Rules on the amount of security for property preservation (full security before suit, no more than 30% of the amount claimed during suit, top-up of security), the banded calculation of the preservation application fee (CNY 30 / 1% / 0.5%, capped at CNY 5000), and the conditions for using property preservation liability insurance as security
Security and fees run on two tracks. (1) Amount of security - pre-suit property preservation requires security equivalent to the amount of preservation sought (courts may act at their discretion in special cases); in-suit preservation security is capped at 30% of the amount sought (where the property preserved is the subject matter in dispute, at 30% of its value); where security is insufficient the court may order a top-up, and refusal may lead to release or partial release of the preservation; security may take the form of property preservation liability insurance, with the insurer issuing a letter of guarantee stating that the insurer compensates the preserved party for losses from a wrong application. (2) Application fee - banded by the amount of property actually preserved: CNY 30 per case up to CNY 1000 or where no property amount is involved, 1% on the portion from CNY 1000 to CNY 100000, 0.5% on the portion above CNY 100000, capped at CNY 5000. The real cost pressure comes from the security tie-up rather than the application fee, so switching from pre-suit to in-suit preservation and from cash security to liability insurance are the main cost-saving routes.
Applicable Codes
- 中华人民共和国民事诉讼法(2023修正)第一百零三条、第一百零四条、第一百零五条、第一百零八条
- 法释〔2015〕5号 最高人民法院关于适用《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》的解释(2022修正)第一百五十二条
- 法释〔2016〕22号 最高人民法院关于人民法院办理财产保全案件若干问题的规定(2020修正)第一条、第五条、第七条、第八条、第二十三条
- 诉讼费用交纳办法(国务院令第481号)第十四条第(二)项、第二十九条、第三十八条
Positioning
What it costs to apply for property preservation and how much must be posted: the difference in security amounts between pre-suit and in-suit preservation (full amount versus no more than 30% of the amount claimed), the rules on written notice and top-up of security, the conditions for replacing cash security with property preservation liability insurance, and the banded calculation and cap of the preservation application fee.
Core conclusions
(1) Amount of security: full before suit, capped at 30% in suit
Article 152 of Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 (2022 amendment): 'Where the people's court, in adopting pre-suit or in-suit preservation measures under Articles 103 and 104 of the Civil Procedure Law, orders the interested party or the party to provide security, it shall notify them in writing. An interested party applying for pre-suit preservation shall provide security. One applying for pre-suit property preservation shall provide security equivalent to the amount of preservation sought; in special circumstances the people's court may act at its discretion. For pre-suit conduct preservation, the amount of security is decided by the people's court according to the circumstances of the case. During litigation, where the people's court adopts preservation measures on application or on its own authority, it shall decide according to the specific circumstances of the case whether the party must provide security and in what amount.'
Article 5 of Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 (2020 amendment) fixes the quantitative cap for in-suit security: 'Where the people's court orders an applicant for preservation to provide property preservation security under Article 100 of the Civil Procedure Law, the amount of security shall not exceed 30% of the amount of preservation sought; where the property applied to be preserved is the subject matter in dispute, the amount of security shall not exceed 30% of the value of the subject matter in dispute.' Paragraph 2 restates the pre-suit rule: 'An interested party applying for pre-suit property preservation shall provide security equivalent to the amount of preservation sought; in special circumstances the people's court may act at its discretion.' Paragraph 3 provides for dynamic adjustment: 'During the preservation, where the security provided by the applicant is insufficient to cover losses that may be caused to the preserved party, the people's court may order it to provide additional security; if it refuses, the court may rule to release or partially release the preservation.'
Key points: (1) pre-suit property preservation = full security (equivalent to the amount sought), which is the essential cost difference from the in-suit 'no more than 30%' - for the same claim the funds tied up before suit are roughly three times or more the in-suit level; (2) whether security is required in suit, and how much, is decided by the court according to the circumstances of the case; 30% is a ceiling, not a fixed rate; (3) where the property in dispute itself is preserved, the base becomes 30% of its value; (4) where the security is insufficient the court may order a top-up, and refusal leads to release or partial release.
(2) Replacing cash with insurance: property preservation liability insurance
Article 7 of Fa Shi [2016] No. 22: 'Where an insurer provides security for property preservation by concluding a property preservation liability insurance policy with the applicant, it shall issue a letter of guarantee to the people's court. The letter of guarantee shall state, among other things, that where the application for property preservation is wrong the insurer compensates the preserved party for the losses it suffered from the preservation, with the relevant evidence attached.' The policy itself does not replace the letter of guarantee: the insurer must separately issue a letter of guarantee stating 'where the application is wrong, the insurer compensates the preserved party for its losses', with supporting evidence attached. Premiums are priced by insurers according to risk, a market matter without statutory standard; in practice premiums often replace the occupation of large cash amounts or bank guarantees, but liability for wrongful preservation is not released by taking out insurance (Article 108 of the Civil Procedure Law: where the application is wrong, the applicant shall compensate the respondent for the losses caused by the preservation).
(3) Application fee: banded by the amount of property actually preserved, capped at CNY 5000
Article 14(2) of the Measures on Payment of Litigation Expenses (State Council Order No. 481), original text: 'For an application for preservation measures, the fee is paid according to the amount of property actually preserved under the following standards: where the amount of property does not exceed CNY 1000 or no property amount is involved, CNY 30 per case; for the part exceeding CNY 1000 up to CNY 100000, 1% is paid; for the part exceeding CNY 100000, 0.5% is paid; provided that the fee paid by a party applying for preservation measures shall not exceed CNY 5000 at most.'
Calculation: the base is 'the amount of property actually preserved', not the amount sought; the bands accumulate progressively (CNY 30 within CNY 1000; 1% on the CNY 1000 to 100000 portion; 0.5% on the portion above CNY 100000); whatever the amount in dispute, the ceiling is CNY 5000 (no further increase beyond). The application fee is thus a low-cost procedural outlay; the real cost pressure is the security tie-up - the economic rationale for the two switches, from pre-suit to in-suit preservation and from cash security to liability insurance.
Boundaries of application
- The 30% security cap applies only to property preservation security ordered under Article 103 of the Civil Procedure Law (in suit); pre-suit preservation is not subject to 30% and remains full security equivalent to the amount sought (special cases at the court's discretion, a case-by-case matter not to be presumed).
- For pre-suit conduct preservation the amount of security is decided by the court according to the circumstances of the case and is not bound by 'equivalent to the amount of preservation sought'.
- The application fee is computed on 'the amount of property actually preserved'; property not actually frozen or taken into control is not counted; the CNY 5000 cap is a statutory ceiling and local or case-level surcharges on preservation fees are impermissible.
- Liability insurance security does not change who answers for wrongful preservation: the insurer compensates under the letter of guarantee, while the applicant's own fault liability remains under Article 108 of the Civil Procedure Law and Article 23 of Fa Shi [2016] No. 22 (compensation for failing to apply in time for release of the preservation).
- The form of security (cash, bank guarantee, liability insurance policy plus letter of guarantee) must meet the specific requirements of the accepting court, and information on the security assets or proof of creditworthiness must be submitted together with the application (Article 1(5) of Fa Shi [2016] No. 22).
- All amounts in this section are statutory standards or rates and include no project-specific security amounts or premium quotations.
Further reading
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment), Article 103 (in-suit preservation and security), Article 104 (pre-suit preservation: 'the applicant shall provide security; where no security is provided, the application is ruled dismissed'), Article 108 (compensation for wrongful preservation).
- Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, the SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (2022 amendment), Article 152 (written notice; full security before suit; in-suit discretion).
- Fa Shi [2016] No. 22, the SPC Provisions on Several Issues concerning the Handling of Property Preservation Cases by People's Courts (2020 amendment), Article 5 (30% cap and top-up of security), Article 7 (letter of guarantee under liability insurance), Article 1 (security asset information and reasons for exemption in the application), Article 23 (liability for failing to release the preservation in time).
- Measures on Payment of Litigation Expenses (State Council Order No. 481), Article 14(2) (bands of the preservation application fee and the CNY 5000 cap).
- Procedural steps (jurisdiction, materials, the 48-hour ruling, reconsideration, the 30-day deadline to sue, the switch from pre-suit to in-suit and the duration of preservation): see the procedural cards on pre-suit property preservation.
Keywords
- 财产保全 担保
- 保全担保 30%
- 诉前保全 全额担保
- 独立保函
- 保全责任保险
- 保全申请费
- 封顶5000元
- 封顶临界点