Lease vs. self-build economics for the construction camp (temporary works): the break-even duration method (external pricing unchanged)
Decide with the break-even duration T* = (self-build net cost - lease conversion cost) / monthly rent: below T* leasing is cheaper, above T* self-building is cheaper; self-build net cost = purchase and installation + foundation hardening + utilities and fire provisions + demolition and restoration - residual recovery. External pricing is unchanged whether leased or built (small temps within measure-fee rates, large temps priced with quotas) — this is an internal cost-optimization question; savings become profit.
Applicable Codes
- TB 10801-2024
- TB 10811-2024
- GB 51114-2015
- SJG 86-2020
Topic Positioning
The economic decision method of "lease vs. self-build" for the construction camp (office/living temporary works): use the break-even duration to judge which option is cheaper, and clarify the external pricing caliber.
Core Conclusions
The decision tool is the break-even duration: self-build net cost C-build = purchase and installation + foundation hardening + utilities and fire provisions + demolition and restoration cost - residual recovery (one-time input); total lease cost C-lease(T) = conversion cost + monthly rent x T. The critical duration T* = (C-build - conversion cost) / monthly rent; usage duration below T* makes leasing more economical, above T* self-building. Decision rules: under 1 year, lean to leasing; 1~2 years, compute with local actual prices; over 2 years, self-build; for multi-project continuous transfer scenarios, prefer purchased container units (higher residual ratio than demountable panel buildings, whose residual is generally about 15%~20% of purchase cost); in urban areas or tight land, prefer leasing. Pricing points: whether leased or built, external pricing is unchanged — minor temporary works are already within preliminaries rates (railway = (base-period labour + base-period plant and small tools cost) x rate, rates per TB 10811), heavy temporary works are priced with quotas based on the scale determined in the project execution plan; rent or self-build costs are not additionally charged. This is an internal cost-optimization question — savings are profit.
Applicable Boundaries
Unit prices (panel-building purchase and installation, yard hardening, monthly rent, etc.) are market experience ranges that must be replaced with local quotations before entering the formula; this card gives no fixed prices. Leased dwellings must meet camp standardization compliance (sound and safe, fire-compliant, per-capita dormitory area, indoor clear height, etc.), with conversion costs counted into lease costs; self-building requires temporary land-use procedures, with post-demolition site restoration counted into cost. This card is for cost decisions only and changes no pricing rules.
Further Reading
Minor temporary works basis: TB 10801-2024 "Measures for compiling design estimates (budgets) of railway capital construction projects" Section 3.6 (preliminaries incl. minor temporary works cost); heavy temporary works basis: Section 3.8 (heavy temporary works definition incl. construction and demolition/restoration) + TB 10811-2024 Section 2.8 (single-item estimate by quotas, maintenance quotas); camp sizing: GB 51114-2015 Clause 6.3.8 (peak average headcount x 5~7 m2/person) and Clause 6.3.7; demolition-restoration attribution: contractor temporary works included in preliminaries without double listing, employer temporary works demolition and clearance under site preparation costs (reference SJG 86-2020 Clause 4.4.2).
Keywords
- 驻地
- 临建
- 活动板房
- 箱式房
- 租赁
- 自建
- break-even
- minor temporary works cost