Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

The relationship between the risk allowance inside the all-in unit rate and contractual price adjustment for fluctuation: within the band the risk allowance absorbs the movement, beyond the band only the excess is adjusted, and the two are never counted twice

The risk allowance and contractual price adjustment are a two-stage allocation of the same pricing risk against the risk band r agreed in the contract: within r, the movement is absorbed by the risk allowance implied in the all-in unit rate (not billed as a separate item, not repaid at settlement); when the movement exceeds r, the adjustment rules adjust only the excess. The exclusion of double counting runs both ways - GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.2.2 states that 'when the risk content and its scope (band) that arises falls within the range agreed in the contract, the contract price shall not be adjusted'; GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.3.5 states that the price differential adjustment 'shall carry VAT but shall not carry management fee or profit', and Clause 8.7.6 states that management fee and profit, preliminaries and other plant and small tools costs shall not be adjusted for changes in costs, that is, an above-band adjustment may not be stacked with risk allowance / management fee / profit. Clause numbers must not be mixed across editions: in the 2013 edition the all-in unit rate is Clause 2.0.8 and the risk allowance is Clause 2.0.9; in the 2024 edition the all-in unit rate is Clause 2.0.9 (excluding VAT).

Applicable Codes

  • GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第2.0.8条(综合单价)、第2.0.9条(风险费用)、第3.4.3条、第5.2.2条、第6.2.2条、第9.8.1~9.8.3条、App. A.2.3、App. L.2/L.3
  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.9条、第3.1.6条、第3.2.2条、第3.3.1条、第3.3.3条、第3.3.5条、第8.7.2条、第8.7.6条、App. A.1、App. A.2.4、App. G.2

Topic positioning

This card explains the relationship in BOQ pricing between 'the risk allowance inside the all-in unit rate' and 'contractual price adjustment for cost fluctuation during construction': they are not two stackable costs but a two-stage allocation mechanism that splits the same market price risk at the risk band agreed in the contract, and it gives the boundary test and the rules excluding double counting. It applies to all stages of dividing the risk scope in tender documents and contracts, pricing the risk allowance into the tender, and processing material price adjustment during construction, with a clause-by-clause comparison of GB 50500-2013 and GB/T 50500-2024.

Core conclusions

I. Characterisation: a two-stage allocation of one risk, no duplication

Within the risk band r: absorbed by the risk allowance implied in the all-in unit rate (priced into the offer in advance, not billed as a separate item, not repaid at settlement, not separately adjusted).

Beyond the risk band r: contractual price adjustment is triggered, and only the portion exceeding r is adjusted (measured afterwards, adjusted to actual).

There is a single boundary test: whether the fluctuation exceeds the risk band r agreed in the contract.

II. The inclusion rules of GB 50500-2013 (terms in Clauses 2.0.8 and 2.0.9)

Clause 2.0.8 all-in unit rate: 'the labour cost, materials and permanent equipment costs, plant and small tools cost, overheads (company and site), profit and the risk allowance within a defined range required to complete one specified BOQ item.'

Clause 2.0.9 risk allowance: 'a cost implied in the all-in unit rates of the priced bill of quantities, used to absorb the market price fluctuation risk within the content and scope agreed by the employer and the contractor in the works contract.'

Two keywords decide its nature: 'implied in' - the risk allowance is not a separately billed item and does not appear in the settlement adjustment tables; it is folded into the unit rates once and for all at tendering, and at settlement there is no pricing opening to 'take a risk allowance again'; 'within the agreed content and scope' - the duty boundary of the risk allowance is exactly the scope/band agreed in the contract; beyond it the risk allowance is not responsible.

At the pricing stage (Clause 6.2.2 tender pricing; Clause 5.2.2 tender price ceiling follows the same basis): 'the all-in unit rates shall include the risk scope allocated to the tenderer in the tender documents and its costs; where the tender documents are not explicit, the employer shall be asked to clarify.' The second half of Clause 6.2.2 is an express negation of adjustment triggering: 'the all-in unit rates shall take account of the risk allowance arising from the risk content and its scope (band) that the tender documents require the tenderer to bear. During construction, when the risk content and its scope (band) that arises falls within the range agreed in the contract, the contract price shall not be adjusted.'

The quantitative allocation of risk (explanation of Clause 3.4.3): tenderers shall fully bear technical and management risks (such as management fee and profit); shall bear market risks to a limited extent (material prices, construction plant usage costs and the like); and shall bear none of the risks of changes in laws, regulations, rules and policies. The explanation further states: 'labour cost, which touches the vital interests of workers, should not be brought into the risk; the risk of material prices should be controlled within 5%; the risk of construction plant usage costs may be controlled within 10%, with adjustment for what exceeds; the risks of management fee and profit are borne entirely by the tenderer', and 'where the contract is silent and a dispute arises between the employer and the contractor, the contract price shall be adjusted in accordance with Clauses 9.8.1 to 9.8.3 of this code'.

III. The boundary test (only the excess is adjusted)

Annex A.2.3 of GB 50500-2013 and Annex A.2.4 of GB/T 50500-2024 share the same basis and distinguish three cases by whether the tender rate is below, above or equal to the base price (the 2024 edition words this through 'price-adjustable factors', taking as the base price the published price information issued by the government construction cost administration 28 days before the tender submission deadline or, for non-tendered works, 28 days before the signing of the contract, and taking the published price information of the measurement period as the current market price):

  1. Where the tender rate is below the base price: when the increase exceeds the agreed risk band value on the base price, or the decrease exceeds the agreed risk band value on the tender rate, the excess is adjusted to actual;
  2. Where the tender rate is above the base price: when the decrease exceeds the agreed risk band value on the base price, or the increase exceeds the agreed risk band value on the tender rate, the excess is adjusted to actual;
  3. Where the tender rate equals the base price: when the increase or decrease exceeds the agreed risk band value on the base price, the excess is adjusted to actual.

That is, the adjustment base takes the side unfavourable to the contractor (for increases the lower base, for decreases the higher base); only the above-band portion is adjusted, and the within-band portion is always borne by the risk allowance inside the rate. Annex A.2.3 of the 2013 edition adds a procedural requirement: before purchasing materials the contractor shall submit the purchase quantities and the new material rates to the employer for checking; 'if the employer fails to respond within 3 working days after receiving the confirmation data submitted by the contractor, the data shall be deemed already approved and serve as the basis for adjusting the contract price. If the contractor purchases materials on its own without submitting them to the employer for checking and then asks the employer to confirm a contract price adjustment, no adjustment shall be made if the employer disagrees.'

IV. The corresponding clauses of GB/T 50500-2024 and the cost make-up of the all-in unit rate

Clause 2.0.9 all-in unit rate: 'the cost required to complete one unit quantity of a BOQ item, comprehensively taking into account influencing factors such as technical standards and codes, construction period, construction sequence, construction conditions, geography and climate, as well as the risk within the agreed scope and band. The all-in unit rate of a BOQ item comprises labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management fee, profit and the risk allowance within a defined range, and excludes VAT.' The explanation: 'VAT is a price-exclusive tax; the all-in unit rate does not include VAT.'

Clause 3.1.6: 'The all-in unit rates and prices of the BOQ items shall be fully inclusive pre-tax prices excluding VAT, composed of labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management fee and profit, including the risk allowance within the agreed or reasonable scope of the relevant BOQ item and the cost of indispensable auxiliary work; the taxes of the BOQ items shall be entered under VAT, except that the provisional sums for nominated specialist subcontract works under the bill of provisional sums and other charges already include VAT, and their corresponding tax shall not be charged again under the VAT of the bill of quantities.'

Clause 3.2.2: the all-in unit rate for the bills of divisional works items shall be a pre-tax unit rate for material procurement, supply and related installation excluding VAT, including the costs arising from the following influences on completing the relevant BOQ item: 1 the costs of meeting the requirements of national and industry technical standards and codes; 2 the costs of errors and omissions in the BOQ arising under lump-sum contracts; 3 the costs of the construction tasks necessary to complete the relevant BOQ item to handover requirements and of their indispensable auxiliary work; 4 the costs caused by construction sequence, construction conditions, environment, climate and other factors; 5 the risk allowance within the scope and band agreed in the contract and in Section 3.3 of this standard.

Comparison: Clause 2.0.8 of the 2013 edition lists labour, materials and plant + overheads + profit + risk allowance; Clause 2.0.9 of the 2024 edition renames this 'management fee', makes clear the exclusion of VAT, and writes the influencing factors (technical standards, period, sequence, conditions, geography, climate) and 'the risk within the agreed scope and band' into the definition; Clause 3.1.6 of the 2024 edition further expresses it as a 'fully inclusive pre-tax price'. The clause numbers of the two editions differ and must not be mixed.

V. Express exclusion of double counting (both directions)

(1) No further adjustment within the band. Clause 6.2.2 of the 2013 edition: 'During construction, when the risk content and its scope (band) that arises falls within the range agreed in the contract, the contract price shall not be adjusted.' Item 7 of Clause 3.3.3 of the 2024 edition lists 'market price movements not exceeding the scope and fluctuation band of cost changes agreed in the tender documents and the contract' as a contractor-borne item, for which 'the changes to the contract price and (or) time caused thereby shall be deemed included in the total contract price and the contract period; save as otherwise agreed in the contract, neither the contract price nor the time shall be adjusted'; Clause 8.7.2 states again that 'where the market price fluctuation does not exceed the market fluctuation band borne by the contractor as agreed in the contract, the amounts of the BOQ items of the works carried out in the relevant adjustment period may be left unadjusted'.

(2) An above-band adjustment may not carry the risk allowance again, nor stack management fee or profit. Clause 3.3.5 item 4 of the 2024 edition: 'price differential adjustments to the labour cost, the material cost and the fuel and power costs within the plant and small tools cost of the all-in unit rate shall carry VAT and shall not carry management fee or profit.' The explanation: 'the price differential caused by cost changes carries VAT only; the risk of management fee and profit shall be considered by the tenderer as a risk allowance in its tender price.' Clause 8.7.6 lists the costs not adjusted for changes in costs: 1 construction consumables; 2 small and medium-sized tools; 3 preliminaries; 4 plant and small tools costs other than the fuel and power costs of construction plant whose prices are adjusted under Clauses 8.7.1 to 8.7.4; 5 the material costs of items that are not price-adjustable items agreed in the contract, save for the abnormal price fluctuations under Clause 8.7.3; 6 price changes beyond the price adjustment scope and band agreed in the contract, or the labour, material and plant fuel-and-power costs of price-adjustable items whose fluctuation does not exceed the band specified in Clause 8.7.2; 7 management fee and profit; 8 costs arising from causes attributable to the contractor itself.

In sum: the pricing basis of the adjustment is 'net-of-tax price differential x quantity, plus VAT'; its nature is to restore the actual cost of the above-band portion, not to re-charge any margin already covered by the risk allowance; and since the risk allowance inside the rate is 'implied in' the rate, it cannot be stripped out, offset or paid twice at settlement.

(3) The lawful premise of the contractual basis. Clause 3.3.1 of the 2024 edition: 'construction tendering and contracting shall state in the tender documents and the contract the risk content and scope of measurement and pricing, and shall not use uncapped risk, all-risk or similar wording to agree the risk content and scope in measurement and pricing.' Where there is no agreement or the agreement is unclear, Clause 8.7.2 gives a fallback threshold: 'where the contract specifies no band or the specification is unclear, when the market price fluctuation exceeds 5%, the contract price may be adjusted by one of the methods in Annex A of this standard.' (The 5% is a fallback for absent agreement, not a substitute for the bands the parties agree separately for materials and plant.) Clause 3.3.5 of the 2024 edition also allows the fuel and power costs of major construction plant to be adjusted as agreed, while 'the other plant and small tools costs may be left unadjusted for market price fluctuation, and the contractor shall consider their risk allowance in the all-in unit rates'.

Applicable boundaries

  1. This card covers the risk allowance-versus-adjustment relationship under market price fluctuation risk; price adjustments arising from time, quantity deviations, variations, claims, force majeure or changes in laws, regulations and policies are governed by their own clauses and do not follow the band test of this card.
  2. Clause numbers, terms ('overheads' in 2013 versus 'management fee' in 2024) and the tax basis (the 2024 edition states a fully inclusive pre-tax price excluding VAT) differ between editions; cite clauses against the edition agreed in the contract and never mix them; the 2024 edition is a recommended standard (GB/T) while some clauses of the 2013 edition were mandatory provisions, so the edition agreed in the contract governs the effect.
  3. 'Implied in' means the risk allowance has no separate pricing line; in practice the within-band risk allowance cannot be separately refunded or deducted at settlement; there is therefore no room to 'claim the differential under the adjustment and add a risk allowance on top', nor any room to 'claim separately for within-band increases'.
  4. The 'within 5%' material price risk is indicative guidance in the explanation of the 2013 edition (within 10% for plant usage cost), not a mandatory figure; the 5% in Clause 8.7.2 of the 2024 edition applies only as a fallback where the contract specifies no band or the specification is unclear; the two differ in nature and must not be equated.
  5. Labour cost (touching the vital interests of workers) should not be brought into the risk scope under the 2013 edition and is adjusted through the labour cost information published by the provinces; the 2024 edition lists labour cost as one of the price-adjustable factors, with the band as agreed in the contract. Risks of changes in laws, regulations and policy do not fall on the contractor.
  6. Adjustment must also satisfy the procedural requirements (Annex A.2.3 of the 2013 edition requires submission to the employer for checking before purchase, with no reply within 3 working days deemed approval; purchases made without prior checking are not adjusted if the employer disagrees).

Further reading

  • Definitions of the all-in unit rate and the risk allowance: GB 50500-2013, BOQ pricing code, Clauses 2.0.8 and 2.0.9; GB/T 50500-2024, BOQ pricing standard, Clause 2.0.9.
  • Risk scope agreement and allocation: GB 50500-2013 Clause 3.4.3 and its explanation, Clause 6.2.2 (tender pricing) and Clause 5.2.2 (tender price ceiling); GB/T 50500-2024 Section 3.3 (3.3.1 prohibition of uncapped risk, 3.3.3 contractor-borne items, 3.3.5 adjustable factors and the VAT treatment), Clause 3.1.6 and Clause 3.2.2.
  • Adjustment methods and above-band calculation: GB 50500-2013 Annex A.2.3 (methods of contract price adjustment for changes in costs); GB/T 50500-2024 Annex A.2.4 (adjustment based on published price information) and Annex A.1 (index-based formula adjustment).
  • Adjustment triggers and the non-adjustable scope: GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.7.2 and 8.7.6; the schedule of price-adjustable key materials in Annex G.2 Tables G.2.1-1 and G.2.1-2 (2013 edition counterparts: Annexes L.2 and L.3, List of Main Materials and Permanent Equipment Provided by the Contractor).
  • Dispute fallback: GB 50500-2013 Clauses 9.8.1 to 9.8.3 (contract price adjustment for changes in costs).

Keywords