Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Judging double counting between masonry scaffolds and finishing scaffolds: exclusivity between the comprehensive and individual scaffold bases, position exclusivity (birdcage scaffold versus wall finish scaffold), the 3.60m height boundary, and one quota line item only where masonry, plastering and coating on the same wall share one scaffold

Non-duplication is judged on four exclusivity lines only: (1) basis exclusivity - wherever gross floor area can be calculated, the comprehensive scaffold applies, and it already covers 'external wall masonry and external wall finishes' and 'internal wall masonry, internal wall and ceiling finishes within 3.6m'; within that scope no interior scaffold or interior wall finish scaffold may be billed again; only works unsuited to the comprehensive scaffold (separately let finishes packages included) go to individual scaffolds. (2) Position exclusivity - 'where the storey height exceeds 3.60m and the ceiling requires plastering, painting, suspended ceilings or the like, a birdcage scaffold may be added and no wall finish scaffold is measured separately'; once a birdcage scaffold is measured for a space, its internal wall finishes attract only a scaffold alteration charge or no further scaffold. (3) Height boundary at 3.60m, but the masonry test is 'from the designed indoor floor level to the soffit (or mid-height of the gable)' while the finishes test is 'the internal wall finish height'; the two must not be mixed; above 3.60m additional quota line items apply to the excess only (masonry to single-row/double-row scaffolds, plastering to the interior wall finish scaffold). (4) Measurement is by scaffold area, not by trade count - interior scaffolds and interior wall finish scaffolds are both measured on the vertical projected area of the wall face; where masonry, plastering and coating on the same wall share one scaffold, only one quota line item is billed and it may not be billed once per trade; under the BOQ basis scaffolds up to 3.6m are not listed as separate preliminary items, their cost already sitting in the all-in unit rates of the divisional and sub-divisional work items (GB/T 50860-2024 clause 4.3.3).

Applicable Codes

  • TB/T 10831-2024 · Budget Quota of Railway Engineering (Volume 10: Housing Works) 册说明四、五、六
  • GB/T 50860-2024 · Standard for Measurement of Quantities of Structures Works 第4.3.3条
  • GB/T 50854-2024 · Standard for measurement of building construction and fitting out works App. R
  • 湖南 2025《房屋建筑与装饰工程消耗量标准》第十八章 脚手架工程
  • 陕西《新编消耗量定额》(征求意见稿)脚手架章
  • 江苏 2026 版《建筑与装饰工程消耗量定额》脚手架章
  • SJG 111.2-2022 · Consumption Standard for Urban Utility Tunnel Works (Volume 2: Utility Tunnel Architectural and Decoration Works) (Shenzhen) 第8.1.4条
  • SJG 77-2020 · Standard for Division of Work Items and Measures Items in Cost Documents of Building Projects (Shenzhen) 第5.10.2条

Scope and purpose

This card settles one of the most common double counts in pricing and review: on the same wall or in the same space, which single quota line item applies - the masonry scaffold or the finishing scaffold (internal plastering and finishes, coating, ceilings, suspended cradles). It gives four exclusivity tests (basis, position, height, measurement by scaffold area), a 3.60m boundary decision table, the billing sequence where masonry, plastering and coating share one wall, and the negative 'no double counting' conclusion. The lead source is the volume notes of TB/T 10831-2024, Railway Works Budget Quota Manual, Volume 10: Building Works, checked against the Hunan 2025 edition, the new Shaanxi draft (consultation draft), the Jiangsu 2026 consumption standard, GB/T 50860-2024 and SJG 111.2-2022.

Core conclusions

1. Test 1: basis exclusivity - comprehensive scaffold or individual scaffolds, never both for the same position

  • 'Wherever gross floor area can be calculated, the comprehensive scaffold line items apply' (Hunan 2025 edition, chapter 18); 'works unsuited to the comprehensive scaffold may be priced under the corresponding individual scaffold items' (TB/T 10831-2024 volume note 5; Hunan the same).
  • What the comprehensive scaffold 'comprehensively' covers (Hunan original text): (1) scaffolds for external wall masonry and external wall finishes; (2) scaffolds for internal wall masonry and for internal wall and ceiling finishes within 3.6m; (3) scaffolds within the vertically enclosed safety netting for member formwork, concrete pouring, member erection, access ramps, hoist masts for vertical transport, loading platforms and construction safety protection; (4) its safety-provision content covers scaffold costs relating to the building itself within the vertical enclosure of the external scaffold. Not included: (1) protection costs not relating to the building itself, such as covered walkways above footpaths, temporary cantilevered scaffolds, personnel crossings and protective frames over machinery; (2) scaffolds to roof frames and to qilou arcades that do not count towards gross floor area.
  • The Shaanxi consultation draft reads: 'the comprehensive scaffold covers external wall masonry and external wall finishes, internal wall masonry and concrete-pouring scaffolds within 3.6m, and internal wall and ceiling finish scaffolds; where the storey height exceeds 3.6m, the excess takes additional corresponding line items, any amount under 1m counting as 1m' - once the comprehensive scaffold is billed on floor area, the masonry and finish scaffold content within 3.6m is not billed again; only the excess takes extra items.
  • Where individual scaffolds apply (Jiangsu 2026 edition): single-storey buildings with eaves above 20m, multi- (or single-) storey industrial buildings, warehouses, free-standing exhibition halls, stadiums, theatres, auditoria, canteens, boiler houses, roof frames above 3.60m, other structures, and separately let finishes packages; all other unit works follow the comprehensive scaffold line items.

2. Test 2: position exclusivity - birdcage scaffold versus wall finish scaffold, external scaffold versus plastering scaffold, never both

  • TB/T 10831-2024 volume note 4(3), original text: 'Where the storey height exceeds 3.60m and the ceiling requires plastering, painting, suspended ceilings or the like, a birdcage scaffold may be added and no wall finish scaffold is measured separately.'
  • Hunan: 'wherever a birdcage scaffold has been measured indoors, no finish scaffold is measured for the internal wall finishes; only a scaffold alteration charge is added on the vertical projected area of the wall face' (the alteration charge as fixed by the local quota manual); it also provides that 'where internal walls, column faces and the ceiling are all finished and the ceiling height exceeds 3.6m, birdcage scaffold costs are measured'.
  • Jiangsu 2026 edition: 'where the clear indoor height (basements included) exceeds 3.60m and the ceiling requires plastering (nailed ceilings included), the birdcage scaffold is measured, and no further scaffold is measured for the internal wall plastering; where the ceiling is not plastered (nailed ceilings included), the plastering scaffold is measured on the vertical projected area of the wall face'; the measurement rules add: 'where a birdcage scaffold is available for reuse, no plastering scaffold is measured for wall, column or beam faces'.
  • On the external side: 'the external scaffold already includes ramps, loading platforms and guard rails' (TB/T 10831-2024 volume note 5.2) and must not be billed again; Jiangsu: 'the external wall scaffold includes the plastering scaffold for one face; the plastering scaffold for the other face may be measured' - the external scaffold already carries one face of plastering, and only the other face may be billed separately.

3. Test 3: height boundary 3.60m, but masonry and finishes use two different height tests (the most error-prone point)

Position / trade Height test Billing up to 3.60m Billing above 3.60m
Internal wall masonry From the designed indoor floor level to the soffit (or mid-height of the gable) Covered by the comprehensive scaffold (within 3.6m); under the individual basis the interior scaffold applies, measured on the vertical projected wall area Excess priced with additional items: Shaanxi 'where the masonry height is beyond 3.6m, the single-row external scaffold line item applies', brick/block internal walls above 8m take the double-row item; Jiangsu 'masonry up to 3.60m high uses the interior scaffold; above 3.60m the external scaffold is used'; railway practice prices concrete walls poured indoors above 3.60m at the single-row scaffold quota x0.3, free-standing columns and single (continuous) beams at double-row external scaffold x0.3, and floor slabs at birdcage scaffold x0.30
Internal wall plastering / finishes Internal wall finish height Covered by the comprehensive scaffold (internal wall finishes within 3.6m); under the individual basis Shaanxi bills the interior scaffold, Jiangsu 'plastering up to 3.60m ... uses the plastering scaffold within 3.60m' 'Where the internal wall finish height is beyond 3.60m, the interior wall finish scaffold line item applies' (TB/T 10831-2024 note 4(2); Shaanxi item 4 the same); Jiangsu applies 'the corresponding internal wall finish scaffold line item' to wall finishes beyond 3.60m
Coating (distempering, painting) Follows the plastering height Billed once with the plastering scaffold, not listed separately Jiangsu: distempering and painting on wall, column and beam faces at the corresponding plastering scaffold line item x0.10; where the clear indoor ceiling height exceeds 3.60m, pointing, distempering and painting under slabs at the corresponding birdcage scaffold line item x0.10
Ceiling plastering / finishes From the indoor floor level to the ceiling face (soffit of the roof slab) Covered by the comprehensive scaffold (ceiling finishes within 3.6m); under the individual basis Jiangsu measures on the plastered ceiling face Birdcage scaffold (basic lift plus additional lifts); Jiangsu for suspended ceilings 'where the clear height of the suspended ceiling finish is within 3.60m but the connection points of hangers to floors exceed 3.60m, the corresponding birdcage scaffold line item multiplied by coefficient 0.60 applies'
Masonry and walls not plastered, only fully skimmed with putty Same test as plastering Jiangsu: 'where ceiling, columns, beams and wall faces are not plastered but fully skimmed with putty, the scaffold follows the plastering scaffold' As above

4. Test 4: measured by scaffold area, not by trade count - one line item per wall face

  • Measurement wording (TB/T 10831-2024 volume note 6(III)): 'the interior scaffold is measured on the vertical projected area of the wall face'; 'the interior wall finish scaffold is measured on the vertical projected area of the internal wall face, with no deduction for door and window openings'; 'the birdcage scaffold is measured on the clear indoor area'; the Hunan birdcage scaffold 'is measured on the actual horizontal projected area erected, with no deduction for attached columns and columns'; the Shaanxi mobile scaffold 'is measured on the clear indoor floor area, with no deduction for columns, piers and partition walls'.
  • Hence the negative conclusion: where one wall face is first built in masonry, then plastered, then coated, the scaffold is still one assembly and only one scaffold quota line item is billed on the vertical projected area of that face; it must not be billed once for each of the masonry, plastering and coating trades, nor may an internal wall plastering scaffold up to 3.6m be billed after the masonry scaffold (interior or external, the external already carrying one face of plastering). Where the main-works external scaffold is reused in the finishes stage with altered lift heights as an external finish scaffold, Hunan adds only a scaffold alteration charge on the vertical projected area of the external wall face, without billing a separate external finish scaffold.

5. Why simple/plastering scaffolds within 3.60m are 'not billed separately'

  • BOQ basis: GB/T 50860-2024, the quantity take-off standard for structures works, clause 4.3.3, original text - 'the preliminary items in Appendix C of this standard do not include scaffolds erected up to 3.6m high. The cost of scaffolds erected up to 3.6m high shall be allowed for in the all-in unit rate of the corresponding divisional and sub-divisional BOQ items.' That is, scaffolds up to 3.6m are already amortised into the all-in unit rates (labour included) of the masonry, plastering and other work sections, and are not listed as separate preliminary items.
  • Quota basis: where the comprehensive scaffold route is taken, internal wall masonry and finish scaffolds within 3.6m are already inside it and not billed again; under the individual route (works unsuited to the comprehensive scaffold, separately let finishes packages), plastering up to 3.60m may still take the 'plastering scaffold within 3.60m' line item, but only once in one place.
  • Boundary between mobile scaffolds and birdcage scaffolds (SJG 111.2-2022 clause 8.1.4): 'the mobile scaffold suits corridor finishes within 3.6m'; 'the birdcage scaffold line item suits ceiling finish works above 3.6m in height where the scaffold stays in use no more than 30d; above 5.2m each extra 1.2m adds one increment charge, any extra under 0.6m not counted; additional lifts of the birdcage scaffold = (storey height - 5.2m) / 1.2m; where the time in use exceeds 30 days, the relevant line items of the current Shenzhen Consumption Quota Manual for Finishes Works apply'. The railway birdcage scaffold uses the same basis: 3.60~5.20m bills the basic lift, above 5.20m each extra 1.20m bills one additional lift, and any amount under 0.60m counts as one additional lift x coefficient 0.50.

Applicability limits

  • 3.60m is the boundary in most building-works systems (railway buildings included), but not a universal boundary for birdcage-scaffold lift increments: the Jiangsu 2026 edition bills the basic lift up to 8m and one extra lift per 2m above 8m, unlike the 5.2m plus 1.2m basis of the railway, Shaanxi and Hunan manuals; values must follow the quota manual in force for the project.
  • The comprehensive scaffold presupposes that gross floor area can be calculated; roof frames, qilou arcades excluded from gross floor area, deep foundations and heavy equipment foundations - parts that cannot or should not be billed on floor area - go to individual scaffolds.
  • 'Comprehensive scaffolds or integral lifting scaffolds that exceed the scale threshold for relatively high safety risks settle according to the dedicated method statement' (Hunan); the banded tests in this card do not apply to them.
  • The railway practice of pricing concrete walls, free-standing columns, single (continuous) beams and floor slabs above 3.60m at x0.3 coefficients is a concrete-pouring scaffold, a different use from masonry and finish scaffolds; do not conflate them.
  • The new Shaanxi consumption quota manual reflects the consultation draft and may change on formal issue; local and sector quota manuals differ in coefficients and lift steps. This card gives the logic for preventing double counting and cannot replace item-by-item checking of the chapter notes and measurement rules of the local quota manual.

Further reading

  • TB/T 10831-2024, Railway Works Budget Quota Manual, Volume 10: Building Works, volume notes 4(2)(3), 5 (individual scaffolds) and 6(III)3~8 (measurement rules for interior scaffolds, birdcage scaffolds and interior wall finish scaffolds); section 4, scaffold works, item II 'individual scaffolds', sub-item (IV) 'interior wall finish scaffolds', line items FY-446 (3.6m~6m), FY-447 (up to 10m) and FY-448 (up to 20m), all per 100m2.
  • Hunan 2025, Consumption Standard for Building and Decoration Works, chapter 18, scaffold works (what the comprehensive scaffold includes and excludes, finish scaffolds, birdcage scaffold measurement and alteration-charge rules).
  • New Shaanxi consumption quota manual, consultation draft, scaffold chapter (scope of the comprehensive scaffold, individual scaffold items 3) and 4), measurement rules).
  • Jiangsu 2026 edition, Consumption Quota Manual for Building and Decoration Works, scaffold chapter notes 1~17 and the measurement rules.
  • GB/T 50860-2024 clause 4.3.3; GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix R (scaffold covering all scaffolds, including those erected as the codes require); SJG 111.2-2022 clause 8.1.4; SJG 77-2020 clause 5.10.2 (preliminaries for fine-decoration works should include scaffolds and protection of completed works, with the interface split fixed by the compiler).

Keywords

Cited By