Differences in final account adjustment between lump-sum contracts (fixed total price) and unit-rate contracts (fixed unit rates): treatment rules for quantity changes, BOQ errors, design changes and cost fluctuation, mapped to GB/T 50500-2024 clause numbers
GB/T 50500-2024 uses 'lump-sum contract / unit-rate contract' rather than 'fixed total price / fixed unit rate'; the substantive difference lies in the allocation of quantity and price risk. A lump-sum contract wraps up both quantities and prices - the measured-works BOQ items need not be re-measured, and price changes arising from BOQ errors are deemed included in the contract total and are not adjusted during performance (clauses 4.1.6, 7.2.2, 8.2.3); only 'provisional quantity' unit-rate-priced items and variations may be adjusted. A unit-rate contract fixes the rates and re-measures the quantities - all BOQ items and quantities of the measured works must be re-measured, BOQ errors fall on the employer, and quantity changes are priced under clause 8.9.1 or clause 8.9.2 depending on the 15% (inclusive / exclusive) boundary (clauses 2.0.6, 4.1.4, 8.2.1). The adjustment rules for cost fluctuation (where no band is agreed, adjustment under Annex A is allowed once the movement exceeds 5%, the differential bearing VAT only, with no overheads or profit) and for changes in laws and regulations and policy are identical for both contract types.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第2.0.6条、第2.0.7条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.3.5条、第3.4.6条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第4.1.4条、第4.1.6条、第6.1.7条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第7.2.1条、第7.2.2条、第7.4.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.1.1条、第8.2.1条、第8.2.3条、第8.7.2条、第8.8.1条、第8.9.1~8.9.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第10.3.2条、App. A(A.1.6 价格指数基准日)
- GB/T 51095-2015 · Code for construction cost consultation 第8.2.5条
Topic positioning
Compares, under GB/T 50500-2024 (national BOQ pricing standard), the adjustment requirements of 'lump-sum contract' versus 'unit-rate contract' at the settlement stage (measurement and price adjustment): how quantity changes, BOQ errors, design changes (variations) and cost fluctuation are each handled and on which clause. It answers 'fixed total price vs fixed unit price: what differs at settlement' and also serves contract pricing-mode selection and settlement dispute assessment.
Core conclusions
1. Conceptual premise: the standard terms are 'lump-sum contract / unit-rate contract'
'Fixed total price contract / fixed unit price contract' is trade parlance; the substance of the standard is 'no adjustment within the agreed scope', not absolute non-adjustability - the difference lies in who carries the risk and what triggers re-pricing.
- Unit-rate contract (clause 2.0.6): the employer and the contractor agree to calculate, adjust and confirm the contract price on the basis of the BOQ, the item descriptions and their all-in unit rates; 'under a unit-rate contract the contract rates are not adjusted within the agreed scope'; 'the all-in unit rates of the contract BOQ remain unchanged within the conditions agreed in the contract and are adjusted in accordance with the contract once those conditions are exceeded; the BOQ items and quantities are determined by the works actually executed by the contractor and liable to be measured'.
- Lump-sum contract (clause 2.0.7): the contract price is calculated, adjusted and confirmed on the basis of the contract drawings and the contract specifications; 'under a lump-sum contract the contract total is not adjusted within the agreed scope'; 'where the construction drawings and the relevant conditions of the works do not change, the parties may not rely on changes in the BOQ items and quantities as a basis for adjusting the contract price; where the construction drawings and the relevant conditions change, the parties may adjust the contract price according to the changes and the contract'.
- In one sentence: a unit-rate contract = rates fixed, quantities re-measured (quantity risk on the employer); a lump-sum contract = quantities and prices both wrapped up (BOQ quantity differences on the contractor; only drawing or condition changes, i.e. variations, trigger adjustment).
2. Comparison table of settlement adjustment requirements
| Adjustment item | Lump-sum contract ('fixed total price') | Unit-rate contract ('fixed unit rate') | GB/T 50500-2024 clause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basis of settlement measurement | The measured-works BOQ need not be re-measured, and the contract price shall not be adjusted for BOQ errors; only 'unit-rate-priced items with provisional quantities' and variations are measured separately | All BOQ items and quantities of the measured works in the contract drawings must be re-measured and priced on the quantities actually executed and liable to be measured | 7.2.2, 7.2.1, 8.2.1 |
| Change in BOQ quantities (quantity difference, not a variation) | Not a basis for adjustment: BOQ errors consisting of differences between the contract BOQ and the contract drawings may be left unadjusted | Quantity deviations found on re-measurement constitute BOQ errors and shall be adjusted: quantity change at or below 15% (15% inclusive) under clause 8.9.1; over 15% (15% exclusive) under clause 8.9.2 | 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2, 7.2.2 |
| BOQ errors (wrong or missing items, mismatched item descriptions, quantity differences) | The contractor bears the duty to complete and rectify, not adjusted under clause 6.1.7; price changes arising from BOQ errors are deemed included in the contract total and not adjusted during performance; preliminaries and the contract duration are likewise not adjusted for such errors. Exception: BOQ items whose item description states 'provisional quantities' have their quantities re-measured under the unit-rate pricing rules with corresponding adjustment of the contract price and the contract total | The employer bears the responsibility for the relevant BOQ errors, adjusted under Section 8.2; quantity changes banded at the 15% boundary | 4.1.4, 4.1.6, 8.2.3, 8.2.1 |
| Re-pricing where the quantity change exceeds 15% | This rule is engaged only where the contract stipulates that the contract rates apply to pricing variations | Where BOQ items and quantities increase - the contract rates and the new all-in unit rates are reasonably reduced in light of the bulk-purchase price discounts on labour and materials attributable to the increased quantities; where they decrease - reasonably increased in light of the loss of those discounts | 8.9.2; banding at or below 15% see 8.9.1 |
| Design change (variation) | Differences between the contract BOQ and the contract drawings are BOQ errors that may be left unadjusted; differences between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings are variations, measured under the variation rules (clause 7.4.3); pricing in two modes: where the contract stipulates that the contract rates apply to pricing variations - adjusted under clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2; where it stipulates they do not - the parties negotiate the all-in unit rates according to the execution of the works and market prices, in combination with the priced-BOQ pricing rules and the tendered rate level | The variation-confirmed quantities are priced and adjusted under clauses 8.9.1 (at or below 15%) and 8.9.2 (over 15%) | 7.2.2, 7.4.3, 8.9.3, 8.9.1, 8.9.2 |
| Which prevails on inconsistency of the pricing basis | Where the contract drawings and specifications are inconsistent with the priced BOQ, the contract drawings and specifications prevail | Where the contract drawings are inconsistent with the tendered measured-works BOQ, the BOQ prevails | 3.4.6 |
| Cost fluctuation | Identical rules for both contract types: only the labour cost, the materials cost and the fuel and power cost within the plant and small tools cost agreed in the contract as adjustable are adjusted for fluctuation; adjustment only where the movement exceeds the band agreed in the contract; where no band is agreed or the agreement is unclear, a movement beyond 5% may be adjusted by one of the Annex A methods (A.1 index-based adjustment / A.2 adjustment based on published price information) | Same as left | 8.7.2, 3.3.5, Annex A |
| Basis for recovering cost differentials | Identical for both: differentials on the labour cost, the materials cost and the fuel and power cost within the plant and small tools cost in the all-in unit rate bear VAT only, with no overheads or profit | Same as left | 3.3.5 |
| Base date for adjustment | Identical: for tendered works, the price indices 28 days before the tender submission deadline; for non-tendered works, 28 days before the contract signing date | Same as left | Annex A.1.6 |
| Changes in laws, regulations and policies | Both contract types adjustable: where newly enacted, amended or repealed laws, regulations and policy provisions, or changed government interpretations of the relevant laws and regulations, cause an increase or decrease in the contract price and/or a delay to the works, adjustment follows the contract and the rules issued on that basis by the national, provincial or sector construction authorities and their authorised cost administration bodies | Same as left | 8.8.1, 8.1.1 |
| Method of preparing the final account | On the basis of the contract total, adjusting the contents agreed in the contract as adjustable and the risk factors beyond the agreed scope | The all-in unit rates within the contractual risk scope remain unchanged; measurement as agreed in the contract, and pricing on the quantities actually executed | GB/T 51095-2015 clause 8.2.5 |
3. Banding order within the 15% boundary (unit-rate contract, clause 8.9.1)
Same construction conditions + same item description -> adopt the corresponding contract rate; same construction conditions + similar item description, or similar construction conditions + same item description -> adopt the all-in unit rate obtained by converting and adjusting the contract rate of a similar BOQ item; same construction conditions + different item description, or different construction conditions + same item description -> negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate based on the execution of the works, in combination with the contract-rate pricing rules and tendered rate level of similar items; different construction conditions + different item description -> negotiate by reference to the all-in unit rates of similar BOQ items in works of the same kind; where the reduction or cancellation of BOQ items materially changes the construction conditions during execution, the varied all-in unit rate may be negotiated on the specifics of the executed works, market prices, the contract-rate pricing rules and the tendered rate level.
4. Order of items in the settlement document (common to both contract types, clause 10.3.2)
Contract BOQ total -> adjustment for BOQ errors -> adjustment for provisional sums -> adjustment for provisional prices (materials / nominated specialist works) -> adjustment of the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions -> adjustment of dayworks -> adjustment for changes in costs -> adjustment for changes in laws, regulations and policies -> increase or decrease from variations -> price of additional works -> claim amounts -> liquidated damages -> other amounts.
Boundaries of application
- Terminology mapping: where 'fixed total price / fixed unit rate' appears, it must first be mapped to the standard terms 'lump-sum contract / unit-rate contract'; the standard stresses non-adjustment 'within the agreed scope', and where the contract agrees a wider or narrower adjustable scope, the contract prevails (agreed terms prevail).
- The above rules address construction contracting on a BOQ basis and do not directly apply to EPC pricing or cost-plus-fee contracts; under cost-plus-fee, the works cost, the fee and the relevant taxes are calculated by the method agreed in the contract (GB/T 51095-2015 clause 8.2.5).
- 'Provisional quantities' is the only outlet for quantity adjustment under a lump-sum contract: where the tender drawings cannot support accurate itemisation and measurement, the BOQ item description shall state 'provisional quantities' and give the provisional quantities, which are then adjusted under the unit-rate pricing rules; items not so flagged cannot afterwards demand adjustment for quantity differences.
- In a lump-sum contract 'the rates in the priced BOQ may form part of the contract documents' and apply, as agreed in the contract, only to pricing variations, additional works and similar price adjustments - they cannot be turned around as a basis for re-measurement and re-pricing.
- Price adjustment during delay periods, force majeure sharing and the like are governed by other clauses and are outside this table.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 (national BOQ pricing standard): clause 2.0.6 (unit-rate contract), clause 2.0.7 (lump-sum contract), clause 3.3.5 (differentials bear VAT only), clause 3.4.6 (priority where drawings/specifications conflict with the BOQ), clause 4.1.4 (allocation of BOQ error responsibility), clause 4.1.6 (no adjustment for BOQ errors under lump-sum contracts and the provisional-quantities exception), clause 6.1.7 (responsibility for errors), clauses 7.2.1-7.2.2 (measurement rules), clause 7.4.3 (measurement of variations), clause 8.1.1 (list of adjustable matters), clauses 8.2.1/8.2.3 (error adjustment), clause 8.7.2 (5% fallback for cost fluctuation), clause 8.8.1 (changes in laws and policies), clauses 8.9.1-8.9.3 (determination of all-in unit rates and the 15% quantity rule), clause 10.3.2 (final account itemisation), Annex A (adjustment methods).
- GB/T 51095-2015 (code for construction cost consultancy), clause 8.2.5 (settlement preparation by contract type).
- Suggested extensions: quantifying bulk-purchase discount adjustments beyond 15%, measurement details for provisional-quantity items, and division of adjustment periods where delay and cost changes overlap.
Keywords
- lump-sum contract
- re-measurable (unit-rate) contract
- 固定总价
- 固定单价
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 工程量偏差15%
- 结算调整
- GB/T 50500-2024