Methods for identifying the major profit points and loss points in project cost planning (item-by-item revenue vs responsibility cost comparison, profit/loss ranking, and dynamic identification via three-cost comparison)
The core of identifying profit/loss points is an item-by-item "contract revenue − responsibility cost" comparison, ranked by profit/loss amount to focus on the major items: in the planning stage via responsibility cost estimation + profit/loss ranking; in the implementation stage via three-cost comparison (budget/target/actual cost), cost variance analysis (actual/planned/target variances) and earned value (CV/SV distinguishing true losses from the schedule-ahead illusion) for dynamic correction, outputting a profit/loss identification table and a cost analysis report.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51235-2017 建筑信息模型施工应用标准 9.3.1
- GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范 11.2.4/11.3.2/11.5.2
- GB/T 50358-2017 建设项目工程总承包管理规范 2.0.8
- RISN-TG 012-2011 建设工程项目经理执业导则 8.3.1/8.3.2/8.4.1
- DB62/T 3214-2021 建筑工程施工项目信息化管理标准 7.6.2
Topic Positioning
This card covers how to identify the major profit points and loss points during project cost planning and implementation: item-by-item "revenue − responsibility cost" comparison, ranking by profit/loss amount to focus on the major items, and dynamic tracking via three-cost comparison, cost variance analysis, and earned value — the general playbook for pre-event cost control and in-process correction.
Core Conclusions
Basic principle: the profit/loss of each work item/BOQ item = contract revenue − its responsibility cost; positive is a profit point, negative a loss point; ranked by amount, the top ~20% of items usually determine 80% of the project's profit/loss outcome. Four planning-stage steps: ① estimate responsibility costs item by item with contractor's in-house norm quantities × market prices (detailed for major items, apportioned for small ones); ② compare with contract revenue (revenue must be net of tax and management fee apportionment to get the item's true contribution); ③ rank by profit/loss amount — profit points among "high quantity, high price" items, loss points among "high quantity, low price" items; ④ produce a profit/loss identification table and countermeasures (protect the quantity and quality of profit points; optimize schemes or prepare claims for loss points). Implementation-stage dynamic identification: three-cost comparison (budget cost, target cost, and actual cost compared periodically); cost variance analysis on three variances — actual variance (budget vs actual), planned variance (target vs budget), target variance (target vs actual); earned value uses CV = BCWP − ACWP for the cost variance, combined with SV to distinguish "true loss" from "temporary overspending caused by running ahead of schedule". Outputs: a profit/loss identification table and a cost analysis report (indicator completion, profit/loss causes, proposed measures).
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to project-level cost planning and process control in construction enterprises, supported by contractor's in-house norms and a responsibility cost estimation system; identification quality depends on the accuracy of responsibility cost estimation, whose basis is set along the target cost/planned cost/responsibility cost chain. Tender-stage profit estimation is upstream and cost assessment downstream — not covered here; no specific project pricing or regional prices included.
Further Reading
See GB/T 51235-2017, Standard for Construction Application of Building Information Modeling, Clause 9.3.1 (three-cost comparison); GB/T 50326-2017, Code for Construction Project Management, Clauses 11.2.4, 11.3.2, 11.5.2 (cost plan preparation procedure, cost control procedure, cost analysis content); GB/T 50358-2017, Code for Management of Engineering Procurement Construction (EPC) Projects, Clause 2.0.8 (earned value BCWS/BCWP/ACWP and the CV, SV formulas); RISN-TG 012-2011, Guideline for the Practice of Construction Project Managers, Clauses 8.3.1, 8.3.2, 8.4.1 (planned pre-control / process control / corrective control, cost analysis report, whole-process accounting management); DB62/T 3214-2021 Clause 7.6.2 (the three variances of cost variance analysis).
Keywords
- 盈利点
- 亏损点
- 成本策划
- estimate-budget-final account comparison
- responsibility-centre cost
- 盈亏识别
- 成本差异分析
- earned value