Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Disallowance grounds on final-account review for double counting of earthwork haul distance: the all-in unit rate cost envelope under GB/T 50500-2024 + the "disposal of surplus (excavated) material" itemisation basis in the measurement standards

Earthwork loading and haulage costs are already included in the corresponding billed (BOQ) items' all-in unit rates (GB/T 50500-2024 2.0.9, 3.1.6); haul distance is an item description (work item specification) — where the description states a distance, the contract unit rate has locked the corresponding transport cost, and without a variation or BOQ error no separate charge is allowed (8.9.1 item 1, 7.2.1); duplicated haul costs fall within none of the 13 final-account adjustment categories (10.3.2) and shall be disallowed. Off-site haulage can only be itemised as "disposal of surplus (excavated) material" (GB/T 50854-2024 A.4.13, GB/T 50857-2024 A.4.6); excavation work content covers on-site haulage only.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
  • GB/T 50854-2024 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算标准
  • GB/T 50857-2024 市政工程工程量计算标准

Topic Positioning

The disallowance-grounds chain for "double counting of earthwork haul distance/transport costs" in submitted final accounts: the all-in unit rate cost envelope under the GB/T 50500-2024 system (2.0.9, 3.1.6) plus the companion measurement standards' itemisation basis for "which BOQ item carries the haul distance" (GB/T 50854-2024, GB/T 50857-2024 disposal of surplus (excavated) material) — for direct citation in final account review / construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal) when finding double counting and issuing a disallowance opinion.

Core Conclusions

Core logic: haul-distance costs are already inside the all-in unit rate; without a variation they cannot be charged again. Clause chain (key sentences preserved):

  1. 2.0.9 (term, all-in unit rate): "the cost required to complete one unit quantity of a billed (BOQ) item, comprehensively considering technical standards and specifications, construction duration, construction sequence, construction conditions, geography and climate and other influencing factors, as well as risks within the agreed scope and risk band (no-adjustment tolerance, e.g. ±5%). The all-in unit rate of a BOQ item includes labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management fee, profit and risk costs within a certain range, excluding VAT." — defining the cost envelope, transport included.
  2. 3.1.6: the all-in unit rates and totals of BOQ items "shall be fully inclusive prices excluding VAT, composed of labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management fee, profit, etc., including the agreed or reasonable-scope risk costs of the corresponding BOQ items and the costs of indispensable auxiliary work". Earthwork loading and haulage are "indispensable auxiliary work" of the excavation/disposal BOQ items — already inside the all-in unit rate; the final account shall not list them separately again.
  3. 8.9.1 item 1: where BOQ items under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract change due to a variation or BOQ error, or the BOQ quantity change does not exceed 15% (inclusive), "BOQ items with the same item description executed under the same construction conditions shall adopt the corresponding contract unit rate". Haul distance is part of the item description (e.g., surplus disposal described as "haul 5 km") — the contract unit rate has locked the transport cost for that distance; without a variation, settle at the contract rate; no re-rating of unit rates for "extra haul".
  4. 7.2.1: re-measurement of BOQ items under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract relies only on "the actual construction drawings provided by the employer and the variation instructions issued and confirmed by the employer", with differences split into two categories — BOQ errors adjusted under Section 8.2, variations under Section 8.9. Items without variation/error settle at the priced BOQ's original rates and quantities — there is no separate adjustment path for a "haul-distance fee".
  5. 10.3.2: the final account price is listed in 13 categories in order — contract BOQ total, adjustment for BOQ errors, adjustment for provisional sums, adjustment of provisional prices after procurement, adjustment for the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions, dayworks adjustment, changes in costs adjustment, law/regulation and policy change adjustment, variation increments/decrements, additional works, claims, liquidated damages for non-performance per the contract, other amounts. Duplicated haul costs fall within none of them — disallow.

Itemisation basis (key to finding "duplication" — which BOQ item carries the distance):

  • Buildings (GB/T 50854-2024): Tables A.1.1 (separate earth/rock, code 010101) and A.2.1 (foundation earth/rock, code 010102) cover work content of excavation, loading and on-site haulage only, with no haul-distance item description; off-site haulage goes to disposal of surplus (excavated) material — A.4.13: "Disposal of surplus (excavated) material covers the loading, unloading and transport of earth/rock from the construction site to the designated disposal point, and shall meet state and local construction administrative authorities' requirements on construction-waste reception and disposal" (the haul distance sits in the item description of disposal of surplus material).
  • Municipal (GB/T 50857-2024): A.4.6 same basis — "The work content of trench, pit, general earth/rock, mined earth, silt and flowing-sand excavation items includes on-site haulage of earth/rock only; where off-site haulage of earth/rock is required, the item may be listed under the 'disposal of surplus (excavated) material' item code".

Three common duplication forms and disallowance bases:

  1. Excavation unit rate already includes off-site haul, yet surplus disposal/earthwork haulage is listed separately: check the priced BOQ's all-in unit rate analysis — where the excavation rate build-up already includes transport quota line items, the haul cost is included; disallow per 3.1.6 + 10.3.2, disallowed amount = quantity of the duplicated item × contract all-in unit rate.
  2. Disposal item description already states a distance, yet the final account adds "per extra 1 km" sub-items: the distance is part of the item description and the contract rate includes it; disallow per 8.9.1 item 1 — no extra-haul charge where the final-account distance matches the description.
  3. Distance stacking errors (quota norms "base distance + incremental segments" double-counting the base segment): a pricing error; disallow the over-charged amount per the contractually agreed national/industry measurement standard.

Applicable Boundaries

  • Applies only to final account review of BOQ items under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract (lump-sum contracts adjust per contract drawings and agreements; this reasoning chain does not apply).
  • Genuinely changed distance (disposal site change, government-designated reception point change causing an increased haul distance): a variation instruction or site instruction / variation record issued/confirmed by the employer is required, adjusted per the Section 8.9 variation valuation rules — adjusting the "incremental haul" while deducting the cost already included within the distance stated in the item description; not a full extra charge.
  • Where the final-account distance exceeds the described distance without a variation instruction: still settle at the contract rate; no adjustment.
  • An incomplete item description (including distance) is itself a "BOQ error" — under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract the employer is responsible; re-measure and adjust per Section 8.2 — a different disallowance path from "double counting"; distinguish the two.
  • Where quantity changes exceed 15%, unit rates are adjusted per 8.9.2 (reasonable downward adjustment for increases, reasonable upward adjustment for decreases), without affecting the "no re-charging of haul without variation" conclusion.

Further Reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024: 2.0.9 (all-in unit rate term), 3.1.6 (fully inclusive price excluding VAT), 7.2.1 (re-measurement under unit-rate contracts), 8.9.1 (five-tier rules for determining all-in unit rates on variation/error), 10.3.2 (13 final-account categories).
  • GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix A: Tables A.1.1 (separate earth/rock 010101), A.2.1 (foundation earth/rock 010102), A.4.13 (disposal of surplus material including distance).
  • GB/T 50857-2024 Appendix A A.4.6 (on-site haulage vs disposal of surplus material itemisation).
  • Extensions: for the cost composition of the all-in unit rate see the all-in unit rate definition card; the 15% boundary and the construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal) basis for all-in unit rate adjustment on variation/error; municipal off-site haul distance confirmation (centroid method, quota norms' "base distance + per extra 1 km" structure) and no double charging of on-site haulage.

Keywords

Cited By