Attribution of quantity gaps between BOQ quantities and quota quantities, and the rate conversion: all-in unit rate P = Sum(Tn) / Q, four destinations of quantity gaps (into the BOQ quantity / into the rate / into quota consumption / into the risk allowance), and conversion points for typical work items
BOQ quantities and quota quantities must be kept on two separate tracks and never swapped: first attribute each quantity gap to one of four classes - content already built into the measurement rules (working space for earthworks) goes into the BOQ quantity; content listed under 'work content' but given no quantity (battering, shoring boards, base trimming and clearing) goes only into the ancillary-works cost or risk allowance inside the all-in unit rate; content carried by the quota through wastage rates or contents (material wastage, rebar wastage plus construction bars at 5%, permissible overbreak in rock works, 0.50m over-concreting of bored piles) goes into the numerator, the quota line-item totals; whatever neither the BOQ nor the quota provides can only go into the rate risk allowance. The conversion formula is P = Sum(Tn) / Q (P rounded to 2 decimal places, Tn kept at full precision without rounding, Q rounded to 3 decimal places). Quoting with quota quantities passed off as BOQ quantities is an explicit error: the dimensional bases differ, the all-in unit rate is understated (omission ratio = 1 - quota rate / all-in rate), and it blurs the parties' respective responsibilities for BOQ accuracy.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.9条、第3.1.6条、第3.3.3条、第6.1.6条、第8.2.1条、第8.9.2条
- GB/T 50854-2024 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算标准 App. A Table A.2.1(基础土石方 010102)
- GB/T 50857-2024 市政工程工程量计算标准 App. J J.2.1
- DBJ/T 15-145-2018 建设工程政府投资项目造价数据标准 第6.1.4条
- DB11/T 2382-2024 建设工程施工消耗量标准 第3.3.1、4.2.6、4.2.15、4.6.5、4.6.6、7.1.32~7.1.34条
- DL/T 5469-2013 输变电工程可行性研究投资估算编制导则 第4.1.5条
- DB62/T 3081-2018 绿色建筑施工与验收规范 第10.2.8条
- TB/T 10831-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 10 房屋工程 册说明(工程量计算规则)
Scope and purpose
This card answers one core question at the rate build-up stage: BOQ quantities and quota quantities are two different rulers - how is the gap between them attributed, and how is it converted into the all-in unit rate? It applies to tender pricing and settlement review of unit-rate contract works priced on a BOQ basis using consumption quota manuals (budget quota manuals).
Core conclusions
1. Premise: two separate tracks, not one ruler
The BOQ quantity is computed under the 'measurement rules' of the quantity take-off standard and is the external basis for measurement and settlement; the quota quantity is computed under the consumption standard's rules plus its consumption rates and is the internal cost basis. The two are computed independently: they must be neither swapped nor converted into each other by one blanket coefficient.
2. Conversion formula and variable definitions (original text)
DBJ/T 15-145-2018, Cost Data Standard for Government-Invested Construction Projects, clause 6.1.4:
'The all-in unit rate of a BOQ item shall be calculated by the formula: P = Sum(Tn) / Q where P is the all-in unit rate of the BOQ item, rounded to 2 decimal places; Tn is the total price of each quota line item applied under the BOQ item, computed at full precision (decimal places not rounded); Q is the quantity of the BOQ item, rounded to 3 decimal places.'
The clause commentary further limits it: 'this standard provides that for BOQ items priced by applying quota line items, the all-in unit rate is the sum of the applied quota line-item totals divided by the BOQ item quantity ... the standard, from a data-standard perspective, fixes and unifies how all-in unit rates of BOQ items are determined under BOQ-based pricing.' The doctrinal basis is the all-in unit rate term in GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.9:
'The cost of completing one unit quantity of a BOQ item after comprehensively allowing for technical standards and codes, construction period, construction sequence, construction conditions, geography and climate, and risks within the agreed scope and bands. The all-in unit rate of a BOQ item includes labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, overheads, profit and risk costs within a defined range, and excludes value added tax.'
Clause 3.1.6: 'The all-in unit rates and prices of BOQ items shall be pre-tax fully inclusive prices excluding value added tax ... including the risk costs within the agreed or reasonable scope of the corresponding BOQ items and the costs of indispensable ancillary works.'
The qualifier 'the cost of completing one unit quantity of the BOQ item' is precisely the doctrinal basis for converting quantity gaps: the rate must carry the entire real cost of completing that one unit of BOQ quantity, including parts the measurement rules give no quantity for.
3. Four-way attribution of quantity gaps (attribute first, then apply coefficients)
| Class | Typical content | Destination | Key normative basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Already in the measurement rules | Working space for earthworks | The BOQ quantity itself | GB/T 50854-2024 table A.2.1, excavation of pits/trenches: measured by volume as the bottom area of the foundation (cushion included) as shown on the design plus the working-space area, multiplied by the excavation depth |
| B. Listed as 'work content' (no quantity given) | Battering, shoring boards, loading, on-site haulage, base trimming and clearing, base compaction, base probing | Ancillary-works cost / risk allowance inside the all-in unit rate | The first entry of the 'work content' column of the same table is 'excavation, battering where required, shoring where required' |
| C. Already in quota consumption | Wastage beyond net material quantities; rebar wastage plus chairs/supports/positioning bars at a combined 5% of rebar; permissible overbreak in rock works; over-concreting length of bored piles (0.50m where the design is silent) | The numerator Sum(Tn) of quota line-item totals, not a separately listed quantity | DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 3.3.1 'consumption of principal and auxiliary materials covers net quantities and wastage'; clause 4.6.5 'rebar wastage plus construction bars totals 5% of rebar quantity'; clause 4.2.6 'consumption of rock works ... shall include the overbreak permitted by the code'; TB/T 10831-2024 volume notes 'the quantity of concrete placed is the design pile-diameter area multiplied by the design pile length (pile tip included) plus the over-concreting length ... 0.50m where unspecified' |
| D. Only the rate risk remains | Actual wastage beyond the quota band; over-concreting beyond design; battering steeper than the quota assumption; non-designed laps and construction bars excluded from the BOQ but unavoidable in execution | Risk allowance | GB/T 50857-2024 Appendix J J.2.1 'apart from laps shown on the design, other laps are not counted in the quantities ... quantities of chairs, raking props, anti-floating bars, spacers and other construction bars not required by the design are not measured'; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.3.3 listing the measurement and pricing risks borne by the contractor and to be allowed for in the tender |
Three questions fix the destination: (1) does the 'measurement rules' column of the take-off standard count it - if yes it is class A, into the BOQ quantity; (2) if not in the rules column, does it appear in the item's 'work content' column - if yes it is class B, the cost goes into the rate; (3) if neither, does the consumption quota carry it as a wastage rate or content - if yes it is class C, into the quota line-item totals; if all three answers are no, it can only be class D, the risk allowance.
4. The most misjudged, largest-value item: battering
GB/T 50854-2024 table A.2.1 places battering under 'work content' rather than 'measurement rules', so the extra excavation from battering is not measured; on the consumption side, DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 4.2.15 requires the quota quantity to 'be computed by volume as the excavation bottom area multiplied by depth, plus locally deepened parts and the batter increment where battering is required'. The same battering is unmeasured on the BOQ side and measured on the quota side - the most typical and largest source of quantity gaps, and direct proof that BOQ quantities must never simply reuse quota quantities.
5. Conversion points for typical work items
Earthworks: BOQ quantity = bottom area of the foundation (cushion included) as shown on the design plus working-space area, multiplied by excavation depth, excluding battering; quota quantity = the battered prism volume including working space. On one worked example (pit bottom 20m x 10m, depth 4m, working space 0.3m per side, batter coefficient K=0.33, machine excavation inside the pit): under the 2024-edition basis the BOQ quantity = (20+0.6) x (10+0.6) x 4 ~ 873 m3, quota quantity ~ 1047 m3, gap coefficient ~ 1.20; against the 2013-edition basis of 'cushion bottom area x depth' (= 800 m3) the coefficient is about 1.31. The gap coefficient moves with the edition of the measurement rules and must be recomputed under the current rules - old or rule-of-thumb coefficients must not be carried over. Note also: the BOQ-side classification of trenches/pits/general earthworks (thresholds of bottom width, bottom length, bottom area) decides which BOQ item applies and may differ from the quota-side classification; judge each separately.
Rebar: the BOQ quantity is by mass from design-drawn dimensions; GB/T 50857-2024 Appendix J J.2.1 provides that 'anchorage bars projecting from cast elements, lifting hooks of precast elements and support bars fixing position shall be taken into rebar quantities; apart from laps shown on the design, other laps are not counted in the quantities'; on the quota side DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 4.6.5 takes 'wastage plus construction bars' into construction consumption at 5% of total rebar, and clause 7.1.33 provides that where the design and codes are silent 'for rebar up to d10, one lap per 12m length; for rebar beyond d10, one lap per 9m length'; where the design requires mechanical connection, the parallel-thread sleeve coupling item applies and lap rebar quantities are no longer measured (clause 7.1.32). In short: laps and construction bars are the classic items the BOQ excludes and the quota includes; their gap is spread into the rate through the numerator and must not be added back into the BOQ quantity.
Concrete: BOQ quantity = the solid volume of design-drawn dimensions, with no deduction for rebar, embedded plates, bolts and single holes up to 0.30 m2 (DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 4.6.6); quota quantity = net quantity x (1 + wastage rate), the control value for ready-mixed concrete wastage generally 1.5% (DB62/T 3081-2018 clause 10.2.8 'wastage of ready-mixed concrete shall be under 1.5%'). The gap appears only as the material-cost increment in the numerator and does not change the BOQ quantity.
6. One-line general rule: wastage is charged, not measured
DL/T 5469-2013 clause 4.1.5: 'Material wastage shall not be counted into building and installation quantities; wastage cost shall be computed at the wastage rates fixed by the quota manual and aggregated into material cost. The rule is shortened to: wastage is charged, not measured.' Local consumption standards take the same line: 'construction intra-site haulage wastage from the site warehouse or central stockpile (or processing point) to the working (installation) point, operational wastage and site stockpiling wastage; the reserve and lap quantities required by the BOQ standard (design documents) are not treated as wastage' - reserve and lap quantities already listed in the BOQ must not be counted again as wastage, to avoid charging twice.
7. Quoting quota quantities as BOQ quantities: explicit error (prohibited)
- Different dimensional bases: the quota quantity is a construction-consumption basis (wastage, operational allowances, battering, over-concreting, overbreak included); the BOQ quantity is a measurement-rule basis. Entering quota quantities into the BOQ bills the increments as if they were net quantities, and they will be clawed back when settlement remeasures against the contract drawings.
- Understated rate: a bid built as 'quota quantity x quota rate / quota quantity' in effect quotes only the quota rate, leaving all class B and class C costs outside the rate. On the earthworks example above (gap coefficient about 1.20), the omission ratio against the correct all-in rate = 1 - quota rate / all-in rate ~ 16.6%, i.e. the rate is understated by about one sixth.
- Misplaced responsibility: for tendered works on unit-rate contracts, completeness and accuracy of the divisional and sub-divisional works BOQ rest with the tenderer (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 6.1.6), though the contractor must still verify it; clause 3.3.3 lists as contractor-borne risks to be priced in 'the costs of all works needed to complete the works described by the BOQ and its item descriptions and by the work content statements of the national and sector quantity take-off standards'. Mixing the two quantity systems deranges both parties' responsibility boundaries at once.
- Do not conflate two layers: the rate adjustment triggered at settlement when BOQ quantities move beyond 15% (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.2.1: up to 15% inclusive under clause 8.9.1, beyond 15% exclusive under clause 8.9.2) belongs to the separate layer of contract price adjustment and is a different matter from the quota-to-BOQ quantity-gap conversion done at the rate build-up stage.
Applicability limits
- The premise is a unit-rate contract priced on a BOQ basis with consumption/budget quota manuals. The P = Sum(Tn) / Q formula in DBJ/T 15-145-2018 clause 6.1.4 is one local standard's general formula; where a region has no counterpart it may be cited as a general method, but the standards applicable to the project govern.
- Wastage rates, batter coefficients and working-space widths differ by region and sector (DB11/T 2382-2024, new local consumption standards and the railway TB/T 10831-2024 each have their own tables); use the edition applicable to the project and never transplant consumption figures across regions or sectors.
- Sector differences are real: railways, highways and power (DL/T 5469-2013) each have their own measurement rules and quota systems; attribution conclusions for individual items may differ - check your sector's rules before applying.
- Under lump-sum contracts the risk split for BOQ errors differs (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.3.3 item 2); the conversion logic in this card is mainly for unit-rate contracts.
- Dimensions and coefficients in the worked example only demonstrate the method; actual values follow the construction drawings, the approved project execution plan and the applicable quota tables.
- The card involves no unit rates, amounts or settlement conclusions for any specific project.
Further reading
- The conversion formula and its commentary: DBJ/T 15-145-2018, Cost Data Standard for Government-Invested Construction Projects, clause 6.1.4
- All-in unit rate scope and the pre-tax fully inclusive price: GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.9 (term), 3.1.6 (basic provisions)
- Risk allocation and BOQ responsibility: GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 3.3.3, 6.1.6, 8.2.1, 8.9.2
- BOQ measurement rules and work content for earth and rock works: GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix A, table A.2.1 (foundation earthworks, code 010102), table A.4.5 (trench/pit/general earthworks classification), table A.4.6 (working-space widths)
- Rebar BOQ measurement rules: GB/T 50857-2024 Appendix J J.2.1
- Consumption-side bases: DB11/T 2382-2024 clauses 3.3.1 (net quantity plus wastage), 4.2.6 (permissible rock overbreak), 4.2.15 (batter increment in quota quantities), 4.6.5 (rebar 5%), 4.6.6 (concrete no-deduction scope), 7.1.32~7.1.34 (rebar wastage, lap rules, parallel-thread sleeves); DB62/T 3081-2018 clause 10.2.8 (ready-mixed concrete wastage under 1.5%); DL/T 5469-2013 clause 4.1.5 (wastage charged, not measured); TB/T 10831-2024 Volume 10 Building Works, volume notes, measurement rules (0.50m over-concreting of bored piles, 0.50m added for CFG and soil-mixing columns)
Keywords
- 清单工程量
- 定额工程量
- all-in unit rate
- 组价换算
- 量差系数
- wastage rate
- 放坡增量
- 工作内容
- 措施钢筋