Characterisation, variation and site-record procedures, the variation valuation ladder, the additional-haul cost formula and the no-double-counting rule when the spoil site (spoil point / waste reception site) is changed and haul distance and disposal costs move
A spoil site changed for reasons not attributable to the contractor (a government dumping ban, expropriation of the site, a different site nominated by the employer, or insufficient capacity of the original site) is a variation under GF-2017-0201 cl. 10.1 item (4), 'changing the baselines, levels, positions and dimensions of the works'; it may proceed only after a variation instruction countersigned by the employer is received, and the unit rate is fixed by the four progressive items of GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.3.1 (an applicable rate is adopted; with no applicable but an analogous rate, reference within a reasonable range; with neither, the contractor proposes from documents, measurement and pricing methods, published price information and its price fluctuation rate for employer confirmation; where the published price information lists no price, a market price with a lawful basis applies). A haul distance change is not a quantity deviation and the 15% rule does not apply; spot site swaps and temporary double-handling instructed on site by the employer are handled as site instruction records under Section 9.14 (record report submitted within 7 days, employer verifies within 48 hours, silence past the limit means deemed approval, pricing within 7 days of completion and payment with the same-period progress payment). Note that site instruction records sit in Section 9.14 -- Section 9.10 is force majeure; the same facts may be priced through either variation or site record, never both.
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.1.1、9.1.2、9.1.4、9.3.1、9.6.2、9.14.1~9.14.6 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9节、8.10.1~8.10.3、8.11节、7.5.2 条
- GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本) 第10.1、10.2、10.3、10.4、10.6 条
- GB/T 50854-2024 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算标准 App. A.4.13
- GB/T 50857-2024 市政工程工程量计算标准 App. A.4.10
- 土地复垦条例(国务院令第592号)第十五条、第十八条
- SJG 111.1-2022 城市地下综合管廊工程消耗量标准(Vol. 1)第1.2.10条
- TB/T 10822-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 1 路基工程 Ch. 1第一节 六、自卸汽车运土
- DB63/T 2013-2022 公路养护工程预算定额 App. A 第A.2.1.3条
What This Card Covers
This card resolves, for earthworks, how a changed spoil site (spoil point, waste reception site) with longer haul and changed disposal costs is characterised (variation or site instruction record), through which procedure it is processed, on which unit-rate basis the price is adjusted, and whether variation and site record can both be priced. It applies to settlement and variation management under unit-rate BOQ-priced contracts.
Core Conclusions
1. First, fix the clause number: site instruction records are Section 9.14, not 9.10
GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.1.1 and its commentary divide Chapter 9 into '9.10 force majeure, 9.11 early completion (acceleration compensation), 9.12 delay damages, 9.13 claims, 9.14 site instruction records'. A sheet citing 'site instruction records under 9.10' cites the wrong clause; it should read 'under GB 50500-2013 Section 9.14'.
2. The test chain for variation pricing (four elements)
- A variation object exists: moving the spoil site is 'changing the position and dimensions of the works'. GF-2017-0201 cl. 10.1 [Scope of variation]: unless the particular conditions provide otherwise, the following occurring during performance shall be varied under this clause: '(1) adding to or reducing any work in the contract, or adding extra work; (2) omitting any work in the contract, except work transferred to others for execution; (3) changing the quality standard or other characteristics of any work in the contract; (4) changing the baselines, levels, positions and dimensions of the works; (5) changing the timing or sequence of the works.'
- Attribution (decisive): the cause must be not attributable to the contractor -- a government ban on dumping / closure of the reception site, expropriation of the original site, a spoil point nominated separately by the employer, capacity exhaustion of the original site by increased design volumes, a written employer instruction to change, and the like. GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.3.1 is premised on 'caused by a variation'; cl. 9.14.1 confines site instruction record matters to 'piecemeal items outside the contract and events not attributable to the contractor that the contractor performs at the employer's request'.
- Due procedure: GF-2017-0201 cl. 10.2 [Right to vary]: 'Either the employer or the supervising engineer may propose a variation. Variation instructions are issued through the supervising engineer, who shall obtain the employer's consent before issuing one. The contractor may implement a variation only after receiving a variation instruction countersigned by the employer ... Where a design change is involved, the designer shall provide the revised drawings and particulars.'
- Pricing nature: haul distance is an item description of the BOQ item, and the contract rate has locked that distance in; a distance change is not a quantity deviation, and the 'adjust the rate above a 15% quantity deviation' rule does not fit -- the proviso of cl. 9.3.1 targets 'a variation causing the quantity of that BOQ item to change with the quantity deviation exceeding 15%'.
Reverse exclusions (no variation, no adjustment): the spoil site was the contractor's own choice, priced as inclusive in its tender; the item description did not state the distance and the contract fixes disposal costs as inclusive; the distance grew from the contractor's own poor logistics, over-excavation or rework; work proceeded with no variation instruction and was papered over afterwards.
3. The variation valuation path (GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.3.1; four progressive items, stop at the first hit)
'Where a variation causes changes to priced BOQ items or their quantities, adjustment shall follow these provisions: 1 Where the priced BOQ contains a rate applicable to the varied work, that rate shall be adopted; but where the variation changes the quantity of that BOQ item and the quantity deviation exceeds 15%, the rate shall be adjusted per cl. 9.6.2 of this code. 2 Where the priced BOQ contains no applicable but an analogous item for the varied work, the rate of the analogous item may be referenced within a reasonable range. 3 Where the priced BOQ contains neither an applicable nor an analogous item for the varied work, the contractor shall propose a unit rate for the varied work based on the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing methods, the published price information issued by the government construction cost administration and the contractor's price fluctuation rate, and adjustment shall follow employer confirmation. 4 Where the priced BOQ contains neither an applicable nor an analogous item, and the published price information ... lists no price, the contractor shall propose a unit rate based on the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing methods and lawful market prices obtained through market enquiry, adjustment following employer confirmation.' The contractor's price fluctuation rate formulas are listed in that clause, one for tendered works (computed from the accepted price against the tender price ceiling) and one for non-tendered (from the price against the construction-drawing based budget); the rate build-up must multiply in this factor.
Applied to haul: where the BOQ already carries rates for 'dump truck haulage of soil, distance no more than 1 km' and 'each additional 1 km', the added distance simply stacks the per-increment rates tier by tier -- item 1, 'applicable rate'; where only similar tonnage or similar process items exist, item 2 applies by conversion (converting only the differing factors); genuinely new work with neither applies is re-priced under items 3 and 4 for employer confirmation. The current GB/T 50500-2024 provides separate paths of 'additional works' (cl. 8.10.1 to 8.10.3) and 'varied all-in unit rate' (Section 8.9); cl. 8.10.3 states that 'where the contractor converts a contract unit rate of a related BOQ item within the contract works into the all-in unit rate of the additional works, the adjusted rate may be determined by the price effects of the pricing-relevant difference factors'.
4. Start point of the new haul distance and the additional-haul formula
- Start point unchanged, only the endpoint moves: earthworks haul is measured as 'the shortest distance from the centre of gravity of excavation to the centre of gravity of filling or of spoil', the centres being fixed per the project execution plan (some local consumption standards, e.g. SJG 111.1-2022 cl. 1.2.10, adopt this rule). After the swap, the excavation centre and the measuring method stay; only the endpoint shifts to the new spoil centre, the new distance measured accordingly; where a bulldozer hauls uphill loaded at a gradient above 5%, or labour or handcart haulage climbs at a gradient above 15%, the haul of that graded section is the ramp length multiplied by the gradient adjustment coefficient.
- Additional-haul formula:
additional haul cost = added distance (converted to increment tiers) x spoil (hauled) volume x rate per increment tier. Here: added distance = new distance - the BOQ / contractual base distance (the base distance agreed in the contract governs; never default to zero); the hauled volume is the natural in-situ (undisturbed) volume per the measurement rules (not loose volume); the rate per tier is the contract's additional-haul quota line item rate or the rate built up under item 3 above. Fractional remainders follow the underlying quota manual (most sector and local manuals: remainders below half an increment unit are ignored, half or more round up to one increment unit; dump truck haulage quota line items usually cap the average distance, beyond which commercial transport is priced separately).
5. The site instruction record track (GB 50500-2013 Section 9.14): applicable cases and time limits
- Applicable cases: spot spoil point changes, temporary double-handling and local swaps instructed on site by the employer are 'piecemeal items outside the contract and events not attributable to the contractor' and go through site instruction records. The Section 9.14 commentary lists: verbal employer instructions to be tabled for conversion into a written record; written employer notices touching execution, for which the contractor must obtain record confirmation; BOQ items that prove different on site (soil category, running sand); stoppages from the employer's failure to provide the site / materials / equipment as agreed, or from water or power cuts; material and equipment prices needing quantity and rate confirmation after market moves; and other changes of site or contract conditions needing a record.
- Procedure and limits: cl. 9.14.1: the employer shall promptly instruct in writing and provide the needed documents; on receipt the contractor shall promptly raise the site instruction record request. Cl. 9.14.2: 'The contractor shall submit the site instruction record report within 7 days of the employer's instruction, and the employer shall verify the report content within 48 hours of receipt and either confirm or give comments for revision. If the employer neither confirms nor gives comments within 48 hours of receiving the report, the site instruction record report submitted by the contractor shall be deemed accepted by the employer.'
- Content: cl. 9.14.3: where dayworks rates exist for the recorded work, the record shall list the labour, materials, works equipment and machine-shifts of plant needed to complete such items; where no dayworks rate exists, the report shall state the quantities and rates.
- Unauthorised execution: cl. 9.14.4: 'Where a site instruction record matter arises on the contract works and the contractor executes it without the employer's record confirmation, the costs incurred shall be borne by the contractor unless the employer's written consent is obtained.'
- Pricing and payment: cl. 9.14.5: 'Within 7 days after the recorded work is completed, the contractor shall calculate the price per the record content and, after the employer confirms, it counts as an increase in the contract price and is paid with the same-period progress payment.'
- Records for mismatched conditions: cl. 9.14.6: where the contract works prove inconsistent with site conditions, ground and hydrology, employer requirements and the like during execution, the contractor shall provide the needed documents and submit them for record confirmation, as the basis of contract price adjustment.
6. Upward adjustment reports and approval limits (the variation track's time chain)
- GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.1.1 lists the price-adjustable events (changes in laws and regulations, variations, mismatching item descriptions, BOQ omissions, quantity deviation, dayworks, changes in costs, provisional prices, force majeure, early completion, delay damages, claims, site instruction records, provisional sums and others); of site instruction records, 'depending on the record content, some fall under variations, some under claims, and some may not involve contract price adjustment at all'.
- Cl. 9.1.2: within 14 days after a contract price increase event arises (excluding quantity deviation, dayworks, site instruction records and claims), the contractor shall submit a price increase report with the supporting documents; no submission within 14 days means the contractor is deemed to have no adjustment claim for that event.
- Cl. 9.1.4: the receiving party verifies within 14 days of the report and documents, confirming in writing or raising comments for discussion; silence for 14 days means the report is deemed approved by the receiving party; where comments are raised, the other party verifies and confirms within 14 days of receipt, and its failure to confirm or object within 14 days means the comments are deemed approved.
- GF-2017-0201 cl. 10.4.2 [Variation valuation procedure]: the contractor shall submit the variation valuation application to the supervising engineer within 14 days of the variation instruction; the supervising engineer completes review within 7 days of receipt and forwards it to the employer; the employer completes approval within 14 days of the contractor's application, and failure to complete approval or to object past the time means the application is deemed accepted; the price adjustment caused by the variation shall be paid in the nearest progress payment.
7. Pricing basis of disposal costs (site occupation / levelling / reclamation)
- BOQ basis for disposal of surplus (excavated) material: GB/T 50854-2024 Annex A.4.13 makes surplus material disposal cover the loading and haulage of earth and rock from the site to the designated disposal point, 'and it shall meet the national and local requirements of the building administration on the reception and disposal of construction waste'; GB/T 50857-2024 Annex A.4.10 provides that where the surplus and waste disposal BOQ items incur disposal or stockpiling costs, 'the work content shall include the reception and disposal required under local regulations'.
- Reclamation costs: Regulation on Land Reclamation (State Council Decree No. 592) Article 15: the party obliged to reclaim land shall carry the land reclamation costs in production costs or the total investment of the construction project; Article 18: an obliged party that does not reclaim, or still fails the reclamation acceptance after rectification, shall pay a land reclamation fee, and the competent land and resources authority arranges the reclamation on its behalf; the amount of the fee is set considering the pre-damage land type, the actual damaged area, the degree of damage, the reclamation standard, the after-use and the works needed to complete the reclamation.
- Inclusive-and-fixed versus listed-as-incurred: where the contract BOQ books disposal, reception and site occupation as inclusive (or fixes them as the work content of 'meeting the reception and disposal requirements'), changes in the actual distance, the actual reception volume or the actual occupied area are generally not adjusted; only where the swap is for reasons not attributable to the contractor, a disposal site is added, or the employer requires new reclamation / levelling does a separate item arise -- through a site record (piecemeal, measured as incurred) or as additional works (where it constitutes additional works outside the contract scope, GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.10.1 applies: the price may be computed from the agreed measurement standards, contract unit rates and tender pricing level, or the rules renegotiated and an additional works contract or supplementary agreement signed).
8. Negative conclusion: variation and site record must not be double counted
The same facts (the same swap, the same added distance, the same batch of spoil) may be priced through only one of 'variation' or 'site instruction record':
- Where the distance cost is already adjusted as a variation (additional-haul items, rebuilt rates), no further record may claim 're-handling / second handling' fees for the same added distance;
- Where spot swap costs are already taken as incurred under a record, the same quantities must not be adjusted again under the name of a variation;
- The record fixes site facts and quantities (time, location, volume, machine-shifts, rate basis); the variation supplies the rate and price adjustment rules -- they divide the work, they do not stack;
- Variation-driven changes to preliminaries (temporary haul road extensions, wheel-washing facilities, detours under traffic bans) must have the intended scheme submitted and confirmed before execution; claims for a preliminaries adjustment filed after the fact lack basis.
Applicability Boundaries
- Applies to earthworks and disposal under unit-rate / BOQ-priced contracts; under lump-sum or cost-plus contracts the contractual adjustment rules govern.
- Agreed terms prevail: who nominates the spoil site, the base distance, whether disposal is inclusive, and how on-site and off-site haul are split all follow the contract and its particular conditions; where the contract is explicit, this card's fallback presumptions do not apply.
- Standard currency: GB 50500-2013 was the original national BOQ pricing standard; the current edition is GB/T 50500-2024, whose numbering and basis differ on variation valuation, additional works and dayworks measurement. The 2024 edition deletes Section 9.14 'site instruction records' and its default procedure of 7-day submission, 48-hour verification and deemed approval on lapse; contract price adjustment now runs through the variation, additional works and dayworks tracks and per the contract. New contracts, and variations arising after the 2024 edition took effect, follow the GB/T 50500-2024 counterparts (Section 8.9 variations, Section 8.10 additional works, Section 8.11 claims, cl. 7.5.2 dayworks cases); the 2013 clauses serve only as contract-incorporated text or the settlement basis of legacy contracts.
- Not applicable: distance growth from the contractor's own causes (self-selected sites, poor logistics, over-excavation, rework, mismanagement); records papering over unauthorised swaps made without an employer instruction; distance changes misapplied to the 15% quantity deviation rule.
- The additional-haul formula depends on the increment tiers of the underlying quota manual (per additional 1 km, per additional 0.5 km, etc.) and its rounding rules; additional-haul items and coefficients must not be mixed across sectors or disciplines.
Further Reading
- GB 50500-2013: cl. 9.1.1 (adjustable events), 9.1.2 (14-day upward report), 9.1.4 (14-day verification, deemed approval), 9.3.1 (four variation rate items, price fluctuation rate formulas), 9.6.2 (quantity deviation rate adjustment), 9.14.1 to 9.14.6 (site instruction records), Section 9.14 commentary (six record cases).
- GB/T 50500-2024: Section 8.9 (varied all-in unit rates), 8.10.1 to 8.10.3 (additional works), Section 8.11 (claims), 7.5.2 (ten dayworks cases).
- GF-2017-0201 (Model Construction Contract): cl. 10.1 (scope of variation), 10.2 (right to vary), 10.3 (variation procedure), 10.4 (variation valuation), 10.6 (time adjustment from variations).
- GB/T 50854-2024 (building and decoration measurement), Annex A.4.13 (surplus material disposal work content); GB/T 50857-2024 (municipal measurement), Annex A.4.10 (disposal of surplus material and waste).
- Regulation on Land Reclamation (State Council Decree No. 592), Articles 15 and 18 (reclamation costs; the reclamation fee and its factors).
- Haul measurement and increment tiers: SJG 111.1-2022 (utility tunnel consumption standard), Vol. 1, cl. 1.2.10 (shortest distance excavation centre to filling / spoil centre; gradient adjustment coefficients); TB/T 10822-2024 Railway Works Budget Quota Manual Vol. 1 (Subgrade), Chapter 1 Section 1 item 6 'dump truck haulage of soil' (no more than 1 km and per additional 1 km as separate line items, graded by truck tonnage); DB63/T 2013-2022 (highway maintenance quota), Annex A cl. A.2.1.3 (dump truck haulage of soil within an average 15 km, beyond 15 km priced as commercial transport; remainders below half an increment unit not counted, half or more counted as one unit).
Keywords
- 弃土场调整
- 运距变化
- variation
- variation record / site instruction
- GB 50500-2013 第9.3.1条
- 第9.14节 现场签证
- 增运子目
- 变更与签证不得双计