Reconsideration remedy against a property preservation ruling or a ruling dismissing a preservation application: apply for reconsideration once to the court that made the ruling within 5 days of service of the ruling; the court reviews within 10 days of receiving the application; execution of the ruling is not suspended during reconsideration
Where the preservation applicant or the person against whom preservation is sought is dissatisfied with a preservation ruling or with a ruling dismissing the preservation application, either may apply for reconsideration once to the people's court that made the ruling within 5 days of the date of service of the ruling, and the court must review the matter within 10 days of receiving the reconsideration application (Fa Shi [2016] No. 22, Article 25). Where reconsideration of a preservation ruling is well founded, the ruling is revoked or varied; where reconsideration of a ruling dismissing the application is well founded, the ruling is revoked and preservation measures are taken. Article 111 of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 Amendment) provides that a party dissatisfied with a preservation or advance execution ruling may apply for reconsideration once, and the ruling is not suspended from execution during reconsideration.
Applicable Codes
- 《最高人民法院关于人民法院办理财产保全案件若干问题的规定》(法释〔2016〕22号,2020修正)第二十五条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第一百一十一条、第一百零八条
Scope of this card
This card explains the remedy path in property preservation proceedings: when a party is dissatisfied with a preservation ruling or with a ruling dismissing a preservation application - to whom, within what time limit and how many times reconsideration may be sought, how long the court has to review it, and whether the ruling is suspended from execution during reconsideration.
Core conclusions
I. Text of the rule (Fa Shi [2016] No. 22, Article 25) 'Where the preservation applicant or the person against whom preservation is sought is dissatisfied with the preservation ruling or with the ruling dismissing the application, they may apply for reconsideration once to the people's court that made the ruling within 5 days of the date of service of the ruling. The people's court shall review the matter within 10 days of receiving the reconsideration application. Where reconsideration is sought against the preservation ruling, the people's court, upon review, shall rule to revoke or vary the ruling if the grounds are well founded, and shall rule to dismiss the reconsideration if the grounds are not well founded. Where reconsideration is sought against the ruling dismissing the application, the people's court, upon review, shall rule to revoke the dismissal and take preservation measures if the grounds are well founded, and shall rule to dismiss the reconsideration if the grounds are not well founded.'
II. The parallel rule in the Civil Procedure Law Article 111 of the Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 Amendment): 'Where a party is dissatisfied with a ruling on preservation or advance execution, the party may apply for reconsideration once. The ruling shall not be suspended from execution during the reconsideration.'
III. Six operational points
- Reconsideration is available only once; it is not an appeal and does not lead into second-instance proceedings.
- The application is made to the people's court that made the ruling, not to the next higher court.
- The time limit is 5 days from the date of service of the ruling, and it applies equally to the preservation applicant and the person against whom preservation is sought.
- The court's review period is 10 days from receipt of the reconsideration application.
- The ruling is not suspended from execution during reconsideration - property already seized or frozen is not released because a reconsideration application has been filed.
- The outcome depends on the type of ruling: for a preservation ruling - if the grounds are well founded the ruling is revoked or varied, otherwise the reconsideration is dismissed; for a ruling dismissing the application - if the grounds are well founded the ruling is revoked and preservation measures are taken, otherwise the reconsideration is dismissed.
Boundaries of application
- This article applies to preservation rulings and rulings dismissing preservation applications. Dissatisfaction with specific enforcement acts in enforcement proceedings, or objections raised by persons outside the proceedings, is governed by the specialised provisions of the enforcement part of the Civil Procedure Law on enforcement objections and reconsideration; the 5-day and 10-day limits of this article do not apply.
- Reconsideration is limited to one attempt; once reconsideration is upheld, no further reconsideration may be sought. The right to damages for wrongful preservation is unaffected and may be pursued separately under Article 108 of the Civil Procedure Law (where the application is wrongful, the applicant shall compensate the respondent for the losses caused by the preservation).
- The 5-day period runs from the date of service and is a fixed procedural period; once it lapses, the reconsideration remedy is lost. In practice, the service date should be checked on the day the ruling is received and the filing timetable planned backwards from it.
- The reconsideration application should address the grounds of the ruling (the claimed amount exceeding the scope, the determination of security, the identification of asset leads and the like) with written submissions and evidence; merely repeating the original application rarely succeeds.
Further reading
- Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues concerning the Handling of Property Preservation Cases by People's Courts (Fa Shi [2016] No. 22, amended 2020), Article 25 (who may seek reconsideration, the 5-day period, the 10-day review period, the outcomes)
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 Amendment), Article 111 (one reconsideration, no suspension of execution), Article 108 (compensation for wrongful preservation), Article 103 (48-hour emergency ruling and immediate execution)
Keywords
- 保全裁定复议
- 复议一次
- 五日内申请复议
- 十日内审查
- 法释〔2016〕22号第二十五条
- 驳回保全申请
- 不停止执行