Classification basis and table numbers for soil and rock on site (soft rock / hard rock / boulders), the threshold position on measuring boulders as rock, and the price adjustment boundary where the actual class differs from the BOQ item description
BOQ item descriptions are entered per Table A.4.3-1 of GB/T 50854-2024 (soil classes 1-4, judged by soil name plus excavation method) and Table A.4.3-2 (extremely soft rock through extremely hard rock); where classes cannot be fixed precisely, describe from the geotechnical investigation report. The quota-system classes 'loose rock / sub-hard rock / ordinary hard rock / extra-hard rock' (Protodyakonov I-XVI) are not listed in the BOQ classification tables and must not be entered as item descriptions. Boulders: the building works position has only a qualitative boundary - clearance of natural obstructions 'removable together with the earthworks' is already inside the earthwork items, while boulders needing separate breaking or crushing are listed separately as rock or handled as missing items or variations; the water sector position expressly measures boulders larger than 0.7 m3 as rock excavation. Where the class differs from the BOQ description, under a unit-rate contract the all-in unit rate is re-determined on the item description actually constructed (GB 50500-2013 clause 9.4.2), with a 15% quantity deviation as the boundary for rate adjustment (clause 9.6.2).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50854-2024 App. A Table A.4.3-1 土分类表
- GB/T 50854-2024 App. A Table A.4.3-2 岩石分类表
- GB/T 50854-2024 App. A Table A.4.1(单独土石方与障碍物清除说明)
- GB/T 50854-2024 App. A Table A.1.1(单独土石方 010101)、Table A.2.1(基础土石方 010102)
- GB 50501-2007 App. A 第A.1.2条及Table A.1.2 一般工程土类分级表
- SJG 111.1-2022 App. C 土壤及岩石(普氏)分类表
- GB 50021-2001(2009年局部修订版)
- GB 50500-2013 第9.3.1、9.4.2、9.5.1、9.6.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第4.1.6、8.2.1、8.9.1、8.9.2条
- DB37/T 5028-2022 第5.4.3条
- T/SDJZXH 004.1-2022 第10.6.1、10.6.3条
Topic Positioning
Classification basis (tables and table numbers) when soft rock, hard rock or boulders are met in earthworks; the threshold position on whether boulders are measured as rock; the on-site confirmation and record trail for class disputes; and the valuation adjustment boundary where the actual class differs from the BOQ item description.
Core Conclusions
1. Classification tables and table numbers under the BOQ
Table A.4.3 of Annex A, GB/T 50854-2024, original text: 'Soil class and rock class in the item description may be determined per Tables A.4.3-1 and A.4.3-2, with descriptions of dry or wet soil added if needed. Where soil class or rock class cannot be fixed precisely, describe on the basis of the geotechnical investigation report.'
Table A.4.3-1 soil classification - classes 1-2 / class 3 / class 4, judged by 'soil name plus excavation method':
- Classes 1-2: silt, sandy soil (silty sand, fine sand, medium sand, coarse sand, gravelly sand), silty clay, weak-to-moderate saline soil, soft soil (mucky soil, peat, peaty soil), soft-plastic red clay, hydraulic fill; 'excavated with a shovel, with occasional use of pick and mattock; machines can dig and load to full capacity directly'.
- Class 3: clay, gravelly soil (rounded gravel, angular gravel) mixed soil, plastic red clay, stiff-plastic red clay, strongly saline soil, plain fill, compacted fill; 'excavated mainly with pick and mattock, with some shovel; machines need partial loosening before digging to full capacity, or can dig directly but not to full capacity'.
- Class 4: gravelly soil (cobbles, crushed stone, boulders, block stone), very stiff red clay, excessively saline soil, miscellaneous fill; 'excavated entirely with pick and mattock, occasionally with crowbar; machines must loosen throughout before digging to full capacity'.
- Table note: soil names and their meanings are defined by GB 50021-2001, code for investigation of geotechnical engineering (2009 partial revision).
Table A.4.3-2 rock classification - extremely soft rock, soft rock, relatively soft rock, relatively hard rock, extremely hard rock (soft rock group / hard rock group), judged by 'representative rock plus excavation method', with parallel bands of saturated uniaxial compressive strength:
- Extremely soft rock: fully weathered rocks of all kinds, all diagenetically immature rocks; 'partly excavated with hand cutting tools, partly by blasting'; saturated uniaxial compressive strength below 5 MPa.
- Soft rock: strongly weathered extremely hard or relatively hard rock, moderately to strongly weathered relatively soft rock, unweathered to slightly weathered shale / mudstone / argillaceous sandstone and the like; 'excavated with pneumatic pick and blasting'; 5-15 MPa.
- Relatively soft rock: moderately to strongly weathered extremely hard or relatively hard rock and similar; less weathered extremely hard and relatively hard rock moves further up the bands to extremely hard rock.
2. 'Loose rock / sub-hard rock / ordinary hard rock / extra-hard rock' belong to the quota system, not the BOQ classification
Note to the Protodyakonov classification, original text: 'Classes I and II in the table are soil classes 1 and 2 of the items (ordinary soil); class III is soil class 3 of the items (firm soil); class IV is soil class 4 of the items (gravelly firm soil); class V is loose rock of the items (soil class 5); sub-classes VI-VIII are sub-hard rock of the items (soil class 6); classes IX-X are ordinary hard rock of the items (soil class 7); classes XI-XVI are extra-hard rock of the items (soil class 8).' The water sector separately uses Table A.1.2, 'grading table of soil classes for general works', in Annex A.1.2 of GB 50501-2007, code of valuation with bill of quantities for water conservancy works. Practical position: BOQ item descriptions are entered as four soil classes / five rock classes (excavation method as the main criterion), while rate application aligns items with the classification table of the quota volume actually used; saturated uniaxial compressive strength, weathering degree and joint development serve only as corroboration and cannot replace the 'excavation method' criterion.
3. Boulders: do they count as rock, and at what threshold
- The building works BOQ position has no volume threshold, only a qualitative boundary: the notes to Table A.4.1 of GB/T 50854-2024 state that 'standalone earthworks items mean the earthworks carried out to bring the site to the preset level (design outdoor level / bottom level of the outdoor ground finish / level specified by the client). Obstruction clearance in the working content means the clearing of natural obstructions that can be removed together with the earthworks during excavation.' That is, boulders removable together with the earthworks are already inside the earthwork all-in unit rate and not charged again; boulders requiring separate breaking, crushing or blasting exceed the original earthwork item's working content and are listed separately as rock items (rock items under standalone earthworks 010101 and foundation earthworks 010102), or handled as BOQ omissions / variations.
- The water sector has explicit volume bands: Annex A.1.2 of GB 50501-2007 provides that 'in soil excavation containing boulders, boulders larger than 0.7 m3 are measured as rock excavation'; the same clause provides that 'the quantity rule for earth excavation BOQ items measures the effective natural volume within the contour dimensions shown on the tender design drawings; the cost of over-excavation and construction additions incurred during construction shall be spread into the unit rate of the effective quantity' and 'earth excavation includes spoil transport; where excavation and transport are in different sections, the excavation and transport working contents are measured separately'.
4. Confirmation chain for class disputes
- The geotechnical investigation report is the first-priority basis (Table A.4.3, original text: 'where the class cannot be fixed precisely, describe on the basis of the investigation report').
- Check on site against excavation method: can it be dug directly with shovel / pick / mattock, can machines dig to full capacity (soil); are hand cutting tools, pneumatic pick or blasting needed (rock).
- Take rock samples for saturated uniaxial compressive strength (or point-load conversion) as quantitative corroboration, cross-checked against the investigation description.
- Procedural record trail, along the two lines of concealed works acceptance and site instruction records: 'the project supervision agency shall require the contractor to self-inspect the concealed works before acceptance and confirm the self-inspection passed'; 'the supervising engineer shall attend on time to inspect and accept the concealed works and sign off those accepted'; 'the works to be concealed shall be measured and checked ... with written records formed and archived'. Site instruction records require that 'before implementation, a site survey be made and the original condition measured and recorded', that 'when the event occurs, quantities and similar information be measured and recorded promptly and image records kept', and that the record 'be reported in writing to the employer for approval after sign-off by the chief supervising engineer'. Among these, 'demolition and handling costs of unforeseeable underground obstructions' fall within recordable items, while 'preliminaries foreseeable from the contractor's construction experience' may not be recorded.
5. Price adjustment boundary where the actual class differs from the BOQ description
- Unit-rate contracts: where the description of any item differs between the design drawings (including design changes) and the tender BOQ and the difference changes the cost, the all-in unit rate is re-determined on the item description actually constructed and the contract price adjusted (GB 50500-2013 clause 9.4.2); newly added work items from BOQ omissions follow clause 9.5.1, with rates per clause 9.3.1; quantity deviations follow clause 9.6.2: 'when the quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased part shall be lowered; when the quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining part shall be raised' (clause 9.3.1 likewise routes variation-caused deviations beyond 15% to clause 9.6.2).
- GB/T 50500-2024 position: unit-rate contracts are re-measured per clause 8.2.1; quantity changes from BOQ errors within 15% (15% included) adjust per clause 8.9.1, beyond 15% (15% excluded) per clause 8.9.2; clause 8.9.2 requires, when items or quantities increase, pricing 'after reasonably lowering the contract unit rate and the new all-in unit rate, taking account of the labour and material purchase price discounts brought by the increased quantity', and correspondingly 'reasonably raising' when quantities fall.
- Lump-sum contracts run the other way: clause 4.1.6 provides that price changes caused by BOQ errors 'are deemed already included in the total contract price and are not adjusted during performance'; only BOQ items stated as provisional quantities and their quantities are re-measured under the unit-rate pricing rules.
Applicability Boundaries
- The item description basis follows building and decoration works (GB/T 50854-2024); water, highway, railway and municipal works each have their own classification tables and item settings, and cross-sector borrowing must return to that sector's measurement standard and quota volume notes.
- The 0.7 m3 boulder threshold is the water BOQ position and cannot be imported directly into the building BOQ; building works judge qualitatively by 'whether it can be removed together with the earthworks', and any executable threshold needs contract agreement or confirmed site instruction record / variation documents.
- Grading by saturated uniaxial compressive strength or point-load conversion belongs to geotechnical investigation / foundation standards, a different system from the BOQ classification tables; the single frk index cannot replace the excavation-method criterion.
- Class disputes not documented through the inspection, site instruction record and variation procedures can rarely support a later unilateral claim of a higher class as a measurement and valuation basis.
- GB 50500-2013 has been replaced by GB/T 50500-2024: new works follow the 2024 edition, and the 2013 position applies to legacy contracts signed under the old edition.
Further Reading
Annex A of GB/T 50854-2024: Table A.1.1 (standalone earthworks, code 010101), Table A.2.1 (foundation earthworks, code 010102), Table A.4.1, Tables A.4.3-1 and A.4.3-2; Annex A.1.2 of GB 50501-2007 (including Table A.1.2, grading of soil classes for general works); Annex C of SJG 111.1-2022, soil and rock (Protodyakonov) classification table; GB 50021-2001 (2009 partial revision, soil name definitions); GB 50500-2013 clauses 9.3.1, 9.4.2, 9.5.1, 9.6.2; GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 4.1.6, 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2; concealed works acceptance and site instruction record procedures in clause 5.4.3 of DB37/T 5028-2022 and clauses 10.6.1 and 10.6.3 of T/SDJZXH 004.1-2022.
Keywords
- 土壤及岩石分类
- 土类别岩石类别判定
- 孤石
- 障碍物清除
- 松石次坚石普坚石
- 项目特征不符
- 工程量偏差15%
- 地勘报告