Cost variance attribution analysis: three-factor decomposition into quantity, price, and efficiency variances (earned value routing + chain substitution method)
Split cost into the three factors "quantity × unit consumption × unit price": first use earned value to route (SV = BCWP − BCWS isolates the quantity variance at budget prices; CV = BCWP − ACWP contains only price and efficiency effects), then use the chain substitution method to decompose: quantity variance = (Q₁−Q₀)R₀P₀, efficiency variance = Q₁(R₁−R₀)P₀, price variance = Q₁R₁(P₁−P₀); their sum equals the total variance, providing a reconciliation check. Material cost must be further split into the "quantity-of-works variance" (attributable to measurement/design, claimable) and the "wastage variance" (attributable to crew management, internally assessed).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范 11.3.2/11.5.1~11.5.3
- GB/T 50358-2017 建设项目工程总承包管理规范 2.0.8
- T/ZSQX 023-2023 城镇给排水项目工程总承包管理规程 14.4.2
- DB62/T 3214-2021 建筑工程施工项目信息化管理标准 7.6.2
Topic Positioning
Answers "is the cost variance caused by quantities, prices, or construction efficiency": split cost into the three factors quantity × unit consumption × unit price, and decompose in two steps — earned value routing + the chain substitution method — into the three attributable components of quantity, efficiency, and price variances; this is the general algorithm of project cost analysis (monthly analysis, profit/loss attribution).
Core Conclusions
Cost = quantity Q × unit consumption R × unit price P. Target Q₀R₀P₀, actual Q₁R₁P₁. Two-step decomposition: ① Earned value routing (GB/T 50358-2017, Clause 2.0.8): SV = BCWP − BCWS is in fact the quantity difference converted at budget prices, routing out the "quantity variance"; CV = BCWP − ACWP contains only unit price and consumption effects, naturally separating out "quantity". ② Chain substitution method (GB/T 50326-2017, Clause 11.5.3, factor analysis): quantity variance = (Q₁−Q₀)R₀P₀; efficiency variance = Q₁(R₁−R₀)P₀; price variance = Q₁R₁(P₁−P₀). Their sum equals the total variance, enabling a reconciliation check. Element-specific points: labor cost — watch over-consumption of worker-days (efficiency/idle time/rework); material cost — watch the wastage variance, which must be further split into the "quantity-of-works variance" (attributable to measurement/design, claimable) and the "wastage variance" (attributable to crew management, internally assessed); conflating them mis-attributes responsibility (T/ZSQX 023-2023, Clause 14.4.2); machinery cost — watch shift idle time and selection; indirect costs — watch management efficiency and rates.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to projects with a budget baseline and actual costs collected by unit work; earned value requires a cost basis (without a budget baseline only time comparisons are possible). The three-factor model targets direct-cost items; indirect costs/measure costs need different indicators. Chain substitution results depend on the substitution order — fix the order and state the basis in the report; in BIM scenarios, the cost management model can auto-extract quantities to support the three-cost comparison.
Further Reading
See GB/T 50358-2017 Clause 2.0.8 (earned value BCWS/BCWP/ACWP and CV/SV definitions); GB/T 50326-2017 Clause 11.3.2 (cost control procedure — value engineering and earned value recommended for finding variances) and Clauses 11.5.1–11.5.3 (cost analysis bases, content, and basic methods); T/ZSQX 023-2023 Clause 14.4.2 (labor/material/machinery/equipment price and quantity variance analysis); DB62/T 3214-2021 Clause 7.6.2 (the actual/planned/target variance measures).
Keywords
- 成本偏差归因
- 量差
- 价差
- 效率差
- 连环替代法
- 因素分析法
- earned value
- 三因素分析
- 成本差异分析