Liability where the amount of a property preservation application exceeds the actual construction payment debt: fault-based compensation centred on 'erroneous application' under Article 108 of the Civil Procedure Law, quantification of the compensable scope, and the rules on security amounts, the duty to seek release, fines and detention for malicious preservation and criminal liability for false litigation, reconsideration relief and jurisdiction over damages actions
An application exceeding the underlying claim does not automatically attract liability, nor is compensation 'pound for pound' of the excess: under Article 108 of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision), 'where the application is erroneous, the applicant shall compensate the party preserved against for the losses caused by the preservation', applied as fault-based liability (Civil Code Article 1165), with compensation limited to the loss actually suffered from the excess preservation; but the portion of the preserved amount exceeding the scope of the claim violates Article 105 ('preservation is limited to the scope of the claim') and is generally found an 'erroneous application'. On security: for preservation during proceedings the security amount must not exceed 30% of the amount sought to be preserved (where the property preserved is the subject in dispute, not more than 30% of its value), and pre-suit preservation requires security equivalent to the amount sought (Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 Article 5). Applications made in collusion or by unilaterally fabricating the basic facts may additionally attract fines (up to RMB 100,000 for individuals; RMB 50,000 to 1,000,000 for entities), detention (up to 15 days), and where the crime of false litigation is made out, criminal liability under Article 307-A of the Criminal Law.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第一百零四条、第一百零五条、第一百零八条、第一百一十一条、第一百一十五条、第一百一十八条
- 法释〔2016〕22号《最高人民法院关于人民法院办理财产保全案件若干问题的规定》(2020修正)第三条、第五条、第七条、第十五条、第二十二条、第二十三条、第二十五条
- 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(2022修正)第二十七条、第一百六十六条、第一百七十一条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百八十八条、第五百九十一条、第一千一百六十五条
- 《中华人民共和国刑法》(2020修正)第三百零七条之一
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第三十九条
- 法释〔2004〕15号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事执行中查封、扣押、冻结财产的规定》(2020修正)第十九条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十一条、第十三条、第二十三条(2026年6月30日起施行)
- https://www.zhxzcourt.gov.cn/index.php/upload/upload/ewupload/index.php?do=announcement&ac=info&cid=3464
- http://zhxzcourt.gov.cn/index.php?ac=info&cid=3464&do=announcement
Scope
Where a contractor (or an arbitration claimant) applies for property preservation to recover the project price and the preserved amount exceeds the construction payment debt confirmed by the effective decision or by both parties, is the applicant liable, for what, for how much, and under what rules on security, release, malicious preservation and procedural relief. For risk assessment of pre-suit and in-suit preservation and arbitral preservation in construction disputes.
Core conclusions
1. Liability turns on 'erroneous application', not on paying back the whole excess.
Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) Article 108: 'Where the application is erroneous, the applicant shall compensate the party against whom preservation is granted for the losses suffered from the preservation.' The liability is tortious in nature with fault as its element; the claim rests on Article 1165 of the Civil Code: 'Where a person's fault infringes another's civil rights and interests and causes harm, tort liability arises. Where fault is presumed by law, the person bears tort liability if unable to prove the absence of fault.' Article 39(3) of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) says the same of arbitral preservation: 'Where the application is erroneous, the applicant shall compensate the party preserved against for the losses suffered from the preservation.'
2. The excess portion usually constitutes 'erroneous application' directly.
Article 105 of the Civil Procedure Law: 'Preservation is limited to the scope of the claim, or to property connected with the case.' The portion of the preserved amount exceeding the scope of the claim (or the actual value of the subject in dispute) lacks procedural basis, and in practice that portion is found erroneous under this Article alone; a reasonable estimate of the debt (settlement incomplete, the disputed amount evidenced) is not itself fault, so partial dismissal of the claim does not mean the application was erroneous. Typical fault patterns: inflating the preserved amount without basis, preserving at the original amount knowing payment has been received, refusing release after judgment or settlement, failing to apply promptly for release when circumstances change.
3. The compensable scope is actual loss; compensatory, not punitive.
Limited to losses directly suffered from the excess preservation, subject to causation and the mitigation rules: Article 591 of the Civil Code, 'After one party breaches, the other party shall take appropriate measures to prevent the aggravation of the loss; where it fails to take appropriate measures and the loss is aggravated, it may not claim compensation for the aggravated part.' The typical loss is the cost of occupation of funds frozen in excess; the customary judicial quantification is: loss on excess frozen funds approximately = (preserved amount - actual debt confirmed by the effective decision or by the parties) x the loan prime rate (LPR) for the corresponding period x days frozen / 365; the formula is common judicial practice, not a statutory computation, and must be proved item by item with the amount in the preservation ruling, the actual start and end dates of the freeze, and the LPR of the corresponding period. The limitation period is three years under Article 188 of the Civil Code, running from when the right-holder knew or should have known of the harm and of the obligor.
4. Security amounts and the form of security.
SPC Provisions on Several Issues concerning the Handling of Property Preservation Cases by the People's Courts (Fa Shi [2016] No. 22, 2020 revision) Article 5: 'Where the people's court, under Article 100 of the Civil Procedure Law, orders the preservation applicant to provide security, the security amount must not exceed 30% of the amount sought to be preserved; where the property sought to be preserved is the subject in dispute, the security amount must not exceed 30% of the value of that subject. An interested party applying for pre-suit preservation shall provide security equivalent to the amount sought to be preserved; in special circumstances the people's court may deal with the matter at its discretion. During the preservation, where the security provided by the applicant is insufficient to cover losses that may be caused to the party preserved against, the people's court may order additional security; on refusal, it may rule to release the preservation wholly or in part.' Article 7: where an insurer provides security through a preservation liability insurance policy, it shall issue to the court a letter of guarantee stating, among other things, that 'the insurer will compensate the party preserved against for losses caused by the preservation if the application is erroneous', together with supporting materials - having paid, the insurer may recover against the applicant under the policy.
5. The limits of the preservation measures themselves (correcting excessive seizure).
Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 Article 15: the people's court shall take seizure, detention or freezing measures corresponding to its preservation ruling; 'where the overall value of the land, housing or other immovable property available for preservation clearly exceeds the amount stated in the preservation ruling, the people's court shall seize, detain or freeze the corresponding value portion of the immovable, except where the immovable is indivisible in use or division would seriously diminish its value'; where bank account funds are frozen, the specific frozen amount shall be stated. The parallel rule in enforcement is Article 19 of the SPC Provisions on Seizure, Detention and Freezing of Property in Civil Enforcement (Fa Shi [2004] No. 15, 2020 revision): seizure, detention or freezing obviously exceeding the underlying amount is prohibited, and the excess must be released promptly once found (indivisible objects with no other property enforceable excepted).
6. The duty to seek release and compensation for failure to release in time.
Article 104 of the Civil Procedure Law governs pre-suit preservation: an interested party may, where the situation is urgent, apply before suing or applying for arbitration to the court at the place of the property preserved, at the respondent's domicile, or at the court with jurisdiction over the case; the applicant shall provide security, failing which the application is ruled away; the court must rule within 48 hours of accepting the application and execute immediately where preservation is ordered; 'where the applicant does not sue or apply for arbitration within 30 days after the people's court takes the preservation measures, the people's court shall release the preservation.' Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 Article 23 lists the six situations in which the applicant should promptly apply for release: (1) not suing or applying for arbitration within 30 days after pre-suit preservation measures are taken; (2) the arbitration institution refusing to accept the arbitral application, allowing its withdrawal, or treating it as withdrawn; (3) the arbitral claim or request dismissed by the arbitral award; (4) another people's court refusing to accept the suit, allowing withdrawal or treating it as withdrawn; (5) the suit or the claims dismissed by the effective decision of another people's court; (6) other situations in which the applicant should apply for release. On receiving a release application the court shall rule on release within 5 days, or within 48 hours in an urgent situation; 'where the applicant fails to apply promptly to the people's court for release, it shall compensate the party preserved against for the losses caused by the property preservation.' Article 166 of the SPC Interpretation on Application of the Civil Procedure Law (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, 2022 revision) lists the situations in which a preservation ruling shall be released: (1) erroneous preservation; (2) the applicant withdrawing the preservation application; (3) the applicant's suit or claims dismissed by the effective decision; (4) other situations in which the people's court considers release warranted; where a preservation measure implemented by registration is released, a notice of assistance in enforcement shall be sent to the registration authority. Reverse relief for the party preserved against: Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 Article 22 - in property disputes, where the party preserved against or a third party provides sufficient and effective security and requests release, the court shall rule to allow it; where the party preserved against requests release of preservation over property that is the subject in dispute, the applicant's consent is required.
7. Sanctions and criminal liability for malicious preservation.
Article 115 of the Civil Procedure Law: where parties collude in bad faith seeking, through litigation or mediation, to harm the interests of the state, the public or the lawful rights of others, the people's court shall reject their claim and may fine or detain them according to the gravity of the circumstances; where a crime is constituted, criminal liability is pursued in law; where a party unilaterally fabricates the basic facts of a civil case to sue, seeking to harm the interests of the state, the public or the lawful rights of others, the preceding paragraph applies. Article 118: fines on individuals up to RMB 100,000; fines on entities from RMB 50,000 to RMB 1,000,000; detention up to 15 days; a detained person is delivered by the court to the public security organ for custody, and where the person admits and corrects the error during detention, the court may decide on early release. Criminal Law (2020 revision) Article 307-A: instituting civil proceedings on fabricated facts that obstructs the judicial order or seriously infringes the lawful rights and interests of others carries up to three years of imprisonment, public surveillance or criminal detention, with a concurrent or sole fine; where the circumstances are serious, three to seven years of imprisonment with a fine; an entity committing the crime is punished twice over; where the unlawful possession of another's property or the evasion of lawful debts also constitutes another crime, the punishment is heavier.
8. Procedural relief and jurisdiction.
Reconsideration: Article 111 of the Civil Procedure Law - a party dissatisfied with a preservation or advance enforcement ruling may apply for reconsideration once; the ruling is not suspended during reconsideration. Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 171: apply within 5 days of receiving the written ruling to the people's court that made it; the court reviews within 10 days of receiving the reconsideration application, rejecting the application where the ruling is correct, or varying or revoking the original ruling where it is improper. Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 Article 25 further distinguishes the consequences of reconsideration against the preservation ruling and against a ruling rejecting the application (well-founded reconsideration leads respectively to revocation or variation, or to revocation plus preservation measures), and confirms the 5-day application period and the 10-day review period. Jurisdiction over damages actions: Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 27 - actions for losses caused to the respondent or interested parties where the applicant, after pre-suit preservation, fails to sue or apply for arbitration within the statutory period fall to the people's court that took the preservation measures; where the applicant sues or applies for arbitration within the statutory period, actions brought by the respondent or interested parties for preservation losses fall to the people's court accepting the suit or the court that took the preservation measures. The submission path for arbitral preservation: Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 Article 3 - during arbitration, a party applying for property preservation submits the application, the notice of acceptance of the arbitral case and other materials to the people's court through the arbitration institution, and the ruling is served on the parties with notice to the arbitration institution; Article 39 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) likewise provides that arbitral preservation applications are submitted by the arbitration institution to the people's court under the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Law.
9. Fixing the debt base (the prior step that decides whether there is an excess).
The benchmark for 'excess' is the 'scope of the claim', so the construction payment debt must first be fixed: on the basis of the contract, the settlement documents, the certified records and the payment vouchers, deduct item by item the payments received, the employer-supplied (free-issue) materials, the discounts given and the retention fallen due, and avoid stacking unfounded penalties, stoppage losses and interest into the preserved amount. On fixing the amount of the debt, reference may be made to Articles 11 and 13 of the SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12): Article 11 (Article 793(1) of the Civil Code - 'referring to the contract's provisions on the project price' covers the amount, the pricing method, the payment time, the adjustment method and the settlement method) and Article 13 (where the price is to be determined by the audit result or a government fiscal review conclusion, but the conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or clearly conflicts with the agreement in the contract, judicial appraisal is permitted; the reasonable period follows the agreement, and failing agreement is fixed by the court but must not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final account documents; where the contract does not provide that the price is determined by the audit result, the employer's request to determine the price by the audit result is not supported). Article 23 of that interpretation: effective 30 June 2026; first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted after that date apply it, and earlier SPC interpretations inconsistent with it yield to it - 30 June 2026 is the boundary, and first-instance cases accepted earlier do not apply it.
Boundaries of application
- Liability presupposes fault: an applicant who reasonably estimated the debt and applied at the disputed amount does not thereby stand in error merely because the eventually decided amount is lower; partial dismissal of the claims does not itself imply error; whether there was a reasonable basis at the time of application must be examined.
- Compensation is compensatory, limited to the losses actually suffered by the party preserved against from the excess preservation, less the part aggravated by its failure to mitigate in time (Article 591 of the Civil Code); punitive damages may not be claimed.
- Preservation within the scope of the claims, even if not upheld in full, generally attracts no liability; only the portion beyond the scope of the claims (Article 105 of the Civil Procedure Law), or preserved despite knowledge that it lacked basis, or not released after circumstances changed, falls within the compensable zone.
- Fines, detention and false-litigation criminality apply only to collusion and unilateral fabrication of basic facts; they run on a separate track from the civil compensation for 'erroneous application', parallel but not interchangeable.
- The 30% rule and the full-security rule address 'security ordered by the court' and are not a cap on liability; insufficient security only triggers additional security or release procedures, and liability is still computed on actual loss.
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies only to first-instance construction cases newly accepted after that date; check that boundary before citing its Articles 11 and 13 to fix the debt base. The Civil Procedure Law cited is the 2023 revision, Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 the 2020 revision, and the Arbitration Law the 2025 revision.
Further reading
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 revision) Article 104 (conditions for pre-suit preservation, security, the 48-hour ruling, the 30-day suit period), Article 105 (preservation limited to the scope of the claim), Article 108 (compensation for erroneous application), Article 111 (one reconsideration, no stay of execution), Article 115 (collusion and unilateral fabrication of facts), Article 118 (fines up to RMB 100,000 for individuals and RMB 50,000 to 1,000,000 for entities; detention up to 15 days).
- Fa Shi [2016] No. 22, SPC Provisions on Several Issues concerning the Handling of Property Preservation Cases by the People's Courts (2020 revision), Article 3 (submission of arbitral preservation), Article 5 (the 30% security amount and full security pre-suit), Article 7 (the guarantee letter for preservation liability insurance), Article 15 (seizure to the value stated in the ruling; specific amounts for account freezes), Article 22 (release on security provided by the party preserved against), Article 23 (the six situations requiring prompt release and liability for delay), Article 25 (the 5-day and 10-day reconsideration periods and the two outcomes).
- Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, SPC Interpretation on Application of the Civil Procedure Law (2022 revision), Article 27 (jurisdiction over preservation damages actions), Article 166 (the four situations requiring release), Article 171 (reconsideration periods and review).
- Civil Code of the PRC Article 1165 (fault liability), Article 188 (the three-year limitation and the 20-year outer limit), Article 591 (mitigation and reasonable expenses).
- Criminal Law of the PRC (2020 revision) Article 307-A (the crime of false litigation); Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 revision) Article 39 (arbitral preservation and compensation for erroneous applications).
- Fa Shi [2004] No. 15, SPC Provisions on Seizure, Detention and Freezing of Property in Civil Enforcement (2020 revision) Article 19 (no seizure obviously exceeding the amount; release of the excess).
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes, Articles 11, 13 and 23 (effective 30 June 2026; the boundary between old and new).
- Court pages (for checking the practical approach): https://www.zhxzcourt.gov.cn/index.php/upload/upload/ewupload/index.php?do=announcement&ac=info&cid=3464 ; http://zhxzcourt.gov.cn/index.php?ac=info&cid=3464&do=announcement
Keywords
- 财产保全
- 申请有错误
- 超额保全
- 保全损害赔偿
- 诉前财产保全担保
- 解除保全
- 虚假诉讼罪
- 保全复议
- 工程款债权