Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-11-01

Distinguishing claims for extension of time from cost claims: an axis-by-axis comparison of the two independent remedies, time and money, on causation threshold (critical path), basis of calculation (delay duration / total float vs actual-cost method / total-cost method), whether profit is claimable, evidence and time limits, plus the rules of combined calculation and joint approval where both are claimed together

An EOT claim asks for time, a cost claim asks for money; both are economic compensation, not penalty (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.31, 8.11.1, 8.11.2). The core divide: an EOT claim is hard-gated by the critical path - delay to work on the critical path is taken at the delay duration; delay to non-critical work that exceeds its total float and turns critical is taken as delay duration minus total float; if the work remains non-critical, no EOT claim arises (8.11.8). A cost claim does not require the critical path, only direct economic loss (8.11.9, 8.11.11). Both share one 28-day procedure (8.11.3); a claim involving both cost increase and extension of time must be raised together and approved jointly by the employer (8.11.3 para 3, 8.11.5 para 3); in calculation the EOT outcome is confirmed first and cost computed on it, each event assessed separately with no double counting.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.31条、第8.11.1~8.11.13条
  • T ZBD 100.5-2023 建设工程结算审核作业指引 第3.1.9条
  • T ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.7.3~4.7.5条

Topic Scope

EOT claims and cost claims are two independent remedies within one and the same claim procedure: one asks for time (extension of the contract duration), the other for money (economic loss / cost compensation carried into the contract price). This card gives the axis-by-axis comparison of elements, each side's basis of calculation and evidence focus, and the rules of combined calculation and joint approval where both are claimed together.

Core Conclusions

1. Basis of characterisation: two ledgers side by side, both compensatory

GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.31, 'construction claim': 'where a party, for reasons not attributable to itself, suffers economic loss, increased costs or delay (or extension) of duration, and the other party is under a duty of compensation or relief arising from the contract or from statutes and regulations, it raises against that other party a demand for compensation of economic loss and/or adjustment of duration and other relief.' The single 'and/or' shows the two run in parallel and may be held together.

Clauses 8.11.1 and 8.11.2: under the Civil Code, where a party fails to perform its contractual obligations or performs them inconsistently with the contract and causes loss to the other party, the other party may demand performance or remedial measures and also compensation for loss or costs; 'a claim is an act by which the employer and the contractor protect their own lawful interests under the contract; in nature it is an act of economic compensation, not of penalty'; 'a construction claim covers compensation for economic loss and adjustment of duration; where they occur at the same time they shall be raised together. Where the price of an event has already been calculated as a contract price adjustment (claims excluded), no construction claim shall be calculated for it again.'

Clause 8.11.1 also draws the boundary: events falling within the adjustment scope of sections 8.2 to 8.10 adjust the contract price under those sections; only events outside that scope are handled as claims under this section - the claim is the residual channel of the price-adjustment system.

2. Axis-by-axis comparison table

Axis EOT claim Cost claim Basis
Object of relief Extension of the contract duration, producing no monetary amount as such; the extension the employer grants the contractor is time added to the contract duration Money compensation for economic loss / increased costs, carried into the contract price (interim payments, interim settlement payments by construction stage, final account payment) 2.0.31; 8.11.7; 8.11.5 para 4
Causation threshold An event not attributable to the claimant, and the work underlying the EOT claim must be work on the critical path, or work whose critical path is shifted by the claim event An event not attributable to the claimant causing direct economic loss / increased costs, wherever it sits on the network 8.11.7; 8.11.9; 8.11.11
Basis of calculation (1) delay to work on the critical path: delay duration = the EOT claimed; (2) delay to non-critical work exceeding its total float and so becoming critical-path work: delay duration minus total float is the EOT claimed; (3) the work remains non-critical after the delay: no EOT claim arises (1) actual-cost method: claim amount = sum (labour of all classes, equipment and material costs, construction plant costs + countable overheads + countable profit) + other losses; (2) total-cost method: claim amount = actual total cost - tender estimate total cost 8.11.8; T ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.7.3
Profit or not Not engaged (duration itself carries no profit) Three tiers: employer fault / breach -> profit claimable (8.11.10 lists 8 classes of case); other employer causes (re-testing that passes, extra inspection and testing, failed commissioning and the like) -> costs only, no profit (8.11.11); force majeure, government authorities and exceptional events -> extension granted and each party bears its own loss (8.11.9 closing, 8.11.12, 8.11.13) 8.11.9 to 8.11.13; T ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.7.4
Evidence focus The employer-approved progress programme (network plan), comparison calculations of critical path and total float, commencement / suspension / resumption records, instructions of the supervising engineer and proof of their receipt The claim cost computation sheet plus element vouchers: site instruction documents and letters, contract documents, statutes, quota norms and published price information, attendance and payroll sheets, machine-shift records, lease contracts, purchase invoices 8.11.3 para 2; T ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.9 para 2
Time limit One procedure, undifferentiated by type: within the contractual period after the event (28 days if the contract is silent) submit the written Notice of Claim; within the contractual period after the notice (28 days if silent) submit the written claim report; for continuing effects, submit continuing Notices of Claim at contractual intervals (not exceeding 28 days if silent) or at reasonable intervals, and the final claim report within 28 days after the effect ends Same (one notice, one report, cost and time in one case) 8.11.3 paras 1 to 5
Handling by the employer Within the contractual period after the notice (14 days if silent) it may request supplementary proof in writing; within the contractual period after the claim report or the supplements (28 days if silent) it replies in writing with its handling opinion; where both cost increase and extension of time are involved, approval shall be given jointly Same; once agreed, the claimed cost is paid at the contractual payment percentage in the current interim payment or interim settlement payment by construction stage, the balance in the final account payment 8.11.5
Consequence of lapse A claim not raised within the agreed time may, save as the contract otherwise agrees and statutes otherwise provide, be deemed waived Same; where the other party fails to reply within the agreed time or makes no reply, the construction claim as raised may be deemed approved 8.11.3 closing; 8.11.5 closing

3. Concurrent claims and the combination rules (four)

1 Raised together: where a contractor's claim event involves both cost increase and extension of time, both shall be raised together (8.11.3 para 3); a construction claim covers compensation for economic loss and adjustment of duration, and where they occur at the same time they shall be raised together (8.11.2). 2 Approved together: where a contractor's claim event involves both cost increase and extension of time, the employer shall, for that claim event, approve the cost claim and the extension of time jointly (8.11.5 para 3). 3 Time first, then cost: where both an EOT claim and a cost claim are involved, the cost claim shall be computed on the basis of the confirmed outcome of the EOT claim (T ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.7.5; T ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.9 para 1). 4 One event, one assessment, no double counting: claimed costs are assessed independently per claim event and exclude cost claims for the corresponding delay caused to later works by earlier delay (8.11.7); amounts already calculated under the contract price adjustment provisions (claims excluded) cannot be claimed again (8.11.1, 8.11.2); loss and direct-cost compensation exclude the losses and/or costs of other events indirectly caused by the event in question (8.11.11 closing).

4. The typical 'money but no time' scenario

Delay to work off the critical path not exceeding its total float (or exceeding it yet not turning the work critical): no EOT claim arises (8.11.8 para 3) - 'work on the critical path has a decisive influence on the progress of the whole project and sets the total duration of the project; extension of work off the critical path shall not be counted as an EOT claim' - but idle labour and plant standby and loss of efficiency can still be claimed under 8.11.9. This is the classic divide where each ledger stands on its own.

5. Claimable cost content (8.11.9, nine classes, excerpts)

Costs of labour, materials, construction plant and utilities consumed by suspension, waiting, loss of efficiency, extension of duration and the like; direct cost increases and decreases from price changes in labour, materials and construction plant caused by adjustment of the contract duration (except where adjusted under clause 8.7.4); necessary measure costs incurred for suspension, resumption and protection of the site; direct costs of reworking, demolition-alteration and repair, plus the direct loss of written-off (damaged) materials; costs of additionally added inspection, examination and testing; losses caused by non-payment of the contract price as agreed; effects of suspension, interruption or stoppage caused by unearthing of cultural relics or ancient monuments; other losses the contractor can prove, and VAT; and a reasonable duration for the delay (or extension) caused by the event. Four heads of suspension and waiting loss: idle costs of personnel already mobilised; loss of materials already delivered but not usable; standby costs of plant already on site but unable to work; other cost losses.

Applicable Boundaries

  • The premise is that the event does not fall within the price-adjustment scope of sections 8.2 to 8.10; events within it adjust under the corresponding sections, without running the claim channel again.
  • The agreed terms prevail: claim periods, whether profit is counted, risk allocation and computation method all start from the contract (the 'contractual period' wording in each paragraph of 8.11.3; 8.11.10 and 8.11.11 open with 'except as otherwise provided by the contract').
  • Where an ordinary cost claim does not apply: for causes attributable to government authorities, the duration is extended accordingly and the economic losses of both parties are borne by each itself (8.11.9 closing); force majeure is shared under 8.11.12 (the employer bears damage to the permanent works and to materials delivered to site; the contractor bears damage to its own plant and its suspension losses; each party bears its own casualties); under 8.11.13, exceptional events (riot and civil disturbance, stoppage or area control ordered by government authorities, safety- or environment-driven stoppages, health and epidemic control) extend the duration and each party bears its own loss.
  • Failure to raise in time may be deemed waiver; failure of the other side to reply may be deemed approval - procedural time bars decide whether either ledger stands at all; a claim sound in substance but out of time is equally damaged.

Further Reading

GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.31 (term); clauses 8.11.1 to 8.11.14 (general rules of claims, procedure and time limits, duration computation, claimable content, profit and loss sharing); T ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.9 (review method: claim classes listed separately, five classes of basis, pricing principles, table 3.1.9 claim events and compensable content); T ZBD 100.4-2023 clauses 4.7.3 to 4.7.5 (cost computation methods, cost-versus-profit dispute determination, time first).

Keywords