What the "approved (validated) documents" point to in the basis of the highway revised estimate: for a revised estimate, the preliminary-design approval document (JTG 3830-2018 Clause 2.2.1 item 4)
Verbatim from Clause 2.2.1 item 4 of JTG 3830-2018 "Measures for compiling estimates and budgets of highway engineering construction projects": "the approved (validated) document of the feasibility study report (for a revised estimate, the preliminary-design approval document) and related materials" — i.e., for a revised estimate the approved (validated) document is the preliminary-design approval document; only the ordinary design estimate is based on the feasibility-study approval. By contrast, Clause 2.2.2 bases the construction-drawing budget on "the approved preliminary design documents (or technical design documents, if any)" — the later the stage, the newer the basis.
Applicable Codes
- JTG 3830-2018 · Measure for Compilation of Preliminary Estimates and Budgets of Highway Construction Projects 第2.2节
- JTG 3820-2018 · Measure for Compilation of Investment Estimates of Highway Construction Projects
Topic Positioning
This card explains the exact referent of "approved (validated) documents" in the basis of highway revised estimates: per Clause 2.2.1 item 4 of the "Measures for compiling estimates and budgets of highway engineering construction projects" (JTG 3830-2018), for a revised estimate it is the preliminary-design approval document; it also gives the comparison with the bases of the design estimate and the construction-drawing budget.
Core Conclusions
Clause 2.2.1 (design-estimate basis) item 4 of JTG 3830-2018, verbatim: "the approved (validated) document of the feasibility study report (for a revised estimate, the preliminary-design approval document) and related materials".
- For a revised estimate, the "approved (validated) document" = the preliminary-design approval document; the investment-control basis of the ordinary (preliminary-design) estimate is the feasibility-study approval document.
- Reason: the revised estimate is compiled at the technical-design stage (per Clause 4.1.1 of the former "Measures for compiling design documents of highway capital construction projects", the technical-design stage compiles the "revised design estimate", which once approved is the basis for construction-drawing design); by then the controlling role of the feasibility-study approval has been superseded by the preliminary-design approval.
- Contrast Clause 2.2.2 (construction-drawing budget basis) item 4, verbatim: "the approved preliminary design documents (or technical design documents, if any) and related materials" — "documents" rather than "approval document", but the logic is the same: the later the compilation stage, the newer the approved document used as the basis.
- Clause 2.2.1 lists 8 items as the design-estimate basis: (1) relevant national laws and regulations; (2) these Measures and the companion quota norms; (3) supplementary provisions and quota norms issued by the provincial transport authority where the works are located; (4) the approved (validated) document of the feasibility study report (for a revised estimate, the preliminary-design approval document) and related materials; (5) preliminary-design (or technical-design) drawings and other design documents, and construction method statements (incl. the project execution plan); (6) local prices of labour, materials and equipment, and plant; (7) relevant contracts and agreements; (8) other related materials. Clause 2.2.2 sets out the construction-drawing budget basis in the same 8-item structure, with only item 4 changed to "the approved preliminary design documents (or technical design documents, if any)" and item 5 to "construction-drawing design drawings and other design documents".
Applicable Boundaries
- Applies only to the highway JTG 3830-2018 pricing system; railway (TB 10801 series) and building/municipal (GB/T 50500-2024) works follow their own rules for the basis of estimates.
- The substitution "for a revised estimate, the preliminary-design approval document" targets revised estimates only; the approved (validated) document referents of the design estimate, the revised estimate and the construction-drawing budget must not be mixed up.
- The budget basis is "the approved preliminary design documents" (the documents themselves, incl. construction-drawing design drawings) — different wording from "approval document"; do not confuse the two when citing the original text.
Further Reading
- See JTG 3830-2018 Section 2.2 (2.2.1 design-estimate basis, 2.2.2 construction-drawing budget basis).
- For the technical-design stage in which the revised estimate sits and its role, see Clause 4.1.1 of the former "Measures for compiling design documents of highway capital construction projects".
- For the layer-by-layer control chain investment estimate -> preliminary estimate -> budget and the stage positioning of each cost document, see Clause 1.0.3 of JTG 3820-2018 "Measures for compiling investment estimates of highway engineering construction projects".