2) of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) from the court where the evidence is located, the court of the respondent's domicile or a court having jurisdiction. The written application must state the basic particulars of the evidence to be preserved, the reasons for preservation and the measures sought, and be filed before the expiry of the evidence-production time limit; security is determined comprehensively by the impact of the measures on the holder of the evidence, the value of the subject matter and the amount in dispute; the application fee is 30 yuan per case where no monetary amount is involved, capped at 5,000 yuan; a party aggrieved by the ruling may apply for reconsideration once, within five days, and the court reviews within ten days.

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025年修订)第五十五条、第五十六条、第五十七条、第五十八条、第七十九条、第八十一条、第八十二条
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第八十四条、第一百零三条、第一百零四条、第一百一十一条
  • 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(2022修正)第九十八条、第一百七十一条
  • 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》(2019修正)第二十条、第二十五条、第二十六条、第二十七条、第二十八条、第二十九条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十五条、第二十三条
  • 《诉讼费用交纳办法》(国务院令第481号)第十四条第(二)项

Topic Positioning

During an arbitration (typically a construction contract dispute), on-site evidence is about to be destroyed - the foundation pit and trenches are about to be backfilled, concealed parts are about to be covered, structures are about to be demolished, materials and plant are about to be cleared off site, construction records will be carried away on exit, and measurement-system data is about to be overwritten. How does a party start evidence preservation: which channel to use, who accepts the application, what the written application must contain, whether security is needed, how much the fee is, how to obtain relief if the application is dismissed, and the evidence-collection window before exit from the site.

Core Conclusions

1. Whether preservation is available: yes, but the route is 'party -> arbitral institution -> court', not a direct filing with the court. Article 58 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision): 'Where evidence may be destroyed or become difficult to obtain later, a party may apply for evidence preservation. Where a party applies for evidence preservation, the arbitral institution shall submit the party's application to the primary people's court at the place where the evidence is located, and the people's court shall deal with it in accordance with law and in a timely manner. Where the situation is urgent, a party to an arbitration agreement may, before applying for arbitration, apply to the people's court for evidence preservation in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China. Where a party applies for evidence preservation, the people's court shall deal with it in accordance with law and in a timely manner.' Foreign-related arbitration has a separate dedicated channel, Article 79: 'Where a party to foreign-related arbitration applies for evidence preservation, the arbitral institution shall submit the party's application to the intermediate people's court at the place where the evidence is located, and the people's court shall deal with it in accordance with law and in a timely manner.' Legislative rationale: the arbitral tribunal is only empowered to 'collect evidence on its own' and to 'request the relevant quarters to assist in accordance with law where necessary' (Article 55) and to organise the testing of evidence (Article 57); compulsory preservation measures such as seizure, detention, inspection and expert examination can only be ordered by a court, hence the dedicated 'referral by the arbitral institution' channel.

2. Three channels (selected by scenario)

  • Channel A, in arbitration (domestic): file with the arbitral institution seised of the case, which refers the application to the primary people's court at the place where the evidence is located (Article 58(1) of the Arbitration Law).
  • Channel B, in arbitration (foreign-related, including foreign-related maritime): referral to the intermediate people's court at the place where the evidence is located (Article 79). Where enterprises inside a pilot free trade zone or the Hainan Free Trade Port refer a foreign-related dispute under Article 82(2) to an ad hoc arbitral tribunal, and that tribunal submits a preservation application to the people's court, the same referral channel applies.
  • Channel C, before arbitration and urgent: apply directly for pre-action evidence preservation to 'the people's court at the place where the evidence is located, the people's court at the place of the respondent's domicile, or the people's court having jurisdiction over the case' (Article 58(2) of the Arbitration Law + Article 84(2) of the Civil Procedure Law, 2023 amendment: 'Where the situation is urgent and evidence may be destroyed or become difficult to obtain later, an interested party may, before bringing a suit or applying for arbitration, apply to the people's court at the place where the evidence is located, the people's court at the place of the respondent's domicile, or the people's court having jurisdiction over the case for preservation of evidence.'). The three venues are alternatives ('or'), so the nearest one can be chosen to save time.

3. Substantive conditions (a) the evidence 'may be destroyed or become difficult to obtain later' - typical construction scenarios: imminent backfilling, covering, demolition, site clearing, data overwriting, records being taken away; (b) relevance to the facts to be proven in the arbitration (quantities, quality, time for completion, price); (c) the subject of preservation must be specific and capable of enforcement, identifying the location, pile number, gridline, room number, batch and the medium of the evidence; a blanket application to 'preserve the entire site' will not do.

4. Application documents and time-limit requirements Article 25(1) of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Where a party or an interested party applies for evidence preservation under Article 81 of the Civil Procedure Law, the written application shall state the basic particulars of the evidence to be preserved, the reasons for applying for preservation, and the preservation measures to be adopted.' Paragraph 2: 'A party applying for evidence preservation under Article 81(1) of the Civil Procedure Law shall file the application with the people's court before the expiry of the evidence-production time limit.' (The 'Article 81' cited in that provision uses the numbering of the 2019 amendment; after the 2023 amendment it corresponds to Article 84; Article 98 of the Interpretation of the Civil Procedure Law accordingly reads 'a party applying for evidence preservation under Article 84(1) of the Civil Procedure Law may file a written application before the expiry of the evidence-production time limit'.) The preservation method is chosen by the court according to the circumstances; Article 27(2) of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Upon the party's application and in light of the specific circumstances, the people's court may preserve evidence by seizure, detention, audio recording, video recording, reproduction, expert examination, inspection and other methods, and shall make a written record.' Paragraph 3: 'So far as is consistent with the purpose of the evidence preservation, the people's court shall choose the preservation measure with the least impact on the interests of the holder of the evidence.' Practical document checklist: (1) the written application for evidence preservation (drafted to the three requirements above, itemised down to the seizure / detention / video recording / inspection methods proposed); (2) the arbitration agreement plus the arbitral institution's notice of acceptance (proving arbitration is under way; essential for Channels A and B); (3) evidence of the urgency of destruction (backfilling / demolition / clearing works programmes, notice to vacate, records of payment stoppage, site imagery, programme milestones); (4) a relevance statement (list of disputed items, the corresponding entries of the settlement submitted for review, the quantity take-off of completed works); (5) security documents; (6) standing documents and powers of attorney.

5. Security: not required in every case Article 26 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Where a party or an interested party applies for preservation measures that restrict the use or circulation of the subject matter, such as seizure or detention, or where the preservation may cause loss to the holder of the evidence, the people's court shall order the applicant to provide corresponding security. The form or amount of the security shall be determined by the people's court comprehensively on the basis of the impact of the preservation measures on the holder of the evidence, the value of the subject matter of preservation, and the amount of the claim in dispute between the parties or interested persons.' Article 98(2) of the Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, 2022 amendment): 'Where evidence preservation may cause loss to another person, the people's court shall order the applicant to provide corresponding security.' In other words: security is compelled only where restrictive measures such as seizure or detention are sought or where loss may be caused; the amount is set at the court's discretion by reference to the impact, the value of the subject matter and the amount in dispute, and need not cover the full amount of the claim; cash or a guarantee letter may be used.

6. Fees Item (2) of Article 14 of the Measures on Payment of Litigation Fees (State Council Decree No. 481): for an application for preservation measures, 'where the amount in question does not exceed 1,000 yuan or no amount is involved, 30 yuan per case; for the part from 1,000 yuan up to 100,000 yuan, 1%; for the part above 100,000 yuan, 0.5%; however, the fee paid by a party applying for preservation measures shall not exceed 5,000 yuan.'

7. Relief Article 111 of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment): 'A party aggrieved by a ruling on preservation or on advance execution may apply for reconsideration once. Execution of the ruling is not suspended during reconsideration.' Article 171 of Fa Shi [2015] No. 5: 'A party aggrieved by a ruling on preservation or on advance execution may, within five days of receiving the written ruling, apply to the people's court that made the ruling for reconsideration. The people's court shall review the application within ten days of receiving it. If the ruling is correct, the application shall be rejected; if the ruling is improper, it shall be varied or set aside.' Hard timing constraints (the other procedures of evidence preservation apply by reference to the preservation provisions of Chapter 9 of the Civil Procedure Law, see Article 84(3)): in urgent cases the court, having accepted the application, must rule within 48 hours, and where preservation is ordered it shall begin execution immediately (Article 103(3) for preservation during proceedings and Article 104(2) for pre-action preservation); if the applicant does not bring a suit or apply for arbitration in accordance with law within 30 days after pre-action preservation, the court shall lift the preservation (Article 104(3)) - pre-action preservation must therefore be dovetailed with the timetable for commencing arbitration.

8. The construction-specific window and its risks Article 15(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (Interpretation II on Construction Disputes): 'Where, before the contractor exits the site, a party applies for evidence preservation, the people's court shall deal with it in accordance with Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law.' After exit the site no longer exists; only the inventory-and-measurement fallback of a construction cost expert assessment remains, and probative force collapses. Article 23 of the same interpretation: 'This Interpretation comes into force on 30 June 2026. First-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect are governed by it.' Wrongful preservation carries liability in damages; Article 28 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Where an application for evidence preservation is wrongly made and causes property loss, if the party concerned requests the applicant to bear liability for compensation, the people's court shall support the request.' The scope of the application must be confined to the disputed items, avoiding over-broad sealing-up that disrupts the other side's normal construction.

Scope and Limits

  1. Confined to situations with an arbitration agreement and arbitration under way (or urgency before arbitration); where there is no arbitration agreement and court proceedings are intended, apply directly under Article 84(1) of the Civil Procedure Law (during proceedings) or paragraph 2 (before proceedings), unconstrained by the 'referral by the arbitral institution' channel.
  2. Evidence preservation only fixes 'the state of the evidence'; it cannot stop continuing demolition, backfilling or clearing as such - where suspension of works or a prohibition of specific conduct is needed, that preservation route must be assessed separately (Article 103(1) of the Civil Procedure Law on 'ordering it to perform a certain act or prohibiting it from performing a certain act'); the two differ in purpose and in documents and must be prepared separately.
  3. 'Relevance to the facts to be proven' is the crux of the court's discretion: where the application does not map 'what is preserved' onto 'what sum or what quality state it can prove', it is easily dismissed as insufficiently specific.
  4. Article 15(2) of Interpretation II applies to the post-termination, contractor-exit construction scenario and only to first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026; earlier cases are handled under the previous rules.
  5. Evidence preservation in foreign-related arbitration falls to the intermediate people's court, unlike the primary-court jurisdiction for domestic arbitration; getting the foreign-related characterisation wrong delays the referral.
  6. The currently effective version of the Arbitration Law is the 2025 revision; its article numbering differs from the old version, so the version must be checked when citing.

Further Reading

  • Arbitration Law of the People's Republic of China (2025 revision), Chapter 4: Article 55 (the tribunal collecting evidence on its own), Article 56 (expert appraisal of specialised questions), Article 57 (production and testing of evidence), Article 58 (evidence preservation); Chapter 7: Article 79 (foreign-related evidence preservation referred to the intermediate court), Article 81 (determination of the seat of arbitration), Article 82 (filing and preservation referral by ad hoc tribunals in the free trade zones and the free trade port), Articles 83-84 (setting aside and refusal of enforcement of foreign-related awards).
  • Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (2023 amendment): Article 84 (evidence preservation and application of Chapter 9 by reference), Article 103 (preservation during proceedings and conduct preservation; ruling within 48 hours), Article 104 (pre-action preservation, security, 30-day time limit for suing), Article 111 (one reconsideration).
  • Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (2022 amendment): Article 98 (written application before expiry of the evidence-production time limit; security where loss may be caused), Article 171 (reconsideration applied for within five days, reviewed within ten days).
  • Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Several Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure, Part 2 (investigation, collection and preservation of evidence): Article 20 (applying to the court for investigation and collection), Article 25 (requirements of the preservation application and time limit), Article 26 (security), Article 27 (preservation methods and the least-impact principle), Article 28 (liability to compensate for wrongful preservation), Article 29 (transfer of evidence preserved before suit to the court seised).
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation II on Construction Contract Disputes: Article 15 (handover of site and records after termination; evidence preservation before exit), Article 23 (effective date and transitional rules).
  • Measures on Payment of Litigation Fees (State Council Decree No. 481), Article 14(2) (banded preservation application fee and the 5,000 yuan cap).

Keywords

  • 证据保全
  • 仲裁证据保全
  • 仲裁机构转交
  • 证据所在地基层人民法院
  • 诉前证据保全
  • 证据保全担保
  • 退场前证据保全
  • 保全申请费