Selecting the contract pricing form when material prices fluctuate sharply: the hybrid mode of fixed unit rate + price adjustment clauses
With sharp fluctuations, neither a pure fixed price (quotes carry risk premiums, disputes brew) nor cost-plus (cost out of control) fits; choose "fixed unit rate + adjustable-price clauses": base price (28 days before the tender deadline, i.e. the FIDIC Base Date) + risk band (no-adjustment tolerance; beyond 5% triggers adjustment absent agreement) + adjustment method (index-based formula adjustment / adjustment based on published price information) written into the contract; price differences carry value added tax (VAT) only, no management fee or profit. Contract prices have only three statutory forms: fixed, adjustable, and cost-plus (Construction Ministry Order No. 107, Article 12).
Applicable Codes
- 建设部令第107号 建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法 第十二条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.3.1/3.3.5/8.7.2~8.7.6条及App. A、App. G
- GB/T 50875-2013 工程造价术语标准 第3.3.6~3.3.8条
Topic Positioning
Answers "with sharply fluctuating material prices, choose a fixed or floating price contract", giving the decision framework — with sharp fluctuations the "fixed unit rate + price adjustment clause" hybrid is recommended — and explaining the defects of pure fixed price and cost-plus.
Core Conclusions
"Fixed vs floating" is not a binary choice: per Article 12 of Construction Ministry Order No. 107, contract prices take only three statutory forms — fixed, adjustable, and cost-plus. With sharp fluctuations the optimum is "fixed unit rate + adjustable-price clauses": ① all-in unit rates fixed, principal materials adjusted per the agreed risk band; ② the base price takes the published price information (government guidance prices) / market price 28 days before the tender deadline (for non-tendered works, 28 days before contract signing), with the source written into the tender documents and contract; ③ the contractually agreed risk band takes precedence — absent agreement, fluctuations beyond 5% trigger adjustment; within the risk band the contractor bears it, beyond it adjust to actuals; ④ the adjustment method is one of two: index-based (formula) adjustment or adjustment based on published price information; ⑤ the list of adjustable materials fills the schedule of price-adjustable key materials as a contract annex; ⑥ price differences carry value added tax (VAT) only, no management fee or profit; construction consumables, preliminaries, and small tools are not adjusted for price changes. A pure fixed price makes the contractor's quote carry a risk premium and breeds "low-price win, mid-course wrangling" disputes; cost-plus loses cost control and is limited to emergency/rescue and similar special works.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to choosing pricing methods and designing adjustment clauses in employer-contractor pricing on a bill of quantities (BOQ) basis. With small fluctuations and short durations (about ≤1 year), a fixed price works directly; with extreme unforeseeable fluctuations consider cost-plus; other contract agreements prevail. Adjustment is not the derivation of new (built-up) rates — only labour/material/machinery price differences + VAT, with adjustment periods defined; for abnormal, unforeseeable fluctuations making performance obviously unfair, share per Clause 8.7.3 by negotiation.
Further Reading
Construction Ministry Order No. 107, Article 12; GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 3.3.1, 3.3.5, 8.7.2–8.7.6, Appendix A, Appendix G Tables G.2.1-1/-2; GB/T 50875-2013 Clauses 3.3.6–3.3.8. The four adjustment elements and the adjustment channels for lump-sum contracts are detailed in related special cards.
Keywords
- 固定价
- 可调价
- 浮动价
- 合同计价方式
- material price adjustment
- risk band (no-adjustment tolerance, e.g. ±5%)
- 成本加酬金
- 固定单价