Direction-specific base rules in the price adjustment method based on published price information when the contractor's tender price deviates from the base price (GB/T 50500-2024 Annex A.2.4, corresponding to Section 9.7 of the superseded GB 50500-2013): rises judge on the higher of the two prices, falls on the lower, a two-way disadvantage that blocks arbitrage, with the selection boundary against the Annex A.1 index method
Under GB/T 50500-2024 Annex A.2.4, the published-price-information adjustment applies a direction-specific base: the base for upward adjustment (price rise) is the higher of the base price C0 and the tender price P, and the base for downward adjustment (price fall) is the lower of the two. Hence when the contractor's price is below the base price (P < C0), rises are judged on the base price C0 and falls on the tender price P; when the price is above the base price (P > C0) the reverse applies; when the price equals the base price, both directions are judged on C0. Only the portion crossing the risk band threshold is adjusted as actually incurred; below the threshold nothing is adjusted; and the price differential carries VAT only, with no overheads or profit (3.3.5).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 App. A.2.4(价格信息调差法 报价偏离基准价的涨跌幅判定基数)
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.2.1(价差公式与基准价、计量周期价格、数量、风险幅度系数定义)
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.2.3(计量周期多个市场价格的取定方法)
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.2.5(发包人认定采购价格的核对确认与逾期视为认可)
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.1.1、A.1.6(价格指数调差法公式与基准日价格指数)
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.3.5条、第8.7.2条、第8.7.4条、第8.7.6条
- GB/T 50500-2024 App. G Table G.2.1-1/Table G.2.1-2
What This Card Covers
This card addresses the most error-prone step in the price adjustment method based on published price information (GB/T 50500-2024 Annex A.2): when the contractor's tendered unit price differs from the base price, which price serves as the judgement base and threshold line for the rise and fall directions respectively. The rule comes from Annex A.2.4 (the counterpart in the superseded GB 50500-2013 Code for Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities sat in Section 9.7, 'Changes in Costs'; that edition has been replaced by GB/T 50500-2024), and its core is an anti-arbitrage rule of 'direction-specific base plus two-way disadvantage'. The card gives only the judgement conditions, without worked numerical examples.
Core Conclusions
1. Original clause text (Annex A.2.4)
Where the base price is the published price information issued by the government construction cost administration 28 days before the tender submission deadline (for non-tendered works, 28 days before the contract signing date) and the current market price is the published price information issued for the measurement period, price changes of price-adjustable factors shall adjust the contract price in accordance with Table G.2.1-1 of Annex G of this standard provided by the employer, within the risk range agreed by the employer and the contractor, as follows: 1 Where the unit rate of a price-adjustable factor in the contractor's tender is lower than the base price, and the rise of the unit rate published by the government construction cost administration for the measurement period, judged on the base price, exceeds the risk band value agreed in the contract, or the fall of the material unit rate, judged on the tender price, exceeds the risk band value agreed in the contract, the excess portion shall be adjusted as actually incurred; 2 Where the unit rate of a price-adjustable factor in the contractor's tender is higher than the base price, and the fall of the unit rate published by the government construction cost administration for the measurement period, judged on the base price, exceeds the risk band value agreed in the contract, or the rise of the material unit rate, judged on the tender price, exceeds the risk band value agreed in the contract, the excess portion shall be adjusted as actually incurred; 3 Where the unit rate of a price-adjustable factor in the contractor's tender equals the base price, and the rise or fall of the unit rate published by the government construction cost administration for the measurement period, judged on the base price, exceeds the risk band value agreed in the contract, the excess portion shall be adjusted as actually incurred.
Symbol definitions (Annex A.2.1): C0 is the base price, being the market price 28 days before the tender submission deadline (for non-tendered works, 28 days before the contract signing date); Ci is the market price of the measurement period; Q is the quantity of the adjustable factor; r is the risk band coefficient, 'positive when delta C exceeds 0 and negative when delta C is below 0'.
2. Judgement table for the two-direction adjustment rules when the tender price deviates from the base price (judgement conditions only)
Let P = the tendered unit price, C0 = the base price, Ci = the market price of the measurement period, and r = the risk band agreed in the contract.
| Tender price relation | Price direction | Judgement base | Threshold (condition) | Adjustment | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P < C0 | Rise, Ci up | C0 (base price, the higher) | Ci > C0 x (1 + r) | Only the portion of Ci above C0 x (1 + r) is adjusted, upward | A.2.4 item 1, first half |
| P < C0 | Fall, Ci down | P (tender price, the lower) | Ci < P x (1 - r) | Only the portion where P x (1 - r) is below Ci is adjusted, downward (offset against the contract price) | A.2.4 item 1, second half |
| P > C0 | Fall, Ci down | C0 (base price, the lower) | Ci < C0 x (1 - r) | Only the portion where C0 x (1 - r) is below Ci is adjusted, downward | A.2.4 item 2, first half |
| P > C0 | Rise, Ci up | P (tender price, the higher) | Ci > P x (1 + r) | Only the portion of Ci above P x (1 + r) is adjusted, upward | A.2.4 item 2, second half |
| P = C0 | Rise or fall | C0 | Ci > C0 x (1 + r) or Ci < C0 x (1 - r) | The excess portion is adjusted as actually incurred | A.2.4 item 3 |
A unified formulation for checking: upward base = max(C0, P); downward base = min(C0, P); anything not crossing the corresponding threshold is not adjusted at all.
Caution: clause A.2.4 only states on which base the excess is judged; it does not spell out the adjustment amount formula verbatim. The amount follows the price differential formula of Annex A.2.1 (differential delta C = Ci - C0 x (1 +/- r), multiplied by the quantity Q and with VAT added), with the base substituted per the table above. If the contract expressly agrees another formula for the excess, the agreement prevails (agreed terms prevail).
3. The anti-arbitrage rule (two-way disadvantage)
- Price above the base price (P > C0): on the rise side the threshold is lifted to P x (1 + r), so the premium created by over-pricing never joins the adjustment and over-pricing cannot profit from rise payments; on the fall side the base is C0, whose deduction starting point is higher than it would be on the tender price, so more is deducted when prices fall -- over-pricing loses on the fall side.
- Price below the base price (P < C0): rises are judged on the base price C0, compensating only the portion by which the market actually exceeds the base price plus its risk band, so the pricing deviation does not distort rise compensation; falls are judged on the tender price P, whose deduction starting point is lower than it would be on the base price, so a low bidder is not doubly magnified by deductions scaled to the base price.
- Concluding statement: the deviation between the tender price and the base price itself never enters the adjustment arithmetic, and neither direction can be turned into an adjustment gain, so 'deliberate over- or under-pricing plus betting on price movements' leaves no arbitrage room.
4. Cross-check of the employer's downward adjustment when prices fall
| Case | Downward base | No-deduction red line | Practical meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| P < C0 | P (tender price) | No adjustment if Ci is not below P x (1 - r) | Lower deduction starting point -> less deducted; a low tender is not doubly magnified |
| P > C0 | C0 (base price) | No adjustment if Ci is not below C0 x (1 - r) | Higher deduction starting point -> more deducted; over-pricing is squeezed on the fall side |
| P = C0 | C0 | No adjustment if Ci is not below C0 x (1 - r) | Single-side threshold judgement |
That is, for a downward deduction on the fall side, first fix the base per the table above, then check the difference between that base x (1 - r) and Ci; a wrong base directly causes over- or under-deduction.
5. Selection boundary against the index method (Annex A.1)
- Both are price adjustment methods offered by Annex A; the standard states expressly that 'the contract price may be adjusted by one of the methods in Annex A of this standard' (3.3.5, 8.7.2); the contract chooses one, and the two methods must not be applied to the same adjustable factor at the same time.
- The published-price-information method (A.2, using Table G.2.1-1 of Annex G, the schedule of price-adjustable key materials no. 1 provided by the contractor): judges the excess factor by factor, specification by specification and measurement period by measurement period on a 'unit rate x quantity' basis; it suits cases with few adjustable material types, an exact published price or a confirmed purchase price, and a need to differentiate the band by specification. The base rules of A.2.4 in this card apply only under this method.
- The index-based (formula) adjustment method (A.1, using Table G.2.1-2 of Annex G, the schedule of price-adjustable key materials no. 2 provided by the contractor): calculates with the fixed weight A, the variable weights B1...Bn of each adjustable factor, the current price index Ft and the base price index F0 (formula variables per A.1.1: delta P is the price differential to be adjusted; P0 is the net-of-VAT contract amount the contractor is to receive in the agreed measurement period, excluding price adjustments, not counting the withholding and release of retention money or the payment and recovery of advance payments, and excluding variations and other amounts already priced at current prices, while errors and omissions in the BOQ and variations and other amounts priced at the labour, material and plant unit rates of the accepted tender are counted in); the base price index is the price index of each adjustable factor at the base date of the contract, and where a cost fluctuation band is allowed the base price index shall take that fluctuation coefficient into account; for tendered works the index at the base date is the price index 28 days before the tender submission deadline, and for non-tendered works 28 days before the contract signing date (A.1.6). It suits overall adjustment with many material types and stable weights, where item-by-item excess testing is uneconomic.
- Practical selection: where the contract sets no band or an unclear one, adjustment starts only when the fluctuation exceeds 5% (8.7.2); both methods share the same risk band concept, but the 'take the higher / take the lower' base rule of A.2.4 does not apply to the index method -- the index method handles deviation through F0 and the contractually agreed fluctuation band, not by tiering on whether the tender price is above or below the base price.
Applicability Boundaries
- Preconditions (first paragraph of A.2.4): the base price is the published price information issued by the government construction cost administration 28 days before the tender submission deadline (for non-tendered works, 28 days before the contract signing date) and the current market price is the published price information of the measurement period, with the price-adjustable factors listed per Table G.2.1-1 of Annex G and an agreed risk range. The source of the base price, the issuing body and the specific quarter (month) shall be made clear in the tender documents (A.2.1).
- The current market price is not limited to published price information: it may also be the market price of the measurement period confirmed by the employer and the contractor, or tender award prices published for works of the same type under the same conditions in the same period (within the preceding month); where the employer-recognised purchase price is used, the contractor shall submit quantities and unit prices before purchase, non-response within the period set by the employer may be deemed approval, and batch purchases may be averaged by weight (A.2.5); where several market prices arise within one measurement period, the price is fixed by the arithmetic mean, the weighted average against completed quantities, or the price during the period of main consumption, and the method and order of precedence shall be agreed (A.2.3).
- Only fluctuations within the contractually agreed adjustable scope that cross the agreed risk band are adjusted; the following are not adjusted for changes in costs: construction consumables, small and medium tools, preliminaries, plant and small tools cost other than fuel and power costs allowed to adjust, material costs of items outside the contractually agreed adjustable scope, price changes beyond the agreed scope and band or fluctuations within the band, overheads and profit, and costs arising from the contractor's own causes (8.7.6).
- The price differential carries VAT only, with no overheads or profit taken (3.3.5); the cost risk on overheads and profit is covered by the bidder within the risk allowance in its tender.
- For delay, responsibility is first allocated under 8.7.4 and the price then chosen: where the employer caused the delay, the price of work after the planned progress date is the higher of the prices at the planned progress date and the actual progress date; where the contractor caused it, the lower; where neither party caused it, adjustment follows 8.7.2 (unless the contract, laws, regulations or policies provide otherwise).
- Not applicable: where the contract already expressly agrees the adjustment base and formula (the agreement prevails); portions of a lump-sum contract agreed not to adjust for cost fluctuation; and adjustments made under the index-based (formula) adjustment method (A.1), which follow the weight-and-index basis instead.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities: Annex A.2.4 (three items on direction-specific bases), A.2.1 (price differential formula, definitions of C0, Ci, Q and r, three options for the base price source, and stating the source in tender documents), A.2.3 (fixing the price when several arise within a measurement period), A.2.5 (checking and confirming the employer-recognised purchase price and deemed approval on non-response), A.1.1 (index formula and the definitions of P0, A, B1...Bn, Ft and F0), A.1.6 (price indices at the base date), Annex G.2 Tables G.2.1-1 / G.2.1-2; main text cl. 3.3.5 (elements of the two methods and VAT-only differentials), 8.7.2 (excess trigger and the 5% fallback), 8.7.4 (pricing after delay), 8.7.6 (list of non-adjustable costs).
- Superseded counterpart: GB 50500-2013 Code for Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities, Section 9.7 'Changes in Costs'; the current edition is GB/T 50500-2024, whose clause numbers and wording govern.