Handling procedures when expert demonstration of a special scheme yields "fail" or "pass after modification", and penalties for violating the demonstration procedure
Per Article 13 of MOHURD Order No. 37 (Order No. 47 amendment): demonstration conclusions are only three kinds — pass, pass after modification, fail — and a consensus opinion must be formed. "Pass after modification" -> after modifying the scheme per the demonstration report, re-perform the Article 11 sign-off procedure (contractor technical responsible person signs and seals + chief supervision engineer reviews and signs); "fail" -> after modifying the scheme, a new expert demonstration must be organized (a new meeting), and after passing, sign-off must still be completed before implementation. Implementation is strictly forbidden before passing or completing sign-off. Violations are punished per Article 34: order correction within a time limit, a fine of RMB 10,000-30,000, suspension of the work safety permit for 30 days, and fines of RMB 1,000-5,000 on directly responsible persons.
Applicable Codes
- 《危险性较大的分部分项工程安全管理规定》(住建部令第37号,住建部令第47号修正)第十一条、第十二条、第十三条、第三十四条
- 建办质〔2018〕31号
Topic Positioning
This card covers the statutory handling path after the expert panel review of a dedicated method statement for high-risk works concludes "pass after modification" or "fail", the procedural red line of the "consensus opinion" in the expert review report, and the administrative penalties for violating the review procedure (Article 34 of MOHURD Order No. 37) — a compliance guide for the step following the expert panel review.
Core Conclusions
Per Article 13 of MOHURD Order No. 37 (2019 Order No. 47 amendment):
- Only three conclusions are possible — pass, pass after modification, fail — and a "consensus opinion" must be formed and confirmed by the experts' signatures; an expert review report without a consensus opinion must be re-submitted to a new expert panel review.
- "Pass after modification": after the contractor revises and improves the method statement per the expert review report, it must re-perform the Article 11 procedure — the contractor's technical responsible person reviews and signs with the entity's official seal affixed, and the Engineer (chief supervising engineer under China's supervision regime) reviews and signs with the practice seal affixed — before implementation.
- "Fail": after revising the method statement, the contractor must organize a new expert panel review (a new review meeting; experts must still be selected from the local housing and construction authority's expert database, no fewer than 5, with interested parties recused), and after it passes, the Article 11 sign-off procedure must still be completed before implementation.
- Before passing or completing sign-off, implementation of that sub-divisional works involving significant hazards is strictly prohibited.
- Penalties (Article 34): a contractor committing any of the following is ordered to correct within a time limit, fined RMB 10,000-30,000, with its work safety permit suspended for 30 days; the directly responsible manager and other directly responsible persons are fined RMB 1,000-5,000: (1) failing to hold an expert panel review of the dedicated method statement for high-risk works of sub-divisional works involving significant hazards that exceed a certain scale; (2) failing to revise such method statement per the expert review report, or failing to re-organize the expert panel review as required; (3) failing to construct strictly per the method statement, or modifying the method statement without authorization.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to the expert panel review stage for dedicated method statements for sub-divisional works involving significant hazards that exceed a certain scale (ordinary sub-divisional works involving significant hazards require only the dual sign-off, no expert panel review); where a subcontractor prepares the method statement, the technical responsible persons of both the main (general) contracting unit and the subcontractor must jointly review, sign and seal it. Where "pass after modification" involves major modifications, a new expert panel review should be organized. Provincial rules may be stricter (e.g., Shaanxi T/XCIA 3-2023 Clause 5.3.8). The Article 34 penalties target the three categories of review-related violations for sub-divisional works involving significant hazards "exceeding a certain scale", and the penalized parties are the contractor and its directly responsible managers and other directly responsible persons.
Further Reading
MOHURD Order No. 37 (Order No. 47 amendment) Articles 11, 12, 13 and 34; Jianban Zhi [2018] No. 31 Article 3 (expert review meeting participants); T/XCIA 3-2023 Clauses 5.3.3 and 5.3.8; DB37/T 5164-2020 Clause 4.4.6 (full process: method statement preparation -> review -> expert panel review -> revision -> approval -> briefing -> implementation -> inspection -> acceptance -> archiving).
Keywords
- 专家论证未通过
- dedicated method statement for high-risk works
- sub-divisional works involving significant hazards
- 修改后通过
- 重新组织专家论证
- MOHURD Decree No. 37
- 安全生产许可证暂扣
- 第三十四条罚则